I can excuse racism and pedophilia, but my financial wellbeing is where I draw the line!
post
You may not realize it but you're humanizing "the left" for him. Its probably keeping him somewhat grounded.
First of all, i don't think you're tooting your own horn, you juuust stated you don't have a car! So its unlikely you happen to have a horn lying about...
Intentional is a good description, but from what i read i want to add sincerity. Thats important, especially in a world of grift and propaganda.
But your story just continues to show that nobody with such strong opinions seem to care until it directly effects them. In your case, it sounds like they are right on the border of realizing this. It just sucks that this is what it takes for them to even consider this.
Talking to him and being a good person can do more than you realize.
I was raised white Christian nationalist, although we didn't call it that and I wouldn't have realized that's what I was. I was taught all the conservative bullshit, both politically and socially. Thankfully there was always a part of me that was like "something isn't right here" and I kept my mouth shut and was never the bully going around mouthing off to gay kids or minorities, but I definitely thought things like "being gay is a choice" and "poor people should just work harder" and "abortion is something welfare queens do" but also "welfare queens have lots of babies for more money".
Being around people like you who were nonjudgmental and just talked about their point of view and occasionally gently challenged my beliefs without being confrontational opened my worldview and helped give me the courage to listen to the voice in my head that was saying something felt wrong with the belief system I was raised in. I'd always been taught things like liberals were stupid and lacked critical thinking skills and acted solely on emotions and I was young and kept in a bubble and was dumb enough to believe it until I started meeting people who proved otherwise. That was enough to start the cracks forming that eventually shattered the entire wall of lies. I'm now a raging socialist and I don't care how people live their lives as long as they aren't harming anyone else. I don't think I would have ended up that way if I wasn't someone who is willing to think for myself and who isn't afraid to be the "black sheep", because leaving that mindset lost me my family, but I definitely wouldn't have ever been able to start down the path I'm on if I was never exposed to people like you who started showing me the lies in the first place.
Talking to him and being a good person can do more than you realize.
100%. Honestly more than anything were suffering a large scale collapse of community. First, the highway system and cars came in and carved up large-scale communities. Everyone riding around in their own personal pods, not having to interact with anyone else.
Then the internet comes in, allowing anyone and everyone to find material that conforms and confirms their biases. Forget about going out and touching grass. Has anyone spent any actual time in an average day brushing elbows with hundreds of strangers and holding casual conversations. Nothing stops stupid behaviors faster than being judged by the community around you.
That's what fixed the rest of what was left of my toxic worldview. I started working in healthcare. I've treated people from all over the world. I've treated people who speak so many different languages. I've treated people of all religions. I've treated different gender identities and sexual preferences. I've treated people I knew were rapists or murderers (fucking worst, but you grit your teeth and treat them like human beings who need healthcare). I've treated so many refugees from various places (love the refugees, keep them in the US!)
All of them are just people. I've met a lot of really shitty people and a lot of really good people. It's hard to hate a group of people when you meet individuals from a particular subset and realize they have the same hopes and fears as you. At the end of the day, we all just want to go to our respective homes and be safe and loved and alive and there shouldn't be anything political about that.
But your story just continues to show that nobody with such strong opinions seem to care until it directly effects them.
Yeah. I've been considering that it's a bit like the difference between empirical and theoretical physicist.
The theoretical physicist uses models of how the world works to make predictions about the outcome of experiments. The empirical physicist has to do experiments to believe it. It's kinda the same for people in politics.
Some people can predict what outcome certain policies are going to have. Others have to figure it out experimentally.
What's the best way to teach a kid to not play with fire?
People who are below average intelligence take a lot longer time process new information and tend to hang onto myths much longer than smart people. Smart people can adapt to new information whereas these folks just can't. They are susceptible to being gaslit because they can't think critically. Personally, I don't think people below a certain intelligence level should be permitted to vote.
Is this not normal? If you treat people kindly and with respect, they're more likely to respect you back and treat you kindly. This common courtesy establishes a level of trust where others are more willing to listen to what you have to say. This is the only way people can ever change their minds.
I have never seen any instance of anyone changing their minds because others were demonizing them and making fun of them. I feel like the people who advocate for others to be dicks to people like this guy tend to be major assholes themselves, and these people are big part of the problem. Yet that views is becoming more and more common. So props to you for treating this guy like person, you might think much of it, but your interactions with him might very well be the reason why he even has the chance of coming around.
you're honestly one of the best. I wish I could have that kind of patience even just for my own family let alone others.
I think I might have cancer from reading some of the responses. And then clicking through to their profiles.
It's truly astounding the things these people believe.
And they believe the same things about us.
We have an actual war on truth and objective facts in this country, and it's being waged by billionaires that control the narrative to pit us against each other. American media is a goddamn propaganda farm run by a dozen or so Goebbels.
