As someone who crosses their arms when comfortable, i'm constantly having to remind people that body language is BS.
post
So it turns out real interrogation experts look for inconsistencies in story rather than using some made-up body language reading system.
I saw recently that the way polygraph lie detectors work is 99% just the interrogator telling the suspect that the machine just said they were lying. They're tricked into thinking the jig is up, and confess.
Whenever they pull up a lie detector on X-Files, I always roll my eyes. Which is a funny thing to be hung up on, considering what the show is about π
While it is a psuedoscience, neurodivergent people are unreadable. All of the indicators don't mean anything when someone has spent their entire life masking.
Are you telling me that βLie to meβ is based on a lie?
bends over and wiggles ass
"What does it mean?"
"I think they're signaling that we are invading their territory."
"Ah, let's leave then."
continues wiggling ass while crying
I have literally had someone explain to me what they are trying to communicate to me when they wiggle their ass.
Were they defending their territory?
It means they have toilet paper stuck between their butt cheeks and need help digging it out.
Where the hell is that from?!??
Fun fact to the commenters here, since it comes up in several: vs random chance, humans detect lies 54% of the time, and no, people trained to detect lies (police, HR, etc) do not do so any better. Usually they overestimate eye contact (that isn't reliable) and underestimate actual tells, although those are pretty rare if the lie is thought out in advance (e.g. hesitation when coming up with a lie on the spot).
However, we do read body language very well because of this fun little arms race while evolving. People get better at deception, people get better at detecting deception, then people get better at deception further, etc., so we do really have a pretty good sixth sense, in a sense. Evolution that predates humans, even.
If anyone wants, I can probably look up those specific articles, although they're mostly referenced in the social psych textbook with the class I teach. I find it really fascinating, although they are a bit contracting when they give information on lying body language and then immediately say you can't detect lies well, lol.
Autistic body language and neurotypical body language do not align at all and I've never met a neurotypical individual who has ever read my body language correctly.
Liars don't hesitate enough in my experience, but then are scanning for if you detected their lie (so like waiting a bit too much, being very alert, very conscious).
Is there anything on women having more developed intuition than men on average? Anecdotally it feels that way. I've been called crazy for clocking people to be dishonest years before they openly did something bad. I've also gone against my intuition because I wanted to force myself to give people benefit of the doubt, only for my intuition to be right. Meanwhile, my partner and some male friends seem to be less attuned.
Nothing in what I've read on this suggested women being any better on average, even if there is a saying about women's intuition. I can imagine being extra cautious, but that doesn't necessarily help in accuracy.
That said, maybe there's an impact of empathy that helps in judging someone's character long term. Empathy isn't necessarily gendered, but social norms do push towards men suppressing empathy. But I'm just guessing; men and women are more similar than different until social roles get enforced.
Someone once said its polite to mirror someone's body language. So I do that. Am I unconsciously mocking people?
Either way. If you think someone is communicating with body language you can always just use word language to ask about it. I think. No Im pretty sure.
I wish more people were better at recognizing pseudoscience. There's dozens of "Body Language Experts" on youtube, and they're all Right Wingers who go around saying "This Democrat breathed the wrong way, it means they're literally Hitler!"
Every adult human should have to read Carl Sagan's book, The Demon-Haunted World: Science as a Candle in the Dark.
Isn't "Literally Hitler" a right wing complement?
"This actress walks while swinging her arms, it's irrefutable proof she's actually a man in disguise!"
If i look away during a convo i am probably hearing, i just got bored with looking at your face
Even the FBI youtube interviews debunked all of these from the start of every one. Body language is specific to each individual and their upbringing/background. You have to notice a difference and change in body language from the default of that person if you want to gain some slight insight into how they act or feel.
Aside from that, and for profiling at least, it's way more important to understand regional differences in common body language so you can differentiate their potential background (ex: Americans smile to strangers often, South Asians have a tendency to stare/gaze, etc).
South Asians have a tendency to stare/gaze
Oh wow I didn't realize this. I've seen so many instances online from women who visited India and came back with horror stories of how they narrowly escaped an unspeakable assault from a guy in public who kept staring at them. Literally never occurred to me that the guy might have had zero intention of doing anything, and just not realized the effect he was having due to cultural differences.
