I was about to comment "all of those are illegal and you will win in court", but then I remember the US exists.
post
Do people legitimately not understand that going after middle managers while billionaires exist is fucking stupid?
And that the billionaire class would love that to be the diving line because that greatly increases the amount of people on their side.
There's not many billionaires, start at the top and work down.
Starting at the bottom and working up is so stupid of an idea I struggle to give people benefit of the doubt on why they'd think this was a good idea or try to promote it.
Let’s say you made $50k/year. It would take you 20,000 years to make a billion.
Let’s say you make $1m/year. It would take you 1,000 years to make a billion.
A billion is a dumb, immoral amount, and we have humans with hundreds of them, in theory. If you make a billion dollars, whatever earnings after should be taxed at 100%. It’s not “socialist” to make this claim. Rather, it’s inhuman to argue the opposite.
I mean I can think of a few nonphilanthropic uses for the money if I was given 10 million, but I could live very comfortably off the interest from 2 million for the rest of my life. If I were somehow given a windfall of 10 million, I can think of a lot of philanthropic things that would also be fun ways to blow through 8 million dollars.
Like buying the schools in town better musical instruments. 8 million could go a short ways.
Just building a nice community center costs millions, upkeep exists too. Generally such kind of projects are very expensive. We have lots of parks and buildings from, say, 200 years ago because off rich ass people. Very unlike people like Musk or Zuckerberg who leave nothing behind. We can easily argue that Gates did a lot of good things with his money, again, very unlike the those 2 people.
Then why are “middle managers” vanguarding “billionaires”?
This. The owning class doesn't have control without class traitors who act on their behalf in exchange for a paycheck.
I hate the state of political discourse that people are focusing on "billionaires" and not the system that gives those people power.
Why are kangaroos flying attack helicopters on Alderaan?
Quick edit:
Even if what you said wasn't as ridiculous as what I said, so fucking what?
Start with the billionaires and work down.
If you start at the bottom and work up to them, it won't work.
It just fucking won't.
Yes, why aren't “middle managers” “starting with the billionaires and work down”?
You don't think there are communists and anarchists in middle management? Don't be daft
precisely why they are class traitors.
I want givesomefucks to see it, say it, and claim them.
Yeah. I mean. That's just not what a class traitor is. Management serves a function that would exist whether or not there was a bourgeoisie. Workers are capable of choosing when they need a management function (coordination, longer term planning, etc) to exist within their cooperative structures and the people who energize that management function are doing actual work that has value.
Yes, the bourgeoisie convinced many managers to become class traitors for a slice of the pie, but it's not inherent to the role like it is for cops or imperial soldiers.
You're confusing a collectively decided role with bourgeoisie lapdogs. The meme specifies middle management, not coordinators, longer term planners, etc.. Not all work requires management, and not certainly bourgeoisie protectors.
Middle management is explicitly not the task masters that supervise workers and police their behavior and explicitly not the c-suite of do-nothing bourgeoisie soothsayers. It's quite explicitly the group of people that analyze the organization, improve safety and training, handle worker complaints, plan things, evaluate decisions that impact the collective, etc.
Middle management absolutely includes coordinator functions, planning functions, etc.
I'm not confusing a collectively decided role with bourgeoisie lapdogs, I am saying that the work that middle.managemrnt does in bourgeois corporations includes much of the same work that would be needed in a large-scale workers cooperative.
I’m not confusing a collectively decided role with bourgeoisie lapdogs, I am saying that the work that middle.managemrnt does in bourgeois corporations includes much of the same work that would be needed in a large-scale workers cooperative.
If this was true, the bourgeoisie would have ceased from existing, as “large-scale organizers” would have already toppled oppressive c-suites and private firms. It is precisely the fact bourgeoisie authorized management the powers to impose sanctions, demotions, pay cuts, worsen hours, worsen conditions, and harass, why the bourgeoisie hold any power. They are the supervisors, the internal police, the “soothsayers.”
No, that doesn't make any sense. There's no way that a procurement manager or a sales VP would have sufficient power or safety to topple the bourgeoisie. That's a ridiculous sentiment. As we all know, the workers could just topple the bourgeoisie too and they haven't, does that make them lapdogs and class traitors?
