80% (or something crazy high) of all malware for android came from the google play store directly. Yet some how forcing you to only use the google play store is going to make you more safe.
post
Android dev here. They already slow forced it on developers, at different times, so as to cause less of a stir.
This happened over a month ago to me, so I removed all my apps from the play store.
The people running the keepandroidopen site refused to even consider a PR I had for a unified developer strike, and I don't have the energy to run something like this, so developer id is going through without any pushback.
well i assume this is bad news if you happen to religiously use revanced...
guess i better get going on a graphene install
Revanced is old news, you should switch to Morphe!
But I highly recommend GrapheneOS. I've been running it on my Pixel 8 Pro for 2+ years and it's been lovely.
guess i better get going on a graphene install
the pixel 10a's put their unlock button above the volume rocker and now it drives be crazy going between my phones -- be aware of this truly awful pitfal :p
I think all Pixels has always had the power button above the volume one.
Fuck this. Installing Graphene on my pixel 9 tomorrow
Does anyone know what happens if you already have "sideloading" enabled? What happens to my "sideloaded" apps? Do they disappear / get disabled until I turn the work around back on? Do I lose any data associated with them?
Yeah that's my immediate worry. I install too many apps for reasons irrational and a lot of them are not from the Play store. Yes, we have ways to bypass this a users whether "officially allowed" or otherwise, but it seems like nobody knows, or no one in google is blowing the whistle.
It's sad already to see some FOSS devs said they will stop developing apps when this comes around, or that some will not support whatever issues coming from this policy, or something yo that effect. This is on top of hand coding devs being pushed out by vibe coders.
They won't disappear for now. But, new installs will require verification and a 24hr wait period before installing apps from outside google play.
Every day, I'm thankful I switched to a (GNU/)Linux phone.
Tell us more, please (a sincere request); I was sort of under the impression that Linux phones where still in the "not-ready-for-primetime" category, but maybe this is no longer the case. What do you think?
It depends, to a degree, on what you're looking for; I'm using an FLX1s+ which uses the Android kernel which works with the device in order to get around some otherwise hardware compatibility issues. So it won't be the mainline kernel but the tradeoff is that much of it works (including calling and texting so I can use it as, you know, a phone). It even has an Android container running LineageOS so you can run Android app.s (though some, even with MicroG, don't work). And, while there are some spots that still need ironing out, they release updates every two months and the edge bits which aren't working or need polishing keep getting their gaps closed.
If you want something that's on the mainline kernel, I can't speak to, as much; I keep wanting to see if I can find a OnePlus 6T (even if used) to try Mobian or BengalOS on but, well, money's tight, as it is.
But I've been daily driving the phone I have since the beginning of this year and that means, when Google pulls crap like this, I just don't have to worry. Maybe it'll get, someday, to the point that the Adnroid container can't work but I'm willing to go without being able to run Android app.s if it means I can have a smart phone that can reliable call and text and is running GNU/Linux.
What does this mean for users of F-Droid on Graphene? And for F-Droid users who don't?
Would this affect eos? I'm guessing not since the playstore is optional there?
See also, if you haven't already: https://lemmy.ml/post/55520114
Sideloading means installing. The fascist department of war contractor is attempting to dictate what you are allowed to install on your own phone.
Here are the steps to bypass verification:
- Enable developer options by tapping the software build number in About Phone seven times
- In Settings > System, open Developer Options and scroll down to “Allow Unverified Packages.”
- Flip the toggle and tap to confirm you are not being coerced
- Enter device unlock pin/password
- Restart your device
- Wait 24 hours
- Return to the unverified packages menu at the end of the security delay
- Scroll past additional warnings and select either “Allow temporarily” (seven days) or “Allow indefinitely.”
- Check the box confirming you understand the risks.
- You can now install unverified packages on the device by tapping the “Install anyway” option in the package manager.
That would work, but it deters people away from installing apps from outside Google Play in the first place. Here is a quote from the homepage of keepandroidopen.org.
