[–] [S] 0 points 3 weeks ago (1 child)

You misunderstood all 3 of my pet peeves.

  1. What you're describing here is not whataboutism. I have no issue with people who bring up Christianity as way of detailing their anecdotes. Personal experiences in of itself serves a point. No, what I'm talking about are the instances where there is no point, or rather the point is derail the conversation.

Here's just a quick hypothetical example. Let's say you make a post criticizing ongoing islamic imperialism campaigns, and you get a bunch of comments bringing up the crusades being bad. These comments have no relevance and serve no point besides trying to derail the original topic and serve as a weak "gotcha" where the implication is that you're a bad person if you don't admit that the crusades are equally bad, regardless of validity. I've seen these types of comments a lot, and they annoy me.

  1. What you're saying is only true to a degree. While it's true that all religious fundamentalist share the same core traits, there is a HUGE difference in environment. Extremism is a relative concept that varies wildly depending on the context. Religious extremists in American are MAGA idiots who want to ban abortion, bible thump, and be homophobic. In my home country of Iraq, religious extremists are literally ISIS. It's perfectly fine to recognize both are extremists in their societies and they both cause harm. There is no issue with Americans talking about fundamentalists in their country. My problem lies when a specific subset of Americans insist that "y'all qaeda" and the actual al qaeda are basically the same or something along those lines. They're absolutely not the same, and implying as such is just ignorant. MAGA would be considered soft moderates in a middle eastern religious extremism scale.

  2. I'm not disputing the statement all religions are bad, I'm saying that's the baseline. Endlessly preaching it to the choir is entirely meaningless, and it actually takes away from real discussions. Again, it's like the "all lives matter" nonsense. We know all lives matter, that's the baseline. Repeating that takes away from the real discussions that lie in the nuance, like how black people are being treated worse than others despite their lives mattering just as much as everyone else's. It's a similar story here. We can't meaningfully criticize harmful aspects of specific religions if all the attempts get drowned and diluted by "all religion bad" comments.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 37 points 4 weeks ago (6 children)

    The Simpsons is full of characters based on stereotypes:

    Fat Tony and Luigi Risotto - Italians

    Groundskeeper Willie - Scottish

    Bumblebee Man - Spanish

    Akira - Japanese

    Cookie Kwan - Asian

    Üter Zörker - German

    Dr. Julius Hibbert and Lou - African American

    Cletus Spuckler - Rural white American

    Yet out all of these, people just decided to get mad over Apu for no reason even though he's been a beloved character for decades and Hank Azaria being a very well liked and respected voice actor.

  • source
  •  

    Here are my top 3:

    1. Whataboutism with Christainity - I've been a vocal critic of islam in atheist spaces for well over a decade. There has not been a single instance of me criticizing islam where I did not get a hoard of atheists bringing up Christianity for no reason. There's no relevance and no point to it, but they get really mad when I try to focus on islam. It's like why can't they just accept that islam or other religions can be criticized on their own merits independently?

    2. Self centered American atheists - Whenever I ever bring up my and my family's experiences in the middle east and how horrible islam is over there, there will always be a handful of ignorant American atheists who can't comprehend that the world is more than their country. No ISIS and your dumb MAGA uncle are not the same.

    3. "All religions are bad" - I hate this statement because it's like "all lives matter". Yeah, no shit all religions are bad. That's literally the baseline of any atheist community. All the discussions lie in the nuances beyond that. Smearing this statement all over atheist spaces is completely meaningless.

    What about you guys? Are there any things in the atheist community that you noticed that make your eyes twitch? I would love to hear them.

     

    Here's the verse in English (Sahih International translation):

    "Men are in charge of women by [right of] what Allah has given one over the other and what they spend [for maintenance] from their wealth. So righteous women are devoutly obedient, guarding in [the husband's] absence what Allah would have them guard. But those [wives] from whom you fear arrogance - [first] advise them; [then if they persist], forsake them in bed; and [finally], strike them. But if they obey you [once more], seek no means against them. Indeed, Allah is ever Exalted and Grand."

    Link (You can also read the Arabic version here): https://quran.com/4/34

    This verse is fairly self-explanatory. It instructs muslims on how women should be treated. The verse states that men are in charge of women and how they spend their wealth, good women are those who obey, and if a woman disobeys then her husband can warn her, forsake her, and finally, beat her.

    Don't believe I have the right interpretation? Fine, here's an islamic website that the echos the same meaning (I'll get to the justifications they use later).

    But first, let me explain why this verse just reeks of misogyny. This verse clearly demonstrates that women are inferiors in multiple ways. The first is that men are in charge of them and their wealth, this sets a hierarchy among the genders where men are placed above women. The verse reinforces this hierarchy by going on to say that women are to be subservient to their husbands. The verse portrays this obedience as being virtuous, however the verse contradicts itself by having the obedience be forced. Virtue is achieved through choice. If I choose to feed the homeless, than that is me taking action on my own behalf to demonstrate moral excellence. However, if I was forced to feed the homeless against my will, then how can it still be a virtue? You're forced to do something, therefore you're longer performing a certain action out of choice, but out of fear. In this case, it is the fear of being punished, specifically, getting beat by your husband. When someone is forced to do something against their will and is forced to obey, then it stops being about virtue and simply becomes slavery. This verse instructs the oppression of women.

