Fuck that leaky browser. Asshole development.
post
Yet people keep recommending products by this scummy company and pile on Firefox for slightest missteps.
The bad news is, if you're not on Team Tux, you're going to have to pay $60 for Brave Origin. Granted, you only need to buy it once, and you'll get unlimited activations across all of your devices.
It's amazing people still believe this BS.
They'll probably hold to it for that exact product. If they rebrand it and add it back, that's no longer the same thing you paid for ;)
Ya, that's the really obvious take. That's teh way you do biz these days.
Like, that's what's gonna happen to all those 'lifetime' Plex accounts. Sure, you still have access to 'Plex-classic'. But you don't get any of the new Plextastic services ... unless you want to pay the $1,999 upgrade fee ...
If I get to use the exact product I paid for a lifetime account for forever that does kinda sound like exactly what I paid for.
Totally off topic, but I drink at a bar called Spaghetti Western!
Hillsboro, OR.
Reminds me of a joke:
My dad always warned us about Septic Tank Steve, and that we should never pay him to do anything, and we should have listened. One day Steve came by and said if we gave him a nickel, he'd swim around in the septic tank. We thought that was hilarious, so we gave him a nickel, and he swam around the tank a while. Then he came and sat next to us on the porch and said "If you want me to leave, gimme $100."
"Origin" is a peculiar choice for a version name. I wonder if they're trying to go off of the popularity of a common extension
I feel like if you're writing the sentence "an optional, paid version of our browser that offers Brave [...] without its extra features," you need to sit back and take a long, hard look at yourself.
Brave has always been a joke. And Brave users will always be a joke. And anyone who’s ever simped for Brave will always be a moron.
Rude. But not inaccurate. Brave pretends to be better than Chrome and Google, but also Mozilla and Firefox at the same time, though Firefox has always done it better and has never contributed to the chromium monopoly. Greed over diversification of the Web and competition between browser engines to effect real change. The least Brave could do is make their own engine.
when do you think brave will overtake firefox in share worldwide?
1 year, 2?
lol
Brave thinks its users are suckers
To be fair.....most of the general population are indeed suckers.
I don't use Brave, but one correction. From the article: "Brave sells Origin to strip added features—a $60 one-time fee (free on Linux). "
Brave thinks its Windows and OSX users are suckers, not its Linux users apparently.
The top comment on that site says you can already disable all of these features from within the settings. Is this true?
I think so, but it's spread among different menus and flags. Plus if even if you disable it, it's still there, one of the origin options sounds like it has it fully removed from the code.
It's true, if you don't want to spend 5 minutes customizing your browser to your needs you can use GitHub script that disables all of the features for you. But I don't see how feature like reader isn't handy, it often lets you bypass paywalls for free.
Brave Origin's main feature isn't what it adds but what it removes: it scraps email aliases, Leo AI, the VPN tool, the Brave Wallet implementation, and Speedreader, just to name a few features. You can either download a browser with all of those disabled, or you can upgrade your Brave browser with a panel that lets you tweak what ones you want to keep.
Are brave and Plex related?
No, but brave "shields", aka pre installed but shittier unlock origin, can sometimes break plex or other sites that require certain things that could look like trackers
I read the article.
But also I'm out of the loop on why ppl hate Brave. Can someone clue me in?
Is there a better cross-platform browser? I like to use the same one across devices.
I don't have a strong opinion on brave, but here's some reasons I can think of:
- cryptocoin shit
- based on chromium (so using this instead of firefox, for example, increases google's hegemony -- and this is true: even though chromium is open source, google completely controls its direction)
- CEO is a homophobe
- scammy business practices like inserting affiliate codes in urls
And this is just the stuff that I know from the top of my head. I don't particularly care about this topic, so I'm sure there's more. Although, having written all this out, I can sense that my opinion of Brave has worsened significantly.
Isn't it open source ? Can someone build a fork with all of this shit removed ?
Yeah I guess. Doesn't really change any of the arguments against it though. I mean, it's good that it's open source of course, but the ceo is still a homophobe, for example. And it still chromium based, and so on.
The CEO is a POS and has ties to other rich unsavory people
In the past they have done money grabs. It's been quite a while now.
They still run their own ad network and search engine, They're definitely down to sell you out if you let them.
If you never sign up for the crypto, or use the VPN, and remove the buttons, it won't hurt you.
If you run a plugin you can remove their newtab / default page
If you change the settings you can move off their search.
it is open source https://github.com/brave/brave-core
The only thing you're getting out of them that's above any other de-googled option is their anti-fingerprinting which is a little better than the others.
The other reason you'd run them is because they have a paid development staff blocking Youtube ads and they're not doing it at the plugin level, so it'll likely outlast the plugin models in Youtube's race to piss people off.
In the end, if you're in it for the paid blocking, doesn't hurt to pay them something if you're turning off all the stuff they're using to make money on you.
If you're in it for any other reason, there are literally dozens of forks you could use that give you the same experience that aren't trying to sell you as their product.
In the end, if you're in it for the paid blocking, doesn't hurt to pay them something
Well other than the LGBTQ community that the CEO funds legislation against, but they don't really matter /s
The CEO is a POS
I said that, but what do i know.
It's sold as a privacy-focused browser but it doesn't actually have a good track record or features for it. The company has made several questionable choices.
