With this devs luck, awww will be co-opted next. Good on them for recognising the mistake and fixing it.
post
It’s not a nazi “reference” if the author didn’t know, then it’s a coincidence. It does suck that nazis have ruined otherwise great things though, Tesla for example.
Dev seems like a good dude with more self awareness than 10 average people combined.
It reminds me if when ISIS (middle eastern terrorist group) ruined the name Isis (Egyptian god, but also person's given name).
The cartoon Archer took the story in a whole new direction in order to disband the show's fictional organisation that was called ISIS (by coincidence). I thought it was such a shame to let real world bad guys ruin things. Surely by caving to that we are giving them more power than if we held the attitude that other people were using that word first and they can't ruin it.
Having said that, the same argument doesn't seem to work all the time. i think the "Hitler" moustache is permanently ruined.
OMG who fucking cares, I'm tired of the entire world being thin skinned bitches.
Epstein files nah-
Israel committed genocide nah-
Look at this random string of characters and become offended.
Look mom I'm a good person.
No you really aren't.
OMG who fucking cares
The developer, clearly. Nobody told them to change the name, they're just explaining their reasoning. Nobody complained, the dev just grew to hate the name
Or shockingly maybe he was just manufacturing publicly for his software. This statement brought to you by Carls jr.
Me when I make a post on the blog I own about the reason I changed the name of the free software I make (I'm manufacturing publicity for literally no reason because this software isn't monetized)
Clout chasing have you ever seen the influencers videotaping helping the homeless. Just do it and shut up about it. You could have just changed the final to any other f word in ya brain nobody would ever know. "False-virtue" would have been a good choice.
You know you can just say "yeah, I overreacted. It's perfectly reasonable for someone to write a post on their blog about why they changed the name of the software they develop. I was having a bad day, and shouldn't have taken it out on LGFae."
And instead you're tripling down and calling it clout chasing. He didn't post this on tiktok with #viral in the description. He didn't contact a news agency to report on this decision. He wrote a journal entry on his personal website, and one of his readers shared it on this community because some of us give a shit about the people who write the software we use
Uhhh what are you chasing then?
What makes you think he’s not being open and sharing something honest?
Bro because it's pointless narcissism. nobody would have even known. but now we all have wasted so much time, all while old boy fluffs himself about how he didn't know
([x] doubt by the way.)
and changed it because he was a good person now or what nonsense the documentation said.
I'm saying this with all the warmth and hope I can muster:
Touch grass.
So how long until Lunduke does a video about how this software has GoNe WoKe?
How wholesome! I also appreciate the move to Codeberg. Don’t forget that Codeberg runs on donations. Please help if you can.
Now if only the GIMP maintainers would come to their senses.
Edit: corrected "it" to "if".
I don't think you should let Nazi's win the war of language.
Agreed, I think the author's feeling towards this is commendable in spirit, but to let a generic phrase be forever attached to a political movement in any setting is a bit much, even if it's infamously memorable, it doesn't belong to Nazis.
Still, it's just a name change, so, aside from a few lines of code to change, it doesn't badly affect anyone. All power to the author
It's case-by-case. Fascists are going to invade and appropriate every shred of culture they can find. But some of their choice culture is so toxic that they will own it for a long time. "Final Solution" and "Concentration Camp". But others like "living space" are probably not forever nazi.
I see what you’re saying, but the fact that it can be ambiguous is actually what makes it so useful to fascist organizers.
They thrive on phrases that allow them to wink at each other when they want to, but claim innocence if someone calls them out.
Isn't that something done by any group being oppressed and not in power, regardless of what kind of cause they are for?
e.g. those who had capoeira and similar things that had martial arts disguised as other stuff, back when they couldn't practice partial arts.
Though I find it hard to understand why they still have to wink now, when there are literal state-sanctioned groups of armed people-robbers around, who are also fine getting filmed in the act.
When multiple countries' governments have switched from turning a blind eye, to actually endorsing such actions, what more are these groups trying to accomplish by using these deniability tactics?
Can someone explain?
Fair reason to rename the project, but isn't it reasonable to consider it already too tainted by historic association and requiring a delisting instead?
Stuff like swaybg, despite being very well built, only support setting a single wallpaper on startup. This means, if you want to change the wallpaper during runtime, you must pkill the daemon
So this...this is the power of Wayland
No, it's a limitation with swaybg so they created a tool that doesn't have that limitation.
