Reading the web and watching the YouTube's yields a plethora of little attention hacks that apparently really help people with their ADHD, but leave me feeling completely alienated because absolutely none of them work for me. In fact, I just don't even implement them, just sort of eye them suspisciously from a distance.

It feels a little reminscent of the advice I'd get for depression in that the bulk of advice seems targetted towards people with less severe forms, and both writers and readers can say, "Wow! Thanks! This really worked for me!"

The feeling that I had earlier that, "OK, now I have a diagnosis, I can start treating the problem" is evaporating away I'm left with a despair that comes from having a version of ADHD that is seemingly not treatable and not work-aroundable and is actually and irrevocably debilitating.

Getting an eval in a week

Edit: If anyone has resources for severe ADHD instead of this Stephen Covery organizational bullshit, please drop it in the comments.

all 35 comments

sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[–] 25 points 1 day ago (10 children)

The feeling that I had earlier that, "OK, now I have a diagnosis, I can start treating the problem" is evaporating away I'm left with a despair that comes from having a version of ADHD that is seemingly not treatable and not work-aroundable and is actually and irrevocably debilitating.

So, sorry to be the one who says this but I think the only path to peace is acceptance. No, I have not achieved it yet.

If these tips and tricks worked for all people all the time, it wouldn't be considered disabling.

Diagnosis has helped me and my spouse be kinder with ourselves and prioritize certain things instead of trying to do it all. We give ourselves more buffer, have more back up plans, and just lean in to what works for us.

It also means being kinder to each other. So maybe if my spouse is stimming super hard and it's driving me nuts I won't snap at him, I'll say "Imma go lay down for a bit" because I'm likely over stimulated at that point and could probably use more than just the stimming stopping. In turn, he recognizes that when I sit with him on the couch with my headphones on I'm not being rude, I'm enjoying his presence while taking care of myself.

I was diagnosed with ADHD in 2023 and medication has been a life saver but didn't fix me. The autism diagnosis was last year and that has helped me give myself permission to take better care of myself in the ways I explained above. I've stopped trying to fix myself and started trying to accommodate.

  • source
  • hideshow 10 child comments
  • [–] [S] 5 points 1 day ago* (last edited 1 day ago) (9 children)

    Yeah, it's hard because all my life I've been telling myself, "If I just do X full bore for a few months I can parlay it into a job/career," and every time the furthest I get is collecting books on the subject and maybe a few weeks or months of sporadic practice. And in the meantime, I feel like what I crave spiritually is exactly just something that I can sink my focus into; so I am left both without income and with nothing to look forward to in my present or my future. So I don't know what kind of peace acceptance would grant me, knowing that I will never have the life I want and I'm just going to be flipping channels until I die.

    I've tried a bunch of meds and they didn't seem to do much for task initiation; instead, I seemed to do the same thing I would have done anyway, I just did a lot more of it. So for instance, instead of doing tasks I should have been doing, I would just be on reddit for 16 hours with no breaks.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 9 child comments
  • [–] 6 points 1 day ago (8 children)

    It's hard and not fair.

    I want to tell you that I have a job that I love but I don't want to suggest that everyone can manage traditional employment and I have also been on leave since June and just recently started a reduced schedule so...

    So I don't know what kind of peace acceptance would grant me, knowing that I will never have the life I want and I'm just going to be flipping channels until I die.

    It's not acceptance if you are not at peace with what you have.

    I don't have any advice on how to get there nor am I trying to suggest that people should just suck it up and be grateful when we are denied full participation and basic needs because of our differences.

    I guess I just want to express empathy. I've been totally hopeless because of the mismatch between my brain and the world, but I've managed to find a bit of acceptance too.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 8 child comments
  • [–] [S] 5 points 1 day ago (7 children)

    Yeah, I don't really care about "traditional employment." I'd love to have some sort of task or trade or skill I could use, even if it's playing bossa novas in Portuguese restaruants or a part-time job fixing woodwind instruments... but I've been staring at a dissassembled clarinet on my table for the past 2 days and I know all I have to do is find the re-assembly instructions on the PDF I downloaded, and it's taking me FOREVER. Like, I can't even handle non-traditional employment because I can't be fucked to learn basic skills.

