I've been doing it for years!
post
Does getting a cheap $4 unfrozen Aldi Pizza, adding grilled chicken tossed in buffalo sauce, covering it with more cheese, and cooking it in the smoker you found on the side of the road, count?


I splurged for a pizza steel, which pretty much means you're cooking with the same tools the takeout is, so you can satisfy even very picky eaters who want it to look like the restaurant.

One thing that I've found really matters is making the dough well ahead of time. A lot of people say the day before, I age it in the fridge for usually 5 days, but between 3 and 11 have all worked great.
The longer it goes the less bready and more crusty it gets, but it also gets stickier which eventually becomes too much of a pita to deal with.
If I'm baking bread that week I will make enough to be pizza crust and it might age between two and 14 days. If I'm not making bread then it's usually a day to hours ahead of time and a different recipe.
it also gets stickier which eventually becomes too much of a pita to deal with
Oil your hands and/or roll the dough ball in flour. You'll still have to wash your hands after but oil is way easier to wash off than stuck-on dough
Aged dough is the best but even 1-2 hours ahead is gonna be great. I’m parital to Adam Ragusea‘s pan pizza recipes.
Charlie Anderson is also great.
I ended up using 12:7:1 bread flour:water:olive oil. 1.5mL fine salt and 1mL of instant yeast per 100 total grams.
So, 720g flour, 420g water, 60g olive oil + 1.5 tsp salt and 1.5 tsp yeast gives you 4 300g crusts.
That yields a crust firm enough that you can eat the whole pizza out of your hand if you want, which I usually want because then I don't have to wash a cutting board.
Working in a pizza shop:
Dough was made the day before for tomorrow.
Dough made in the morning could be ready for the evening if it was real busy.

Made pan pizza a few weeks ago and it beats the pants off of delivery for a fraction of the cost. Gotta love home made
Cast iron makes a great pizza crust.
One tip I like, is to sprinkle corn meal on the pan to lift the dough ever so slightly. It makes the crust just that bit more crispy on the bottom and chewy on top.
I have to try this. I have an Ooni and I am not really happy with how it cooks pizza. Too hot so constant turning and if you’re too generous with toppings, it never cooks in the middle. Always needs an oven finish. I have a 12” pan that should work a treat for next time.
Been working on perfecting dough in my bread maker off and on this year.
Last weeks pie.

I don't follow any particular recipe for the dough. I only rough measure, don't weigh anything. I started with a pretty standard no knead bread dough and messed with it until it worked well for pizza. 3+ day cold ferment.
Toppings are whatever I have.
I really need to find a way to make gluten-free dough that doesn't suck and doesn't take a ton of effort. Gluten-free flour is not a thing where I live and is prohibitively expensive to import.
Have you tried cauliflower crust?
Yeah, I wasn't a huge fan, sadly. I much prefer thick, yeasty crust. Ideally, I'd like to do something like a Detroit-style or even a grandma pie sort of thing. I can probably get there with some combination of rice flour, xanthum gum, and some other stuff, but it's such a pain compared to flour, water, yeast, salt, and sugar.
I've only had them at chain places and they aren't bad, I would even say good! And that's mass produced slop. I'm certain if I were to make it home it would be a hundred times better.
So say we all.
You got a lot going on there. What are your toppings?
Ok so this one is kinda out there: The A&A, which is artichoke and avocado, also with carmalized onion, goat cheese, mozzarella and sharp white cheddar.
I mostly stick to the classics, but I've made some crazy (good) pizzas in my day.
Do you buy the bread(already made dough)? Or do you make the dough at home? I cook three meals a day (middle Eastern food), but never tried making pizza at home to be honest. I’m now intrigued. Do share your secrets, please.
I make two kinds of pizza dough. If I'm making bread that week I'll make enough dough for pizza and let it age in the fridge for days to days and days.
I start with 360 grams of flour, a tsp of salt, a tsp of sugar, 1 tsp each of oregano and basil in the dry mix. I add 295 grams of water with 1 tsp sugar and 7 grams of yeast that had been bloomed.
I add flour as needed during the 8 minute knead. Maybe as much as 120 grams. Maybe half that.
This is two pizzas worth of dough.
Rise once, shape to pan with oil, butter, corn flour, semolina or parchment paper between it and the pan. Toss a cast iron pan on the bottom rack of the oven. Crank the oven to 450 or 500 f. Assemble the pizza and bake it for ... Until it's done. Depending on thickness this might be 10 to 30 minutes.
Sure you can buy the dough. But honestly that's a waste of money. Pizza dough I'd literally 4 ingredients - flour, water, oil, salt. That's it. (Unless you want a thick crust, in which case you add yeast)
So just a normal bread. I’m sorry if these are dumb questions, but I’ve never really made a pizza. lol. Do you ferment yours, or just make the dough and go to town?
pretty much, flat bread with toppings. the recipes/books i have all do bulk ferment in the fridge at least overnight to a few days, divide/shape to balls a day before (and back in the friddge)
Pizza dough is risen like bread, preferably longer than most breads. I do mine in the fridge for a couple of days. It is bread, just with stronger (gluteny) flour, pulled flat, and cooked very hot. It also usually has a little more oil than a typical loaf bread. Most bready products are variations of those ingredients with different techniques and 1-2 additions/subtractions.
And yeast! One extra I always do is tiny pinch of gluten to make the crust pizzeria-chewy.
Counter offer, you make a pizza at my home
Cost per person before toppings: $2.77
Will tbf, split a costo pizza between 4 people and you're already ahead 🤷
I don't have a Costco membership. Or a Costco within 24 miles.
Now that looks tasty. Did you make your own dough, or use a dough from the deli?
EDIT: Durr. Should've read all the comments.
Cost per person is $2.77? I see only 2 portions in that photo.
I make French Bread Pizzas with a big Cuban loaf from the grocery store. The trick is to coat the bread with garlic olive oil, and toast it for about 5 minutes before putting the sauce, cheese, and toppings on. That way, it's toasted all the way through, without burning the toppings.
We make them all summer long in the pizza oven and heart shaped pizzas for Valentine's day. The kids love helping make them and coming up with different toppings to try.
The smoke detectors in my place go off every time I’ve made pizza so I don’t make pizza at home anymore :c
Pizza looks SO good! I think I'm seeing peperoni, olives, and banana peppers? Good combo if so!
The distribution of olives is all outta wack.
Been using this recipe (serious eat is my goto) in a (big, oblong) air fryer that only does 210C, so you have to par bake it on baking paper for ~ 6 min before toppings. Comes out as good as delivery pizza (so not as good as it could be, but I no longer have a normal oven). The food processor thing works surprisingly well, but you have to be careful in timing, too long and it gets super sticky and annoying (equivalent to over kneading I guess), pull it when it's in the ball phase (like 12 seconds) and knead a bit manually with flour, divvy into balls and fridge for a few days.
Now I'm going to experiment with cast iron and/or the Weber, thanks for the inspiration.
I need to try this again. Every now and then I get pre-made dough from Aldi and do a stromboli with their Italian trio (genoa salami, provolone cheese, and pepperoni) and some extra mozzarella. We've talked about doing a pizza with Aldi dough, but we've never actually done it. I brought home a take out pizza from a local restaurant today, so it's pizza night for us, too.
Where the recipes at?
I love homemade pizzas! Nice toppings. On the subject of toppings and price, if you do want something delicious and a bit more expensive: Fig & Prosciutto pizza.
- Flatbread
- Fig Spread + a little pizza sauce
- Fine shredded mozzarella
- Prosciutto
Anyone know a good gluten free base recipe? Tried and tested if possible!
all 75 comments