Giraffe

ONLY 1% OF PEOPLE CAN SOLVE THIS PUZZLE

Capybara

Giant Red Panda

That's Archibald.

Some sort of beetle (3/4 of species are beetles, so playing the odds here).

Rectangle

Large Pony?

Leopard gecko

Whatever it is, it's gonna be a crab soon.

Weird dog

If you mean the black rectangle - it's a horse's cock

Potoooooooo.

Killer whale.

Catdog

That's Frank. He's kind of a dick.

Tree crab

Some kind of 'taur?

Is mayonnaise an animal?

Unicorn

American Quarter Horse © Scott Smudsky

EDIT: SOURCE

Not horse.

I heard hoofbeats, so it must be a zebra

It's Pikachu

Gotta be a pigeon

It’s a bunny. With the front half of a horse. And th back half of a horse.

Spider definitely.

stallion, hopefully

Unicorn

A walking clock?

What did you call me?

pig

Square

A mule

Select the square that doesn't contain a horse.

Well I hear hooves, so I'm assuming a zebra.

Two people with decent sewing skills.

Chair

🐎

pikachu

The Bog

Hornse

Machetornis rixosa

ITS A DONKEH

Look a unicorn!

Hmm. It looks like some kind of quagga, only less stripey.

Barnacles

Chocolate

Ha!

Looks like a long legged cow.

uhhhh nsfw

Crocodile!

Mettaton

kangaroo

Capybara

That's the Well-hung Stocking-leg

Gopher?

Sarah Jessica Parker!