    And a friend dropped off a bunch of stuff for me to sell on marketplace for commission and I've had it for months and I think I'm just going to return it to her today. Even though I'm broke as fuck and having been eating nothing but beans for a week and been largely housebound to avoid spending money on gasoline, I'm just not motivated by money to bother taking a picture, writing a description, and posting it.

    I mean what the fuck.

    Thanks for your words of support, though, it's at least nice not to be completely alone.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 7 child comments
  • [–] 5 points 1 day ago (6 children)

    Okay I can't help myself: do you think you might be burnt out?

    Every decade or so my life falls apart and I am unable to do anything. Autistic burnout is not the same as the other type and can't be treated the same way. I don't want to hear you say "how can I be burnt out if I don't do anything?"! Maybe have a gander at the concept.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 6 child comments
  • [–] [S] 4 points 1 day ago* (last edited 1 day ago) (5 children)

    Absolutely! This time around, I am not running to therapy and psychiatrists because I'm depressed because I've been through that before and its never helped. Instead, I'm seeing any depression I have as an outgrowth of this frustrating process I've described, the core reason for my depression all of my life, in retrospect, which has gone almost completely unacknowledged and untreated.

    So, yes, I'm liking the burnout hypothesis much more for myself these days. In addition, I actually DON'T feel depressed most of the time except as a result of a realistic look at my situation (fuck CBT).

    My problem with burnout is that there doesn't seem to be much I can do about it. I spent years on dsability before without getting anywhere until a faint hope of normal life ignited a small enough fire that I could start working again. But maybe things will be better because the whole trying to treat depression was an enormous boondoggle, an enormous waste of effort and cause of shame and failure (not to mention all the meds probably blunted my affect, making it harder to find joy).

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 5 child comments
  • [–] 3 points 1 day ago (4 children)

    making it harder to find joy

    Comrade, it sounds like you are treating it like occupational burnout, which is (simplified as) a mismatch between your values and your life/work etc.

    My personal opinion is that a lot of advice for occupational burnout is downright harmful when trying to treat autistic burnout.

    Autistic burnout is a mismatch between demands and abilities, and is more about the nervous system.

    What made my autism "click" for me was polyvagal theory, and framing the relevant challenges with that.

    I don't really have it in me to post resources ATM, but I'll do my best to come back to this post tomorrow 💚

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 4 child comments
  • [–] [S] 1 point 1 day ago (3 children)

    I've definitely have had occupational burnout. My trained occupation, social work, was pretty brutally and self-evidently unethical, and my awareness of the harm caused by all of it has only grown over the years; there's also an autistic component of needing to get along with tragically neurotypical co-workers. All the other jobs I've had have been based on taking as much money as possible from people, either directly or as the entire mission of the organization ...

    It's perfectly possible I'm suffering from both autistic and occupational burnout, but recovering from occupational burnout would require me to muster enough attention to pursue skills that grant me better occupational options; I am ensnared and the more I struggle, the worse it gets.

    Re: polyvagal theory. I hear that theory mentioned in The Body Keeps the Score and EMDR, and in both cases it's been criticized as having weak evidence, but if you find the conceptualization helpful, I'd love to hear more about how it's useful for you.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 3 child comments
  • [–] 11 points 1 day ago (4 children)

    My psych told me this: "ADHD brain hates routine, but needs it."

    It's the biggest thing that had a very real effect. I wake up the same time every day, eat same time every day, exercise at the same time etc.. It was rough, hard work to get here, but it made a real difference.

    I found this article very illuminating: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12728042/

    I hope it helps you as well.

  • source
  • hideshow 4 child comments
  • [–] [S] 2 points 18 hours ago (1 child)

    I did manage a little bit of routine for several years. Every day, my first thing was to study language (anki vocab mostly) while I drank my mater. Since my burnout, I've left that behind, but think maybe it's time to replace language with piano....

    Thanks for the link!