Firefox or fork of choice plus a couple of extensions
Firefox, or its fork Librewolf if you really value privacy.
Zen is just preselected no telemetry Firefox, also bleeding edge with Firefox updates
Brave is fine ish but they have issues, and a lot of them, which they usually fix within 24 hours but they've had a track record of like 8-10 issues per year, so just under once a month.
Don't downvote me to hell cause it's a reddit link, sorry, this is the most concise list I know of: https://www.reddit.com/r/browsers/s/AErPH6iMl0
Brave is the only browser I'm aware of whose "issues" rise to the level of "we're going to hijack your URL bar and insert our own affiliate links"
Apparently it was an auto complete issue that was fixed within 48 hours, but even still, there's always something wrong with Brave multiple times a year
Imagine actually believing that lol
Of course it was fucking intentional, they just got caught
I haven't heard of Zen and just checked out the wiki on it.
There are so many browsers! It's hard to decide. I've tried quite a few over the years. Been running Brave as primary for 3-4 years.
I appreciate the Reddit link. Yikes. I've noticed the enshittification of Brave but didn't know all the bad stuff they've done.
I do like that Brave works well on all my devices and sync is reliable. I don't like running different browsers on diff platforms.
Time to do some testing and research...
They hate the politics of one of the developers.
Edit: wtf. I've gotten downvoted to oblivion in the past for simply mentioning that Brave search has its own search index. Now I try to pass along the message of those downvoters and I get downvoted again.
It's so hard to find good things as it is. Adding in politics of devs adds yet another layer to it!
I recently started using FUTO keyboard and then learned someone they associate with is a bad dude.
It's like, come on guys. I'm trying to degoogle, avoid enshittification, and be privacy and security aware... and then there's this curveball that I have to factor in too.
Can we agree that Brave:
-
Is scummy.
-
Has a shady ceo, and a shady history.
-
Is possibly a security risk.
-
Is still orders of magnitude better than using Google Chrome.
And that:
-
This headline is both true and clickbait-ish.
-
You can turn these things off in Brave’s settings, for free.
-
That doesn’t make this feature not scummy.
Basically no one should be using Brave, but no one should be using Google Chrome either, yet here we are.
And the revolving door of “best unabandoned Chromium fork to use” (Helium for the moment, or Ungoogled Chromium if you don’t mind some broken features, just to name two), is buried under so much SEO that it’s legitimately difficult to research.
So… I’m not gonna go out of my way to flame Brave users. If they’re trying to do better than Chrome, good! Not-Google is good. They can pay for this I guess. I’m not installing Brave, though, I’m not recommending it, and this certainly isn’t making me want to.
use vivaldi if you want a chromium browser. its very customizable
Vivaldi concerns me a little, because I keep catching them trying to replace web addresses for major retailers with what appear to be affiliate links. For example, if I start typing the address for Amazon (I know, shitty company, but it's the first page that comes to mind) it will pop up an auto complete to click on. If I click it, I can see that I'm redirected to Amazon through what appears to be either an affiliate or a tracking link. However, if I type the address fully in the browser and don't use auto complete it takes me straight to Amazon, no redirecting or strange links popping up first. They do not disclose that they are doing this anywhere that I have found and I think it's shady as fuck. I don't have any extensions installed and it happens on multiple devices (phone, laptop, PC) and only on Vivaldi, so it's definitely the browser and not an untrustworthy extension or a compromised device.
Ooh, thank you. I get they need to make money, but I hate this. It also won't seem to turn off for me, I disabled the setting for direct match, deleted all my cookies and such, deleted the browser cache, and it's still popping up and still redirecting through the affiliate link. Boo.
Hmmm, that's weird, I didn't even realize this feature existed until I read your post. Guess I have always had it disabled, and I've never run into the issue. Have you also deleted the default bookmarks? The address bar will prefer bookmarks when you start typing an address, so if you don't delete the default ones that come with Vivaldi, they might be autocompleting?
I did delete the bookmarks, yes. I'll have to keep playing with it and see if I can make it stop, but it does make me feel a little better knowing what it is. I just wish they were more open and transparent about it. Seeing my browser just randomly redirecting me through third party links with no warning is alarming and makes me want to go find another browser and I've gone through like 6 in the last 2 years trying to find one I like.
This seems to be disabled for me on mobile, but enabled on the desktop. Seems like a helpful feature, though they could've just done something like Firefox where it's an offline search for a website with the same starting letters.
Still, appreciate the writeup and trying to minimize data collection while calling a 3rd party service in the browser and the option to disable it.
Catch it and report it
that might be the search engine you are using. that doesnt happen to me. i use amazon every day
I've been able to replicate with DuckDuckGo, Startpage, and Ecosia. Interestingly enough while testing it out to see if that was the issue I've noticed that it isn't happening every time, more like every other time. It redirects so fast it's easy to miss, but I was able to screen record and grab a screenshot of the link it's redirecting through. It's the same regardless of search engine.

Yeah. Or SRWare Iron, IIRC. Or DuckDuckGo or Orion on mobile. Cromite. Firefox, Zen, whatever.
There are tons of good options, certainly more than I know. But it’s a hard thing for the average person to research, especially when forks get abandoned or whatever.


top 100 comments