Desktop environment, and OS in general is just something you eventually find one you like, and there's no need to change. It's GNOME for me, it just works in a way that doesn't get on my way and that's all it needs to be
post
KDE is my favorite, but I'm excited to try Cosmic once it's a little farther along.
I also love Cinnamon, not because it looks great, or has a ton of customizablity, but because it is so stable. It's been the best #JustWorks DE in my experience.
Those are the only two I use regularly. Xfce is nice once you get it customized, but it's kind of a pain to get configured. I don't have much use for sophisticated tiling, so tiling window managers are just curiosities to me. I've played with i3, Sway, Hyprland, and a few others over the years.
I wish I had a use case for them, but alas, all my day to day needs are handled just fine with basic Window snapping, tmux, kitty tabs, and occasionally using a second virtual desktop.
the first DE I used on Linux was cinnamon and I was like βwow, this is great, everything makes sense to me out of the boxβ
And then I tried Gnome and was incredibly put off by it, like βwhy the hell is this over here, this layout is strange to me. Why are all these unconventional features on by default, this is very annoying.β
And then I tried KDE and I was like βwow, this is great and everything makes sense to me out of the box, also thereβs all these features and options, I donβt know what they do, but i donβt have to interact with them if I donβt want to.β
KDE and GNOME each have their shortcomings. KDE has never been completely stable for me but itβs so much better than it used to be. GNOME is the best at what itβs good at and the worst at everything else. Thereβs no grey area with gnome.
Cosmic looks super promising. I need to play with it.
I just install the Fedora spin of COSMIC. So far, I have to say that I'm impressed by it. It's pretty lightweight and nimble on low-end hardware while still having just enough customizing to be satisfying. The DE is also pretty easy and simple to use. It also appears to be very stable and tolerant during use.
If you got time, I would tell you to just try it. It has quickly gone from "I'm not very sure about this choice." to "Hey, I kinda like this."
I quite like KDE Plasma on my steam deck, but on my desktops I always use XFCE
I just want a conventional desktop paradigm that feels relatively integrated. For almost a decade I used Cinnamon until I found myself really wanting Wayland. For the past 5 years or so, I have used GNOME. It's clean, and with a few tweaks it meets my needs.
I've been using KDE since ver 2.something.
I like the idea of tiling window managers.
But I'm old.
I'm set in my ways.
I don't want to get used to new things.
KDE was wild a feral in the early days of plasma. It was heavier than GNOME. It was unstable. It was a nice visual refresh but functionally terrible. Itβs really pulled away from that thankfully.
Still waiting for XFCEβs Wayland support. Until then Plasma it is
Booooo Wayland
Get over it. We all have to.
x11 still running strong on my machine
Yeah, that's fine that's what you use. I don't have a pig in this fight. But I'm using Wayland because that's what Fedora has adopted for a good while now. I do have to say, it's been a seamless transition. Everything just works. My dual monitor setup, running Kinonite, has never been so easy and trouble free as it is with Wayland. The single monitor box I have with a low power mini desktop with 8Gbit of shared memory, runs Wayland without a hitch.
The thing is, everything has its time under the sun. Whether its X11 or you and me. The guy that has been maintaining X11 doesn't want to do it anymore. And it appears no one else wants to do it either. So X11 will fade away and Wayland will have it's time now. And someday Wayland will also be replaced. And people will mourn it's passing just like X11.
I've been using Linux for twenty years. I didn't use KDE until they declared Plasma 5 ready for primetime. (I hated Plasma 4, and didn't like the look and feel of KDE 3.5 at all)
Since hopping on with Plasma 5 I have absolutely no interest in anything else. I love KDE Plasma and it just keeps getting better.
That's me in OP.
I tried lots of DE's when distros started switching to GNOME 3.
Now I just run Xfce on everything.
How I feel about gnome
I like the ones that are forks of pre-ruined Gnome. MATE is my favorite of that type.
Windows 10! Hell no I'm on windows 3.11 before they ruined everything!!
I know this is a joke, but before I discovered GNU-Linux I used XP and didn't hate it. I was usable. Microsoft hadn't yet completely stripped away user autonomy.
When did you stop using XP?
The next laptop I bought came preinstalled with Windows Vista (AKA Windows Millenium version 2). It was so frustrating I decided to investigate alternatives. I even considered going Macintosh. But I was at a bookstore and saw one of those Linux magazines with a free disc from which I could install Linux. I think it was Ubuntu on the disc (before Unity). I was hooked. I use Trisquel now.
I mean, everyone liked XP and most everyone tried to keep using it years after Microsoft wanted us to stop. Everyone hated vista.
But modern gnome is excellent. My joke was trying to point out that hating it while liking the old version seems like a uniquely old man thing to do, just hating change for being change
Gnome 3 got rid of desktop icons and the menu of Gnome 2, it was also a resource hog. Mate offers what I liked about Gnome 2. Sue me.
Alas, we cannot sue for wrong opinions :/
I dunno about the resource hog comment especially. I run it on a raspberry pi 5 just fine, and at least compared to mac os and windows 10, it always feels snappier to me on all the hardware I have been able to try multiple options on.
The fact MATE exists is proof I am far from alone in my views. Indeed, this is one of the benefits of FLOS software. Noone is ALLOWED, for example, to create a fork of Windows XP if they want to. Microsoft would quickly stamp down and take to court any attempt to do so. But you and I can both be Linux users who prefer different GUIs. Some of this simply comes down to preference - I prefer GNOME as it was before it was ruined and that is what MATE offers me π
Yes, and I prefer GNOME once it was modernized and made to look like it was not designed by 1990s developers (who are NOT designers, and it shows).