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • I saw you mentioned trying meds and having an issue just doing the same thing you'd normally do but for longer as well. I recently started meds and have noticed the same thing, and especially if you were undiagnosed for a long time I think this can be a big problem. The meds help a lot, but they aren't a cure-all. They really require discipline as well, especially for people who are older when they start them. You went for possibly decades with a chemical deficiency in your brain. Your brain built up a whole set of habits and neural pathways dedicated to hacking this deficiency, and gaining dopamine any way it can. Now the meds can help regulate that dopamine, but the ingrained habits are still the path of least resistance. The meds can't overcome that on their own. Your brain has an immense amount of experience feeling like 'being productive' gives no dopamine, no reward. The meds make it so that being productive can feel rewarding, but all the little hacks that you picked up along the way to get that dopamine fix also still feel rewarding with the meds, sometimes even moreso than before. So you need to overcome that inertia and train your brain to realize that no, actually laundry isn't a torturous experience that must be avoided at all costs anymore. Now with the meds it actually can feel like you've accomplished something. But in order to do that you need to build those habits, and then initiation will get easier and easier. If you start the meds without a routine, they can easily just reinforce the bad habits that have been built up over years of your brain being wired wrong which is something a lot of doctors don't talk about/realize with older patients.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 8 points 1 day ago (2 children)

    Ugh, I hate that stupid Pop-Sci flavored "advice" too. Way too often it comes across as if the person giving it has absolutely no idea what ADHD is about and just spits something out that sounds about right to them.

    As for resources, Dr Russell Barkley is pretty much the only source I respect. Especially this video: https://youtu.be/_tpB-B8BXk0
    A point in there that I actually found really insightful is that when you have ADHD, you don't just struggle with delayed gratification but also with delayed punishment. So situations like you fucking up with time management and your friends just silently don't invite you somewhere a couple weeks later won't have any learning effect. So taking more accountability than normal and asking to be corrected right away might actually be the better path

  • source
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] [S] 4 points 1 day ago

    I think the mechanism is that most people with any condition are not going to have it severely, so most of the bandwidth is gonna be filled with bandaid patches that work minimally with the needs of the more extreme ends being completely unaddressed/unfindable.

    Thanks for that link!

    Also, friends?

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 9 points 1 day ago

    Get medicated, try hacks while medicated, see if any of it sticks while you are taking a break from your meds. Most won't and the few that do won't be a replacement for medication, but at least it's something.

  • source
  • [–] 4 points 1 day ago (2 children)

    Yeah, absolutely. No hack is going to patch the actual executive dysfunction, and it probably only worked for those people temporarily, because doing a new system, provokes that sweet sweet novelty dopamine. So on face value it seems like a good tip, and it might work for a time.

    Then you have to decide, is this the system I want to stick to after the dopamine has deserted me. If yes, then you have to build a system of a thousand pulleys and wenches to keep it going. Either find a way to keep injecting the novelty dopamine, by being able to switch it up. Or strap it down and tape it's eyes open with alarms. But then also you gotta think about the cost to your nervous system if you keep sending it into debt via cortisol overexposure (alarms).

    I feel like it's more about breaking everything down into the smallest part.

    What are you trying to achieve / defeat?

    I have combined ADHD, and it absolutely kicks my ass every second of every day.

    I dug right down to the foundations, to try and make effective changes. For my whole life I motivated by cortisol and adrenaline and low and behold hit 40 and I've built myself a nice little nest of fibromyalgia out of all that nervous system assaulting.

    So in trying to lessen my fibromyalgia symptoms I need to lower my cortisol and adrenaline. (Which is a slightly longer quest than that spunds).

    In lowering those, I notice a knock on of lowering my attention woes and foibles. And that's true for neurotypical brains too, stress reduces your hippocampus functionality, and causes some pretty huge damage to that poor little monkey with cymbals.

    I don't want to overload you with info, if you want more like and subscribe below and I'll follow up with more..... I watch too much YouTube...

  • source
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] [S] 3 points 1 day ago (1 child)

    Yes, thinking through this, I feel an active aversion to wanting to do the things I say I want to do, which feels more like Pathological Demand Avoidance, and I think all the tips and tricks don't work when my nervous system actively sees the task as a threat. Whereas most of the tips and tricks assume 0 motivation, not negative motivation....

