I was always told it's a bit rude to use a language that not everyone present understands, since you're basically excluding people from the conversation. Your example seems a bit silly though.
post
Racist, and a way for management to know if workers are discussing unionization.
Not always, it's also a politeness thing, it depends on context
Preserving "politeness" is the same tactic they use to keep workers from discussing their pay with each other, which is also deeply anti-labor.
I don't agree. Forcing people to use a language they are less comfortable with just so others can eavesdrop has nothing to do with "politeness."
It's not eavesdropping lol. I worked a company that was primarily Chinese people at the head office and they made a rule of speaking in English for inclusivity.
The post references any usage of spanish as bannable. There's a difference between workers speaking spanish with each other while someone who only speaks English is present, and workers speaking spanish with each other when nobody else is involved with the conversation. I also worked at a company with a huge portion of speakers that were uncomfortable with speaking English despite myself only speaking English, any attempt to ban their language would hurt the company.
Right? Hence context
I am directly replying to the context listed out by the user, which in this case seems to be racist and anti-worker.
And I am directly replying to you saying there is context and I specifically said not always
It is always negative in the case of the user's context with the information we have. You implied an entirely different situation, meaning it's an entirely different question.
It's not an entirely different question. This is how conversations work on message boards. You say something in response to the post, and people add to the conversation. In this particular situation with the OP it could be racism, it could be dissuading people from talking about unions, quite simply all you're doing is guessing, because you don't have the entire story. I added that there could be more, not flat out denying what you said, saying there is context that could be the reason for situations such as this.
The context in the OP outright states anger at any use of spanish, period. This has nothing to do with "politeness," and is always some form of racism or worker control. If OP had stated that this was only the case when said charge was involved in the conversations and felt left out, then this is a different context from the one OP provided.
You came in here trying to invent a situation that is, at its fundamentals, unique from what OP described.
Yes as i said above this is how message boards work, you say something and people add to it, hence the not always i didn't "invent" a situation, I was talking about other situations, there is more than just this example that happens you know. Conversations are supposed to evolve
You didn't add, though. By just saying "it depends on the context" without providing the alternative situation you were talking about, it implies that the OP's situation may be fine with different context. Now you're acting demeaning and pretending I must not understand how message boards work.
Here's an example of what you could have done:
I agree that in this case it's probably due to racism or to prevent unionization, but there are good reasons to speak a common language at work, such as if the OP's charge was being shut out of conversations they were involved with.
This makes it clear that you're talking about a different context, and prevents this entire back and forth.
Was it really that unclear that I was talking other possible situations (based on the actual question that op posted) about not always and context seems to me to be fairly self explanatory.
Yes, it was unclear.
I'm sorry it wasn't clear enough lol
You're forgiven. Try to add to the conversation from the beginning next time, otherwise it looks like you're disagreeing that this is an instance of racism and exerting power over workers
I would also like to point that I agreed with you here, being that this particular point was about racism and abusing workers. Here
Yes, after the fact. Your use of "context" without justification implies that OP's specific situation, in an alternate context, would be fine, not that an alternate situation may be different.
E: you know what this stupid bickering is, well, stupid I wish you well, and I will stop responding to this thread.
You mean, what you ignored?
I think you should have asked what context was being referred to.
I can't really imagine a context where it would be a politeness thing unless the English-only speaker was actively involved in the conversation but was being intentionally shut-out, and not because it was easier to convey in non-English languages but deliberately for spite.
I can't really imagine a context except for this very common context which completely negates my point
Well said!
You can tell it's not that cuz of how quick the person got angry. If it's remarkable enough to seem strange, there's a reason.
Why do you care about what I do if I'm not talking you? If talking a different language seems impolite to you and you're not the one talking, who the fuck cares? That's a you problem.
I had a bilingual coworker that, after a customer came with a complaint, would turn to me and say "this asshole can suck my dick" in spanish and i would just nod thoughtfully like some important piece of information was given to troubleshoot with.
Shit was so funny. Very rude but i still laugh at that.
Ive never had coworkers talking meaninggully behind someones back in another language, and yeah thats rude too.
I have been the only people talking english somewhere and i felt rude for that.
Whether any of this rudeness justfies work place punishment or should or shouldnt be allowed just depends on the job.
That's extremely risky, a TON of people speak Spanish, including a bunch who you would assume did not by surface-level appearance. Your coworker got really lucky that they didn't get caught and called out.
Sounds like that wasn't your employer, that was your manager. I'd take that to the employer and ask if this rule is authorized, because it seems like a huge overstep on your manager's part.
If you're scared of another language it just means you're a puta gordo
50+ Caucasian cis male multinational tech company middle manager here.
I speak Spanish on work zooms, when everyone else is in Mexico.
TBH I do it because I try to avoid being the asshole boss who everyone else has to accommodate, and instead be the pluralistic, humble boss that shows appropriate deference and respect to the employees that actually do the work.
I'm trying to figure out why a manager would assume that people speaking in Spanish are doing it to have a nefarious, malicious secret code, when Spanish is the fourth-most widely spoken language on the planet, and is not a difficult second language for English speakers to start picking up comprehension with.
If I wanted an evil secret code, wouldn't I pick something far more obscure?
I live somewhere where French is prevalent but thereβs also an important English community.
When people are speaking in English on break thereβs normally no problem β¦ but ! If you speak Arab, Spanish or even Creole on your break youβll probably lived exactly the same thing you experienced.
My point is β¦ racism, pernicious racism and control
Wouldn't work here. We only use English with coworkers who have not yet learned the local language.
For the most part I think you should be allowed to speak whatever language you want so long as you aren't speaking it with a customer, co-worker, boss, etcetera, that doesn't understand it.