I care more about functionality than superficial design. I take a similar position in media (TV & film). For example, I love Babylon 5 even though the special effects are admittedly primitive compared to modern science fiction programs. The WRITING and DIRECTION in Babylon 5 is brilliant. I can forgive something superficial if there is substance to it
Is "superficiality" not valuable in UI design? I look at these other DE settings UIs and they're an absolute mess. GNOME could do better also, but I pretty much can find everything common in an obvious place, and the more weird options are somewhere I can also find them, typically in GNOME tweaks.
In effect everything about UI design could be called superficial. But humans operate based on "superficial" things all the time. I could use a terminal to do many more things than I do (which is already a lot) but as a human I'm kinda evolved to operate visually, so I often opt for that. Nothing wrong with it.
TIL I am not a one. I never chose XP; I didn't ever install that cartoonish bloatfest over win2k on my home pc.

while liking the old version seems like a uniquely old man thing to do, just hating change for being change
Gnome 3 was a huge paradigm shift. Most people who noped out of Gnome afterwards disliked very specific things about it, not just hating change for being change. This is a really dismissive and kind of insulting take.
@orlyowl @TrickDacy for me it was entire session crash on compositor crash. And gnome is still keeping this very useful feature, but making this crash even stronger with wayland
I'm interested in other DEs, i swear! I just don't use them, or like them!
I've been using kde for years and really enjoyed the fact that it was simple and worked out of the box.
Recently I heard about niri, I had a look and thought it was cool. I set it up with a desktop environment around it and in less than 1 hour I had a working de. I've been using it a couple weeks now on my work computer and I have to say that I'm really enjoying it, I feel it makes many operations much simpler and moving around different windows is very easy.
I use two screens, and I really like that I can have the applications bar on both on them, which was one major gripe I had with plasma.
I use two screens, and I really like that I can have the applications bar on both on them, which was one major gripe I had with plasma.
Csn't you just add a new panel to your second display and add the applications applet? In plasma 6.3 you can even clone your panel. Or am I misunderstanding?
I'm waiting for Cosmic to mature
I tried Cosmic for a week. It looked nice but I returned to LXQt because I want:
- To display time in ISO 8601 without also messing with locales
- To customize my file manager columns
- To use Emacs in a terminal emulator
- To not have my windows scattered to the four winds every time I lock my screen because the fancy window tiling feature is half-baked
- To have the X window manager back. I'm sure some people with use cases besides mine that are compatible only with Wayland, but I simply don't see the need nor do I wish to be a guinea pig submitting bug reports when so many guinea pigs before me had years of their lives sacrificed polishing X.
Also, the performance of programs like the default Cosmic file manager was much slower then comparable alternatives like pcmanfm-qt which I know run fast even on 2005 Compaq laptop hardware.
I've yet to see anything that compares to kde, and I just don't understand why so many distros default to gnome!
Never had a problem with XFCE, even doing some weird stuff with metrics in the task bar.
Though I do not tinker like I did when I was younger, nor do I know what Plasma has over XFCE that's not cosmetic in nature.
Red Hat has invested so much in GNOME they will probably never want to hear about changing to KDE Plasma. And Suse will follow Red Hat (which never made sense to me).
SuSE use KDE as the default, them and Manjaro are the only two bigguns that do, really
Gnome is the most stable DE with all features included, it also has minimal amount of system options to still have all features.
XFCE misses a lot of features, such as printers. KDE has all bells and whistles but is less stable.
I've enjoyed KDE since Mandrake 6. The control you get to have as a user is amazing. Thought to be honest, I really change very little. But the Cube! I will die for that Cube.
But I have used probably every DE that runs on Linux one time or another. Each has its own charms and quirks. While my laptop lives comfortably with Fedora 43 Kinonite, the cheap mini desktop I'm using right now currently has COSMIC on it. And to be honest, as much as I like LXDE, dnfdragoria as it's package manager, someone at Fedora needs to take dnfdragoria out back and launch it into the sun. COMIC is far lighter feeling than I thought would be. I will live with it for a while I think.
I went from Gnome 2 to Mate, and switched to Plasma last year. Can't see myself moving away anytime soon XD
I'm still stuck on i3 and sway. I hear there's a version of KDE that is tiling...? But I haven't found anything definitive on that.
I've heard this which made me assume it was like an option I can just enable, but every search has only come up with some baroque scripting or configuration guides, which seems like a lot more work than just using an actual tiling window manager.
E: Oh I get it now, you just install Krohnkite. This is a bit of an improvement, I will admit.
still stuck on i3 and sway
That's an odd statement. I'd place i3 and Sway deeper down the rabbit hole, being build-your-own[^1] as opposed to packaged deals like KDE.
[^1]: in the sense of building a configuration - not in the sense of compiling code.
Iβd place i3 and Sway deeper down the rabbit hole ...
I mean they are, but my mind and fingers have been so twisted by vim that I can't really interact with floating wms without feeling honestly pretty intense discomfort. I see people having fun with their cool Plasmas etc and I wish I could make the leap, but every time I try I just bristle at all the mouse use. The lack of control makes me feel like I'm trying to use a computer while wearing oven mittens.
My point is - why go backward? You already have your Sway[^1] based setup, configured just the way you like it, with the ability to switch various components in and out. What does a monolithic[^2] environment like KDE have to offer you?
[^1]: Assuming it's Sway and not i3 because I assume you have already switched to Wayland. You switched to Wayland, right? You need to switch to Wayland. Why are you not switching to Wayland?
[^2]:, Yes, you can tweak KDE, but since all the various parts were created to fit together switching one will always result in awkward UX.
KDE's absolutely excellent, but if you need every little kilobyte RAM, go Sway. SwayβIt's Technically Graphical β’
Khe Khing Kabout KDE Kis Kits Kobsession Kwith Kits Knaming Kheme.

top 99 comments