No, I don't like the Twitter format.
post
No, I don't get the attraction to that medium format just like I don't understand X, Bluesky, etc. It's a soapbox format.
No, cause I don't know enough people I would want to follow over there and have enough other content to keep me occupied.
FWIW, you can just follow a few hashtags that interest you (like #cats, #yourhometown, #politics, #favoriteauthor, #scifi or whatever) and it will likely generate quite a bit of feed content until you start finding out who you like enough to follow them directly.
I have an account but I don't really use it. I don't really know who I'd want to follow or what I'd want to post about. Same problem I had with (Pre-Musk) Twitter. I much prefer a platform like Lemmy, where I can subscribe to specific topics instead of people.
advice: you can follow hashtags
not just users
this may help
Okay but what would I even follow hashtag wise? I surely don't want to follow ~500 #'s for politicians names or something. Sports teams I can review stats online, unless I was looking to following something like #bengalsinjuries or something, but who would know to tag that in a post letting me know if their linebacker didn't tear his ACL but rather had a sprain?
Don't the hashtags change quite often? I feel id end up with a slew of opinions about the war in Ukraine, and same with Iran, but nothing useful.
I think I just followed people who had garden stuff and chickens, same with loops, but neither have I really used enough to say I "use them". Like it's been 6 months since I signed into mastadon, and loops I signed into maybe a month ago to see how it was going.
i hope it works for you
but you can set keyword filters follow the big hashtags for example #politics #technology and many more
and then you can set it to show content warnings instead of hiding the entire thing (because it may hide normal stuff) so you can filter out useless stuff
Which is cool, but it's still not really what I'm looking for. Like if I follow a hashtag like #technology or whatever, I'll just get a huge jumble of random opinions, repeating news articles etc. Whereas on something like Lemmy, it's much more structured. Like when there's some big news event, discussion will be concentrated on one post per community generally, and duplicates will be removed. I prefer having that kind of more orderly structure.
That is actually super nice.
lemmy communities are just users.. so you can follow lemmy from mastodon
I'll say the same thing as everyone else, but with different emphasis:
If I cared about "microblogging"-style social media, which I don't, Mastodon would be the service I would use.
I do not, because I just don't like the format. I never used Twitter either.
I grew up on vBulletin 5 forums and prefer longer thread-form content rather than short form Twitter style feeds. Reddit used to scratch that itch, now it's Lemmy. Its just hard for my brain to navigate so I avoid it.
The people-centric nature of Mastodon never worked for me. The only people I would follow on there, were folks who basically only post about a single topic, and of course that topic had to interest me. I just don't care what a stranger on the internet had for breakfast or how their local sports team performed...
I'm not a huge Twatter user to begin with, but the Mastodon learning curve was too high for me to overcome.
I also had a lack of motivation to keep digging because I didn't put a lot of work in to find content that I was interested in, and didn't present itself immediately.
Lemmy takes up enough of my time as it is.
Bluesky is more Twatter-like, but I'm still wary that it's a proprietary system and could enshittify at any moment.
No, I use Bluesky.
Don't get me wrong, this isn't an ad for Bluesky and it's not an incrimination of Mastodon, but it's just being realistic about what the platform offers. In spirit I appreciate what Mastodon is doing and I absolutely loathe the staff behind Bluesky and feel almost certain the platform will nosedive like every other to date. But I need to be where the people I want to follow are: my friends, journalists, scientists, authors, artists. They all gravitated to the easy-to-use drop-in replacement.
I'm here on Lemmy because I believe in the idea of federation, but what this platform offers me is something different. It's a content aggregator and an open forum; I'm not particularly here to socialize or get to know individual people.
If Mastodon really wants to grow its user base (and I'm honestly not sure it does), they need to seriously address the onboarding issue. It needs to be dead fucking simple to just get an account and follow the people you're interested. No, no, don't explain to me, I already know. I'm talking about the average user. You know the average user. Dead. Fucking. Simple. Simpler than that, even.