    This verse is repulsive and vile, and doesn't receive nearly as much criticism as it should.

    In my experience, there are generally three common non-islamic defenses for this verse, and all are weak since they are disingenuous and rely on logical fallacies:

    1 - The first defense has to do with the word "اضربوهن" (adrabohen). It is translated as "strike them" in the translation. People who try to use this defense state that the word has multiple meanings, and the meaning cannot be accurately translated into other languages or that you misunderstood the actual meaning. However, this defense is very fallacious because it sets up a No True Scotsman.

    If you concede even a little (especially if you don't speak Arabic), then no matter what you say you will always will be met something like "but that's not the REAL meaning". However, the very premise of this argument stems disingenuous misinformation. Now, it is true that the word has multiple meanings (I'm an Arabic speaker), the word can both mean to hit/beat or to multiply. However, the context is crystal clear that it's not talking about multiplication, but about wives. The word can literally be translated to "to hit/beat them (females)", it's important to note that Arabic is a gendered language and the "هن" is the plural feminine version of the "them". Therefore, the word, when the context is taken into account, does in fact mean to hit/beat wives.

    2 - The second defense tries to justify the wife beating by saying it doesn't mean to beat your wives, but to "lightly" discipline them. They say that islam has a rules about how to beat your wife, and that it doesn't allow super hard wife beatings.... This argument is clearly trying to downplay the wife beating, and it fails at it because you can never ever justify wife beating.

    Another common version of this defense tries to justify wife beating by saying it's only allowed "in the most extreme cases". However, that's simply not true. By just using this very verse, you can easily figure out what the necessary conditions are to permit beating your wife. All that is required is for the wife to simply disobey you more than two times.

    Considering a woman daring to disobey her husband to be an "extreme" case that warrants wife beating is simply anti-women. No matter how disobedient the wife is or how many times she disobeys, that doesn't give anyone the right to beat her, or anyone really. Domestic violence can never be tolerated, yet both of these examples are used in the website that I used earlier to justify it.

    3 - Finally, the third common defense is the good ol' Tu Quoque fallacy, also known as, whataboutism. It is when they try to appeal to hypocrisy by bringing up other religions (especially Christianity) and saying "why are criticizing islam when these other religions have it too". However, just because wife beating is present in other religions doesn't mean that it's justified in islam. This defense is just a poor attempt at derailing the conversation, and doesn't negate anything.

    At the the end of the day, this verse is indefensible. You can't justify oppression and wife beating. This verse is sexist and misogynistic, and it could very well be argued that this verse is a direct influence on the misogyny present in islamic culture to this very day.

    Note: I'm thinking of doing a series on islam where I create posts like this where I go through various verses, hadiths, and religious traditions and critique them directly on their own merits to the best of my abilities. However, I'll only do it if there's interest from the community so please let me know if you would like to see more.

     

    I come on here every so often to see what's going on, and every time I leave disappointed. This is my top 3 grievances at the moment:

    1. This place feels dead. It's usually quite, but lately it really feels like a ghost town. Idk what the actual stats say, but I feel like the amount of comments, posts, and variety seem to have gone down quite a bit over the past few months.

    2. The amount of genuinely hateful content has gone up. I feel like Lemmy as a whole used to have better moderation even just last year compared to now. Every time I get on here, I'm seeing more and more gross content that's either racist or bigoted or just downright gross. This content doesn't get taken down even when reported. As horrid as Reddit's moderation is, it's still not this bad.

    3. Outside of the tech communities, there's no information hygiene anywhere in sight. The news subs publish the most questionable of sources, sometimes outright misinformation... and nobody cares? People don't criticize weak sources or call out false claims or even value accuracy. I've seen multiple instances of users saying something false and getting upvoted for it and a person correcting them getting downvoted for it. Like, what's even happening?

    I don't know, I feel like when I joined a couple of years ago Lemmy was so much better. It felt more active, the community felt more down to earth, kind, and friendly, and the content was higher in quality. There was much optimism surrounding the Fediverse that's not there anymore. Now it feels like a more left wing version of Voat than a genuine Reddit alternative. Am I the only one feeling this way or do other people feel the same?

     

    In yet another effort to boost text posts on Lemmy, I have created new community for complaints. Have something that's been bothering you? Some event in the world is leaving a bad taste in your mouth? Have some grievance you want to vent? This is the place to share it.

    !complaints@lemmy.world lemmy.world/c/complaints/

    If you're reading this, check out this new community and maybe drop a complaint that's been on your mind. It will help you feel better.

     

    A few months ago I created the MarkMyWords community here on Lemmy. Similar to the original subreddit, this is a community where users can come and share their predictions about the future with everyone so they can have proof that they’ve called it before it happened.

    I made this community to boost text based posts on Lemmy because I think that's where the best and most engaging discussions happen. Please take a minute to check out the community and maybe even leave a prediction of your own if you feel like it!

    !MarkMyWords@lemmy.world

    https://lemmy.world/c/MarkMyWords

     

    In an effort to boost text posts on Lemmy, I have created https://lemmy.world/c/MarkMyWords. Similar to the original subreddit with the same name, this is a community where users can come and share their bold predictions with everyone so they can have proof that they've called it before it happened.

    I have created a couple of sampler posts in hopes of garnering engagement to get this community to start growing. I hope everybody reading this checks it out!

    view more: next ›