[–] 4 points 6 days ago

How many situations have there been in actual Batman media^[Excluding the ones that ignore the no killing rule, obviously] where Batman refuses to kill someone knowing that doing so will directly cause the imminent deaths of innocent people? Not some theoretical future harm based on an assumption that a criminal will escape and kill again, a situation where subduing a criminal is not enough to prevent them from killing someone and the only way to save a life is by killing the bad guy first.^[The closest I can recall is a cartoon where he and several other heroes had the opportunity to kill Granny Goodness, and then later he had the opportunity to blow up Apokolips and take out Darkseid and all of his minions. The former is a somewhat questionable decision because she can't be arrested and imprisoned, it was a choice between killing her and letting go and the harm she would inflict afterwards is predictable if not immediate. The latter is a more impactful decision, but it's a lot harder to argue that getting everyone out alive and ending the immediate conflict is obviously morally inferior to killing an entire planet full of people (including yourself, your team and the people you came to rescue) just to take out its leaders.]

The argument always seems to be that Batman should kill the Joker instead of capturing him because the Joker will escape again and thus will kill again. Of course, in-universe the Joker's escape is not inevitable. We only know he will always escape because he is a popular villain that the writers will keep bringing back. Batman can't know that. And even with that knowledge the argument falls apart because killing Joker won't stop him anymore than arresting him would.

But beyond that, why is it Batman's job to play judge, jury and executioner? And exactly how do we decide when someone is so evil and dangerous that they should be killed even if they could instead be captured and imprisoned? The whole argument starts looking a lot shakier when we take away the costumes and start applying the same logic to normal people in the real world. I suspect most of us would be uncomfortable with a cop just shooting someone instead of arresting them because they figured they'd end up back on the street at some point, or a paramedic letting an unconscious murder suspect bleed out because they might kill again.

Also, we already have Batman but he kills people. He's called the Punisher. Somehow, despite decades of waging a much more literal war on crime, all those innocent people don't seem to be any safer. Funny how that works.^[Yes, I know, this is applying meta logic again, but that's half the point. No course of action the hero takes will ever succeed if doing so would completely undermine the core concept of an ongoing series. And without being able to rely on some out-of-universe justification to claim that the consequences will be better, it's pretty fucking hard to argue that the Punisher's methods are morally superior from an in-universe perspective.]

  • source
  • [–] 3 points 1 week ago

    He's not getting removed by this Congress. If the next Congress somehow manages to get enough Republicans to cross the aisle or be absent during the vote in order to actually remove him from office, his replacement will have be approved by the senate. Either way, it's hard to see any of these asshats coasting into the job.

  • source
  • [–] 18 points 1 week ago

    There is no law against advocating for impeachment. If there were such a law it would be blatantly unconstitutional on first amendment grounds.

    What I haven't seen pointed out yet is that even if there were some case that could be made, the speech and debate clause still covers this and grants immunity to members of congress for this very reason.

    Unfortunately, even with 56 Democrats in the senate it would still take at least 11 Republican senators to remove Blanche from office (assuming no absences). I'm not terribly optimistic that anything he does will ever be enough to sway those votes. But if anything is likely to do it, it's gonna be systematically tearing through the safeguards that protect those very senators.

  • source
  • [–] 13 points 2 weeks ago (1 child)

    This makes far too many unsupported assumptions.

    • That an effect capable of turning a woman straight must also be capable of turning a man gay.
    • That the requirements for both tasks are the same, or at least similar enough to dismiss the idea that one might fall outside the realm of possibility.
    • That if something is theoretically possible it must actually exist.

    Proving the existence of King Midas does not prove that there are other monarchs out there capable of transmuting matter into silver, or lead, or helium. It might imply that such a thing is possible, but without more information we can't say for sure.

  • source
  • [–] 7 points 2 weeks ago* (last edited 2 weeks ago) (1 child)

    It's your standard superweapon problem. Why put all the money and resources into a single massive weapon that can be destroyed when you could instead make a lot of smaller, more practical stuff for the same price? We don't make battleship sized tanks, and not just because of the physics problems they'd have trying to move on land. Hell, we don't make giant battleships for the sea any more either, and that's the one place where there isn't a physics problem.

    What advantage is there to using a giant robot? What does it do that's more effective than existing vehicles, drones, weapon platforms etc? Sure, it can walk over terrain that might be hard for some ground vehicles, but we already have shit that can fly. It could have multiple weapons to choose between if it uses them by hand, but we are still paying for those and could instead mount them on cheaper platforms and use them all at once. Other than style points, the only thing I can think of is the utility that comes from having giant hands to pick stuff up. Being a heavily armed combat crane is probably not worth the investment.

  • source
  • [–] 29 points 2 weeks ago* (last edited 2 weeks ago) (2 children)

    Setting the agenda: Trump can veto any legislation they pass, but that will almost certainly backfire on Republicans if the Democrats pass bills that will be popular with the people. With enough pressure, Trump may let some things through or some Republicans may join Democrats to overturn a veto. A recent example would be the Epstein Files Transparency Act which managed to get through because the political cost of opposing it became clear to Republicans. Plus, the government needs funding so if Trump vetoes the funding the government shuts down, which will definitely hurt Republicans.

    Investigations: This is the thing most people are talking about and it is a very big deal. They can issue subpoenas, compel testimony, and drag all the shady shit into the light of day. And even if Trump pardons people the evidence uncovered by these investigations can be used in state court and civil suits.