Nine steps, 24-hour wait, buried in Developer Options, delivered through a proprietary service that Google can revoke whenever they want. That's not sideloading. That's a deterrence mechanism built to ensure almost nobody completes it. And since it runs through Play Services rather than the OS, Google can tighten or kill it silently.
This needs to be a sticky on all comms about phones and Android.
Who knows how long this will be an option for or when they will add even more dark patterns to the bypass procedure
For existing GrapheneOS users, I don't think this is required or even an option. At least it's not as of this moment after the latest update today.
I also don't see these options but I have been tweaking things hard for a bit. Would still love to get on a Linux phone that fits my usecases.
Can you remove the developer mode after this? If not then none of my banking apps will work.
I can't test it out to help you but I am guessing not
I'm in developer mode and my banking app works fine. Is this something new?
I guess it's time to switch my fairphone 6 to Nura. Too bad about the NFC payments,but I can soldier through.
I support the move to Linux. I'd also suggest keeping the Fairphone on hand, or maybe a Pixel with GrapheneOS as a side phone in case you run into issies with daily-driving Nura.
I cheer you on brave soldier 🫡
Life without NFC isn't too bad, I use Graphene so i can't use GWallet, but i always have my physical wallet and card on me. Plus think about it, if you lose your phone you don't lose your method of payment too!
We need regulation. Unregulated capitalism does not work with monopolies.
I would like to know where I can complain. Does EU have some way to submit issues like this?
BTW, Developer Options now has "Apps from unverified developers". You can start the advanced flow already, and see for yourself how ridiculous it is.
I was hoping to be on GrapheneOS by the time this rolled out, but I need my Click Communicator to arrive first (work apps), and it was just delayed because of the Republican/Israeli war on Iran constructing international supply lines.
We're in the darkest timeline.
Google already has app verification.. Something called scan installed apps in Playstore
This is developer identification and has nothing to do with app verification
Only requirement is for Google to verify the app!
Add to the mix that android 17 silently blocks all you app from accessing local network.... Goodby self hosting....
Yeah, you can bypass, but it's a permission you need to enable, and "normal" people will just complain that doesn't work...
And this is why after I replaced the battery of my phone and do a complete wipe, I installed De1984 and not let any Google-related apps to have internet access This means though that any banking app would not work in my phone
My next device will be running Nura. Android can go fuck right off.
why are you downvoted?
I call them my downvote fairies.
When you are a human rights activist that speaks against fascism, bigotry, and genocide, you tend to get downvoted on every thing.
I'm proud of my auto down votes.
oh... had to check by myself, it's funny they all come from the same instance 😅
where can i get those?
I have not followed too closely. Will this affect GrapheneOS in any way? Or will it be able to run both verified and non-verified apps?
Google says almost all developers have already gotten on board with verification.
Because they don't have a choice?
Well yeah, I put a gun to his head and the dude did everything I said!
Here's another link on the topic: Keep Android Open
Screw google and their bait-and-switch tactics.
In its current state I won't effect anyone here all to much. Its mostly fear mongering to prevent the average user from leaving play store but has a lot of potential for enshitification
So no more side loaded apps?
From reading the article, it looks like not exactly but kinda yes. You can still get unverified apps but need to jump through a ton of settings to get them.
You will be able to re-enable it after the update. But you'll be forced to wait 24 hours.
ADB will be unaffected.
It sucks but I can wait 24 hours one time before updating my FOSS apps again. But they definitely could push this too far and I'll be on GOS if I must.
Please could anyone clarify whether apps deemed as "undesirable" by Google are blocked after the 24 hour period is over?
Estimate that 90% of my apps are not from the Play Store, Google might take exception to some such as Obtainium, Grayjay etc (if not now, in the future). Does it restrict what we can install or just enforce a 24 hour restriction for installing from alternative sources?
An OS update recently came through which I think includes the 24 hour restriction so I've not installed yet.
I despise these Big Tech nannies dictating how we use our hardware. The faster Linux phone matures the better.
all 25 comments