If I need spyware to ensure I’m playing a game right, that’s a game I don’t need.
post
If the game Rust is what is keeping you away from being on Linux it might be best you never go to Linux. Just save us all the future headache, thanks.
I mean if you run on an operating system, you’re not really serious about anti cheat. You should require all of your players to buy your own hardware that is sealed in a titanium box. They should have to give a blood sample before each session, and they should have to be completely surrounded by webcams the entire time. Better yet, have them report to their nearest prison’s solitary confinement wing for a 100% monitored play session.
Let’s get actually serious about anti cheat.
The last "serious about anticheat" game was hacked on release day. On Windows. With kernel-level AC.
Fuck off with your lies.
I hear hackers run rampant in Rust.
Are they trying to say Valve isn't serious about anti-cheat?
If you can't play a specific game on linux due to anti-cheat and you still have to encounter cheaters on windows - is this a linux problem somehow?
15 years ago, any developer who wanted to install low-level malware on your system would have been rightfully laughed out of the room.
It really shows how tech illiterate the modern user is.
The headline confused me for a second. I was like, aren’t they adding more and more rust to the kernel?
Arc Raiders was just deck verified
... Rust still exists? As in, the murder-hobo-survival game that was early access like, 10-15 years ago?
It's been polished a lot since then (they update every month), but yeah, it's still around and it's fun. Sucks that Alistair has this take tho.
It is very different from the Early Access times. At some point they have rebuilt the whole game from ground up. Still is a murder-hobo-survival but is much more fun, nicer looking, better optimized and higher-skill-based game.
Since rust, the game, was launched one year after rust, the language, can we get the rust foundation to sue them for shits and giggles?
Why hasn’t the amazing economy propelling AI industry fixed cheating yet?
My suspicion says that Valve use AI in VAC these days. I have no proof of anything but in my opinion it would be the smart thing to do. And something major happened in TF2 a few months ago where they finally managed to ban the rampant bot cheaters. Could be AI or it could just be Valve finally taking the problem seriously.
There are so many alternatives to these sort of games now. I am not sure it's a good idea to just give your players the middle finger like that.
And nothing of value was lost.
Ok, I wasn't gonna play that anyway, I prefer games that don't incentivize cheating.
Third rate game's developer says people who already have EAC working on proton are "not serious" uh....
So much for my Steam Machine plans.
Welp, enjoy your rootkits and privacy violations.
Rust? That's a beverage in star citizen
I tried to get into Rust a few times and never liked it. One time I even played with a decent group of people and it still sucked. They can keep their game.
I enjoyed rust by hosting my own personal whitelisted server for my friends and I to mess around on, that's my favorite way to enjoy the game. You can play on linux by disabling their anticheat on your community server (since the server just rejects the proton client with EAC enabled, you don't get banned).
Gosh, stop trying so hard to make me not want play your game, I can only take so much!
Games shouldn’t be serious about anti-cheat.
Games should be serious about anticheat, it just shouldn't require a rootkit into the players computer
It's interesting how gamers are supposed to have a problem with people cheating in a video game, but not with their computer being compromised by bad actors.
This always screams of a person that thinks their views are the default views of reality. Really shows how self centered he is.
Well, I for one am serious about anti-cheat: if the company making the game makes it more important than the game itself, I make game not important for me
Rust isn't serious about anti cheat though...
Let me tell you, the average Rust player doesnt care and Facepunch know it.
Then I have 'no plans' on ever giving them money for their shitty designed game
Oh, this is about that shitty survival game‽ I thought it was talking about the rust language. I was so very confused.
The irony of it all is the best cheats of which I won't discuss bypass all anticheat including theirs. Their concern is only for the low hanging fruit for appearance only.
I remember previous outbursts from facepunch. This has nothing to do with anti-cheat, they have been staunchly anti linux for some time now. They have floated the idea of removing linux support for garrys mod for years.
Oh no, where will I go now to have 12 year olds tell me to kill myself while shouting racial slurs at my base.
Seems I correctly assessed that game as sketchy bullshit
Actually, games that force kernel level spyware on users to combat cheating when the company literally controls the servers the game runs on and can afford to pay for moderators are not serious about catching cheaters.