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 2 points 22 hours ago

    I've had negative motivation for many things, I have not been able to get around some of them but, for the ones I have been able to deal with, my most effective driver has been spite.

    The best example I have off the top of my head is I had some pretty weird back pain / sciatic a nerve impingement symptoms. I also have hypermobile EDS. I went to a physical therapist to see if they could do anything and I researched the specific one that I wanted to go see because he was supposed to be really Hands-On and might help like with massage and scraping and not just send me home with exercises. He did the basic intake form with me and then punted me off to some less qualified less licensed assistant type person who did not listen to my complaints or pay attention to my chart at all. She had me do a couple movements and decided that my ass was weak. Those are the literal words she said. "Your ass is weak, that's the problem." My ass was not weak because I didn't have any muscle, my hip was not seated properly in the ball/socket joint at the time and therefore I had significant weakness in one leg. I told her that and that I knew that wasn't the problem, she refused to listen. She sent me home with a handful of exercises that I knew were not going to address the problem so I did the research for what would actually help for myself and did those exercises very specifically and not the ones she gave me out of spite. It worked of course and I went back the next session, in between I had also been able to put my hip back, and did all the things she asked me to very easily and she was just flabbergasted at how I could possibly have made so much progress. I told her "I said I had EDS and that my hip was out, that's why my leg didn't have much strength." This bitch had the audacity to say "you have h-EDS? I had no idea! I should have given you completely different exercises!". I of course never went back to that physical therapist's office but I continued to use spite to "prove this bitch wrong" and it was soooo motivating. That has been the best and longest run of dedicated strength training and cardio exercise I have ever started, all because the beginning motivation was "fuck you bitch! I know what's right and I'm not going to be gaslit into listening to your stupid fucking face when you won't listen to me and don't know what the fuck is going on."

    I found that creating that sensation of "fuck you! I'm going to do the thing I know is right just to make you fucking angry and show you how wrong you fucking are" is the best way for me to turn negative motivation into positive motivation.

    It's almost like you knowing what you should be doing is one polarity of a magnet and you knowimg you don't want to do it is the other polarity and they cancel each other out and you're left stationary, but somehow adding spite into the mix kind of flips the polarity of one or the other and gets you moving. I have even been able to do things out of spite of my own brain. Like, the negative self-talk voice in the back of my head is being such a cunt and I'm just like "you know what Steve!? (I named the negative voice in my head Steve) I'm going to get up and do the thing just to prove how fucking wrong you are because you are being such a stupid bitch right now!" I try not to think about it too hard because it works for me and I don't want to examine why and have it stop working so... do with that what you will.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 4 points 1 day ago (2 children)

    When I watch YouTube and people there give me ADHD advice, I remember a quote from the movie The Forbidden Kingdom: "Learn The Way, then find your own way". Seeing how someone handles their own ADHD helps me to think of ways that advice can be applicable to my personal brand of ADHD. I almost never do what people say to "master" ADHD, but I do take their advice and find a way to integrate it into my routines and rhythms. The advice and guidance isn't worthless, usually, but it's not something I adopt on a 1:1 basis. I take bits and pieces of the advice and assemble it into something that works for me. I hope you can do something like that too. Best of luck 🫂

  • source
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 4 points 1 day ago

    My ADHD is pretty severe and most of them don't work for me either. We should both keep trying, it affects everyone differently, eventually we'll find people like us and it will work.

  • source
  • [–] 3 points 1 day ago* (1 child)

    To borrow and expand upon the existing adage:

    If you’ve met one neurodivergent person, then you’ve met one neurodivergent person.

    I personally think that a lot of the culture and norms in online video are incompatible with many neurodivergent folks, though I’ve not been able to explore this beyond my own experience of largely abstaining from that content. because it’s not compatible with my brain. but things like rewarding views and monetization have the side effect of amplifying voices in isolation to a community that resists generalization

    And the fact is that the most successful appear to be authentic, drawing from what they know, and with the intention of helping people, but we reach this inflection point where the people that it can help that haven’t seen it get harder and harder to reach, but the algorithms do the things that apply to communities that are more generalizable because that’s generally successful and the unintended effect is that everyone gets the most popular content irrespective of if it would help them.

