Is there a way to make sure people can accept criticism? Or will they always feel offended?

edit after the first few comments: this is about criticing others i collaborate with in online communities where we predominantly communicate through text

all 44 comments

sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[–] 23 points 1 day ago (2 children)

By making it constructive. Don't just point out what is wrong, show them a path to get to the right place.

  • source
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • Also, are you in a position where it's expected that you give feedback? If not, might be worth leading with, "Hey, are you open to a small bit of feedback on [...]?" Or just learn to keep it to yourself. Things don't have to be perfect, and your way isn't necessarily the only way.

    Basically, there's no simple answer.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 5 points 23 hours ago

    Careful here though; people often react negatively to being told how to do something they’ve already been tasked with doing, because it looks a lot like micro managing or taking over.

    Two things that help are: asking for help yourself, and making the suggestion for how they should do Y in the context of how you should do X, asking them if they think that approach would be a good idea.

    Then you come across as approachable, demonstrate collaboration by example, and get to sneak in the right way to do things so it’s on their mind while they’re trying to find their own solution.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 17 points 1 day ago (1 child)

    Damn, is this is the default sub for unrecognized autism?

    As an a peer-reiewed autistic person, the answer is no. Though if you are required to, you are supposed to precede and follow the criticism with a compliment to make a jellyfish sandwich which hopefully only stings after you've left the room.

  • source
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 14 points 13 hours ago

    Give feedback, not criticism. Avoid using the word "you" as much as possible -- that is usually interpreted as an attack and shifts them into the defensive. Talk about the effect that their actions or choices had on you. Focus on your experience and try to put it to words. Use I-statements (as opposed to you-statements). Name your feelings and needs in the situation. Feelings and needs are universal, so you're much more likely to connect and get through to them.

    These are some of the principles of Nonviolent Communication. If you want to dig in (much) deeper, read the book by Marshall Rosenberg. Good luck!

  • source
  • [–] 11 points 23 hours ago (1 child)

    The more narcissistic they are, the worse they take it. The more people enable them, the more narcissistic they get.

  • source
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 10 points 23 hours ago* (last edited 4 hours ago) (1 child)

    Context is everything.

    Is it the place, the time, is it actionable, is it between their area of responsibility, are there other factors out of their control that conditions their actions, are they acting in good or bad faith, is it a matter of attitude, skill, resources, willingness, priorities, awareness, assumptions, incorrect information, and a whole slew of conditionals I'm forgetting right now.

    You mention you all have the same goal. Start by challenging said assumption in yourself. That shall clue you in on where you need to start the conversation. Find the logical reason why they are acting in a way you see as erroneous. Because you think is wrong, but obviously they don't. Few people do things they think are wrong on purpose. Ask them, and try to see the issue from their perspective. Then it will be obvious how you should address the issue.

    PS: always be kind and empathetic. Address actions and consequences, not character and personality. Remember, unless you're psychotically talking to an LLM, there's a human on the other side of the screen. Just like you.

  • source
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 9 points 23 hours ago

    Criticism is better received when it’s about an action or outcome, not a person. Saying “you” a lot puts someone on the defensive. Focus on a specific event and its effects.

  • source
  • [–] 9 points 12 hours ago (2 children)

    Just start your message with "No offense".

  • source
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 8 points 23 hours ago (2 children)

    Oi fuckface, stop doing that, it is shit. Do it like this.

    Very effective, it may offend them, it may not.

  • source
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 7 points 23 hours ago

    It's pretty easy when the person you're criticizing is mature.

  • source
  • [–] 6 points 1 day ago (1 child)

    I don't think there is a way unless you already know them.

  • source
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 1 point 21 hours ago

    If you are familiar to someone or if you have met them in person, that means that your ability to convince them of something is surely improved. However, there is surely an appropriate way to try to come to an agreement with someone that is a complete stranger to you. For example, if I was waiting in a line and someone stepped in front of me, I would say "Um, excuse me, I was in line. Were you... also trying to get in line?" (which would imply that they should have gotten in line behind me rather than in front of me, while expressing that I think that they merely didn't notice that I was in line rather than that I think that they intentionally "cut in line"). I expect that saying that would lead to me getting what I want (which is for them to move out of my way so that I retain my position in the line), and even if it doesn't immediately lead to me getting what I want I expect that it will lead to the people around me believing that I should not be in line behind the person I talked to (which will likely result in me getting what I want).

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 6 points 23 hours ago (2 children)

    "Doing A causes B." This identifies the action and explains the results of that action, without criticizing the person at all. It doesn't even directly criticize the action, just points out an undesirable result.