But at the end of the day I'm a Millennial, I've seen the rise and fall of so many platforms at this point. When one sinks you just groan and find another. In this way I'm a bit worried for the younger generations who grew up with these big platforms already well-established and thought they were somehow more stable or trustworthy than they actually are. Fuck 'em. Move on.
onboarding
This is consistently what I hear from X / BlueSky users when I try to turn them on to Masto.
Mostly it boils down to the need for a central or nearly-complete index, so people can instantly be found rather than percolating across federated islands.
Well, that plus Metcalfe's Law
Yeah, I think that's the point I was trying to make.
The microblogging platforms (or whatever you want to call these) really want the appearance of centralization while Mastodon is trying to break centralization through federation. Keeping the appearance strong enough and functional enough while breaking it into secure and resilient enough federated bits is a lot finer of a hair to split than I think some of us estimate.
No. I don't understand why I would want to follow people instead of topics.
I use Mbin instead of Lemmy, so I don't need to. I'm following whom I want to follow from my Mbin account.
wait platforms can federate to each other
Yeah, ypu sometimes see mastodon posts in Lemmy/Piefed, it is weird but really cool.
I believe you can do the same with Pixelfed, and other platforms in the fediverse, you just need to post it correctly and it will work.
Yeah, Lemmy, PieFed and MBin are all completely different platforms as well. Even then, PieFed and MBin users can follow Mastodon users. Mastodon users can create posts for all Threadiverse users (Lemmy/PieFed/Mbin) by mentioning the name of the community.
For instance if they mention @asklemmy@lemmy.world in their post, the first section of their post is turned into the title (up to the first '!', '?', or '.' character encountered). The entire post is then placed in the main body.
Now I'm wondering how everyone is going to react when they notice a Threads user making a post on a Lemmy instance...
Yes absolutely. Anything can federate (with Lemmy, Mastodon, etc) as long as it implements the ActivityPub protocol, doesn't even need to be a social platform. I remember seeing a federated AI training project once.
Of course, supported feature sets will differ. Mastodon for example doesn't have a concept of communities, so it treats Lemmy communities as regular users. This means there's no moderation semantics or other community-specific features, and subscribing/following them is a spammy mess because Lemmy communities boost every single comment made in them. But Mastodon users absolutely can subscribe to Lemmy communities if they want to, and they can even post to them by mentioning them.
Mbin is designed as an alternative to Lemmy that also has explicit support for Mastodon-style platforms in addition to the threadiverse (Lemmy/Mbin/Piefed). So it lets you follow users, boost posts, has a mechanism for automatically sorting posts into a community, and has a fallback pseudo-community for when a post really ends up without a specific community.
I believe Piefed also has added following users (including Mastodon ones) this year.
I don't have anything against Mastodon. But I don't use it for the same reason I never used Twitter. I don't find microblogging sites useful.
Edit: I wrote this before reading the comments and I'm glad to see people still wanting to go back to the forum style of communication.
In my experience microblogging is not interesting. Mastodon has the exact same niches as Lemmy but way more annoying: science, annoying liberals, and linux.
My favorite example of this is a liberal user was criticizing past protests using the term anarchist. I pointed out their use of the term is incorrect and they are misrepresenting the protests. They then reply how dare I talk down to a black woman…
how could I even know they’re black or a woman and does this fact somehow protect them from being wrong? Classic American liberal mentality. Victimhood mentality.
Yep, Mastodon is my Twitter replacement. Never buying into a commercial social media app again (which is why I cannot understand in the slightest why people all jumped on BlueSky like it was a savior from above).
I also don't like the twitter format. I prefer stuff grouped by topic, not user, so forums are generally preferable.
Microblogging is kind of about following a person, and I'm normally less interested in a person than a topic (Reddit-style).
I made very limited, no-account use of Twitter.
There are a few things that I have found Twitter (back before it was login-required) to be good at. Lots of users, so lots of content, and hashtags and retweets were better than the Reddit approach at letting letting temporary, ad hoc communities quickly form for short term events, like natural disaster coverage. Some random person posts cell phone video footage from an incident, other people find it and retweet with hashtags, just works well to tie together relevant information wirhin minutes or hours or an event without the slower Reddit-style community-building approach.
