post
If someone who's been to a fancy art school mutilates a sheep and puts it on public display, then it's "thought-provoking" and "challenging the perception of what art is", but if I do it then I'm "disturbed" and "a sociopath".
I don't know why people are so upset. If somebody pulled off a scenario like the comic happening consistently to passersby, the idea of being part of the art through the author predicting my behavior, and then finding out they described the actions I just did ahead of time, seems fun.
The thing is that it is only that, all the time, who comes up with the edgiest/smartest "thing".
Like the dude who exposed "nothing" (it's literally nothing) and sold it for $18.000.
You get a certificate, like for the banana taped to a wall (how to change the banana etc).
It's just a luxurious scam.
And people who like art get annoyed by it because they steal the show and the money from real artists, who can no longer make art because you can't live off of nothing...
If you buy it, you also need to buy the banana taped to the wall to feed them.
It's on purpose. It's rich folks making up an impenetrable world for outsiders so they can signal to each other they're in the inner circle.
Kinda how the whole collective noun thing like murder of crows came to be. That too was just an intellectual game by rich folks and using the wrong one showed you weren't inner circle.
Now I'm curious, what's the story about the murder of crows, or am I missing something?
It's on purpose. It's rich folks making up an impenetrable world for outsiders so they can signal to each other they're in the inner circle.
Having been to "community art galleries", I can say it's got nothing to do with rich folks. There's the exact same things happening with things of no or very little monetary value. This is just pretentious people participating in a an eternal "emperor's new clothes" of "art".
A lot of big art is tax evasion and bullshit yes, but I've been a gallery worker. There is a very real love of art shit and that way of viewing and talking about the world, legitimately, that runs through the entire field.
Think of how many trod on, burned out game lovers work in the bullshit over-financialised games industry.
It's a real tragedy what the MBAs did to the creative fields.
Art History and Art Theory is available for anybody. Go visit your local library.
This is a prime example of willful ignorance to think that anything you don't know or understand is meaningless and a conspiracy. This is how religious fundamentalists and MAGA idiots approach the world. Don't be one of those idiots my dude.
Besides money laundering, art like this functions by making people talk about it and consider the presented idea. If that's not art, then I don't know what is.
There was a piece recently called "take the money and run". The artist borrowed a stack of cash that was supposed to be positioned on a display, but then he just took the money and ran. That made both the art and crime news several times. Good stuff.
art like this functions by making people talk about it and consider the presented idea
You can also talk about how stupid and pointless art piece is. If "talking about it" is the criteria then there's no criteria. Anything and everything can be "art" which is exactly what people are complaining about. Art should require some skill and talent, should have some meaning and should affect people in some way.
On my last visit to Madrid I visited both Prado and Museo Reina Sofia. In Prado every room has pieces that really struck you, even if you're not any kind of expert on art. In Reina Sofia you struggle to find anything interesting. That's why so many people dismiss "modern art". It's just a snobfest with people trying to outsnob one another.
It can be both. I consider something art if it communicates something that could not have been stated otherwise. Lots of modern art fails at that.
There was this one guy who made a piece in which he raised the water surface in a fountain by urinating in the fountain. It's a funny idea, but the entire idea was already in the description, so the act of actually doing it wasn't art in my opinion.
Anything and everything can be βartβ which is exactly what people are complaining about.
I'm sure you don't mean it this way but to me your comment sounds like the kind of thing an art snob would say.
So other people can complain about it and that's fine because then it's not for them. Personally, I love all that weird shit and appreciate the skill and talent to craft meaningful experiences that affect some people.
Imo anyone who is trying to express something interesting to them by arranging the world to express it (be that arranging pigments, pixels, people, or even situations like in the joke comic) is pretty neat. I might not like it all, but I appreciate.
PS I'm not meaning this in any kind of antagonistic way. Like, I respect your subjective experience, I just don't share it.
No, I think we agree. I also think that anything that "is trying to express something interesting to them by arranging the world to express it is pretty neat". The thing is that most of the "modern" art doesn't really does that. Just putting something together that doesn't convey any idea, just "is there" doesn't count as art for me. Like this "painting" costs $14k:

It's just manufactured by dozens of assistants in a big workshop, slapping dots on canvases all the time. How is that "art"? If this is "art" anything designed by anyone is. Like a t-shirt from Zara is art and a bicycle is art. It doesn't convey any ideas, it's just worth money because a famous "artist" signed it. And modern art is full of cases like that: become famous by doing weird stunts and "going viral", cash out by doing anything, really. It's pointless.
I'm more lenient in my definitions maybe, but I think we do see eye to eye. I try to sidestep what constitutes "art" because it's so often muddied to mean just whatever we approve of. So for that matter I do think art can be anything, which makes the term meaningless, which is fine by me.
But yeah someone trying to express something...weirdly is probably the best definition I can think of. Effort and intent matter as much as taste and execution imho (opinions will vary wildly).
I think what I object to more is monied art, or art that exists within the cynical gallery industrial complex. I don't really care if art is low-effort, that's fine, but putting a $1M pricetag on anything that is not worth that in raw materials to me is missing the point.
I know artists like to kind of play rich people, but they don't realise how much they've been corrupted by their money.
If that's not art, then I don't know what is.
Probably an oil painting or something idk
These types of threads always reveal just how many people (its not necessarily the majority but always more than I'd hope) are utterly tasteless and interpret even the slightest artistic challenge as a scam and attack. It's pathetic. And the idea that it's all money laundering. "I don't understand it so it must be money laundering". Meanwhile half of these people's idea of great art is big titty hentai from some gooner mmo or at best super realistic pencil drawings because its simple enough for the uninitiated to appreciate the difficulty of (difficulty being the only metric the artless have to measure art). If you have ever spoken to an actual artist or gone to an actual art show you would find that there are very legitimate artistic reasons for these "pretentious" displays. Very very few artists are rich, very very few even try to be rich. Yet these stupid ideas abound because people are afraid to think for themselves and when they see an art installation that looks simple or silly or seems confusing or pointless, it triggers some deep Neanderthal instinct that it is a scary enemy and must be made fun of. No wonder artists are in their own circles, if this is the kind of idiocy to be found in the general public.
What does "sitting on Lady's piece" mean in this context?
Shit like this makes me remind everyone that the CIA heavily promoted this kind of "art" all through the cold war bcs they were afraid any real art or culture would lead people to communism.
all 44 comments