Remember folks, a lot of the republican playbook only works because people are this ignorant.
post
Do these people think that the city government pulls money out of thin air to fund these services? I really want to know what they think.
Right wing propaganda has many facets, and the one that targets the "muh taxes" crowd (and one they love to repeat thinking they are arguing in good faith) is the idea that their current taxes are already enough to cover all the municipal services they need, it's just "not being spent appropriately." They parrot conspiracy theories like embezzlement, kickbacks, handouts, unearned welfare, etc, so they can target other services they don't use and don't like. Public schooling and public libraries that challenge their religion, planned parenthood and women's health clinics that provide life-saving medical care, etc.
Why does this propaganda work?
- One, the believers are struggling financially like the rest of us, their wages have not kept up with inflation so they're trying to claw back any money they can.
- Two, companies are the real benefactors of low taxes, so they flood the zone with that nice simple catchphrase "cut taxes, rein in spending" so they piggyback on this political momentum.
- Three, these people are extremely uneducated so they need a nice simple world to understand, confronting systemic inequality and the demons of capitalism makes them angry because they struggle to understand the concepts.
The problem with this propaganda is that it's self-destructive, as the proponents keep taxes so low that the services they do use (public roads and bridges, functional waste management, clean air and water) are now degrading to the point they notice. Simultaneously, companies are cutting back operating expenses to make more money, so all the private services they use are degrading too. They're in too deep now, their pride and ego would never survive the admission that they were wrong, so they keep going down this irrational spiral. The only solution is more privatization: private roads, for-profit firefighters, and worse.
Stick with me for a moment ... The "problem" is that it is in fact true that there is "embezzlement, kickbacks, handouts, unearned welfare, etc".
But nothing about cutting taxes solves any of that! Audits, investigations, ENFORCEMENT OF EXISTING LAWS, etc solves it. Which, ironically actually costs money to do, but earns back the cost and then some. Well to a point, there are diminishing returns eventually for sure.
And that's when you REALLY get into the bad faith arguments because right wing propaganda loves to take a nugget of truth, generalize it across everyone especially "those people", and come up with exactly the worst possible solution that hurts those already hurting and turns a blind eye to the rich and corpos.
Based on my interactions on my local subreddit, people seem to think that the mayor/city councillors get to pocket any extra money coming in.
There is a not insignificant number of them that do. They rarely get prosecuted, and when they do, usually little to no money is retrieved and they just get a slap on the wrist. And reporting on that makes media companies millions of dollars from additional views and advertising revenue. Can you really blame people for thinking that it's happening everywhere all the time?
Most of our current issues stem from media companies either actively reporting misinformation because their billionaire owners gain from that... or media exaggerating things like this because it results in more advertising revenue. It's one of the reasons why independent publicly funded news is so important. No billionaire owners, and no advertising revenue to "optimize" for that ends up skewing towards inaccurate and overblown reporting.
Basic multi-step reasoning is something that around 40-45% of the U.S. population can not do. This includes simple math problems or a two-step logical reasoning.
College/university level education extensively teaches this type of thinking. This is why more education changes how people vote. Educated people are trained to connect the dots.
Voting to cut local property taxes results in less revenue for the local municipalities. Less revenue means municipalities have to cut services to match their budget.
A causes B, B causes C: 40-45% of the people voting are unable to complete this reasoning process.
So…if she…weighs the same as a duck…
And when it comes to reading comprehension, the situation worsens.
Only 13% of the population is proficient in these three areas: able to compare viewpoints in two editorials; interpret a table about blood pressure, age, and physical activity; or compute and compare the cost per ounce of food items.
Take these two things together and you can manipulate these people to hell and back, and that is exactly what is happening.
I can see why. The federal government literally does pull money out of thin air, they just kind of assume all levels of government can do that.
and the problem with pulling money out of thin air, is, of course, that it cheapens existing money. it's basically just an indirect form of taxation
I favor the MMT view that this is only true if the money supply increases without increasing the demand for money. Money is an accounting tool, a unit of currency represents a unit of economic activity. The danger is increasing the amount of currency without increasing economic activity because that leads to inflation - that's how you get wheelbarrows of money for bread.
War is inflationary. Building bombs creates some jobs, sure, but dropping those bombs leaves the whole world poorer.
Useful services aren't really inflationary, they grow the economy because people are happier and healthier and more productive.
Most city councils don't operate a mint and a central bank though..
I also was gonna point this out, but I think as sensible as MMT is, it's still way above the level of the conversations in these tweets
The problem comes from the other direction: people actually think the federal government gets its money from taxes. It's why they're always talking about federal spending as "tax dollars" and they criticize fraud and wars from the angle of "wasting tax money".
At this level of conversation people don't really know anything.
I mean, I don't blame people for that, governments of all stripes have been speaking about it that way for decades or longer...