I agree with what you said, but I'm like 5% worried you might be referring to "leftist propaganda".
You think leftist propaganda doesn't exist?
I think there's only a small handful of leftists in American politics at all, and that their propaganda apparatus would be small, if it exists at all. Maybe centrist, neoliberal propaganda, but leftist? Where?
Oh it absolutely does, but nowhere near the volume as rightist propaganda.
Literally all of the major news channels are owned by conservative billionaires now. And a substantial amount of newspapers. They bought your local TV news, too...and in doing so they bought your trust.
Every time I click on a conservative news source, there are half-truths, lies through omission and/or emotional language in an active voice. All the news channels have talking heads scream-talking in an elevated, authoritative voice and have banners run across the bottom in all caps as if it's yelling at you. It wants your attention, and it wants you to think it's important and scary.
These are age-old tactics of yellow journalism. Does it happen in leftist news? Sure, sometimes. Not nearly the same level.
The problem is, generally speaking, the full story with whole-facts is damning to the right. So they keep only the news that works for them.
If this wasn't obvious by the time Kellyanne Conway got up on Meet The Press and told us about "Alternative Facts", then it should've been by the time Trump talked about Haitians eating pet dogs on the debate stage.
In today's political climate, Leftist propaganda isn't a threat. It's irrelevant.
I say this as someone who firmly believes in capitalism and limited government.
Fascism is the only threat that matters right now.
You don't think Charlie Kirk or Trump shooting are related to propaganda?
First of all, those shooters were right wing nutjobs. So leftist propaganda was definitely not involved.
Virtually all political violence in America is done by rightwing extremists. That's a fact that's been true for 45 years. You can look it up.
If you sincerely believed that those shootings were caused by the political left, then you need to fact check your news sources and check your own gullibility, because you got tricked.
Second of all, I meant a threat to our society, democracy, and our way of life. I didn't mean a threat to individual fascists.
If tankies ever become significant, I'll be right here arguing against them. But they're not significant. That's another fascist lie.
They will be, until they are personally affected
That video Don't be a Sucker should be mandatory yearly viewing. It won't solve everything but people would learn to better recognize the divide and isolate patterns.
Or maybe not. Humans are complicated.
It's the party of pure selfishness, they do not understand empathy. Until they themselves are affected at all, they won't understand .
This is the case for most people. People change their opinions when they're personally affected because first hand personal experience is as real as its going to get.
Anyone who has empathy can see how bad things are for others without going through it themselves though
But that's a matter of perspective. Empathy as a concept is vague, subjective, and fluid.
Sure, but the definition is about putting yourself in others shoes. If someone said "let's lock up all (ethnicity)" and you can't imagine how shitty it is to be locked up due to ethnicity, then you got a problem
Sure, but let me give you the same example but in a different context.
Let's suppose that instead of "let's lock up everyone from this ethnic group", a politician says "let's stop illegal immigration". Stopping illegal immigration is a perfectly rational, reasonable, moral stance to have. If someone hears the latter phrasing, they might take it at face value even if the politician really means the former. Thus, this individual has come to indirectly support the former even though they think they're supporting the latter. The end result is the same because the politician's intentions never changed, however, the morality of this individual is no longer as black and white as in your example.
And if said person can see what is happening, for example with ICE, and they don't question what is going on, after gaining an understanding, then its right back to being as black and white
But you're making the assumption that it's inevitable to gain an understanding. I think you're underestimating the sheer levels of ignorance that people like this live under. Some people are so ignorant that their only sources of information are Facebook and Fox News, and so they only ever see one perspective, and that perspective is their truth. Their perspective, their truth, is basically whatever Trump says taken at face value and regurgitated by right wing media.
And there is a certain level of responsibility that everyone has when it comes to educating oneself. It doesn't absolve them
I can agree with that, but being ignorant or uneducated doesn't mean someone lacks empathy.
Yes that is true, but it's besides the point
How is it besides the point? It is the point. These people are genuinely ignorant and uneducated, and their sources for information are very narrow and distorted. Their perceptive can only change when they're directly affected because that experience is what gives them the change necessary to learn and grow. You're implying that they're all malicious and evil, but I disagree with that view. I don't they all lack empathy, I think they're good people who have been brainwashed by a handful of genuinely vile people who seek to manipulate them for their own personal gain by keeping them blind, poor, miserable, scared, and angry. Do I think this of all MAGA? No, but I do think it applies to a significant chunk.
Ben Shapiro quaking in his Jewish little boots rn. Turns out if you're instilling hate about all the minorities, they'll eventually get to yours.
