I wasn't banned, but I rolled over after 3rd party apps were taken away on the day they stopped working. I only use the app for it so taking that away made it pretty easy to stop and no i wasnt going to use their own because they forced my hand. Apps were limited on lemmy at that time and had to wait like 4 months before the one i used to use was released, but it was worth it.
post
Reddit didn't ban me, I banned them.
Banned? No. Other way around. I banned reddit from my devices after the API fiasco.
there is a way, but its much more convoluted. different IP/device and browser is the usual method, as long as you are not repeating the same exact pattern as before. but why spend that money anyways, the only people that do are the ones using reddit to drive traffic to thier own sites/OF agency, of whom reddit is constantly playing cat and mouse in detecting them. i also have supsicion reddit preferentially dont ban aggresively against propaganda bots as much as the ones i mentioned above.
Banned for using a VPN for “ban evasion” but never had been banned before.
Appealed. No response.
I took that as a fuck off message.
I came here after the Reddit API mess but still posted on Reddit.
Got a temporary Reddit ban for a short statement saying Biden was caught genociding, then recently a permanent ban for saying the only way Trump is leaving office is if 100,000 people drag him out. "Inciting violence."
303,000 comment karma, 8,388 post karma, 14+ years.
Going corporate is never good.
I didn't get banned. I left after the API change. I was already reducing use naturally, and what time I did still spend there was mostly to mod a very small niche hobby sub.
Without the mod tools I used before the API changes, plus the influx of MAGA-bots on reddit as a whole, I could longer mod the sub in a way the community asked for and that I was comfortable with. So I resigned, wished the remaining mods well, and went about my way.
There were other subs trying to go dark and impact reddit's advertising opportunities, and reddit was banning some of the mods doing that sort of thing. I decided even if reddit changed course, I was past the point I could ever come back to it.
Dito, not banned, but left with the API change as well. Still keep RIF on my phone just so that if anyone sends me a redditink I get a 401:forbidden and have to reevauate if I actually give a shit enough to view it in a browser. The actual app is just as bad as ticktok when it comes to nicking every data point that isnt nailed down.
Left reddit in the api blockage
Now I spend my days shit chatting with MLs
I got 'soft banned'.
I had stopped commenting on Reddit back in 2022 after receiving warnings on similar topics. Continued to lurk and scroll. Now reddit has an uncloseable popup on web telling me to use the app. So I don't use reddit.
you would get banned if you logged in after a period of inactivity, i think many users noticed they got shadowbanned after using old accounts that went dormant and then suddenly became active. reddit was and still doing this since last year. allegedly its combat bot users who did the same method. it was noticed by a forum i visited on reddit bans/evasions.
I just stopped using it. No ban necessary.
I did get one or two temporary bans some years ago. First time was for criticizing their censorship. The second time was for sending the middle finger emoji to Spez.
I'm not going to go out of my way to delete my dead user or posts or anything. It's not my problem. Quite frankly, I just don't give a shit about their site.
No ban, it just reached a threshold of enshittification where I said "enough is enough" and left.
Not banned but forced to use their shit app. They shut down Reddit is Fun, fuck them
After Reddit cut off api access to third-party apps, I left. Well, not right away, I did give RedReader a try for a month or so.
Basically the same for me. After they squashed the counter protests I decided "fuck them".
20 year old account with probably 10k karma. Not much by today's standards, but I gave it my best.
does karma mean anything? I got more from a single bad joke on a popular community
on reddit, its apparently makes your account more reliable as an actual user, so you wont get banned very easily. that is the theory, and does hold true to a certain point. reddit does detect/notice organic karma gain, and the ones that farm karma. and some subs require a certain amount of karma to engage in.
I always interpreted it as the number of people whose day I made slightly better. That's a nice feeling.
I got banned for making a comment about some hockey player needed attempted murder charges for using his skate blade to slash a rival players throat during a game. Blood spirting out all over the ice. I was banned for inciting violence. When I asked how what I said was inciting violence they perma banned me. I then came here.