  • source
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 2 points 22 hours ago (1 child)

    You could also express "I think that doing A causes B, but I'd like to know more about whether that's true."

    By using "I think that", you express that you have some doubt in yourself and that you accept that you could be incorrect, which indicates that if a person disagrees with you it's not a huge problem. Expressing that "I'd like to know more about whether that's true" reinforces that indication, and additionally expresses that you are inviting discussion about your thought because you are interested in becoming more "correct" (I considered suggesting to use "I'd like to be more certain about that", but if you are incorrect in your thinking then becoming less certain might lead to you becoming more correct: "sometimes a little uncertainty isn't all that bad").

    As an alternative to expressing doubt, you could express confidence by using words like "I am 100% confident that" so that you can express that you would probably not become more happy if someone disagreed with you. If you don't express any information about how comfortable you are with someone disagreeing with you, someone who does disagree with you might be uncertain about how you'll react to an expression of disagreement, which will surely lead to them being less comfortable and will surely make it harder for them to choose how/whether to inform you that they disagree with you.

    I'd like to note that if you always express doubt by using "I think that" then it will become less interesting as time passes: if people notice that you always express doubt then they'll surely begin to "skim" your messages by skipping reading "I think that" any time you write that, so at some point you might as well just save everyone time and stop writing that. Therefore, I try to provide more specific information about my confidence level by using different vocabulary, like "I suspect that" (to express low confidence) or "I expect that" (to express relatively high confidence, while still expressing that I would be surprised but not angry if I turned out to be incorrect) or "It's surely true that" (to express that I have extreme confidence (to the point that I am assuming that what I'm expressing is 100% true), while still avoiding any explicit expression that I would be angry if someone disagreed with me (if I expressed "It's surely true that the store closes at midnight" and it turns out that it closed one hour before midnight, I wouldn't be angry at the person I said that to since they didn't contribute to me being incorrect)).

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 2 points 20 hours ago* (last edited 3 hours ago)

    I realized that I didn't mention an alternative for "I think" that I use often: "It seems". To me, "It seems" is quite similar to "I think", though "It seems" expresses more confidence (it expresses that a thing definitely has a particular quality, though that quality is only "seeming" (having an outward appearance), which doesn't comment on the reality of the situation since how something "seems" is only related to someone's initial interpretation of the overall outward appearance of that thing), and "It seems" also expresses that your opinion is influenced by an actual observation (I could say "I think that Berlin and Moscow are close to each other" even if I don't have any relevant experience about that topic, but if I say "It seems cold today" it expresses either that I have actually been outside to experience the weather or at least that someone has reported information about today's weather to me).

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 5 points 23 hours ago (1 child)
  • [–] 5 points 23 hours ago

    In a business setting, I would advise having this discussion with the person in person. In writing you miss out on tone. You could read my text in a condescending tone or in the friendly neutral one I intend. But I have no control over that once I send my text to you. There is a danger of miscommunication and these little things build up.

    Is there a way to get the person on a video call?

    Different people behave in different ways. I think there is a good chunk of people that will see reason when presented with it. However, being caught in an error isn't a nice feeling for most. So a scenario where you tell somebody in person matter of factly they effed up, they quickly think about it, nod understandingly, and swear to never do it again is not very likely. There will be resentment. The question is how long will it last. And a lot of that depends on how you present your criticism.

    Feedback is hard. Both giving and receiving. As a giver, you need to choose your words carefully. Tackle the ball, not the player. Don't make personal attacks but describe the process that went wrong and how to do better. Start the conversation with something positive, a compliment that needs to come across as heartfelt and not perfunctory. That's often the hardest part for the giver. You probably have an idea of how the conversation will go. You need to be able to adjust your presentation when the conversation doesn't go as expected. And you need to know that there is a good chance they will leave this conversation thinking you are the bad guy. Ideally, this wouldn't last more than sleeping on it a couple of nights. But people are people and people hold grudges. That's often just the way it is.

  • source
  • [–] 5 points 16 hours ago

    If you come off as accusatory then people will respond defensively. Conflict virtually always takes two.

    When I felt disrespected I pulled the guy aside and asked if I had unknowingly offended them and what I can do to make it right. Turns out his behaviour had nothing to do with me. He apologized and acted extra nice towards me from there on.

  • source
  • [–] 4 points 20 hours ago

    If they wouldn't appreciate the criticism and it's none of your business, I recommend keeping your mouth shut. It's not your responsibility to police other people.

    If the behavior in question is affecting you and or a broader community, that may (or may not) be another matter. In such a case, try to speak positively about what good an alternative behavior might do rather than on criticizing their negative behavior.