Everyone hates getting taxed, idk how ppl cant come together on taxing the ultrawealthy more so we get taxed less, they just avoid it entirely, idk how mfs still believe in trickle down economics
There would be no incentive to become a billionaire if you have to give away 0.1% of it! It only grows at like 8% a year in the first place! 😭😭😭
Basically the ultra-wealthy are presented like a superstar, like a celebrity in american media. That way, everybody wants to identify with them, and that causes the thought that if they have more wealth "that's good for all of us" because they identify with them.
It's basically because they have superstar status that people worship them. That's what this is all about.
I'm fine with taxes.
Like, as in the way they are at the exact moment in time of this post?
Taxes are great as a concept but who pays what and when: seems rigged in favor of those who have.
You don’t need taxes if the government owned a few key assets that actually generated profit.
The only reason we have taxes is because we decided long ago that only private enterprise should make money.
She'll forget about her 'outrage' in a week ot two, then go back to praising all his 'wisdom and leadership'.
PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE be Compassionate! She THOUGHT that by Electing Trump ONLY Trans and Brown kids would be Hurt! She NEVER Thought Jesus Trump would go after WHITE People too! Be NICE!
See a normal person would see this as opportunity to bring this person over to their side. This could be an opportunity to explain to this person that this is how other people feel too, that her she's not alone in her rejection of Trump, and that she's better off joining everybody else in the fight for everyone instead of just for some.
However, a deranged person would see this as opportunity to mock and belittle this person for changing their view because they view people as inherently evil.
My friend, people have been explaining that shit to them for decades. This person will 100% vote for the next fascist who hurts brown people and lgbtq people
The point isn't to convert, politics is not religion. The point is to use common ground to establish coalitions and utilize diplomacy tactics (compromise and cooperation) to advance practical policies that seek to benefit the greater good. You're not going to see eye to eye with everyone, and it's wrong to think that you should only ever work with people who do. If people like her share a common stance with us, it would be foolish not to capitalize on it.
Or, theres more issues than just trans people. Ffs, America is fucking doomed. Youre not upset that theres a fucking nazi Gestapo running around, youre just upset that arent taking away the people you want taken away. What a fucking mess.
I cannot bring myself to believe that this is real. The only way I can believe someone so eloquent of a writer would believe Trump is if they are in on it and it seems she's not a billionaire. Also, I don't think people who would vote for Trump 3 times would ever have the ability to reflect and change their view on him.
If they would be capable of that, we wouldn't be here in the first place.
100%. Rightwingers believe people who use welfare are mostly undeserving except the occasional outlier. They'd more easily accept that the dems simply won't let Trump release the Epstein list or some conspiratorial nonsense than call it the Epstein shutdown. This is a lib doing a "How do you do fellow cultists".
Rightwingers believe people who use welfare are mostly undeserving except the occasional outlier.
And all of their family members who rely on welfare are in the "outlier" group. Because they aren't like those other people. They really need it.
The moment she expressed concern for people who weren't her, or directly related to her, was what broke the suspension of disbelief for me.
Don't doubt the human capacity for self reflection deception. I've met quite a few of articulate imbeciles who voted orange.
Edit: deception. Self deception. Autocorrupt got the best of me.
For me it was how easily they slipped in the phrase "Epstein shutdown" that gave it away. That just seems so clearly phrased by someone who always hated Trump cosplaying as victim of a face eating leopard.
The mistake is believing the capacity to disappoint isn't unbounded.
If you haven't had the "pleasure", talk to a Republican in real life. This is how they think...
When someone leaves a cult, ya got two choices. Accept them or reject them. If you reject them they'll just run straight to another cult
She voted 3 times for a racist idiot. The last time she knew he was also a pedo.
I may have missed some posts, but I didn's see a word about deportations tearing apart families. She's cool with that. She's angry because Trump hurt the "wrong gmoups". He was supposed to hurt only some other groups.
Fortunately for me, I don't live in the US, I am not a US citizen, and I don't have to "accept her".
I bet she will rally behind the next guy promising to hurt "others", but posing as anti-Trump because he hurt some "good" Americans.
didn't say you had to forgive. Just that you had two choices.
Rejection will 100% guarantee they will flock to the next leader promising to retaliate for them
Why would acceptance be any different? Do we have any faith in these people? Only they can make themselves stop being assholes.
What is the difference? On a very basic level think how germany turned out after WWI vs Germany after WWII
This seems pretty hard for a lot of people to grasp and there's a lot of personal colouration being applied.
No you don't have to forgive. They don't have to be your friends. The administration doesn't get off scott free. But we're literally talking here about the people who are waking up and realising what they voted for, full of regrets and want to get the fuck off the wheel of madness.
So you can indulge your own dumb lizard brain punishing people for being lead about by the nose and realising they shouldn't have, thus perpetuating the cycle of stupidity or you can just not.


top 96 comments