I didn't get banned, I left Reddit voluntarily when they announced that they were going to be increasing censorship on their site a year or so ago.
My reasoning was, 'It's only a matter of time before I *do* get banned for something stupid, so I might as well leave this site on my own while I'm still ahead.'
THe censorship came in the form of mass site wide banning and shadowbannings, apparently thier AI was doing it so carelessly the admin stopped listening to appeals because there were too many. this is thier intention. and preparing reddit for an eventual takeover as a right wing propaganda source. allowing palantir AI bots is the latest example.
I got ahead of all that and jumped ship to Lemmy before it got really bad.
I got a 7 day ban for criticizing the current administration. Then I responded with go fucj yourself to the mod team and got my ban.
Not sorry.
Reddit admins, go fuck yourselves
Me. I got shadow banned, without ever hearing why
Getting banned on reddit was how I first learned about lemmy, but tbh I see the same kind of shit-flinging here, and I go back and forth. There's a kind of smugness here about not being like reddit, but I think it just feels different because people who would be targets on reddit get to be flingers here.
Funny enough I have never been banned on reddit, but I have been banned on .ml memes for stating that not everybody in the military is a fascist pig and some people only join because it's one of the easiest ways to get family healthcare with no deductible in the USA. (Literally why my father joined) But obviously since I'm not actively sucking CCP knob the mod banned me, rule 1 as is the way with the shit mods here. No forums immune from it! Overall I would say I'm much happier on Lemmy because of the more genuine seeming human interaction, which I think is a result of being a smaller community and maybe having less bot traffic and astro turfing.
I think the interaction is a LOT better here - for one thing the community is so much smaller you get tons more replies here, which is more engaging and feels more being seen and heard. I still feel a strong one-answer-is-correct atmosphere, like you mention on .ml memes. But I guess that just means some subjects simply aren't discussable objectively, because that involves questioning your own ideas, which is seen as enemy infiltration. I'm slowly learning to avoid the echo chambers, but far from successful yet lol. Overall I heart Lemmy.
That’s funny, I got a ton of engagement on Reddit. I get plenty here, too, for its size but Reddit was was impossible for me to keep up with replies.
I feel you there, I actually love Lemmy BECAUSE I loved reddit. Sure it's a shit show now, but to me Lemmy feels the way reddit did like pre 2015 where communities were smaller, not as many people had heard of it etc. Around 2016 it all started going downhill fast, I'm forever thankful to spez for fucking with the api stuff as that drove me out and found Lemmy (well I found kbin first, but through kbin found Lemmy) which feels a lot like reddit of days gone by. In the end Aaron Swartz is who I think made the reddit I love, and after his passing in 13 things started sliding in the wrong direction.
Not banned but they stopped letting me use bacon reader. so that was a deal breaker
I was permabanned in Elon's post-inauguration bloodbath, after 12 years, and a million Karma.
I know it sounds like sour grapes, but Reddit had already fallen far, and it's fallen much farther since. I was checking out a thread that came up in a search, and I had to endlessly scroll through puns, novelty accounts, more puns, trolls, tangents, etc. I gave up before ever getting to anything resembling the subject I had searched. Useless.
its not a bot, it apparently they are using AI moderation now, if you get that generic message "your accounts has been banned for violating 1 or more whatever" its an AI banning. and they dont elaborate what was the specific incident.
Banned just over a year ago due to rump and anti nazi comments with a few fuck Ford’s in there as well.
I was "harassing" a climate change denier by @ing them on climate change related news. The dude refused to block me and just kept getting annoyed once or twice a day instead. 10/10 would get banned for antagonizing someone too stupid to use the block button again.
Not banned, left voluntarily. The experience was so shitty I finally just said fuck it and left
Me in the last few weeks. Its majority bots and fake redditors from India nowadays. Every time theres a discussion that is against the billionaires agenda you can watch them flood in to brigade it. Its just not even worth my time anymore.
I hope Lemmy is taking notes and does something to prevent the same happening here.
