I just want China to start producing competitive gpus so they they stick it to nvidia, fuck Jensen Huang
post
On top of this, the ram China sells will generate profit, instead of being looped back into the perpetual no-return money hole.
Actually it will. That's what all capitalism even China's State capitalism does ultimately. Just because you or no one you know aren't profiting doesn't mean no one is. When Capital can be imaginary, intellectual property. Profits often are equally imaginary. They are absolutely 100% making line go up for themselves. Much like the monarchs Etc before them.
First cheap Chinese DRAM, next hopefully cheap Chinese GPUs. The arrogance of big US and Taiwanese tech companies pays off for consumers in the end.
In the short-term. Yes. Long-term though China is still a state with their own bourgeoisie. They will turn protectionist and exclusionary the moment they think it makes sense. It's nothing unique to the United States even if we are one of the biggest examples currently.
It absolutely will be nice in the short-term at least to see the cartels get their comeupance for a short time.
Of course, no one predicted the AI bubble would kill off hardware companies and hand over another monopoly to Chinese industry.
I've assumed the memory shortage is more than just an unfortunate byproduct. To the extent that LLMs have any use, its a threat to the datacenter model if people realize they can be run well enough locally. Hearing stories of datacenters hoarding hardware they can't use yet make me think they want extra time for people to get used to the norm of subscribing to a service. I'd love for a reporter to ask Sam Altman if he'd be happy to see consumers get access to cheaper ram again.
its a threat to the datacenter model if people realize they can be run well enough locally
There will likely always be an advantage to running the biggest models. And you will not be able to run those on your local PC.
Sure, just like there will always be a speed advantage for the newest Ferrari or Lamborghini. Are they worth leasing though? Or do Honda Civics go fast enough for the vast majority of people?
Why would you be a sicko because you like lower RAM prices?
It’s an ironic label. American technocrats would likely call anyone celebrating this development as sickos. OP is jokingly self-applying the label.
Aren’t we all sick of this unnecessary price inflation? 😉
Absolutely, which is why the drawing is moronic, as it labels people who want lower prices as sickos.
You are not a sicko for being sick of things that suck. Sicko means something completely different.
https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=sicko
A person that has mental problems. A person that is sick or has a polluted mind.
Your flailing a bit here. It's not making light of sickness or actually implying that someone is sick. It's common that conservatives call anyone that thinks we should accept gays or trans people and treat them like anyone else degenerates or sickos. The same with legalizing drugs etc.
This is taking the piss on the accusation. Showing who the actually sick people are. The ones that find joy or safety in the persecution and exploitation of the vulnerable. Whom the war on drugs and many other societal norms focus on.
So this is an American thing, which makes it no wonder I find it unfunny, because we don't have the "Republican" mental disease here to anywhere near the extend of USA. Republicans are insane, and if it's making fun of them, I can see how Americans would find that funny.
But without a special social context, it's just stupid.
It could just as well be understood as people who are happy about lower priced RAM from China, are sickos because they are happy China is selling RAM in the West. That's the context I saw.
Hardly an "American" thing. I don't know where you are. I know you have conservatives. If you're in Canada, you have that mental disease. UK, Germany, France, Italy, Australia, Japan, Africa, Asia, Europe yup. The one place that's relatively free of it is the Arctic.
Any humor outside of slapstick and pratt falls requires context. You were given it. It follows basic concepts and principles of comedy that are recognized everywhere. Subversion of expectations, ridiculing those with power. It's plenty humorous. The problem lies with you not it.
It could just as well be understood as people who are happy about lower priced RAM from China, are sickos because they are happy China is selling RAM in the West.
They're litteraly the type the cartoon is ridiculing. That's the whole point of it. Many in western nations, not even remotely just the US. Will unironically 100% chastize and attack anyone expressing that sentiment. Because they are commies etc. Even though China isn't even remotely communist. Even though the semiconductor cartels absolutely deserve no sympathy or defense. If not carrying water or defending abusive semiconductor cartels makes you a sicko I will wear the moniker with pride. And I think you would too. That's all that was ever implied.
lol it’s a funny joke.
In this case, we’re watching the economy of inflated chip prices and are cheering on the number going down. We’re outside the norm for that. It’s hyperbole.
Except the actual meaning of sicko makes it not funny. Without that "detail" it would have been.
But personally I don't care much for being called a sicko.
Ben Garrison is a satirical artist who portrays good things as being wanted by "sickos" in opposition to the hyper conservative characters in his cartoons.