Mastodon doesn't have the scale of Twitter, so never really drew me in, given that I was never really rabid about the microblog format in the first place.
Yes, I do. Sometimes I get an urge to say something witty about the stupidities of politicians or to share a good news. Often I get a human reaction to my blurp and it makes me feel understood.
I think I still have a login somewhere. But I like Lemmy's format better.
i think if the character limit was higher, it would've been better
different Mastodon instances can have different character limits
I just found this one https://hear-me.social/about
On this server, the maximum number of characters in a post is 12,000. The Mastodon default is 500, but I bumped it higher. Also, note that a URL in a Mastodon post always counts as 23 characters, regardless of its true length. URL shorteners are not required for Mastodon posts.
I don't use Mastodon or Bluesky. I never liked the Twitter format or way of how it is ever managed. I saw Twitter as an example of how saturated social media is in general when it's just a freaking comment box with a stupid character limit.
It's the combination of not liking the twitter format and the saturation of American political bitching.
The format doesn't work for me. Same with Twitter and Bluesky.
Posts, ok I understand, but the way comments and discussion are done is not intuitive for me.
I do a little bit because there are some interesting posters there who aren't here. I don't understand why the format is so popular either though.
I follow hashtags for environmental concerns and it creates a very relaxed feed with a lot of high quality photos and news/articles. Due to the lack of commenting, there is a lot less angst when using it as the content mainly speaks for itself.
But, this positive is also a negative as it is not a platform to find out further information or read about people's experiences. I'm reminded of an incident I had when I first started using it, someone posted informally about plants who lived not far from me and I was interested in the species choices and what a couple of them were. Their profile said "science communicator" so I asked them a question and they never replied. It made me feel like people that post on there are "science narcissists". I deleted that comment and have never commented since.
I like Mastodon but I also don't like it. For a relaxed browse, it's great once it's set up with tags and following a few people that post about topics I'm interested in as their business/weird hobby.
Think of it as journalists throwing headlines at you.
I have an account on mastodon.art but I donMt really get the point of the microblog format, I mostly get annoyed at it.
I have an account, actually had it longer than lemmy I think, but only barely use it, mostly to post some of my drawings. I'm not really a fan of the "follow individual users instead of topics" model or the constrained character limit. Basically the same thing I infrequently used Twitter for before Elon took it over.
I've been on Mastodon for 8 years and I currently use 3 different accounts on different instances. I do enjoy the format and following hashtags but admittedly, I don't feel like I've made many friends there. Much like Lemmy, it's been more about subjects than relationships.
I do wish I could figure out the secret recipe for that.
I am chronically online and I literally never used Twitter except for porn sometimes after Tumblr was ruined by Christians. I don't need to hear everyone's shower thoughts throughout the day.
Never bothered with mastadon.
I use it. It's an OK way to share status updates.
I do wish it had more local communities though. Feels like some liberal pools have only adopted bluesky, which is kind of a sad state of affairs considering the ownership model is just as messy as any other public corp. Just because you add the word "benefit" to the title doesn't mean it's at all trust worthy lmao.
I have a Mastodon account, but I only use it for testing interactions between the larger Fediverse and the Threadiverse.
I don't really like the Twitter format, so I'll stick with PieFed.
I use Mastodon. I have an account and I follow people. I try to use it as my doom scrolling replacement which it does an ok job of being. The big problem is I don't know anyone who uses it. I would like to have an incentive to use it more, but until even a fraction of my social circle uses it, it's just going to be a "I'm trying to be the change I want to see in the world" app.
I'm running software that does both. My lemmy username is my mastodon username.
I'm happy with bluesky so far but sometimes I think about giving mastodon a shot too
I don't use mastodon. I have an account, don't remember what instance it was on. I went on it a handful of times, didn't have enough engagement or people to follow to make it worth being memorable. This post actually reminded me it existed I should go look at it.
