Now do wage theft, specifically by retailers
post
Wow that’s a big amount! At that amount, groceries might as well do the ethical thing and… hire back real fucking people to do the checkout!
The Home Depot by my house has a clerk at each self checkout to scan your stuff for you
At the Lowe’s you have to hunt one down and drag them to the cage you need unlocked.
Then they carry the item for you (you can’t be trusted not to run) and then watch you self check.
It’s honestly demoralizing and if I don’t need it that day I’m getting it on Amazon.
Fuck buying anything on Amazon though
I have family that worked at one of the amazon warehouses.
I already hated the company, but having heard firsthand how nightmarish it is there, we dont engage with anything in the online retailer space now.
I'd sooner drive my ass to a shop in the middle of nowhere to buy something.
I worked in one of their offices. Pretty crazy there, too. High turnover due to the fact that you're doing the work of 1.5 people. Which is why you're constantly bailing out your co-workers and helping them with their work, so you can't get your work done, and then you get in trouble... (And before you say anything, I couldn't say no, because my manager said yes to that)
I used to get downvoted on reddit saying shit like this. I'm so happy to see this comment, with the fucking swearing too
They did this for us too, fucking weird. Like they regret ripping out all of their normal checkstands and trusting people. Now as a normal customer I feel like I'm not trusted, and it makes me angrier at them. Just hire cashiers back damnit, I want to dump my stuff on the belt.
walmart does that here during thanksgiving weekend.. it's way slower than at a regular register, and still slower than if we did it (legitimately and accurately) ourselves.
Walmart is doing this in Canada. But fuck Walmart anyway, nothing about what they do is ethical.
I'm actually hoping for the old old school grocery model where you just hand the guy your list of shelf stable goods to gather for you from a warehouse style store, then get your fresh goods directly from the supplier by delivery or in an open market.
Depending on how you feel about the gig economy and the permanent under class that is required to make it work this already exists.
Our local (regionalish) grocery chain had this service over 2 decades ago and it required no gig employees.
I think Stop & Shop/Giant/Whatever they are called in your market does it all in house too.
Or rather, have the butler arrange it.
No this was actually just how the average person shopped until the early 1900s when Piggly Wiggly opened.
This probably makes me a less profitable customer, but I'm checking cans for dents, eggs for cracks, picking the milk, bread, etc with best dates and selecting the best produce I can or not buying it. I don't really trust the store to do all that.
Trying to make it sound like it's everyones problem. They are stillmaking wild profits, right?
Wage theft in 10 states alone is worth $8 billion.
https://www.epi.org/publication/employers-steal-billions-from-workers-paychecks-each-year/
I’m feeling that that $10B number is rounded well up for corporate insurance fraud.
What do you mean? They take that $10 worth of stolen items and then multiply it by the lost future growth from not having that money in the bank at 400% growth per year for the next 42,000 years. It's allvery simple and straight forward.
Just like hospitals charging your insurance $300 for a simple Tylenol.
This isn't a crisis, this is awesome. Why wouldn't we give ourselves discounts?
No, see, we were told that self-checkout was going to save money. We're just making sure that's getting passed on to the consumer.
I gotta hand it to them, they were right, I'm saving fucking heaps.
Not that I mind some percentage of my cost subsidizing those who cannot afford something they need, provided those items are distributed fairly and someone isn’t just taking more than they need. But what’s annoying is they now don’t have to pay a cashier, instead I have to do that work (for free), and where does that “savings” go?
I have ZERO problem with people experiencing poverty taking money from the large corporations who screwed them over.
The wealthy treated thriving as zero-sum, and they deserve to be the losers. 100%.
But they’ll distribute that loss back to paying customers.
You think that if theft drops they'll pass the savings on to customers?
They'll squeeze as much as possible out of customers regardless of costs.
That’s my point. The cost of theft is already rolled into the regular price.
No the cost is as high as they can make it for maximum profits. The theft is just the cost of doing business. It's not marked up because of theft.
No the cost is as high as they can make it for maximum profits
No, it isn't. They often keep them down as they are trying to compete with other shops. Although lately most have given up being cheaper and just go with some of their products are as cheap as Aldi.