This is tremendously funny, you just lack context.
Tariffs in 3 2 1.
I saw a video comparing standard CXMT ram vs high end Kingston and Crucial I think, with faster speeds etc.
Very comparable was the Chinese one.
So I think a lot of buzz (from the before times) about the higher speeds and lower latency etc was for a very small niche market of people. Everyone else including gamers wouldn’t see a difference except in capacity.
Therefore, I welcome our Chinese saviours.
I call BS. Yield on high-speed, high-capacity RAM at scale is pretty hard to manage. If it was, Chinese manufacturers would have 'flooded the market' sooner.
It'll take them years to get to the point where they can match the yield of Samsung, Hynix, Micron, or even Kingston. And those guys are all focusing on the highest margin packages.
Sorry, we're all screwed until demand drops.
Man, China as a country is certainly poised at this point to really pull some wild political optics with this move. Their manufacturing quality has been noticeably improving in recent years and their tech industry has a huge opportunity to show up western firms by undercutting the shit out of them in consumer NAND and DRAM. It would be wise of them to take QA extra seriously over the next couple of years to make themselves the "heroes" of the people by delivering better quality and dramatically lower prices than those bloated western companies. Hell, I'm even possibly in the market for it soon if the price is right. I have a feeling western corpos will continue snatching defeat from the jaws of victory and not notice that some of these Chinese corporations already quietly got their shit together a while back and probably won't shoot themselves in the foot this time. This could be the optical turning point for China as an economic power.
Hopefully the Chinese people can continue making progress in fighting the CCP bourgeois for better labor rights, especially with western corporations losing access to terrible enforcement of already inadequate CCP labor laws. The Chinese workers will start having a hell of a lot better bargaining position with this development and the ACFTU/CCP can get fucked.
Seriously, both large American companies and American government have adopted the attitude of "Haha we're fucking up everyone's lives and the world for our own benefit, watcha gonna do about it?". That leaves the space wide open and the bar so low, that China's government and companies can clear it and appear like decent actors, even if some of my gripes with both remain.
It's certainly an opportunity in global soft power for the CCP, but I think the headline here is better framed as a shift in global economic power, specifically in tech. The current American government is certainly fucking things up for American soft power globally, but the political capital built up over the decades just can't be ignored as that just doesn't disappear overnight. Not to mention the human rights violations in Xinjiang, government corruption problems, aggressive naval maneuvering, and recent isolationist past that the Chinese CCP needs to overcome to become a serious contender as the new number one. They're kinda making their way through it, but it's definitely not inevitable, and too many short-term and long-term metrics are working against them. This particular situation could certainly be a solid foundation to build on, but the CCP and many Chinese vulture capitalists have a history of shooting themselves in the foot for short-term gains.
Xinjiang human rights violations [against the Uyghur population], aggressive naval maneuvering [in South China Sea], corporate vulture capitalism
I'm glad you have mentioned some of the biggest of my gripes, because I didn't get to it in my original comment to keep it succinct and cohesive. And we'll see what happens, I agree it's not inevitable but this is like China's best shot at world dominance through soft power that its had yet. I think certain members in the CCP have some awareness that invading Taiwan is going to, maybe counterintuitively, blow up the opportunity and the soft power credibility they built through Belt and Road.
Yeah, I think that really is the foundational tension in China; the internal power struggle of a deeply authoritarian CCP versus the cooperative stance needed to gain/build political capital worldwide. As it stands, their system will resist any legitimately populist movement and disincintivize honest efforts to dismantle harsh authoritarian policies and violent state oppression. You don't maintain power (or your life) in a quasi-dictatorial party without keeping those who benefit from the system happy.
Yeah, with Trump and the weak Biden administrations they got what they wanted, complete immunity.
The only thing causing issues for them now is the EU, but they have pointed their massive lobby machine toward them.
I seem to recall the EU being fucking stupid and signing a deal that they will accept US safety standards on US made cars.
Wasn't there also a law that said that American cloud providers that wanted EU business had to build EU only datacenters for the EU customer's data that would not be shared with the US, the providers promptly broke that law and the EU ignored it
The optical turning point is here for a lot of things.
The non-US world is seriously considering Chinese cars, which was always a high burden to clear (see Japan and Korea getting their manufacturing together enough to field a competitive product)
I suspect we'll see some flailed attempt to block Chinese RAM from the US market (cf. The router fiasco) but this one might have enough corporate inertia to sail through. When every business in the country can't afford even basic 16GB office desktops, Intel, Dell, HP, and Apple are probably going to be making compelling arguments to their captive legislators. This might be the only way to avoid huge losses on their non-datacentre product lines.