(edit: oh fuck me, I should have known this would be a magnet for everyone's "well acshually..." stories of SA in India, who all completely miss the point that judging individuals based on the actions of other people in a group is the textbook definition of bigotry. Yes I know SA is a highly publicized problem in India. That's exactly why "this guy must have been trying to rape me because he was Indian and looking at me" is such an insidious, not to mention racist, poison.)
I (big white American guy) was traveling in India on a train with my Malayalam tutor and a young woman friend of hers. A guy came into our compartment, sat down, and started staring at me and the young woman. As the train was slowing for a stop, he reached over and grabbed the young woman's breast and then ran off the train. This all happened too quickly for me to do anything, although I'm not sure what I would have done anyway; I weighed about twice as much as the dude but I'm not violence-prone in any way.
The woman was not terribly bothered by this, said it happened all the time to women traveling alone there (or even traveling with people).
I should mention there's a difference between gazing for a while and gazing indefinitely with intent, those fears were not misplaced for India lol.
Regardless, it's not seen as a good habit either (at least in Pakistan), but its something that makes you more easy to profile because it would be uncommon in other regions.
meh, or it means youβre autistic and hate common forms of body language - speaking as an eye contact avoided
yeah, autistic here. All three of the non-joke panes of this meme are just me trying to pay attention to what someone else is saying and to not get distracted by infromation overload from non-verbal signals and my environment.. I do understand that most people read my own non-verbal signals negatively, but I have a different non-verbal communication template from the normies.
They don't undertand that, but at least I do, so I forgive the misjudgements as much as I can.
Autism body language can sometimes mean the exact opposite.
Crossed hands: I'm pulling back because I need to process this, give me some time.
Look away: Eye contact to distracting for me no concentrate on what you're saying.
Tilting head: I'm uncomfortable so I'm shimming stimming with the inner ear thingy for balance.
You are a moron if you think you can tell with absolute certainty what others feel with body language.
You are also a moron if you think nothing is to be gained.
There is a difference between a conviction in court and surviving a team meeting without being a clueless asshole nobody likes.
This is kind of silly and simplistic, and also incorrect.
I won't claim I am an expert, I am actually autistic. But I can read people: I had to learn it manually, like one knows a shit ton about trains or baseball stats.
I am a breath of fresh air in the conference room. /joking, I will call your shit right out.
I'm pretty sure it's silly and simplistic on purpose, as a setup to the 4th panel
What you're actually reading are things like micro-movenents. And your brain is kind of just doing it in the background.
you can most certainly read body language, though it requires observation of contextual variables.
crossing your arms could mean anything when observed alone. observe someone with their arms crossed, pacing, eyes shifting around, and quietly mumbling to themselves? they're likely highly agitated and on the verge of becoming aggressive.
Me when I'm really interested in someone or having a great intense conversation:
Crossing my arms because I don't know what to do with my hands.
Wandering gaze because I find prolonged direct eye contact too intense. Would ideally talk to someone sitting side by side on a couch rather than face to face.
The head tilt neck exposing stuff just sounds like bullshit though.
As someone professionally trained in neurolinguistic programming, I'm absolutely not offended by this. Eyes up and to the right
I tilt my head to the side when I'm confused, interested, sore, leaning on my hand, or relaxed.
I avert eye contact when I am disinterested, sure, but I also do it when thinking, when annoyed, when there's something more interesting elsewhere, or when I don't feel like engaging in a staring contest. I most often do it as a show of disrespect for the person talking, although that's only when I look away. Often times I'm not looking to begin with because I rarely lock eyes with people I talk to.
I cross my arms when I'm cold, when I refuse an alcoholic communion, or when it's more comfortable than leaving them at my sides. I don't cross my arms when I'm defensive or anxious. When I am defensive, I widen my eyes vertically a small amount and sometimes harden my jaw or set my teeth, and when I am anxious, I place my index fingers against my thumb nails or rub my thumb pads against my index finger knuckles.



all 82 comments