cross-posted from: https://piefed.social/c/mrlovenstein/p/1660117/volume
cross-posted from: https://piefed.social/c/nonpolitical_comics/p/1657114/mr-lovenstein-volume
[Mr Lovenstein] Volume
Hey everyone! In case you haven't noticed, this is a new community focused on NonPolitical Comics (NPCs), which essentially means no gloom and doom of the day stuff. If you like the idea, help out by upvoting, commenting, or even talking about us! Remember, click like and subscribe!
(insert lengthy explanation and complaint about compression and audio mixing here)
I had this with ads. It made me hate whatever product they were advertising.
This is because Reptilians don't have human ears, and can't tell how to balance audio correctly
Subtitles!
TBF this always ends up with a lot of misplaced blame on the consumer
TV manufacturers decided/figured out long ago that Joe public cares more about a screen being thin, at time of purchase, than it having any semblance of audio quality. And they assume anyone who cares about audio will buy a set of speakers or (increasingly) a sound bar anyway, so they just need the bare minimum included.
This has gotten to the absurd point now where the speakers included in your average TV aren't much better than a particularly loud phone speaker.
It's basically impossible to get something that sounds even audible on those speakers, without doing what adverts do and compressing the shit out of the signal, which has the bonus of sounding loud and bad for everyone, there's no bringing the detail back that was squashed out. Movie studios aren't going to mix a movie that sounds bad on a system designed remotely properly (e.g. a cinema or reviewer's TV), so we're in the current situation.
The unfortunate situation today is you basically need some kind of separate speaker(s) with a TV because the manufacturers all have cheaped out across the board and don't include anything good enough any more. The consumer shouldn't be expected to know this and have to pay extra, the TV should come with speakers capable of producing audio properly.
It's very weird how many pro audio people knowingly fail at their core job in this way
When someone left the TV on max volume and I load up Netflix whilst everyone is in bed.
And then suddenly an advert at a volume loud enough to ablate the skin right off your face
I swear by now there should be a media player that would have auto-balance build in. Nowadays i can't watch movie without a subtitle, i just can't subject myself with them merican can't pronounce word properly and bad audio balance.
I remember one movie I tried watching that was exceptionally bad in this department. I want to say it was Interstellar from 2014? I gave up not long into it because it was just torture to watch.
It is nutty the skill-gap that has opened up for audio engineers since talkies existed.
Large dynamic range is a good thing, in audio and video. There are a number of ways to reduce dynamic range, if you really need to. Expanding dynamic range after capture is possible, too, but more fraught.
Shannon information theory gives us ways to perfectly reconstruct the lower range version from an expanded range version, but it also guarantees that reconstructing the higher range version from a reduced range version cannot be perfectly accurate across all inputs. (Assuming a fixed output range capability.)
Trying to watch Sons of Anarchy in bed is too much like this.
settings: anything but movie settings
There's already a solution to this. Limiters / compressors. TVs should have them built in as software with easy to use controls. Whenever I watch movies via VLC I turn the compressor on.
Modern filmmaking. I had this issue with Minority Report many years ago alredy. Now I mostly use headphones - so this isn't as pronounced, but it's still an issue
This is why I use earphones.
all 98 comments