No, it's more like "why don't they stop throwing money into the incinerator, are they stupid?"
The reality is that city budgets are some of the most highly scrutinized. They answer to the state, the feds, their bond holders and their voters, and are typically required to balance the budget.
You can still choose to allocate money differently or raise other taxes than residential. I don't know the exact playbook for your cities but mine has a financial problem and solves it by postponing expensive building projects, also playgrounds and cut support for the public pool. Anyway saying you pay less taxes = less service for you is not always correct. Also i feel like the lower the taxes the better. Public entities are champions in wasting money.
the city pulls money out of thin air all the time, for roads and fighting their citizens in lawsuits
No take! Only give!
Counterpoint: the lost revenue from cut taxes for the average person can easily be replaced by increasing the taxes for billionaires, businesses, and churches.
Where do you think "the budget" comes from? Here's the thing about municipal services: the things that you DO like (police, fire, city infrastructure, libraries, schools) are paid for by the things you DON'T like (taxes).
I actually do like taxes. They can reduce
- price inflation
- pollution
- urban sprawl
- inequality
And that's before even spending it on anything. Even throwing it in a big fire would be better than giving the rich unearned income.
Are there really people out there who don't realize this?
They're everywhere
'Murica is loud about it, but Greece is famous for stupidity around matters of tax, and that's just two examples
People forgot Trump's COVID policies killed a million people after a few short years. Education is severely lacking in the US.
I find it hilarious that people think that when taxes get cut, the Mayor will cut his own salary first. Those are typically the same people who always have money for cigarettes and beer no matter how tight their own budget.
George Carlin: “Think of how stupid the average person is, and realize half of them are stupider than that.”
The corralary to this is how everyone thinks they're in the top half
Ya, "Think of how stupid the average person is, and realize half of them are smarter than that!" doesn't stroke the ego quite as well.
In fairness, the type of person who listens to smart people and actually thinks & writes about things is more likely to be in the top half.
How do people not know that taxes pay for government services?
They think most of it is going into the pockets of politicians instead. While working in retail, I once had a customer that was totally convinced that a tax to fund 911 call centers didn't go to the call centers at all and went straight to the governor's pocket. These people have genuinely fully bought in to the idea that taxes are theft.
This is because of shit like the reflecting pool scam where tax dollars were routed directly to a trump family member via no-bid contracts.
Arguing that this shit mostly doesn't happen is awful tough when a counter example spent 2 months on the front page of cnn
It is theft, when the burden falls entirely on the lower classes while the corporations and politicians employ endless tactics to avoid paying their share. Its a form of theft when greedy politicians cut taxes only for the highest tax brackets or allow endless loopholes to prevent corporations from being taxed at all. There definitely are plenty of corrupt politicians that are also actively stealing from their constituents, but there's also the theft inherent in the capitalist system which is causing an ever-increasing burden to fall on those with the fewest resources at a time when their wages are also stagnant and inflation and cost of living are skyrocketing.
The lower and middle classes absolutely should have their taxes lowered, and be provided with better services, and corporate interests and corrupt politicians should be punished for interfering with politics and embezzling taxpayer money. But for that to happen it would have to be possible for someone to gain power at any level of government without millions of dollars of corporate sponsorships, and those people would have to somehow navigate through the existing political landscape that has been infested with capitalist leeches. The system is entirely rotten right down to its core.
I’ve been harping on this for a while. The tax cut proponents are the property investment companies and hoarders looking to skip out on more taxes and push the costs off on homeowners who will still have to pay somehow for municpal infrastructure and services. Those companies don’t live there, they don’t care, and all these anti-tax fools buying into these social media posts about not having kids in school or increasing home value being reasons to not have to pay, or pay a lot less. Probably wanting to privatize more services and make them subscription based.
I have a dog who absolutely refused to learn fetch. He loved to chase the ball, but would not ever bring it back. I had to fight with him every time to get the ball back.
This tweet gives me the same energy as "no take, only throw".
Btw he eventually learned to fetch. Not sure if this person is capable of the same development.
Honestly, where do these people believe the money comes from. Public services are funded by taxes, which have to come from somewhere. No money in means no services out.
Do people think public services are funded by unicorns and fairy dust?
"Why do we spend so much money on farm subsidies? It's the 21st century, just go to the grocery store."
Actual comment I've seen in the wild from someone who absolutely should know better, and likely makes more money than both of us. People don't understand how thing work. They understand very tiny bubbles of things that immediately impact them, and the rest is the invisible hand of God. The cell phone in their hand isn't a masterwork of artifice that took millions of man hours to delicately assemble. It just is. Why would they understand that taxes pay for public services?
What the fuck... It's times like that where I can't not interject and ask the obvious questions. Failing public education is fucking is all over
Yes. They also believe that efficient, well-run public systems are inexpensive, common and need little oversight from voters and elected officials.