    Blocking nominations: Senate approval is required for most presidential nominations and many of the clowns we are stuck with only barely made it through under Republicans. Judges, US attorney's, Supreme Court justices, and anyone filling a vacant cabinet position would need a majority vote. Even military promotions could be affected, though that's only likely to come up in extreme cases.

    Impeachment: A simple majority in the House can start an impeachment, but it takes 2/3 of the Senate to remove someone from office. That means Republican votes would be needed, which means that the only people we would be likely to see removed from office are the ones that would probably resign or be fired before getting to that point.

    Don't overlook the state elections: All the attention goes to the House and Senate, but governors, legislatures and attorneys general at the state level are also hugely important. A lot of Republican power has come from their ability to use their power in state governments to tip the balance of elections. The long term consequences here can be huge. In less than a decade Wisconsin has gone from Republicans having supermajorities in the legislature as well as the governor and the state supreme court to having Democrats in control of all three branches, and you can trace it all back to Democrats winning a gubernatorial election and a supreme court election.

    The machinery of politics: The fallout here will reshape both parties. Democrats had lost a lot of ground after writing off huge swaths of the country and the victories they just saw will only reinforce the need to compete in every state, something that the new leadership in the DNC finally made a priority. The conversation about who can get elected and where just got a lot more complicated, but the obvious takeaway is that candidate quality matters.

    For Republicans, there will likely be a tremendous amount of finger pointing. Trump has hollowed out their party leadership and personally chose many of their losing candidates. That they lost races in deep red territory, even with unprecedented campaign spending, should lead to an absolute bloodbath, but after purging anyone that would even mildly oppose Trump, it's hard to imagine them doing a 180 and cleaning house. But if they can't separate themselves from Trump and get some competent leadership, there's a very real chance that they could pay dearly for it in 2028.

  • source
  • [–] 10 points 3 weeks ago (2 children)

    The attempts to portray Sayed as a terrorist and threat to national security are stupid and racist.

    But this article's main argument is that it's somehow absurd to label any candidate a national security risk, or a potential leaker of classified information... which is an almost impressively bad take when the White House is currently occupied by an obvious threat to national security who has a long history of giving out classified info.

  • source
  • [–] 12 points 3 weeks ago (5 children)

    Assuming no Republicans cross the aisle. That's a fairly reasonable assumption today because the Republican party has been purged of anyone who would be willing to cross Trump.

    But I suspect that assumption might not remain so valid if we were to see the kind of blue tsunami it would take to get anywhere near 2/3 of the Senate. Even if you only had 64 seats instead of 67, that still means almost every state went blue, including most of the deep red ones. Any politician with basic survival instincts is going to recognize that tying themselves to the lame duck president that has practically destroyed their party is not going to be a good long term strategy.

    It's not much more plausible a scenario than one where Dems win a full supermajority, but if it were to happen, I would be shocked if every single Republican chose to go down with the ship.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 80 points 3 weeks ago (6 children)

    First of all, the headline focuses on Trump's order but fails to inform people of the more important fact that a lawsuit has actually been filed.

    Government attorneys filed a lawsuit Friday arguing that the presence of Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. on the ballot would confuse voters who support the sitting senator, Daniel S. Sullivan, in the unusual matchup of two candidates with the same name up against a Democratic candidate.

    Second, this has already been adjudicated, it's a matter of state law, and the case isn't ripe because they are suing over a hypothetical that has not happened yet.

    But even if there weren't all those other reasons to toss out the suit, the whole thing is nonsense anyway because Alaska has ranked choice voting. Anyone who is confused can pick both Daniel Sullivans. The only way it could possibly become an issue is if the two Dans come in first and second, which has effectively no chance of happening.

  • source
  • [–] 4 points 3 weeks ago (1 child)

    This is true, but it's also worth noting that the only member of the crew he has a significant conflict with is Riker. And ultimately, Riker is the one who is repeatedly out of line in that situation. He's insubordinate, he refuses to follow orders, and he undermine's Jellico's authority.

    And that last point is uniquely important in their mission. He's managing a tense situation with cardassians, and he knows they are looking for the slightest hint of weakness. If Riker, second in command on the Federation's flagship, can't behave like a disciplined officer, the cardassians could very well see that as proof that the federation lacks the resolve for a real fight.

    He's flawed and could absolutely have handled things better. And we see that he can when he goes back to Riker because he's needed for the mission. He patiently lets Riker vent at him, lets the whole conflict between them get aired out, and then sets his own ego aside and appeals to Riker's sense of duty and asks him if he's willing to take on the mission. He's not backing down and still being himself, but he's letting Riker get what he needs emotionally and trusting him to do what needs to be done.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 18 points 3 weeks ago (5 children)

    That's why he was so perfect in TNG. He comes in to replace Picard and the audience is primed to hate him. We see him from the perspective of the crew who have to adapt to this new hard ass that wants to make seemingly arbitrary changes and who lacks the flexibility of their previous captain.

    And yet, his character isn't just another incompetent asshole from starfleet command. He's a leader taking command in a crisis that will very likely result in a war. He doesn't have the luxury of slowly getting to know the crew and earning their trust, and respect, and friendship. He needs them to be as ready as possible as soon as possible, and he needs to know his orders will be carried out to the letter and without delay. His orders aren't unreasonable, he just isn't indulging the crew and being the warm and fuzzy type.

    Any other actor and this would have probably been an unremarkable B plot.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • view more: next ›