Bitwarden
post
Keepassxc/keepassdx, synced with syncthings/basicsync.
Using a headscale/tailscale setup so things stay synced even when i am not home.
Vaultwarden - self hosted bitwarden server that any bitwarden clients can connect to.
Keepass2
pass: the standard unix password manager for tech-savvy people. It's dead simple: just a directory of GPG-encrypted files that you can sync across devices using git or other means. It has a CLI interface, an Android app, and a Firefox extension.
BitWarden and a self hosted VaultWarden
Fun part of that sollution is that you only need one app.
You also need a secondary service on your server if you want to keep them in sync.
Not really. Bitwarden is hosted by Bitwarden, why would you want to run the sync yourself? Vaultwarden is self hosted anyway.
A few years ago I set up KeepassXC using Syncthing temporarily to sync the database across all my devices. I fully expected to have to move to Nextcloud for database file management.
The KeepassXC / Syncthing combination has worked so well that I have no reason to change it. The databases are seamlessly synced across all devices (including my phone) without requiring any attention from me. Database issues due to multiple device use are almost nonexistent.
One note: For me Syncthing works much better with multiple devices using a star topology. When I initially set up a mesh configuration I had regular file sync issues. With a star topology they are very rare.
What do you use on a phone?
Syncthing-fork from Fdroid.
There were some repository ownership questions a few months back that were ironed out. In addition, Fdroid vets apps far better than Google ever has so I'm comfortable with the app's security.
Oh, sorry, I meant the password manager. There's multiple KDBX compatible apps.
In addition, Fdroid vets apps far better than Google ever has so I'm comfortable with the app's security.
I agree but they aren't checking every version for malicious changes. they would likely only get to know if a user checks it and notices it, and the developer could just make the change for a single release version.
of course that applies to any app but this handover/takeover was very sketchy.
1Password family account with spouse, kids, and my parents. Vault management, ease of sharing, and remote management for my parents is nice, along with multiplatform for everything important, and the price feels quite reasonable at $1/user/month. No major security incidents ever, and I was pleased by their core service design whitepaper that I read many years ago. But as they’ve become increasingly corporate over the past several years I’ve felt like they care less and less about individual users, and the CEO’s recent pledge to Omarchy really pissed me off. So it’s been a great service for me but I don’t recommend it for new users unless they like nazis. I pay for a year at a time so I haven’t scrambled to migrate my family to a new solution quickly, but it sounds like Vaultwarden is most likely the way to go next.
Seconding Bitwarden, have been with it since my previous one (Lastpass? I forget, it was red) moved most of the good functionality behind a paywall many years ago. 11/10 I usually pay for the subscription, I like their product and want them to have a little walkin' around money. But currently on the free tier which is perfectly fine (2 devices when I used pro for 3, but I hardly use my laptop.
Remember the password to my email. Create account on site. Log in and remain logged in. When eventually logged out click forgot password. Log into email and click reset link.
I'm an old man yelling at clouds but I don't trust any of the password storing technologies. I have a system of making/writing passwords and a save a short form of them on my pc. Without knowing a specific segment you'd never be able to guess what they were so the segment is the only thing I need to remember. Having to access accounts when not at home is a massive pain in the ass though lol
Idk if this is the right choice but I write them down on a piece of paper and store that paper in my locked fireproof safe.
Not very user friendly, but not wrong either
Definitely the most secure!
Bruteforcing a safe might be easier than a password manager.
Mostly i get by by not telling others how or where I keep my passwords
Same one on every site. But don’t worry it’s 10 characters instead of 8. And I tossed a bang at the end to throw off attackers.
I moved away from Bitwarden because they removing values from their motto and some other shady stuff. I chose to go with AliasVault, it has a pretty nice alias email feature.
Firefox remembers my passwords. For other things, text documents stored in a Veracrypt container
I use online bitwarden for unimportant accounts and offline keepassxc for important ones.
I ask AI to make me a random password for "x" service. Whenever I need to remember it, I just ask again \s
Vaultwarden
I ask AI to make me a random password for “x” service. Whenever I need to remember it, I just ask again
I've already seen someone do that, a certain family member. At first I found it funny when they asked an LLM about their WiFi password, which was some gibberish. But it worked. There's no way something like that would be default across entire product line.
Indeed, when I asked, I got "I gave it screenshots of everything because I didn't know what to type where".
I write down a password hint on a physical piece of paper.
Since the primary threat vector is remote access and not physical access, I'd argue that is fine.
Additionally the password hint has to pass through several thought chains in order to provide the actual password.
I do wish sites would up front tell you what the password requirements were when you logged in though.
Selfhosted Aliasvault
A bit of a tangent but these are the right people to ask... What do you think when a site or app says that your password is too long?
I think the site stores my password in its original form, without hashing. its way too common, even at high profile services like banks, university or government systems.
I'm glad they told me and didn't just truncate it forcing me to reset everytime.
I use KeePass database for all my passwords and other database for recovery passwords (like from 2FA codes etc). I have it synced in my Nextcloud and ProtonDrive (In case my Nextcloud would fuck up).
I stick to brain based. I have a system that makes it easy for me to remember which password is for where. Step one is to use passphrases instead of password. Obligatory reference: xkcd correct horse battery staple
Mostly with a mooltipass. I also save them in a keepass db that is only written to a thumb drive, for redundancies sake.
I use several tools depending on context (keepass for work accounts, a custom hosted solution for everything else). But I also have a system for my passwords that allows me to figure out what it should be in case I forget. Most of my passwords follow a specific pattern that incorporates the platform and a series of characters.
This specific implementation is now out of date, as it's not really necessary (or at least it shouldn't be) to have all the special characters; length should be the critical property of a secure password, but unfortunately many, many sites still require a mix of upper/lower/numbers/special chars. Regardless, it should still be simple to come up with a way for you to know your passwords, without them all being the same.
Have you considered trying pass phrases? Weirdly, they can sometimes be easier to remember depending on where you take it from.
Self host. Keepass, NAS with a sync app across devices. Occasional manual backup. Probably overkill.
all 78 comments