Yes, though not actively right now. Still, I'm specifically on an Mbin instance because I want to use both Mastodon and Lemmy from the same username. Been doing that since Kbin.social (RIP) and I find it quite convenient. Wanna browse some posts in a forum-style presentation? I can do that. Wanna check my feed for random blurbs and posts? I can do that too.
Yeah, I use it because I follow a few cool Orgs there (nearly every organisation that has to do with free software is on there) and some comic artists I like (J.L. westover, Bad and Ralph Ruthe (German). And then I follow a few other cool people, that I found through other means and found out that they are on Mastodon or people I found through Mastodon.
But yeah, the main thing that keeps me coming back are the daily comics.
Yes. Because it has a great community of people who talk about the things I like
I use Mastodon under the same username. I do this to support the network even though I'm not a fan of the microblog format. Thankfully most Mastodon servers allow unlimited post size, so its not such nonsense as Twitter was.
Its a good news feed in lieu of another network of its like. Between Lemmy and Mastodon I feel like I have my fill of social media.
Yes, I have a couple hashtags I keep open in their own column and then several more in my main feed. I don't keep a close eye on it though I do check it a couple times a day and occasionally post about my personal projects.
I like the local community content too and population size has been good for tastes.
I had no idea what Mastodon was before reading this thread. I'm glad I did, because it sounds like it's a Twitter alternative, which is great because fuck big tech, but the format is not my cup of tea. Oh how I miss the old forums built purely on HTML. But alas, ASCII art has sailed into The West.
Yes, I switched from Twitter 4 years ago. I was “fed” up with rich assholes controlling the narrative and Bluesky didn’t look like something that was safe from that.
It has some problems but it has improved a lot over time. I had to switch instances once because the previous one just randomly decided to shut down (with some time to prepare). And because you can’t take your posts with you, that was a bit of a shock for me. But it also showed why the fediverse is pretty much immune to being destroyed as a whole.
Still, it’s all a bit niche and will probably stay that way. You won’t find many celebrities and corporations there and the media doesn’t care what happens on Mastodon, which is all good in my opinion. If it works for you depends on what bubbles you are in.
There are some ways to bridge with Bluesky but it feels a bit sketchy and I don’t have a need for it anyways.
I generally stopped caring too much about social media and sharing everything that I do with the world. So a smaller, more focused network is fine for me.
I've got an account, but don't really use it. I've been thinking of maybe giving it another go lately, but haven't yet. I do use Bluesky though. People are more chill there.
I don't because I never really liked the twitter & bluesky thing (or microblogging whatever it is called..) I prefer the forum look!
I also do not like the Twitter format, but I have a Mastodon account just in case. I mostly just use it to log into some services and to repost stuff. My activity is as good as zero in Mastodon. Most of my time on social media is me dwelling here.
mastodon.radio is my online ham radio club. like old old twitter, with more flexibility.
I don't. I think "microblogging" is a dumb concept. The only real difference from a traditional forum is the order they show posts in a thread is completely ass backwards and the character limit is just plain moronic. Nothing was stopping people making super short posts on other sites, so I don't know why it blew up having the entire point being super short posts.
I think that some of Twitter's features are aimed at making the platform very, very approachable. If all tweets are very short, then you don't have to learn quoting etiquette, where you learn the syntax and to just quote relevant bits
you can only respond to the bit in question. I still think that the short message thing is a pain.
is mastadon the replacement for twitter/bluesky, if so no, i dont like that form of communication. just like forum style.
I did until I fell to a trap where some alarmist said that AI makes people not learn things, makes them delearn things and asked people for thoughts.
Turns out they didn't really want to hear experiences and surprisingly enough they also knew better than me that I actually hadn't learned things that I thought having learned.
Pettiness aside it's a small and quite tighly woven group of people, which makes arguments feel more personal. Here I don't know anyone by their handle so it's like talking to a hivemind. There you see who's taking who's side and it's quite expressive.
I liked that it doesn't have algorithms and advertisements, but I'm not sure if that format is good mentally. It's addictive and turns into doomscrolling easily.
For some reason I feel the need to share my thoughts in the internet so maybe I'll continue to do so here.
all 88 comments