
post
My grandma is more informed and on the ball than this clown.
So. One of the things DOGE got rid of was the CAB - Change Advisory Board. I'm pretty sure there were established Change Windows with approvals required and a documented test plan and rollback plan. Don't need those! That just gets in the way of business! Let's get rid of it and see how that goes!
Yeah. We saw how it went, alright.
Edit: I should have said it's apparent that DOGE got rid of CAB. Because this isn't the kind of thing you do with an Information System if you have a CAB.
INCOMPETENCE. The answer is incompetence.
Apparently the plan was to modernize air traffic control by testing upgrades during Friday rush hour, then modernize accountability by blaming the contractor. If nobody can explain why the work happened then, the biggest system failure might be the decision making above the control tower.
Wasn't it even on a Friday afternoon?
Definitely FNGs. Nobody that's been in IT for 10 minutes updates shit on a Friday afternoon.
You would also probably want to advise the pilots currently in the air before takeoff..
sometimes you'll do anything to feel something through the numbness of it
Depends. I'd say that logic applies to the old IT people, ones who came in / had high salaries and valued their personal time with family etc. The people who implemented things like read only fridays.
Younger workers, or people chasing money due to lower salaries/job insecurity though.... an issue translates as OT, and as an easy marker to point at for "what you do here" to people trying to cut jobs. Even the older workers know, when shit works smoothly people wonder what you do -- but when it breaks, they're all thankful you fix it.
Similar mentality as I've heard with cops. They'll bust a kid on an inflated minor charge near the end of their shift, because the arresting officer is required to fill in the paper work, which translates as hours of OT pay.
The whole point of read only Fridays, is that you know shit can go wrong, and you don't generally want to have a bunch of people doing unplanned OT on the weekend. It's based on a shared understanding that personal time is important, and that no one desperately needs/wants unplanned OT. So if enough people in the mix don't care so much about personal time, and/or want that extra cash... so long as you can deflect the problem as a fault with "decades old routers"....
Watch him eventually admit.
"grok thought it was a good idea to test on heavy traffic".
I guarantee, if Grok isn't lobotomized, it would have recommend a cautious and sensible approach. My local AI is smart enough to point out problems, as is Kagi's assistant.
The members of the Trump Regime simply have the patience of a toddler, and none of the forbearance to handle being told "No."
Just another notch on the failure belt of this idiotic pedophile regime. They're already clear up to the buckle of this fuckin belt. Incompetent child molesters.
"I'm just surface lying here. I never gave it too much thought, as I don't really know the patterns of "working for a living". ".
Saw a post shortly after where Donnie specified 'I claim no responsibility for it', which probably means he told them to get it done before the weekend and blames the tech people for it failing.
If it were me, I would have started with the least used routes for rolling out, confirm that they are in good order after a couple months, slowly expand the rollout locations over time. All the while being administered and monitored by experts whose sole purpose is to assess everything - cost, tradeoffs, problems, improvements, personnel training, the whole enchilada.
My approach isn't nearly good enough, yet Duffy is even below that questionable bar.
🤨
Maybe conservatives shouldn't be making important decisions for the public.
This is what happens when you select employees by loyalty instead of proven competence
But its the old system's fault. We need money to upgrade ... to the new things we installed that caused the problem.
Because every aspect of the current American system is a clownshow entirely peopled by unqualified boot-lickers....
Does this make me Sherlock?
As democracy is perfected, the office of president represents, more and more closely, the inner soul of the people. On some great and glorious day the plain folks of the land will reach their heart's desire at last and the White House will be adorned by a downright moron.
H.L. Mencken, On Politics: A Carnival of Buncombe
"Democracy is by the people, of the people, for the people."
Does that mean people support stupidity and pedophilia for electing Trump?
Yes. Enough people with voting rights do that. That's the simple explanation. Those people are shit and want to see shit in charge.
If you can convince the lowest white man he's better than the best colored man, he won't notice you're picking his pocket. Hell, give him somebody to look down on, and he'll empty his pockets for you.
Lyndon B. Johnson
I can't say I understand Trump voters. I assume that most of them are just completely ignorant of a LOT of things. First, because they don't pay attention to politics, and second because the news sources they do occasionally catch are captured and closer to propaganda. I'm also reminded of Hanlons razor: Never attribute to malice that which can be sufficiently explained by stupidity. While I support trials and convictions and incarceration for those responsible for this massive con job, I also think it's vital to provide a path of forgiveness and grace to let the folks who fell for the con. It's socially devastating to admit that you fell for it, tons of people never report falling victim to confidence scams because of embarrassment. So somehow we have to give that THIRD of Americans some way to diplomatically save face before they will change their mind.
Lol. Only fools test in production.
Everyone has a test environment. Some people are lucky enough to have a separate environment for production...
Much like the saying, "any machine can be a smoke machine if you use it wrong enough."
How long until we find out it was the AI package they bought? A week? Duffy has been fucking lying since Friday so you know it was something stupid and woke.
I'm sure Claude thought it was a good idea. Everyone who knew better has likely been fired or "retired" long ago.
We just let a contractor have full access to a single point of failure. See? Not our fault!
Fucking incompetent idiots.
The USA voted for mediocrity, this is what mediocrity looks like.
A bunch of absolute idiots that are not even aware of how stupid they are, in positions of power because they were born with a silver spoon up their ass.
