Shame that A/C isn't on the list, I find it so annoying trying to hit a small spot on the screen while moving.
post
I went into this thinking it was a little bit silly since nobody would design a car without most of those but:
If you have a Model Y from 2025 or later, press the brake pedal to pull up the drive mode strip on the touchscreen. Tap the drive mode strip to shift into Park. You can also press Park on the overhead console.
You have to shift gears with a touchscreen?? WHAT??!? I knew they were shit cars but what the actual fuck are they thinking?
I never drove a car that shifted gears on a fucking touchscreen. I am not going to do that.
Let's be honest, these cars were made for rich children who can't read or count.
Musk's goal is to eliminate all human input - including the steering wheel. He has said “Almost all input is error. Car should do the right thing automatically.” Removing physical controls is the first step.
This is probably a mistake. But Musk is unlikely to ever admit this.
yes and no ;) i mean you can just get in and assuming you are not reversing, press the "accelerator" and go, get out at the other and walk away. No need to lock, engage park brake, change "gears" etc
theyre automatic cars, so the only time youd shift gears is to park, or switch from go to reverse or vice versa, both usually done while breaking, so its understandable to some extent. it also prevents someone from shifting gears while in motion.
had evs be "manual" then that would be dangerous
an example of bad physical design would be cars with gear shift knobs near a volume knob, which would be infinitely more dangerous
It really wouldn't be crazy. The polestar 2 has a physical shifter and acts exactly like you'd expect from a shifter. You bump it forward to put it in reverse, and pull back on it to put it in drive. You can shift both directions while rolling slightly, which is actually really nice and useful. I think I tried shifting while it was driving and it likely has a software limit to the speed at which it let's you shift while rolling (above 5 mph for example). I think only going from drive to reverse requires touching the brake, similar to a standard automatic.
I don't get what was wrong with a PRNDL with big physical detents and feedback. I don't understand what these goofy little knobs and blobs improve about the user experience.
It’s not dangerous. They are all electronic. If it’s unsafe, it just won’t do it.
It’s really not that big of a deal. They also have no ignition/start button, which is the only sane way of have it in a EV. You just get in and drive.
DUDE!!!! WHY WAS THE GEAR SHIFT AND THE ABILITY TO TURN IT OFF ON A TOUCH SCREEN AND NOT MECHANICAL?
Why isn't door handles on the list?
Especially the gears, did we not learn anything from Anton Yelchin's death?
We learned shitty Jeep transmissions should not be used to park a vehicle. People who refuse to use parking brakes deserve what they get.
Seems a bit harsh... Especially as if I put my car into park then the electronic handbrake turns on anyway. I never have to pull it manually
If you have automatic brakes... then you are infact using them...also the fact they exist proves the point the vast majority do not use the brakes.
That might be more of a culture things, i grew up with manuals and pulling the handbrake and putting it into first or reverse is still second nature to me and I'd think most people here. If anything the introduction of the auto handbrake is causing people to lose the habit.
But with my car I don't really see how anyone could make a mistake. If you open the door in anything other than park, it screams at you. If you are in park and open it then it loudly applies them.
So 99% of people who drive automatics?
Pretty much nobody knows why they should even use it.
I think this is a good thing. But I hope that they can do so intutitively. During the telescope guy recent review, he made a good point that many manufacturers seem to bring back buttons for compliance reasons or just to say they have buttons (he was trying to praise the car he was reviewing for going beyond that). I thought he had a good point.
My 2024 Citroen EV has all those as physical controls and more.
I want the two sliders for the AC/heat back. Like wtf do I need a phd in auto consoles to cool off while driving?
Emergency call system
So this is mandating SIMs and tracking in cars? Don't love that. I'm sure the manufacturers will ensure that the infotainment system will be mostly useless if you go in and disable the tracker
It isn't clear from the article that they're mandating the presence of an emergency call system. The "if present" note on the driver assistance function appears to have been added in this article and is not noted in the list from the linked article about the draft regulations:
A draft for public comment has been completed and will be released soon, which specifically includes the following functions:
- Lighting: Turn signals, hazard warning lights (double flashers), horn
- Gear shifting: P/R/N/D (screen-only shifting is prohibited)
- Driver assistance: Activation switch for the advanced driver assistance system
- Safety/emergency: Windshield wipers, defroster/defogger, power windows, Child/Accident Emergency Call System (AECS), and electric vehicle power off switch
My impression was more that if it has that call system, it has to have a physical button for it. That said, I haven't read the regulations myself, so it's entirely possible I'm talking out of my ass.
My work van has an emergency call system and it malfunctioned and dials it all the time, especially in low service areas. This causes it to constantly dial the SOS number and the only way to stop it is push a tiny hang up button on the infotainment system. The hands free controls for calls don't work with the SOS system. It is incredibly annoying, distracting, and dangerous. It has been back to the dealer 3 times to fix it and has yet to be fixed for good.
So a physical button for this system is very important.
I think car manufacturers don't care about the 0.000001% of people praying out SIM modules out of their cars that much.
Teslas hang a significant amount of their MCU functionality on the built-in SIM. Assuming the system doesn't glitch out completely, you're going to be staring at an arrow on a big gray box in the middle of a big tablet screen while it fails to load map data. They explicitly did not build Android Auto or Apple CarPlay into their vehicles because they wanted you to drive everything from the MCU itself. It would occasionally pop up reminders at me when I switched to Bluetooth Audio because I was using it to stream an app that was already native to the car (Audible kept glitching out and losing my place when I resumed on different devices).
I'm sure there are other auto makers that are happy to follow suit. I just switched from a Model 3 to a Hyundai Ioniq5 and it feels like much of the user interface was locked down until I subscribed to BlueLink.
I'm starting to get way more interested in the concept of a super basic, modular vehicle with only doodads you build onto it attached. I hope the Slate truck can make good on what it's promised so far.
I'd be fine with that tbh. as long as it doesn't fuck with actual operability.
I don't want manufacturer infotainment anyways. I want climate controls, audio controls, a good spot to mount my phone with known good software, and a 3.5mm jack for audio input.
Most manufacturers have been doing that on their own, for a least a couple years now.
My 2019 Tesla has all of those except the power off button, and windshield defroster. It doesnt have a emergency system anywhere so not relevant.
Do any EVs have a power off button that actually powers it down? There is an option in the menus on the Tesla but thats still not a full true power off.
My BYD Atto 2 only has a physical power button, no touchscreen power off. (and an app, but that's another matter)
What happens if you power it down, do you need to press the button to get the car to activate beyond opening doors / 12v stuff?
Removing buttons is an idea. An idiot idea, but certainly an idea.
I don't love the idea of having to regulate for fuckin buttons, and think it should be avoided if possible, but I guess here we are in hell, anyway.
Is there a distraction running on the side?
all 71 comments