Still, past few years they have been pushing extremely cheap veg just before Christmas each year. Like you can get 5kg of veg for 10p in some shops. I pickled a bunch of it last year.
Sure, its a loss leader. But I was filling my bags with that and nothing else. Maybe some of their cheapest vinegar.
While I am not exactly pro-theft, I will say that your argument is structurally and conceptually wrong.
Competition drives prices down, demand drives prices up. Companies will always charge as much as they can get away with. They will raise the price to the maximum the market can bear even without theft. The only effect that theft might have on prices is to lower them. With enough theft demand will drop therefore the market will not bear the same high prices.
Why would they be competing with other shops if not for maximum profit? They aren't lowering prices out of the goodness of their hearts. The point is theft isn't driving prices up, they're already doing what they can to maximise profits and the theft just eats into that a little bit along with all other business costs.
Obviously competitors would drive prices down, but that's because of competition and because keeping higher prices would no longer maximise profits. But, lately they've been getting record profits while people are really struggling.
They often keep them down as they are trying to compete with other shops. Although lately most have given up being cheaper
Listen to yourself, dawg. Read the words that you wrote. They simply aren’t keeping their prices down to compete with other shops, lol. Rather than theft raising prices, it’s more like theft is planned into the business model, and thus ultimately harmless. Also the vast majority of theft from grocery stores is by employees, but let’s not even go there.
Sounds like a reason to steal the amount its already in the cost for then!
Then stop shopping at Walmart. Support a small local business that employs people as cashiers
I wonder if I sent walmart a bill for my time spent scanning groceries theyd pay it...
So, what you're saying is that since retailers keep using them, self checkout has been funneling more than $10b annually from the economy (by way of human wages) into corporate profits.
It's just another way for them to launder money. $2b or less actually gets stolen/lost, they call it $10b and pocket the $8b difference.
Legitimate defense IMO. If you did the things to the best of your knowledge you're scot free. The rest is up to the retailer.
If they give a shit they should staff the store or make changes to the process. And if the customers hate it, hopefully the retailer dies because they weren't smart enough to adapt to the changing market place.
But that would require a functioning society and legal system.
It’s almost like this thing we all hated and didn’t want wasn’t a good idea.
"National crisis"
LOL, $10 billion is the billionaire's problem. Why is $10 billion a lot when we're stealing from them, but not when they're stealing from us?
The industry term is shrinkage, not theft, for good reason. The inventory doesn't match their sales, which means that it could be any number of problems including spoilage, waste, breakage, scanning errors, inventory errors, or finally, theft. Assuming a fixed percentage of shrinkage being theft when you're reflowing the entire checkout process is naive.
Plenty of people make honest mistakes because they're not trained cashiers, and only do one transaction per week. They're not going to be as efficient or accurate as someone who does hundreds of transactions per day, and assuming that it's theft feeds into the corporate bosses' incorrect worldview that the losses aren't their own fault, it must be someone else screwing with them.
Shrinkage can also come from internal operational error, which happens a lot more frequently when you don't pay your employees enough to care about their jobs.
This isn't really the fault of self check out as a thing as much as it is the inadequacies of the human element still required to oversee the checkouts. 1 person standing at the end of of the area is clearly insufficient. Hire more people, ya cheap bastards.
Oh, and those people aren't going to do anything, even if they think someone is stealing.
I don't blame them.
Last time I bought frozen burritos I just grabbed the box instead of getting the dozen out individually and brought it to self checkout with the rest of my crap. I was adjusting the quantity when a very stern redshirt appeared at my elbow.
"Can I help you?"
"I don't think so, just checking out."
"How many are in that box?"
"It says there's 12, I didn't count them."
She then makes a big show about counting the $2 apiece frozen burritos and finishing my ring up. Lady, did you think I was hiding a PS5 in there or something? What the fuck. Some people just enjoy the tiny power rush, I guess.
next up: mandatory self-checkout licenses
no more staffed check outs! every adult has to have state issued self-checkout operation license
licenses are mandatory to enter stores, applying for license takes a fee, you've got to renew them every five years, each store might require applying for additional supplementary training and paid supplementary stamp in your license paid in a subscription model
each scanning session will be recorded and analyzed, any and all mistakes are eligible for instant vindication, yt DMCA strike style
check out times will be measured, slacking off may invalidate your license and make you retake courses and exam
Tesco are not far off doing all of that here. Its "optional" but they charge you more if you don't get it.
no way, how do they call it?