    It’s not something i want to see solved either, the easier we are to categorize the more readily we can be discriminated against.

  • source
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] [S] 1 point 18 hours ago

    The algorithm definitely has a type. Among the amateurs, young white women, from whatever country come first, and a lot of them are raising children. I have no idea why that is, though I suspect being able to stay home full time is socially more accessible, and I imagine you need huge amounts of bandwidth to pull off a successful YouTube channel and at least a small amount of money for a good setup.

    The other thing I notice is a divide between professionally successful and professionally unsuccessful autistic people. There's a whole ass video about helping your kid get through college and get into a career and how jobs can accomodate it, but it all rest on the very definitely and explicitly stated condition that that autistic kid is world-class in some activity. And that is fucking annoying to me, because I'm not particularly good at anything and if I were better at the things I would like to do, they're not really job skills... anyway, just another wrinkle to the landscape.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 2 points 1 day ago (1 child)

    Problem is that Autism and ADHD are both just categories, not specific enough alone. But the specific ways that they manifest can be very different for each person. So not all advice is going to apply to every person. For me, the way I've figured out most things is talking to lots of other people who have the conditions and figuring out what applies to me and then trying the things they do to mitigate those specific issues.

    Also, the fact that these diagnoses are often treated as "diseases" is pretty misleading. For the vast majority, they are only disabilities because society makes them disabling. Much like someone who is missing an arm could probably not have as much trouble using a computer if keyboards were made for people with one arm, much of society is designed for people who can focus at will, have the ability to form habits like getting up at a certain hour of the day and completing their daily routines and commutes without using any significant mental effort as opposed to many of us who are already tired by the time we first get to work and who get distracted constantly by open floor plans in offices, etc.

  • source
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] [S] 1 point 18 hours ago

    Yes, I'm fully on board with the social model of disability. People's need for incessant need for chitchat and constant validation is their fucking disability as far as I'm concerned, but somehow the world has managed to make it my probloem.

    But the ADHD side of things for me is where it really does feel like a disability, when an important project sits unattended on my desk, or a piano goes unplayed, or blankets unwashed, or papers un-gone-through, for weeks or months, all that start to feel like a disability because there isn't anything between me and the tasks but myself.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 2 points 1 day ago (3 children)

    The best advice I got was that not all advice is going to help all the time. And there's two sides to that, the first being that as you noted the pop-psychology listicle advice columns are usually too broad or for the lowest common denominator that they fail to help the people they claim to be giving advice for.

    The other one that I'm constantly coming to terms with is that the advice that worked for me yesterday might not work for me tomorrow. My specific example: if I don't have a to-do list I don't have a hope of getting the things I intended to do done - but often having a to-do list makes the tasks overwhelming and it doesn't matter if that list is one or one hundred tasks. Pomodoros are fabulous, except when they're impossible to start. Gamifying is a great hack except when it isn't.

    Incidentally, I'm looking at my to-do list right now, thinking fuck me, why did I write this?

    The idea that not everything works is both liberating and a curse. Like, if something doesn't work then you can just try something else, no biggie. But sooner or later you'll have a thousand tips and hacks, and choosing which one to attempt to apply becomes a challenge of its own (fortunately there's tips and hacks for making that choice, unfortunately there's a bunch and they don't always work)

    The most impactful and enduring strategy for me came from Tiny Habits by BJ Fogg. When it works, it works great, especially when my problem was starting a task - any task at all. It was also handy for breaking out of the thought that if I can't finish something entirely then it wasn't worth starting. As the saying goes, anything worth doing is worth doing half-assed.

    It's not working today though. Maybe tomorrow

  • source
  • hideshow 3 child comments
  • [–] [S] 4 points 1 day ago (2 children)

    Someone linked Russel Barkley and he said it's a disorder of INTENTION. We know what to do, we just can't bring ourselves to do it. So maybe hacks help nibble a bit on the edges, but I feel a bit like it's bad advice because it's just more knowledge.

    Like when my girlfriends or bosses would get made at me and just tell me to take care to not forget things. Like, if I could remember to not forget things, I could just remember the things!

