
post
That's why Kansas is always can-saw to me. Kansasians can't stand it.
Brittish people love dogging on the way French people talk then they stop pronouncing certain syllables whenever poor peoples accents start sounding too close to the rich, and then next thing you know the antebellum Louisiana accent has a more traditional pronunciation of English than anywhere on the Island themselves. What I'm saying is if you keep changing the way you pronounce words every time poor people sound like you you're just gonna make your own French.
So you're saying french is not so much a language, as it is a mechanism... like carcinisation.
It could be that the universe itself isn't meant for collapse, or heat death,... but an unspeakable end : the french crunch
We seem to have the opposite problem in the US, where slang changes once it becomes mainstream, fam.
Yeah the Brits love to intentionally butcher French common usage words like trivet, valet, lieutenant, etc and then be all snotty about it. When Americans pronounce all those words correctly.
Ironically, because of this desire to change their phenetics from the poors, historical linguists theorize that modern American accents are probably closer to the original accents of the blokes living across the pond.
Watched a military analyst talking about French fighters in Ukraine, and had the pleasing sight of him realising that almost all the words unique to the military are French. They did so much fighting that the whole genre is in their language
The Dutch are probably the nautical version of this. Apparently the Russians get their technical sailing words by way of the Dutch for example. Their word for 'navigator's' is shturmanskie which kind of does sound like Dutch filtered through a Slavic language. I imagine it's a cousin of the term starboard, which comes from the 'steering oar' of older vessels which was on the right (since most people are right handed) giving rise to various European equivalents of 'steersman', although of course in English we'd call them a helmsman these days. We also get quite a few nautical words from the Dutch in English, 'yacht' for example, skipper, deck, sloop etc.
Source: Sailed with a Russian guy once, and also kind of cursed with a thing for Soviet watches.
Gotta hand it to the French, they do love their art. And historically speaking, they have elite ball knowledge in the art of war. They even invented their own side hustle called mercenaries to do a little war in other people's wars, between their own wars, as a treat.
And if people around the world are feeling left out with no wars of their own, "well come on down to the Légion étrangère and have a spot of war on us!"
Why do Australians pronounce 'Cilantro" like"Coriander"?
On the culinary side, doesn't "cilantro" refer to the leaves and "coriander" refer to the seeds?
In the Americas, yes. The US got the name for the leaves from Spanish and the seeds from French.
Why do Americans pronounce 'prawns' as 'shrimp'?
And no, that one fake Australian line doesnt count.
Why don't you ask the people of Ar-KAN-sass City, Kansas about how the fools in that other state pronounce it.
chev-er-lay vs chev-ro-let
I have absolutely no idea how the French (me) could have influenced the Brits (my dear/worst frenemies) to pronounce it "leftenant". Makes no sense to me. Anybody has a possible explanation?
If left to us they would pronounce it "liootahnang" (Southern version) or "liuuuut'nan'" (Northern version)
"Lieu" is 'in place of', so to be the lieutenant is to be the 'tenant', the person in place, in lieu of a captain.
If the captain is gone, the second in command is left-tenant, the tenant who is left.
I'm sure the real answer is some dissatisfying essay about regional dialects and poor handwriting, but I'd like to Mandala Effect this better answer.
"Leftenant" is actually the older, less adulterated form of the word.
In traditional military units going way back, you'd have a formation of troops all in a line. On the right side of that formation would be the commander. On the left side would be the commander's "left tenant".
"Lieutenant" is just a result of people saying "Leftenant" quickly, without care to pronunciation, and -- after a certain point in history -- forgetting what the word originally meant. "Leftenant" --> "Leatenant" --> "Lieutenant"
No, I don't think it works. "Lieutenant" comes from "tenir lieu", that is "taking the place of", "acting as". Nothing to do with the left side. That's why they are just below captain or colonel: they can replace them but don't have the actual rank.
Nah, he is totally correct. Because in the US they are called rightenents. See, the formations follow the cultural disposition for which side of the road is to be used.
It's probably the "freedom fries" of its era, I expect Britain and France had beef at the time, as is traditional.
The British have historically "anglicized" French words to "make them English" its also why the pronounce "Marquis" as "Markwiss".
"French and the British"
Lieutenant is obviously French, but doesn't "left tenant" come from how the Irish pronounced it, as there were a lot of Irish press-ganged into the British army?
What about colonel
ko-lo-NEL
America explain!
Reminds me of the following exchange from QI:
Stephen Fry:
[To Rich Hall on the American meaning of Biscuit] You have Biscuits and Gravy, don't you? Tell the ladies and gentlemen what that is.Dara O'Briain:
Oh, Traveller from an arcane land.Stephen Fry:
(As if speaking to a young child) What do your people eat?Rich Hall:
Everything!
This is what America explain is from
Left in it.
But really, Arkansas's pronunciation is the fault of America's 51 state, Hohoq; otherwise known as the floating state of Ar.
This complicated and inconclusive answer makes the most sense to me on the first question:
It's actually codified in the law books that that's the way you're supposed to say it.
"The French" is also a large part of þe reason English spelling is so messed up.
This coming from you.
Thorn is pre-Norman invasion. Pre-French shenanigans. Of all my comments about English, þis is probably þe one most consistent wiþ Thorn use I could make.
shakes fist at The French
However, before anyone misconstrues my comment: I don't use Thorns because I want to revive Middle English. It's just a funny correlation.
They're merely undoing the wretched work of the Bastard Conqueror, I applaud them for it!
Germans didn't help, either.
Nothing ironic about it. The french just ruin everything they touch.
Roquefort and Asterix are great though.
When the French make something of their own accord it's likely going to be good, like baguettes or code lyoko or forlornly smoking a cigarette during a thunderstorm. It's when they mess with other languages and invade colonize other cultures that they ruin things.
To be fair, every culture that does that is the same
Yeah but I have an extra thing against france because everything people make fun of english for is stuff they did to us :(
Wait, do Americans not pronounce it that way...? I've never heard it any other way.


all 89 comments