I personally don't see any reason why the language you speak should be policed so long as you aren't using it with people who don't understand it, unless they're saying illegal things, but even then that can be shaky depending on what country you're in IMO.
Fucking stupid. The Haitians didn't speak English and we needed our bilingual guy to speak Spanish sometimes or else we wouldn't get shit done. Oh also the boss's English was shit too and sometimes him and the others from the country our company was from needed to communicate clearly
Honestly, time to talk to HR who I'm sure would have a quiet word with this manager.
This sounds like bullying, triggered by racism/xenophia/paranoia or just plain bigotry. And yelling at people? That's terrible too.
Just another expression of that innate American/Western fear that informs their actions and ends up with them in racist rallies, lol. Ridiculous.
Personally, assuming its the local language, I'm fine with the idea.
People who are multilingual don't always seem to get how it looks/feels for monolingual people -- but it's a way of excluding them from participating in whatever the conversation is. I think back to a camping trip described by an X with her friends, where in most of the group spoke english and chinese -- except my X, who only spoke english. Because one or two in the group were more fluent in Chinese, for most of the weekend the vast majority of conversation was in Chinese, which really drove home how isolating / alienating it can be to be the person left out. You're basically being pre-excluded from a conversation, just to make it easier for communication with someone else -- your basic participation is less important than the other person's ease of communication. My X had no concern about them "talkin bout her behind her back" or anything, they were all friends, but she finally understood how it comes across.
While the majority of the work force may speak another language, the "main" language in a country is to me, meant to serve as a default for business. If I were multilingual, working in a foreign non-english country, I'd expect any business I worked for to require me to use their local language. Even more, when it comes to supervisors/team leads, hearing the conversations can also help you target potential issues -- like if you overhear a team member teaching something incorrectly. So there's a potential business liability type reason to make sure that all team members, especially oversight, can understand what's getting said if it pertains to the business.
Seems like a horribly xenophobic policy. Honestly a red flag.
I personally speak Spanish and French at work, in addition to obviously English. Work is the only place I really get to practice speaking French, and I take any chance I can to speak Spanish since I don't want to lose it
I think it makes sense to have a common language among all of the staff that is spoken whenever business is being discussed, in meetings and things like that.
I think that policing private conversations is kind of weird. I don't know why they would do that.
I could see this becoming necessary. In Amsterdam and other European tech hubs itβs common to have English-speaking offices, so itβd be bad for team cohesion to have the native speakers form a clique in the lunch room.
Here I am thinking that it would be sick to have more multilingual coworkers. I'm struggling through learning the basics of a couple second languages (not complaining, it is what it is and I'll get there eventually). So its nice to have a native or fluent speakers around to help communicate with someone who doesn't speak english that well. Or at all. At work our english-speaking offices expect people who are stationed there to be able to speak English, or to learn it if they don't. But it's not mandatory to speak it in-office. Usually it's just faster for people to speak other languages with non-english locations or ESL people. Honestly its usually it's the other way around, with people in other places learning English to talk with us, but that doesn't always work out well. Its nice to be able to do both.
Your (edit - former?) manager sounds sheltered and unprofessional, to say the least. I hope HR gets involved (unless they're racists too...)
At the break table talking another language, no problem. Needing it to be able to understand their job, problem. Unless your clients are mostly Spanish it is their needs that are being overlooked. They need someone fully competent in an official language. If nurses revert to Spanish when they don't understand things, then their manager doesn't know what it is that they are having a problem with, unless someone is translating for her. She could end up in trouble for putting someone on a task that they are not able to do. I don't immediately see it a a racist problem (although it could be) but a work safety problem.
I mean, foreign languages can and sometimes are used to talk shit about people without them knowing. Speaking English in a non-English place is rude for that reason as well, to make it less bait-y.
If even brief, well-explained excursions into Spanish are punished, that's ideology or personal paranoia, though.
I think it's mostly stupid and ethically questionable, except when your speech needs to be evaluated as a routine part of the job. I don't think worker to worker conversations should be impacted though.
That frankly sounds like power-tripping / intimidation, but perhaps I'm biased living amd working in a multi-lingual environment.
I believe "ah, claro, y seΓ±or puede chupar mis juevos con salsa fresca" would be a proper response.
I've actually had the opposite experience. When I happen to work with people that speak my second language it's usually them who don't want to speak their other language bc they don't want to exclude teammates.
I hope they then talked about this person right in front of her in Spanish. LOL.
Employers can go suck a big fat cock.
If the enployee can communicate with their managers and co-worker in English when needed and talk in an other language when they talk between them, there's nothing wrong.
Maybe this person is an asshole and has the reasonable expectation that people will say rude things about them if they can't understand what they are saying.
It sounds like you're dealing with a multinational company.
There may be value in having all employees operate in the company's ligua franca over a better language as it provides practice to employees to function in the common language.
It may be easier for you to function in Spanish now, but you may have to interface with employees in the future where they know English and not Spanish.
How do you help those who can't speak Spanish?
What companies are doing this?
It's being pushed in a lot of NZ hospitals at the moment. The claim is something along the lines of "all healthcare discussions need to be in english to avoid miscommunication", but in reality it's a bunch of white people getting upset because they think brown people are talking shit about them behind their backs.
Employers should mind their own business. The only people who have a problem with people speaking other languages in personal conversation are control freaks who think they have the right to know what everyone is saying all the time. The person I'm talking to understands that language, therefore I'm accomplishing my goal of communication with the sounds I'm making. Why do you care?
In meetings English or Dutch depending on the language skills of the people. Eating or anything else together the same. Two people from the same country collaborating on something with just the two of them, their own! Way more effective as long as their documentation is in English again :)
all 84 comments