If ring-0 access is the only way you can stop cheaters, your game must be poorly programmed.
Nah, cheating is just absurdly hard to stop. Even ring 0 anti cheat doesn't stop it entirely. At some point, I feel like the answer is similar to piracy, in that you must accept that there's going to be some amount of it, and then find a way to mitigate the damage. Because there are solutions to both of them that both go too far.
I think the way that CS does it is really the best one. Prevent the simple cheats, record games and let people handle the edge cases based on reports and suspicious activity.
While I agree that this is usually enough, you end up with the issue that with volume the process becomes bogged down to the point of inefficiency. The best bet is to implement this system with a much more robust server side cheat detection, and ideally not send occult information or recieve bad information from the clients to minimize the damage that can be done with a cheat.
I didn't know CS did this, but yeah, at a high level, that's how I'd address it, too. It's probably not a solution that scales super well due to the manual review required, and I know that game has a reputation of people still being annoyed by cheaters, but it might be the best we can do without being very invasive, like the ring 0 stuff.
Doesn't Counter-Strike still have this? It serves a different use case than a proper ranked mode, usually, though I'll admit I'm long out of the loop on Counter-Strike.
You can use analytics to detect cheating effectively. Companies don't do this because it hurts their bottom line (stopping cheaters). Companies pay lip service to cheating and play stupid games of cat and mouse.
Cheaters should not be banned, they should be forced to play against other cheaters. If you are so inhuman that you are the living embodiment of "got gud" then you get to play with cheaters.
Everyone is happy except for the cheaters and that one got gud guy. Waiting for the first brave company to implement this.
You could argue this would hurt competitive gameplay but it is obvious it is already hurt and the other answers (giving complete control of your OS) are a non-starter for me.
Reminds me that DRM used to run Kernel Side until software side drm was the safest/less sketchy option.
I love having rootkits on my pc to play a poorly coded and Un-optimized game!
Can't have Rust on Linux? Just do it in C/C++!
Thank you for your insight, Nude Bullying Simulator dev. Obviously you know about serious subjects.
The words of a man who made a game that is now irrelevant mean nothing to the ravenous Linux user.
What a stupid excuse. It is possible to detect cheaters without even touching memory or cpu. You could do the magic on the servers, if you are really serious about anti-cheat.
And I actually liked facepunch, especially what Garry was doing.
Edit: Checked who Alistair McFarlane is. Just a producer. Has no idea about technical stuff. So why the fuck do they let them speak about technical topics if he clearly has no clue about them?!
If you're willing to spend some money on cheating there's no way to prevent people from just aimbotting based on video output and feeding it as USB mouse commands. These anti-cheat systems are just shit solutions compared to server-side culling, superhuman reflex detection and report/review systems with premium servers and bans. Just give people in-game currency for correctly agreeing with the consensus and some people will go nuts on it for less than $1 per hour of in-game items.
Anti-cheat systems basically fuck with the kernel so if a game has it there's a case for not playing it.
If they're so confident about that stance they should remove their games from Valve's services.
oh noooo, what am I gonna do if I cant play the game that typically involves me being chased by heavily armed end game players, screaming racial slurs at me for no good goddamn reason other than sociopathy?
I guess I'll just have to console myself with the thousand other games that run perfectly fine because their devs arent self absorbed fuckwads.
Rust is a toxic shit hole. Wasn't going to bother anyways but now I'm REALLY not going to bother with it
Ok. I'll continue to play Elden ring, assassin's creed, hollow knight silk song, and all these other great games. There are so many good games to play, I'm good to skip rust.
Much like people who craft their games with human hands aren't really serious about AI generated art.
I remember there was a script(server side) that disables EAC for Linux/proton and enables it for Windows, for some reason scripting is done in C# (native language). (BTW I never played rust but learned this from a friend)
Thats fair, I dont expect every game to open up to linux. I know Kernel AC can be easily bypassed but it still filters some cheaters and raises the barrier to entry. It also gives a lot of people peace of mind.
top 41 comments