They call it a clubcard. Very frequent to see things like £2 or £3.50 if you don't have a clubcard.
Children can't get a clubcard because they are too young to consent to the data harvesting/selling. You don't need one to use regular self checkouts yet but you do need it to scan as you shop.
Have I taken 10 sticks of 1/2 inch emt after only scanning 1? Yes. It was a bundle and there was a barcode. Not my fault
Self checkouy is the stupidest thimg. You shift the responsibility of handling payments from someone who is instivised by salary to act in your company's interest to someome who is only insentivised by social standards to act in your company's best interest. If an employee makes a mistake, you can correct them and if it happens a lot, you can fire them. If a customer makes a mistake you can't do shit. If it happens a lot, you can ban them or call the police, but you'll have to prove intent and it also doesn't happen a lot. Your real problem is not the big thefts, but the many "small mistakes".
Surely I deserve something for my labour? After all, it's not like they're paying us to do the job of a checkout operator.
What they don't tell you is that they're still coming out ahead by not having to pay humans a living wage.
Bananas? Rookie mistake you want brown onions ;)
Now compare this to how much of my time they have stolen from me forcing me to scan shit. You didn't pay to train me, why should I care if the machine makes a mistake in my error?
Not sure how it is in USA, but where I am at self checkout has a weight built in and if you put something that is lighter or heavier than ps5 game case it'll won't let you scan anything until clerk comes and edits entry for you. Bananas have to be weighted and printed a special qr code before you get there.
If you manage do get a banana that weights the same as ps5 game then you might be able to cheat the system. But in doubt it is so easy around here.
Every self checkout ive been to just has you weigh the produce at the register. You could easily just tap onions on the screen then put anything on the scale.
No, you're mixing up the directionality of this one-way issue.
You're right that it would be really hard to get a bunch of bananas that weighs exactly as much as a PS5, but that's not the direction of the deception. But the system isn't expecting the weight of a PS5. It's expecting an arbitrary weight, and will apply the per-weight pricing of bananas to whatever it detects on the scale.
Even if, like you're saying, the scale is not located at the checkout, you carry the ps5 to the banana section, put it on the scale, and let it print out a QR code for a bunch of bananas that weighs exactly as much as the PS5.
Around here they just put everything of moderately high value in a security case, or sometimes its not even on the shelf, just a card with a picture of it and you have to get staff to go get it for you after paying. Even steak has security tags. Then you can't get out the store without scanning your receipt to open a barrier. It's really annoying if you didn't buy anything to get out.
They have that in the US, too, with different areas/neighborhoods having different standards of what gets locked up. But the corporate bosses also know that locking things up seriously reduces sales volume, even legitimate paid transactions, so they've been going back and forth on what types of items to keep locked up or not.
They want it both ways: people browsing and impulse buying, but not stealing. Then they want to not pay staff, but also don't want the higher losses associated with self checkout. I'm hoping they finally realize they can and should just have more staff.
They have the same system in the USA, this person is just goofing around lol
ticket switching is a petty common tactic in retail theft in the US even before self checkout was invented, cashiers used train on reading the description on the monitor and pay attention to the price and if that makes sense for the item. granted it's much easier for items like clothes and other similar items, but people pulled it off even before self check. needing same weight items isn't that difficult, but also every one I've used in CA recently allows scanning and putting in your basket instead of the bagging area.
Bill Burr bit is a classic - https://youtu.be/FxINJzqzn4w
Yes I know he's not everyone's favourite person but it's still a great bit and it has nothing to do with the controversy.
What, are you gonna cut my hours?
One time it started beeping saying possible shoplifting while I was talking to an employee. All because I scanned and kept it in my hand for too long.
Wait, is Wall St. posting gains or are these losses slow to show? I feel like someone is lying here.
6 employees watching self checkout and one employee working a register, meh, you caused this problem...
Definitely buying all the donuts in the bag. (but notbthe ones in my tummy).
top 100 comments