This is exactly what MAGAtards complain about DEI not realizing DEI avoids this while their white-evangelical-men first policy is exactly what they supposedly hate so much
Given the global nature of the industry, is it even realistic to wait for a 'down' period? I suppose for local traffic, which would be the majority at international hubs. Would be interesting to see the graphs.
im no stoner, but id put money on 4:20am est being a better time to run that than when they did. /s jk am stoner
If you don’t run your change on Friday, at the very least you have people available to deal with any issues, without paying overtime.
But yes, I’m sure sometimes are quieter than ithers
He's another one of the know-nothings maga loves, since they sound as misinformed and clueless as they are, very tribal.
Maybe their AI told them that?
One would think that very few people have access to the master update files and even less have full access to direct it to every computer. They're probably all based on sccm, so I'm kinda flabbergasted that enough computers took the plunge at once to close all traffic. Seems like maybe more market manipulation as a much easier answer as to how and why.
Nah, my bet is on it being a combination of old hardware/infrastructure, and newly rolled out AI systems.
The new ai systems they rolled out most likely had built in 'fail safes' to trigger ground stops in a variety of scenarios. I can easily imagine a 20-something year old vibe coder setting one of those conditions along the lines of "If there's a significant rise in data gaps/integrity loss, such that you are being 'blinded', trigger a ground stop". Rationale could've been something along the lines of it being an indicator of a potential hack/breach, alongside the general preference of protecting lives vs gambling on an AI with blind spots. That tools integrated into all the airports, with the same logic, and likely connected via cloud channels to centralized AI farms.
If you accept that as plausible, then I'd go a step further and say it's plausible that the comments about network devices is potentially legit as a contributing factor. Older networking hardware would struggle to push through the amount of data a centrally-based AI control type system would be seeking. The way data gets routed through those infrastructure devices, would be as chopped up packets of data -- and the more overloaded a system gets, the more it drops individual packets of data. This either results in the computer needing to re-request the lost packet (increasing the load on the network even further), or it just tries to make do without the packet of data. Those lost/delayed packets add up over time, and start causing system faults.
To the second note, airport networks are generally already pretty overloaded in this sense from what I understand, adding in AI-level data harvesting would absolutely cripple them -- and to the first point, if there's a 'threshold' of packet loss / data integrity issues that'd trigger a ground stop, you'd hit that threshold at a semi unpredictable time (though it'd happen as the load increases, which sorta makes sense that it happened at a busier time after the AI tool was integrated).
The above seems to sorta 'fit' with most of the information I've heard so far at least.
Tech companies are heavily leveraged in AI, and they're highly involved with the US Administration. So any fault related to AI will be downplayed significantly. Sorta like that Iranian schoolgirl bombing incident, which was apparently carried out due to bad information provided by Palantir's AI, paired with the US cutting a bunch of safeguards around military strikes -- if palantir says fire, press red button! Hegseth Strongk! .... those sorts of AI stories get downplayed, as they'd have a negative impact on stocks. AI killing us all is only a good investor pitch so long as people aren't seeing the corpses the AI companies are already making. So if you can blame anything else, be it "Maybe the Iranians bombed themselves?" or "copper wires", so long as it shifts blame away from AI, you can keep that hype train going.
Going by what they said, since that’s all we have, a new router can easily be misconfigured to take out a network, whether it’s publishing bad routes, flooding the net with verbose data, or not throttling the fiber side down to what the copper side could accept. Thats why you have redundancy and very conservative process.
That’s not what happened at all.
It's the exact same answer as to the previous question: "why deploy a data hungry system (SMART) on an infrastructure that was guaranteed not able to support the load (old copper network)?"
Because incompetent fucking idiots make loads of stupid decision all the time.
I'm going to put on my conspiracy theorist hat to say someone is lying because this looks like an attack.
Never Attribute to malice that which can adequately be explained by incompetence
Wouldn’t an attack be a good thing, from a narcissistic sycophant point of view? Look how quickly we responded! Buy all our stuff! Let’s have Hegseth bomb someone!
I mean, isn't visibility better during the day?
Seems like you'd rather it go down on a clear day than at night or during a winter storm.
You'd rather it go down with as few flights in the air as possible. Ideally no flights in the air...but ideally you can do this without taking the system down entirely.
I would say the number of flights at nightis not lower enough to matter, especially because other countries with different time zones are sending planes at different times.
You would be wrong. Go look at flights out of any national airport between 11pm - 5am. They're significantly cheaper and have less options for a reason. Because demand is much lower during those hours and it provides a window for other work to happen to keep the airport safe and operational.
That's leaving. What about arriving?
Air travel, after all, generally makes the most sense when you cross oceans
You can look it up, it's significantly less. It's a fact you can check. Literally just go into an airport at midnight and count the people. It's about 90% less than are there at noon.
You make an ass out of yourself when you assume others live in the US.
This whole thread is about flights in the United States being grounded. I did assume someone so invested in the topic might live in the country. For what it's worth, I'd bet money there are less flights in most countries at night as well, for the same reasons I'm mentioning in my other comments.
I don't appreciate being called an ass, we were having a discussion. I think I've been cordial with you, not sure why you're upset. I'd rather not continue this, I made my point and you've ignored it several times.
For passenger flights, even major airports can shut down their terminals overnight
We don’t really have any details but presumably they were able to continue with manual processes. We used to do that all the time and it still works. Just doesn’t scale, so you’d want as little traffic as possible.
all 3 comments