Given how spread-out Lemmy is, it'll be pretty hard to screw it in the same way Reddit got screwed, though. Like, if a given instance doesn't like you, or you don't like that given instance, there are plenty of others for you to move to, or you could host your own if you have the hardware and admin skills.
Ahh. Good point. I hope it doesnt happen but I'd be amazed if bots aren't at least scanning lemmy and injesting what is being discussed.
it does make sense INDIA subs are making the front page quite alot.
Being Scottish and spending time in r/Scotland made this pretty obvious. Scots use language patterns, slang, and colloquialisms that come from Gaelic, Doric or Scots that needs knowledge and experience to interpret. Bots/paid brigaders trip up because they dont understand meaning or context. They are instantly recognisable.
There is 100% a well-funded project to influence political thinking. Mention anything about right-wing politicians, bigotry, lgbtq+ rights, the environment etc. and it triggers some action. They all pile on, thread makes it to 'all', thread gets locked. Rinse and repeat.
10 years in. Banned for suggesting that Trump’s immigration policy should keep the white trash South Africans out of America and not employed as ICE agents.
Never got banned but have been on threadiverse since the Apollo killing a few years ago. That was plenty for me to leave that site.
I made a suicidal joke once and got a 7 day ban and the automod locked on me like the plague.
Got another 7 day ban for quoting Garfield for promoting violence,
got a 7 day ban on a post by rawdawg comics when he said he loved his boyfriend for saying "ha gay" because apparently that promotes hate.
and then the final one was on distressing memes when someone was talking about the funky town video , I was literally giving context to a person that didn't know what the video was, and only my comment got removed .
Haven't been banned yet, but I avoid politics on Reddit and I rarely post/comment over there ever since the 3rd party app fiasco.
I ditched it when they said you could be banned for upvoting pictures of Mario's brother. I figured it was only a matter of time before I got banned.
probably a good thing, because its so astroturf and so easy to get into argument with bots, you will be banned for saying something that the sub doesnt like.
Using a VPN.🤷♀️
Also, welcome! 🇵🇸✊
I did that for a while, they got me though. Which vpn are you employing?
Mullvad. I kind of suspected that I'd get banned, since Mullvad is one of the most widely banned VPNs on mainstream platforms. I tried to appeal it several times, but no matter how I expressed myself, I never received any response whatsoever. I have kept an account just to be able to lurk, but I hate their (the company's) guts. 🤣
Main user got eventually banned for liking a comment, i was on a last warning and subsequent alts got caught by machine algorithms detecting uncharacteristic behavior for a new user or some links to the original banned user, like device ID or browser ID. All alts got shadowbanned after first few comments.
After few weeks of trying different approaches i gave up and decided it's more effort to try to bypass the detection algorithms than it's worth to browse reddit.
oh yea they started targeting UPVOTES as bots, also any acitvity from an old accoun they will ban, even newly created accounts. and some subs do not like new accounts. they retroactive ban people to, which is a new thing. there was ways to evade it but its not worth it, since it requires to pay for things like new devices, a different ip, use of unique proxies that reddit doesnt detect immediately, and anti-detect browser which uses these proxies to create new instances of your browser(hence theoretically seperating the accounts from one another). these cost money though and it seems to geared towards people earning money through reddit(by directing traffic to thier own site).
plus they look at you fingerprinting on your browser, and device components too.
No, I was targeted. I would say anything eventually and it would trigger a 24 hour ban near immediately. Then I’d appeal, win the appeal, come back to say one thing and BAM suspended within the hour.
I’m pretty sure I was on some list. My comments would get thousands of upvotes. I ran economy for a fucking minute (by way of being the first to respond to propaganda posts). Every time maga would attempt their bullshit I was there in a minute to respond to it. Then these suspensions kept happening, and eventually I started getting suspensions for months old posts immediately after an appeal went through.
I know it sounds crazy but I’m telling you, this was a targeted thing and I’m not the only one.