  • source
  • [–] 4 points 23 hours ago* (last edited 4 hours ago)

    Asking questions to point out an alternative option can sometimes help and let people provide input on the idea, without telling people they are wrong.

    For example at an environmental group:

    More direct and may hurt feelings:

    CO2 emissions are destroying the planet and by allowing gas cars, we are certain to collapse the AMOK, leading to food supply collapse. Our current campaign is bad and won't make a difference. We shouldn't be spending our influence campaign telling people to recycle and need to ask people to call their elected officials and demand better cheap green transportation! Not collapsing the AMOK should be the priority.

    Less direct but may spare feelings:

    I know we've been thinking about doing an information campaign about recycling, but I've been wondering more about the AMOK collapse, which seems likely to happen and is so linked to CO2 emissions. I wonder if anyone has thought about our campaign focusing on having people write officials to push for more green public transportation to try to slow down the AMOK weakening. Do you think educating people on the risks of the AMOK collapse would be too confusing or would it be effective?

    I also think that sometimes being extremely emotionally aware and too careful can sometimes be unhelpful. Like, if the goal is to not hurt people's feelings, then asking for input can help. If the goal is actually to not waste time or resources, than being direct is better.

    Also, this is an example, I am not sure if AMOK collapse is directly tied to just CO2.

  • source
  • [–] 4 points 18 hours ago

    Robert's Rules of Order Revised is a published manual of parliamentary practice (which might be used during an in-person meeting of a board of a corporation or of a charitable organization), and it describes "debate" (essentially meaning "organized communication performed in order to allow people to clearly explain their opinion about whether a particular thing should be done"), and it specifically describes "Decorum in Debate": https://robertsrules.org/rror-07.htm

    The 1915 version of Robert's Rules of Order Revised describes at least one thing that I've seen elsewhere from this discussion: "It is not allowable to arraign the motives of a member, but the nature or consequences of a measure may be condemned in strong terms. It is not the man, but the measure, that is the subject of debate."

    The copyright on the original 1915 version of Robert's Rules of Order Revised has expired, so it is in the public domain and is quite easy to access. However, I want to note that rules for "electronic meetings" are at least somewhat different from the rules for in-person meetings. When discussing something with people in person, it's a trivial matter to explain to someone who's sitting next to you that something unfair has happened (you can just turn your head towards them and start talking). However, I don't think it would be a trivial matter to contact other people who are far away from you if someone were to "accidentally" remove you from a conference call or if someone maliciously interfered with your ability to transmit information using the Internet. For at least this reason, you would probably be better off by acting at least somewhat differently when you're interacting with someone using the Internet than when you're interacting with someone in person. Information about how to act for "Electronic Meetings" is documented in more detail around https://robertsrules.com/sample-rules-for-electronic-meetings/

    I'd like to note that the "Robert's" manuals also make reference to or define certain rights which might provide useful context about what a useful "debate" is (or perhaps even context about communication that is not a "debate"), such as "the right to introduce questions and the right of free discussion before being required to vote on finally disposing of a question". These manuals also define how to exercise "the power to suspend these rules and rights". https://robertsrules.org/robertsrules.pdf

    I believe that the "Robert's" manuals are essentially guides on how to be polite while trying to make something interesting happen. I hope that, by reading one or more of them (or even just a part of one or two), you can become more proficient at that.

    Because you are "collaborating" with other people, you might be interested in various parts of the "Robert's" manuals. For example, you might benefit from understanding the procedure for voting, since there are subtle effects of the procedure. A specific example is that if nobody expresses that they want a particular thing to happen then nobody is required to express that they oppose having that thing happen: no thing can be considered legitimate without gaining support from more people than the number of people who oppose that thing ("Any legitimate motion not included among those mentioned below as requiring more than a majority vote, requires for its adoption only a majority; that is, more than half of the votes cast, ignoring blanks, at a legal meeting where a quorum is present, unless a larger vote for its adoption is required by the rules of the assembly."), and people who support doing something have to vote first ("The question is on the adoption of the resolution [which the chair reads]; those in favor of the resolution say aye; those opposed say no."), and when both of these things are true that means that if nobody expresses that they want a particular thing to happen and then nobody expresses that they oppose having that thing happen that means that the number of people who supported the thing happening did not exceed the number of people who opposed having that thing happen (0 is not more than 0) so the thing happening wouldn't be considered to be legitimate even though nobody supported or opposed it.

  • source
  • [–] 4 points 22 hours ago

    Is there a way to make sure people can accept criticism?