The public sector is damned to deliver a service at half the cost, half the time, and twice the quality. Couple that with an ignorant public (I.e., United States) who vote for tax cuts and our services are a shitshow.
I guess Mexico is going to pay for it?
Some people think money just materializes out of thin air to pay for all their needs
How about we sell your municipally run sewage treatment to a private company? That'd be cool, right?
As much as you guys love to hate Florida.
The main issue is corruption.
People got tired of footing the bills, the taxes more than doubled in the last 6 years and somehow nothing beneficial happened, oh I guess a stupid baseball stadium got the roof repaired by taxpayer dollars with the notion of one day FEMA will reimburse it. For fucks sake, Chicken FIllet got permission to tear down houses and businesses to expand their parking lot. Besides, SunStar, a private EMS, will be there before the fire department EMS gets there. PD is stuck doing traffic stops all while people run red lights right in front of them; I literally saw that... more than once. There's government workers making 250k to almost 500k with the bennies.
So yeah all people see is a bigger bill. I get to pay for waterway treatment through the water bill AND the property tax. Like Fuck off, my water drains like shit. I see nothing happening but I'm paying for it. Welcome to Florida. This isn't a leopords ate my face, this a getting rear-ended by a leopard while your head is stuck in a fence.
Nah, this is still a Leopards Ate My Face moment, and I say this as a Florida resident who voted against it. It basically just helped centralize the corrupt power to the state level by removing a local source of revenue. So now local governments need to take flak by introducing new sources of taxation for revenue, cut services, or suck up to Desantis and his cronies to get State funding for anything.
It was plain as day from the second it was introduced. Tons of people warned about it non-stop. Anyone who still thought this was a good idea is a fuckin moron.
Our local government doesn't do shit for us anyway. My city's mayor just got caught on a hot mic calling someone a "fucking idiot" for being against data centers, they secretly approved a data center BEFORE asking the people if we were okay with it, and now the city tried to SUE THEIR OWN RESIDENTS because we wouldn't vote to give them more money for Flock cameras and shit. So its either we lower our taxes and get fucked on the services, or we keep paying and get fucked on the services.
Yep. The potholes remain, the sewage issues stay, and we still pay. But, hey, let's build more shit apartments and data centers. And yeah it's nice to see a camera in a parking lot, I feel so safe. And all the homeless people have to find out where they have to go now because it's snow turd season so it can't look bad. It's like my 30k home is made up to be worth 500k, it's all bullshit.
"Tax cuts" has become a dog whistle for cutting services to the unworthy poor. It's just an extension of Starve the Beast.
As someone that left FL in 2024, corruption is 100% the problem.
I talk about it a lot. The power companies and insurance companies are funding GOP campaigns. That's why rates are going up so much. It will continue indefinitely. A substantial portion of your power bill and insurance bill go directly to funding the campaigns of individuals that are directly against the best interest of 95% of the citizens of the state, and that's why there will be absolutely NO relief. It's by design.
That's aside from the systemic compromise of voting systems that's been in place ever since the hanging chads.
This is how a lot of Americans think, unfortunately. They want the best possible public services and infrastructure, but they don't want to pay for any of it. It's the ultimate entitlement mentality. They want everything but they don't want to have to pay anything. They don't care who does end up having to pay for it all so long as it isn't them.
And if anything gets taken away, they want it taken from other people and not them. They don’t want undeserving people taking what they’ve “earned.”
I mean for the vast majority, the ones who would have been middle class 50years ago, that's probably in part because of a misguided sense of class consciousness. They recognize that their money and their labor is getting them less and less with each passing day.
The truth is, the average person shouldn't have to pay more. They should, in fact, be paying much less. But that would require a total restructuring of the political and economic system, and redistributing the trillions of dollars that have been stolen and forcibly extracted by the oligarchs. Instead of acting like it's utter entitlement to not expect taxes on the average person to keep raising with nothing to show for it while the rest of your wages also suffer from a massive decrease in spending power, you should be trying to help these people understand that if they want lower taxes for themselves, they need to demand higher taxes on the rich and corporations.
Or better yet, that capitalist democracy is a complete contradiction and an utterly failed experiment.
Instead of acting like it's utter entitlement to not expect taxes on the average person to keep raising with nothing to show for it
Our Federal budget is especially misallocated, with much of the money going to a massively bloated military industrial complex that absolutely should not be as large as it is. That's true. But, nearly half of the budget is just Medicaid, Medicare and Social Security. The recipients of those programs would not say that they have "nothing to show for" the taxes they've paid. In fact, there are many millions of Americans for whom those programs are absolutely essential.
