Yesterday I saw a James Acaster bit about "spag bol" which was really funny. Then today I read this.
post
But what about if you add a bit of ham, it's similar to a British Carbonara?
Who gives a shit? Do they think we care what we would think of how they put ketchup on everything and call it American?
If food tastes good, eat it. Claiming "x" is not really "x" is stupid as fuck.
“embarrassing to be known around the world for something that doesn’t exist” What a whiner.
It does exist you can order it almost everywhere, you wouldn't be able to do that if it "doesn't exist".
It’s even worse than that, it’s about the fucking noodles. Basically saying “spaghetti with red sauce is an affront but a different long noodle (tagliatelle) makes this a cultural icon”.
Get out of here with that nonsense. I hate pretentiousness when it comes to food. Food changes and evolves as it moves through different cultures and palates. It’s fine if you want to be authentic but crying about the type of noodle is as sad as crying about fruit on flatbread with cheese.
Italians are the woooooorst about this kind of thing. I can't think of a country that gatekeeps their food harder.
In my house we always say the most important step to spaghetti is to break the noodles in half "to make the Italians cry"
My partner calls everything spaghetti - They said they were making Spaghetti one night and then put down bow ties. So I'm confused, "I thought we were doing spaghetti tonight?" and, straight-faced, they go "Yeah."
So now I gotta clarify "Like, long noodles or just pasta?"
My child has resorted to just calling everything noodles + the color of the sauce (the type of noodle of of no importance to them). My child and your partner may be of the same ilk.
Spaghetti is noodles and red sauce
alfredo is noodles and white sauce
macaroni is noodles and yellow sauce
and so on.
It's not all the descriptive or helpful but fuck it, we ball.
When they say "authentic" they mean "historic" and nobody bothered to correct them.
Even that is debatable. Like the original pasta carbonara is a recipe invented by an American army cook. The first written recipe does contain cream (which is now considered a crime akin to putting pineapple on pizza) and the cut of porc changed from bacon, to pancetta, to guanciale.
So the historicity isn't even the important part, it's about the perceived rules.
I'll tell you why without even reading the article.
Italians are food snobs.
Thanks for coming to my Ted Talk.
Protectionist I guess? Like I also do not care if Parmasen cheese is made in Parma or not but they get real pissy about it.
They don't even really deserve to be either. There's good stuff in Italian cooking but French and Japanese are clearly superior among others.
Just ask people in Bologna if they add milk or cream to the Ragu or not. You can start a civil war over that question.
White wine versus red wine can start a fight, too.
Funny, I follow Marcella Hazan's recipe and it calls for milk and white wine, and to reduce both down, the meat gets such a lovely texture and flavor.
I'm not gonna get into a fight over that cause I know it's delicious, anyone who wants to fight over it will be easily ignored.
https://theirreverentkitchen.com/2016/02/28/the-classic-bolognese-sauce-marcella-hazans/
Too many cultures have too many rules. There should be no culinary and mannerly rules. Both should be judged objectively.
Screw you and your wrong pasta shape or no seafood and dairy or no garlic and onions. Screw your eating with the wrong hand.
Nonsense.
Eat what you like. Try different things. Don't be gross.
(With Italian ancestry here)
I love the fact I'm italian and don't fucking care. Is it good or is it slob? That's the only metric. Names are to understand what ingredients are on the plate beforehand. Unless you get it completely wrong and tastes like shit.
Your thoughts on breaking the spaghetti before boiling? 🫣
I'd love to see what they think of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naporitan
The dish consists of soft-cooked spaghetti, tomato ketchup, onion, button mushrooms, green peppers, sausage, bacon and optionally Tabasco sauce. Naporitan is claimed to be from Yokohama.[1]
For the Americans in particular, it should be noted that bacon in Japan is boiled back bacon, or sometimes boiled belly, that is neither smokey nor crispy at all.
I think spaghetti without the bolognese is kinda boring. It's just tomato sauce at that point. Gimme the meat.
I would vomit of someone above the age of 10 said "spag bol" in from of me.

all 6 comments