you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 4 points 13 hours ago (1 child)

I mean for the vast majority, the ones who would have been middle class 50years ago, that's probably in part because of a misguided sense of class consciousness. They recognize that their money and their labor is getting them less and less with each passing day.

The truth is, the average person shouldn't have to pay more. They should, in fact, be paying much less. But that would require a total restructuring of the political and economic system, and redistributing the trillions of dollars that have been stolen and forcibly extracted by the oligarchs. Instead of acting like it's utter entitlement to not expect taxes on the average person to keep raising with nothing to show for it while the rest of your wages also suffer from a massive decrease in spending power, you should be trying to help these people understand that if they want lower taxes for themselves, they need to demand higher taxes on the rich and corporations.

Or better yet, that capitalist democracy is a complete contradiction and an utterly failed experiment.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 1 point 3 hours ago* (last edited 2 hours ago)

    Instead of acting like it's utter entitlement to not expect taxes on the average person to keep raising with nothing to show for it

    Our Federal budget is especially misallocated, with much of the money going to a massively bloated military industrial complex that absolutely should not be as large as it is. That's true. But, nearly half of the budget is just Medicaid, Medicare and Social Security. The recipients of those programs would not say that they have "nothing to show for" the taxes they've paid. In fact, there are many millions of Americans for whom those programs are absolutely essential.

    It is true that anyone under the age of Medicare and Social Security eligibility, or who is ineligible for Medicaid, doesn't directly get anything from those programs, even though they are helping to pay for them. Although, I would argue that we all benefit from living in a society where the poor and elderly are not destitute or left to suffer and die for not having the money to pay for necessary healthcare themselves. That said, I would certainly prefer Medicare eligibility to be expanded to everyone, but that would increase the Medicare budget, probably significantly.

    while the rest of your wages also suffer from a massive decrease in spending power

    Part of the reason we have persistent inflation is that we pay for our Federal budget with debt that must be repaid with interest. Interest on the debt is 14% of the total Federal budget, at nearly $1 trillion. That's almost $1 trillion every year just to pay the interest in our Federal debt. If we don't increase taxes and cut spending to pay down the debt we'll just have to keep borrowing more money creating a never ending spiral of new debt chasing after old debt.

    I think there's a better way: the US Federal government is a sovereign currency issuer. Basically, the Federal government makes its own money and it can make as much as it needs to. The Treasury department could theoretically go to the Federal Reserve and say, "hey we need $7 trillion to fund the government this year," at which point the Federal reserve goes over to their little Federal reserve computer, types in $7 trillion and hits send. That money goes to the Treasury department, the Treasury funds the government and there's no debt that needs to be repaid and no interest expense.

    But, I know. Inflation. If the Federal reserve is creating trillions of dollars every year that's being added to the money supply through Federal spending, there's going to be inflation. That's where taxes come in. Use taxes to manage inflation by taking money out of the money supply. Increase taxes during times of higher inflation, decrease taxes during times of lower inflation.

    If that idea scares people because it's too novel or radical, then I don't see any other option than austerity. We're going to have to cut spending and raise taxes to turn the budget deficit into a surplus to pay down the debt. Of course any tax increases should be progressive, with high income earners paying more, and we should cut any unnecessary spending, but if we're going to make a dent in our $40 trillion of debt, taxes will have to be increased across the board.

  • source
  • parent