    Or like how the solution to being depressed and not getting out of bed is to just exerecise.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 3 points 1 day ago (1 child)

    I think the unfortunate reality is that there is no magic bullet solution, no matter how much we wish there might be. All the hacks and medication in the world aren't going to solve the societal problems that cause us the most distress. Vyvanse might help me fold my laundry, but it's not going to change that rent is due on the first and if I'm late to work again I'm going to get fired

    Depression really is its own bag. I'm not in medicine, but frankly I think it's more of a symptom than a disease of its own. It's comorbid with ADHD, autism, PTSD, compulsive disorders, anxiety, gender dysphoria, poor diet, and even just living under the constant pressures of the modern world. We have medications to manage the symptoms, but a lot of the time they're a crapshoot and without treating the underlying cause you really aren't likely to show improvement.

    I also think treating depression is prone to a cart/horse problem where people confuse cause and effect. Anybody who has suffered from depression probably knows and was infuriated by the advice that if you just get out of bed and exercise then you won't be depressed. Then one day you get out of bed and exercise and don't feel so depressed. The outside observer sees the exercise and concludes that it cured your depression. They don't see the countless hours of therapy, the constant reframing of problems, the restructuring of your life to accommodate self care, the medications that got you to that point, etc

    It's beyond naive to think that some pushups and going for a walk cures depression, but having experienced it for yourself you might even conclude that was the case. But I posit that you were able to get some exercise only because you were less depressed than you were before, and something else had to happen to get you to that point. It's tempting to look at the data that shows the correlation between people who exercise and people who are depressed and conclude that a healthy lifestyle fixes depression: but another interpretation is that the people who are depressed can't lead a healthy lifestyle.

    Personally I think that's where a lot of the well-meaning advice is helpful but also totally misses the mark. People will say (or insidiously get paid to say) that something helped them and it brought them out of the funk, but it was probably a myriad of things that working together helped elevate them to a point they could take back some control over their life. There's a million billion articles about whatever self care fad is a miracle cure, but if it does indeed help then it's just a piece of the puzzle.

    Pessimism aside, self care is pretty important. But it's also personal, only you know what truly makes you feel better. My experience is that if you do anything specifically to make yourself feel better without forcing yourself, then it probably does help you feel better. We're tempted to look at the action (taking a bath, reading a book, putting your phone away), but it's really the intention that helps (I want to feel better, so I'm going to do something to feel better). It's a mental problem with a mental solution, and while that solution might be mercurial or difficult to take hold of, it's the best tool I've got.

    Anyway, rant aside: I also hate that the solution to being depressed is to not be depressed. It's doubly extra super frustrating that my best advice also boils down to "stop being depressed," although I hope I've framed it in a way that shows that it's not as simple a solution as it sounds

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] [S] 1 point 1 day ago* (last edited 1 day ago)

    I think we're mostly on the same page. I think we have a tendency to emphasize solutions that give us agency, even if if those solutions are just foam on changing streams. For instance, I can spend the entire day wanting to get out of the house but not doing it. Then for some reason, I get out of the house, and then I start to feel better. Did getting out of the house make me feel better, or was getting out of the house the first thing I do once I had already started feeling better? I think the latter is much more likely.

    I think depression meds are mostly placebo, actively disorder your brain, and prolong the depression. This is based on the actual research, not anti-vax Scientology bullshit. And when you do go off most psychotropic meds, the withdrawal induces the exact symptoms it was supposed to treat so it devilishly convinces you you need to be on them. Anti-psychotics do seem to work in the short-term, but recovery rates went from aproximately 66% percent before the intrdocution of medication to 3% today. The whole "psychiatric disease is just like diabetes" is an enormous boondoggle. And again, this isn't RFK, Jr balderdash--Europe is experimenting with short-term protocols for anti-psychotics and the overwheliming evidence from the WHO is outcomes are better in countries that don't have Westernized psychiatry.

    Anyway, it's a whole thing.

    Unfortunately, AuDHD has a natural recovery rate of 0%, so it seems the best skill to learn is how to not compound your problems by misinterpreting their cause.

  • source
  • parent