This was my experience as well. Definite targetting. Most of the bans coming after being critical of Capitalism. The Reddit incels and rightoids like to whinge that Reddit is anti-right wing and moderates those viewpoints into oblivion, but it's just cognitive dissonance or gaslighting. You can do just about anything short of direct threats or doxxing on Reddit and be just fine, as long as you don't question that which is unquestionable, i.e. Capitalism. Even inside some very socialist or left-leaning subreddits you see this.
Got banned twice recently. First time was for using kirk as a verb and the second time for pointing out the irony of israel working with nazi sympathizers to genocide muslims.
Not banned. Just productised.
- Can't use the app of my choose. Must use Reddit app.
- Can't have an anonymous account, must be tied to email.
- Can't have a non-age verified account, must have your ID
All whilst selling data to AI training companies.
Fuck off!
My 7 year acct is banned over an f-ing movie quote in a sub asking your favorite movie quote? I even cited and referenced to 2 MODs and even their AI said it's a quote. But since the quote "promoted violence" it was removed and now when I post on the acct it's shadow banned.
The quote came from Samuel L Jackson from the beginning of Jackie Brown when he started with "AK-47."
I wonder if you'd have gotten the same ban for sharing a "violent" quote by the same actor from a different Tarantino film.
Or would that one have been ok if you credited it to Pete Hegseth
I got banned for visiting my mother. No really. I decided to log on from her house, and the anti-bot bot noticed I was using a different IP address and flagged me for being a bot. Did the little dance to confirm I'm a real person, which resulted in a permanent ban. Thanks Reddit!
Today is my 3 year Lemmyversary, so I'm not exactly a new user. I mostly left Reddit after the API change, but did continue to use it lightly. Got banned about three months ago for commenting on a story about the IDF torturing a one year old baby in order to get information from the boys father. My comment said basically I can kinda see the terrorists' [against Isreal] point.
Honestly being banned for anti-Israel/anti-Zionism rhetoric is kinda a badge of honor.
Someone asked if a resuscitated prisoner has finished their life sentence, I said you have to be irrevocably dead, Reddit said that promoted violence.
Who hasn't been banned from a number of subs on reddit? It's a fascist place.
I don't know. I went back after leaving for ethical etc reasons and my old reddit account was reported suspended, but also doesn't come up in a search at all. I tried to read something on a web page on my computer, to which I've never logged into reddit, and it said something about blocked, and I couldn't even load the search suggestion, that had generated it, found it on another site, anyway. I miss my content, but the site is no loss, it's a bot heavy slow boil to Nazism.
I was sitewide banned for criticizing war thunder owner Gaijin on their own subreddit by saying they are biased to make russian vehicles always perform better than other nations at the same battle rating.
As far as I understood from others it's because subreddit mods have the power to sitewide ban... For some ridiculous reason. And in this case nobody at Reddit gave a damn or dared confront someone as big as Gaijin for someone as little as me.
Edit: at least I think that's why. Reddit bans are ambiguous as fuck. I remember trying to figure out why exactly but the message was similar to "banned because you broke tos" or some bullshit like that, with no link to an actual comment.
Reddit does seem to give subreddit mods a good deal of credit in their flags of users.
But a lot of it is dishonest, if you get traction criticizing a powerful group, they will find an unrelated reason to ban you. Because we have no rights to fair enforcement of the rules, they don't have to bother to make their accusations believable.
Israel is the main one I'm familiar with that they do this for, but all sorts of other stuff too.
bailed on the mod purge when they tried to tell mods how to mod their subs.
I deleted my account, remade another
Defended lgbt people and fought against racists
Got banned for being a bigot I think a few weeks later.
I have no idea why anyone would want to stay there, but I hope they do or the Lemmy communities will get overrun by nutjobs
There was no way to argue against the ban either. Seems that the current strategy is just reporting people who hate trump. As long as you have the right keywords, it might even be automated at this point
Whereas, on Facebook, nobody gets banned, and racist comments get promoted because they have the most engagement.. and the racists whinge that Facebook is getting blocked for kids
top 99 comments