Yeah, I don't think Lemmy is in any way toxic. It's a great place! If you found out (hypothetically) that you were the reason people were being scared away from a platform as awesome as this, I feel like you'd temper your responses. That level of antisocial behaviour is toxic, and worth talking about, even if there's worse out there, and we're not "as bad" as some spaces. Even if we're better, we can still strive to be better still. Evolution or personal growth, shouldn't stagnate or plateau. And your personal growth shouldn't be measured against and only a modicum above the worst out there.
It's not about being better than them. It's about personal growth, bringing people in, building a place where we're all included and inclusivity is a priority, they don't exist in that measure. They (the worst out there) have no relevance against it. We should all be striving to be better versions of ourselves, regardless of what's happening in the world. Learning, growing, being able to rethink your beliefs entirely, that's true wisdom. None of us want to be emotionally immature elders, that's not a good look.
I'm not really referring to the specific topics mentioned, because it'll be something different next week. Don't yuck someone else's yum. You don't have to snuff out their conversation with negativity, you can let it die in obscurity, scroll past, or post about other topics.
I absolutely believe everyone should have exposure to the information behind the evil JK Rowling. Personally I can't engage with those conversations in good faith.
And it's not that you can't say it, it's in how you say it. For instance, your mate Bobbo comes over and he's super excited to tell you about a new thing he's found he's in love with, he doesn't know the controversy around it that you do know about. You wouldn't trounce him. You couldn't look into Bobbos soft excited brown eyes and crush his hopes and dreams, and if you fell for a trap similarly, you would want to be told kindly. You might say, something like "oh man, I'm so sorry to tell you....(insert info here)" that's kindness, and you've still said the thing. Just imagine these people are your naive friend Bobbo and try not to crush his hopes and dreams, let him down easy!
It's so easy to incrementally backslide and become all sharp edges. It needs to be a continually moving machine, so if you're ever on the other side of it, you're brought back in with kindness. Kindness is a fucking power they can't take from us. Those running the corporation machines know squeezing us causes us to be cruel to each other. Kindness in the face of that wish, is rebellion!
Because yeah, we're fucking awesome here! I'm so proud, and grateful to be a part of this place. Let's keep working to build a better version of this place for others and reap the benefits of the better person that helps us, as individuals become, along the way.