It is true that anyone under the age of Medicare and Social Security eligibility, or who is ineligible for Medicaid, doesn't directly get anything from those programs, even though they are helping to pay for them. Although, I would argue that we all benefit from living in a society where the poor and elderly are not destitute or left to suffer and die for not having the money to pay for necessary healthcare themselves. That said, I would certainly prefer Medicare eligibility to be expanded to everyone, but that would increase the Medicare budget, probably significantly.
while the rest of your wages also suffer from a massive decrease in spending power
Part of the reason we have persistent inflation is that we pay for our Federal budget with debt that must be repaid with interest. Interest on the debt is 14% of the total Federal budget, at nearly $1 trillion. That's almost $1 trillion every year just to pay the interest in our Federal debt. If we don't increase taxes and cut spending to pay down the debt we'll just have to keep borrowing more money creating a never ending spiral of new debt chasing after old debt.
I think there's a better way: the US Federal government is a sovereign currency issuer. Basically, the Federal government makes its own money and it can make as much as it needs to. The Treasury department could theoretically go to the Federal Reserve and say, "hey we need $7 trillion to fund the government this year," at which point the Federal reserve goes over to their little Federal reserve computer, types in $7 trillion and hits send. That money goes to the Treasury department, the Treasury funds the government and there's no debt that needs to be repaid and no interest expense.
But, I know. Inflation. If the Federal reserve is creating trillions of dollars every year that's being added to the money supply through Federal spending, there's going to be inflation. That's where taxes come in. Use taxes to manage inflation by taking money out of the money supply. Increase taxes during times of higher inflation, decrease taxes during times of lower inflation.
If that idea scares people because it's too novel or radical, then I don't see any other option than austerity. We're going to have to cut spending and raise taxes to turn the budget deficit into a surplus to pay down the debt. Of course any tax increases should be progressive, with high income earners paying more, and we should cut any unnecessary spending, but if we're going to make a dent in our $40 trillion of debt, taxes will have to be increased across the board.
This is about Florida. Did they pass their ballot measure on property values subject to property tax initiative? This was definitely the outcome that would follow if it had.
In the pyramid schemes upon pyramid schemes we've built modern society off of (when I say we I mean boomers...) property taxes and suburb utilities are a ticking time bomb. They're a part of the reason housing is unaffordable. It creates a strong incentive for the city to do things that make property more expensive... because that's how they get more money from property taxes without "raising" them.
Utilities are part of the same problem. The number of residents served per 100m of pipe is abysmal. If homeowners had to pay the full price of utilities and their externalities (40-60 year lifespan, $1-2 million per km) you wouldn't want to live in the suburbs... Utilities would absolutely destroy you even more than they are currently. New builds at the margins of the city are what pay for your deferred maintenance within an existing neighborhood. Except if you stop building new buildings, who pays? Also, not nearly enough money is being put aside to maintain existing utilities which all need work in giant gluts that mirror past building booms.
It's also why infill housing is massively more expensive than it needs to be because for old neighborhoods, new builds are still what pays for utilities and their maintenance. So all of the deferred maintenance funding that should be coming from the surrounding 50 boomer houses is foisted onto one infill building (not all cities work like this but my hometown did.)
Thankfully it all implodes some day and nobody can stop it.
Side note: Taxes like income taxes are supposed to give the government incentive to raise people's incomes. What about a tax that goes up as cost of living goes down? Wouldn't that be funny? haha the government would actually be strongly incentivized to lower our cost of living since they could claw a portion of that savings back as tax revenue. Funny idea...
in the immortal words of Ron White, "you can't fix stupid". pointing out that less money results in less service will not register. It must be said, but know it will not be understood by the stupid.
after all, to them less money means, 'cut the waste and fraud' which in their view always exists. no amount of math or exposed accounting will change their minds. most of the cost is still "waste and fraud", unless it is something that benefits them personally - then it is a sacred cow.
Seem too, that a lot of people don't know what fractional reserve banking is, and how the Federal Reserve has stolen trillions. And tis jus Ame. Other countries hav larcenied differently.
In the most general case for a sovereign state with its own currency, cutting taxes does not necessarily mean having to cut government spending, because government spending comes first: It spends (creating new money, i.e. new debt) to later collect some of it back via taxes (deleting old money, i.e. old debt). Depending on political rules regarding debt, though, municipalities may not have money creation capability and be only money users like other private actors.
It’s not even that there’s less.
There was a sebtance that said all cities/municipalities can extend the exemption to the full cost (aka just 100% get rid of property tax basically) so, we’re fucked.
Yes they must use all $0 they get for services! Woo!!!!! What a good bill!!!! Save me money (maybe $2000 a year max?) and save billionaires money (like, save Bezos a cool 2 million a year. We don’t need that tax revenue) and make them… have nothing… to spend on services…. Coooooooooooooooooool.




all 100 comments