    No, no matter how helpful it might be or how kindly worded or whatever other circumstance you account for, you can't control other people, so they may or may not accept your criticism, there's no 100% surety about it.

    Or will they always feel offended?

    False dichotomy. As others have provided advice for, there are many ways to provide criticism without offending, but that's no guarantee that your criticism will be heeded.

  • source
  • [–] 4 points 14 hours ago

    I try to couch criticism and disagreement with something I liked or agree with first, or that I repeat back, paraphrasing to the person how I understood their argument, before I launch into the criticism. Using passive voice to describe the counterpoint or negative consequence instead of accusing your message recipient directly can avoid defensive knee-jerk reactions. I think you want to invite reflection and a serious consideration of your argument or criticism, so that's what I would do.

  • source
  • [–] 3 points 22 hours ago* (last edited 4 hours ago) (2 children)
    1. I've noticed [problem] is happening.
    2. This seems like a problem to me because [reason, if not obvious].
    3. It looks to me like [your behaviour] is contributing to [problem] by [explanation, if not obvious].
    4. Do you think i've missed something? How do you think we can address [problem]?

    Some variation of that is what i do, taking out anything that would seem patronizing.

    I try to keep open to the possibility of me being wrong, even when i know i'm not, to create a vibe of peers working a problem together rather than heirarchical smart-person yell at dumb person kinda thing.

  • source
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 1 point 13 hours ago (1 child)

    I was shit at giving negative feedback and I have to do that regularly at work. HR gave me a variation of this PDF, that feels basically like your list.

    This is called STAR/AR, and it basically says to stay as objective as possible and follow almost the same steps for both positive and negative feedback. After you get the person somewhat comfortable, you do this:

    • ST - describe the situation or task that you're giving feedback to
    • A - describe the action the person took
    • R - describe what was the result of the action

    and then, if you want to correct the behavior, you use the AR (that stands for alternative result) - ask the person what could have been a better action to avoid that result. You can then help them to explore alternative actions of they struggle to think of anything.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 3 points 20 hours ago

    WRONG.

    Just kidding. But actually, that's sort of an example of the literal opposite way to handle things: See if there's anything you can be positive about and agre with. Start with that, and then try to bring in the things you think are wrong a bit more softly. The more you can agree with them about, the better the chances they'll be open to listening to your suggestions for corrections.

  • source
  • [–] 3 points 23 hours ago

    Isolate the actions that this person did and criticse the actions, with an explanation of why they're 'bad' and what the 'good' alternatives are.

    Remember that, when you're in a team, you're trying to improve the whole team.

  • source
  • [–] 2 points 4 hours ago

    For irl criticism, the biggest things are 1 making sure it the appropriate time and place, and 2 is it appropriate for ME to be giving this feedback or am I being nosy? It may be legitimate for them to push back and I am the one not taking that feedback appropriately.

    Online both are harder. DMs tend to be better than in public, and if it's not something solicited or directly affecting you, maybe it's best to let it go. Especially if you don't have a prior relationship with the account online.

  • source
  • [–] 3 points 1 day ago (2 children)

    Nowadays, there is no way to not offend someone. People doing shit wrong are a protected class and telling them they are wrong is likely going to cause you big problems.

    Just let them be wrong knowing there is nothing you can do about it.

  • source
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 1 point 8 hours ago

    I generally find that describing how that person's actions make other people feel and the impact of such actions on others usually works.

    That said, whilst most people do shit things without actually thinking or realizing the full impact of their actions on others, some people do not give a shit in any way for or shape about the harm and hurt caused to others by their actions and such people will be offended merelly by being confronted with it.

    Also, constructive criticism is done privatelly. Doing it publicly is a form of public shaming and, IMHO, only the assholes that couldn't give a damn about others deserved it, not because they're actually shamed but because of the negative impact for them when others around them figure out the kind of things they do and how little they care about how much it fucks other people up.

  • source
  • [–] 1 point 7 hours ago

    No. You can't. They will be offended 95/100 times.

  • source
  • [–] 0 points 15 hours ago* (last edited 2 hours ago)

    first: does what they do directly affect you in any way shape or form? like will it impact you and your life in a negative way? and if so is the concern that you need to address them in order to for them to understand how it is impacting you in a negative way?

    second: if the above does not apply; did they explicitly ask you for your criticism on the thing?

    third: are you absolutely, without one iota of a doubt know enough about the situation to be the one giving the criticism? and i mean absolutely sure. like you did your research.

    if you answer 'no' to all questions: Then no. there is no way to make someone accept what you are giving as criticism cuz it is not constructive criticism you're giving.

  • source