...have you actually used Wayland? If you're using Plasma or GNOME, its indistinguishable from X11 except it actually has a slightly more (inexplicable tbh) polished feel to it.
This comment is incredibly misinformed
I still bounce back to x11 over a handful of deal breaking issues I run in to every time I try. Screen shares are extremely low quality, barrier (vkvm software) crashes intermittently, and inevitably I run in to clipboard issues. After a couple of days I just want my computer to work again. I use Plasma
In what way? I've been using triple monitors for close to a decade now and my KDE switched from X11 to Wayland at some point without me noticing, so I'm wondering what I missed.
Something KDE has done seems to have resolved the issues I used to have with DPI related scaling problems in Wayland. Once Plasma 6 hit, it's been nothing but rapid improvements with Wayland as a focus and man does it feel nice.
That said, there's virtually no downside to still using X unless you have explicit display features you need from Wayland like HDR or the per-display scaling. Xfce is stupid lightweight and still my default for anything where battery life is a benefit.
Ah, my monitors are all identical and stay plugged in all the time, so it's a much less complicated use-case than yours.
I do have one issue where, because I picked the wrong 9070XT on launch day and couldn't exchange it due to lack of availability, one of my monitors is on HDMI instead of DisplayPort and takes annoyingly longer to wake from sleep or change modes than the other two. But I think that's more likely a hardware or driver problem than a Wayland one.
The fact that you're comparing Wayland to XFCE tells us you're not entirely sure what you're doing. One is a compositor and the other is a desktop environment.
Your problems are with GNOME. I dont even think you could define what X11 and Wayland are based on your posts, much less articulate why one is better than the other
Start by reading about Wayland. Don't make shit up and defend a position you can't even articulate. It's cringe.
I'm literally reading your posts and responding to your words.
The real issue is that even today, some apps (Firefox, gedit, some terminals) don't adjust their scaling to the new screen
This shows you dont know what fractional scaling is otherwise you would have used the term.
I work in Linux as a daily driver for work and personal. I don't care what the tools are, but they need to work and stay out of the way. Right now, Wayland implementation of multi monitor for my hardware is too much bother, I'll try it again in a year.
This is you being stubborn because you're justifying your inaction based on false manufactured premises.
I have no objections to Wayland itself, but I value the kind of stability xfce gives me, which is stable, predictable, and gets out of the way. Right now, on my hardware, Wayland/gnome is not there.
This shows you don't understand what Wayland is because you compared a compositor protocol to a desktop environment.
Really? I have two 4k monitors, one being 160hz and I find they're handled way better by Wayland over X11. Even fractional scaling is perfect now
Yeah I tried it, out of the gate my favourite WM - i3 isn't supported.
I tried some of the other WMs, and they all kinda sucked imo.
I tried Gnome but it didn't work for me when I tried using guake.
I also had issues with Spectacle on Plasma (captured area is just plain white).
In both - OBS didn't work properly either (black screen with some capture methods, massive lag with others) and games were a bit laggy (stutters/frame time spikes).
Last one could be that Wayland doesn't play nice with the proprietary Nvidia driver or that unlike with Xorg, Proton/SteamPlay dont support launching a gamescope nested session from a Wayland session (or didn't back when I tried it) which usually ensures silky smooth performance.
So yeah, this was a while back but.
he gave me the wise advice that perhaps I should choose a name I love, rather than one I won't be ashamed of
awww.
A thoughtful and reasonable explanation, I hope the new name serves the project well ☺️
Perfect reaction to a stupid mistake. And you made me discover the project, thanks 😁
People were less sensitive about such names back before Nazism came back from its supposed extinction. The record shop in the book/movie High Fidelity was named Vinyl Solution, and I’m pretty sure there wasn’t any subplot about the owner either having Nazi sympathies (because what remotely sane person would stan a bunch of vanquished monsters?) or having made a terrible mistake (because nobody would make the, in retrospect quite obvious, leap, as everyone knows Nazis are extinct).
A cautionary tale for the ages about the dangers of naming something that sounds cool without looking it up.
Now excuse me, I need to go back to working on my startup, White Grand Dragon LLC.
Good on the dude and good on them for reaching out to someone for advice who in turn provided fantastic advice. AND they moved the project to codeberg. win-win all around.
The Catholic guilt that it everywhere should stop. He made a mistake and fixed it.
If more people owned their fuckups like this, the world would be a better place.
all 20 comments