I struggle here.
I hate this law, but I also hate Meta.
Can we pan this hell of a law and still dump Meta?
I struggle here.
I hate this law, but I also hate Meta.
Can we pan this hell of a law and still dump Meta?
It would be a sad day if this is what makes the government do an about-face on this moronic bill made by dinosaurs who have no idea how technology works.
They won't do an about face for this. It would be nice if the government has realized that the bill is untenable due to it being unconstitutional, and this was just Meta trying to score a PR win by making it look like they had a real hand in it. But in the end, this is going to cost the public reall money to overturn.
For context: I'm in the Canadian government, but I will not say which part cause it's not that relevant (and probably obvious anyway)
My job uses Whatsapp for basic internal/external communication. If this bill goes through, I will laugh a little as now my bosses have no easy way to pass information down at like 3 in the morning.
Will I also weep as my vpn no longer can function within Canada without the backdoors the powers that be crave?
Yes. But I'll still laugh at my bosses when our very employer has fucked us out of an easy communication service, and now they have to either deal with not having 24/7 means of contact, or reverting to texting. Or actually calling.
It'll be funny.
"New phone, who dis"
If our government is running things via whatsapp, that's a problem in itself. US tech should be getting excised from every area of the government. If the government can't function without US service providers, we aren't sovereign.
Agreed! But until recently this wasn't seen as a problem because of how close we were with the US. Now it is.
The government is very reactionary. Regardless of who's running the show. Needs to experience long term pain for something to shift.
We are experiencing long term pain.
More theater.
https://cybernews.com/news/whatsapp-encryption-lawsuit-meta/
A whistleblower showed than WhatsApp isn't end-to-end encrypted, and even though the lawsuit was later thrown out, it just means a federal judge prevented lawyers from requesting discovery needed to prove their case, probably under pressure from various agencies who like that WhatsApp is a giant "encryption ;-)" honeypot.
Meta would actually pull WhatsApp rather than disclose it's running a fake encryption scam to secretly collect data, but that doesn't mean there was ever real encryption. Meta = Government. They are the same damn thing.
What can we do to stop this? Are Carney and Poilievre both on board with this? They may not be as insidious as the US but I'd still rather the government stay out of my business.
Are Carney and Poilievre both on board
I suspect
Oof. So no bite, we canucks just have to take this then?
Well, yes and no.
If it's gotten through the Senate, the next step is to find someone harmed by this -- likely a VPN or encrypted chat company -- and convince them to sue the government.
If it's not through the Senate yet, write your senators and explain to them why this is bad and why you oppose it. Write on paper, with a pen and envelope and stamp. And then call their constitency offices to say the same things.
A public record of thoughtful disagreement can sway senators. Especially if you have independent or, uhg, libertarian senators from your province.
Be real, whoever is in charge would have taken the Meta money for bill C-22. I do have no idea why PP is not opposing it.
Carney is obviously onboard. It's his bill.
Conservatives have a far more reasoned approach.
https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/bill-c-22-surveillance-privacy-law-enforcement-9.7220814
Conservatives have a far more reasoned approach.
A sentence is never thought I'd read in my life, but I guess it makes sense when the Conservatives are fundamentally opposed to everything the Liberals do, lol
Yea I signed TOS with Zuckerfucker to have all my personal data... not Orange Poosolini /s
My ask has more to do with the fact that this can be broadly applied to any organization and not just meta. I use privacy services other than Meta that may decide to stop operating as a result of this. Do you have any suggestions on how one can go about going through the necessary channels to stop this or do you just want to levy sarcasm at the situation?
My ask
You're thinking "question", right?
I'll be using SimpleX Chat if Signal leaves Canada.
Would they consider pulling their other services out? I mean, I fully oppose the bill, but since I expect it to go through anyway it would be nice if we could just get Meta as a whole to leave.
the cia / nsa spy on everyone anyway. encryption is an illusion. they can see everything on your screen.
Just knowing how the technology stack works.. that is wholly unfeasible.
For one, I'd notice the traffic.
For two, cryptography is an illusion?
What? Is algebra also an illusion? Statistics? These aren't theories, it's applied math.
And three.. oh, it's a troll.
Damn, they got me.
all 56 comments