Yep, I keep forgetting about Chinese EVs. However, and pretty much exactly to your point, I think the US and western corpos are gonna have a much harder time keeping out Chinese RAM versus the relative ease of keeping out very conspicuous (in more than one way) Chinese EVs. The US government can make trade protectionism work, but that requires serious investment in domestic production in the same targeted sectors that get tariffed and uhhh... well. Happy early birthday, Chinese renewables, I guess?
I guess one of the reasons they are where they are is centralized planning through CCP, very cheap labor and possible really bad working conditions. Take those out of equation and who knows what happens, but it most certainly won't be good for the consumer. That said I really do hope they improve their work conditions.
Pretty sure the primary driver is the cheap labor. The poor working conditions kinda go hand in hand with that. However, with a shift toward domestic Chinese firms directly dependent on domestic Chinese labor, that gives the workers there a ton more leverage versus when it's western corporations that can threaten to move elsewhere. A win for Chinese workers is a win for all of us.
Check this out
How would you even know about this? What are you, some kinda nerd?
It makes it to the news before. The HDMI forum is understandably upset by that
GPMI is not any better with all its "security" functions. It's security against the user, the american way but in chinese flavour.
it also does not sound to be good idea to have high power delivery so near to normal signal wires, noise, shorts, more power strain on the graphics hardware, and all that.
displayport for the win.
Might be a stupid question but why not displayport instead?
Bigger power delivery spec. The hope is that it should be possible to drive a huge display from a single cable for data and power
it sounds stupid to force through the computer a meaningful amount of energy that is only intended for a peripheral
By your logic type PD spec is stupid because it is also used in PC. The use cases extend beyond PC. Think video wall system where cabling can be messy and pretty much everyone got their own standard. This would allow a single daisy chain and simpler cabling.
Don't threaten me with a good time. Deliver it.
God bless Chinese manufacturing
You mean borderline slave labor? Because that's pretty much what Chinese manufacturing is.
Maybe if you are comparing it to the US cost of living? The average manufacturing job for tech companies in China is around 12k usd a year, while a middle class yearly income starts around 15k a year. So they are in the upper end of the working class.
The basic cost of living is just extremely cheap compared to western countries. Although the wages are only 20-25% when compared to US manufacturing, the cost of basic necessities like housing and food are about 3x cheaper.
It really matters what region you are talking about, tier 1 cities are quite a bit more expensive than tier 2 and 3, but still affordable compared to western nations.
As someone who actually knows some Chinese nationals, no it isn't. What you are actually objecting to is Chinese people having jobs.
Some of these jobs have dorms, which accounts for why there are so few people who are street homeless.
American capitalist create a chip shortage, china saves the day: china bad
CapitalistS. You still have to pluralize even if there happens to be an S nearby.
Yeah, you’re gonna have to take that up $4 trillion tech company, Apple. I am physically disabled, so I use the voice to text and you get what it gives you.
Yeah, I know I’m not gonna go with that 1990s bullshit anymore. The middle class is stronger than the American middle class so I hope you’re not an American… because that would mean you occupy the same corporate dictatorship that I do. Suppressing free speech everywhere. Pushing half the country into poverty while china pulls theirs out? Yeah bro must really suck to live in China right now.
I have connects in China. Some Chinese have fixed salary work contracts and their money is allegedly deflating. I'm jelly, I had to warn people not to brag.
Deflating? Isn't that usually very alarming?
Not if your company is required by law to pay you a certain amount based on buying power, according to this guy I spoke to. Granted, this is stuff I'm learning secondhand from friends, I'm not a financial expert and they could very well be blowing smoke in order to brag on themselves.
Chinese manufacturing did a major turn around in the last couple of decades though can still be awful.
Chinese fishing on the other hand is still almost 100% powered by slaves. Just look up the conditions these people are in while absolutely decimating our oceans: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2tuS1LLOcsI
The consumer market is starved for competition. I hope they upend the memory market and then go on to upend the GPU market as well as any other consumer market that gets the bright idea of artificially AI constraining their supplies. Companies threaten consumers with higher prices and labor with layoffs. Well I'll threaten them back with buying Chinese goods. Won't that undermine my own job? That was already under threat by the CEO!
Yes please, I've been wanting to switch to a self built NAS but the ram prices are the only thing holding me back
"Flooding the market" AKA increasing supply to meet demand.


all 34 comments