Middle management are not the supervisors, by definition. Supervisors of front line staff are excluded from the definition of middle management. Without supervising workers, middle management cannot be "the police" because they are not interacting with front line staff directly and cannot monitor them. Middle management primarily works with abstract collections of information, generally responding to price signals, and provide the information management tasks required for organizations to make decisions.
And they are not bourgeois soothsayers because middle management doesn't talk to investors, bankers, creditors, and politicians. That's upper management and explicitly excluded from middle management.
So no, middle management are not police and are not soothsayers. They are well paid members of the working class who are given a larger cut of the surplus in exchange for operating the bureaucracy of capitalism instead of the machine rooms of capitalism. They can be as much class traitors as individual laborers can be class traitors. But the role/work in and of itself isn't inherently class betrayal.
Apparently both literature, the meme, and reality conflict with your definition of the police of the bourgeoisie. Until the bourgeois police empower the proletariat, we have nothing further engage in.
Ah yes, anarchist literature. I had a feeling someone like Malatesta would make an appearance in your argument sooner or later
Have fun with your moral crusade wherein you are the template for the hero and everyone else is your enemy. I am sure that will build class consciousness, revolutionary potential, and sustainable transformation.
I hate to say this, but I think youre completely full of your own shit.
Managers aren't like cops. It's not some moral quoundry to take a managerial position. Very often, the position is given to someone who's very competent at their jobs and has the respect of their coworkers.
Of course, there are evil and shit managers too. And there are evil and shit working class non managers. Whatever your personal grudge is should remain just that. Keep your personal enemies.
Our public enemy is the billionaire class. If youre telling me that the guy making 55k a year and managers a team of 8 is on par with the billionaire class, you've lost the story completely
Did we read the same meme, or are you this apologetic to the bourgeoisie lapdogs?
Managers are the exact reason bourgeoisie have remained bourgeois for millennia: the bourgeoisie have convinced their brownshirts loyalty for a bigger cut of the pies they larceny. They both need to go, because they are both the oppression.
If you are one for movie theaters, you should go see The Weight. I rather enjoyed it and I think you would too
Pay attention to Avi Nash's character. You'll like him.
Their employers? What are they supposed to "start"? Every US state except Montana is completely at-will employment, you can be fired at any time for no reason. You think a floor manager at Amazon has any particular leverage over Jeff Bezos? A middle manager has no greater advantage against the billionaires than anyone else.
¿Por qué no los dos?
Because two things can't be the fucking priority...
If everything is the priority, nothing is, which is why oligarchs always want to defocus movements.
You really never noticed that?
I mean, go after the useless positions and specific assholes. Not every business has an org chart with 37 layers and transparencies with lines showing who's working on which projects and transparencies with lines showing interoffice "romance" shipping/betting pool positions. Every office should have an org chart with a transparency with lines showing interoffice "romance" shipping/betting pool positions, otherwise the office is too small or too boring.
Corporations and top-down management are the true Petit Bourgeoisie. We need worker coöps and worker democracy.
Nah, they can't.
They can't even fire you without good reason. Let alone pay you less.
They signed the contract as well as you.
And if they try, you can see them in court.
my greatest joy in middle management was when people didn't even realize I was their boss.
I have never been able to understand how the people in the US are under the misconception that they're living in a democracy with freedom, when the reality is that almost all of them are living in a dictatorship of their employer.
And then on top of that, they refuse to allow the government to restrict their employer so that they as an employee can actually have rights.
The reasoning is backward.
I don't. Was just unlucky enough to be born here. Most of us share this exact same sentiment, but bills gotta get paid and at least where I live the unhoused people get disappeared. I get involved with politics and try what I can, but you only have so much time and energy.
Pardon my language.
No, most of us fucking don't share that sentiment at all, and that's part of the problem. I wish everyone felt like that. People here are conditioned to believe it's their own fault they don't have that perfect job. We think we're lucky to be born someplace with so much choice. We have the highest GDP!
then get together, bury your boss, and run the factory yourselves.
You can buy you bills as soon as you seize your means. Getting shit done together IS how you liberate yourselves.
So get fired, fix nothing, and possibly some prison time. On the plus side the rent, food, and medical issues would be resolved. For real I hear what you are saying but I'm not sure you quite understand what it would take to make something happen and this is with precedent at least towards unions. Even with large strikes. It would take far more people than I and everyone I know that would be willing trying to get others to for this to work. I'm not saying I won't but looks at bank account I've got enough to run for 2 weeks in the bank with no opportunity for more. There is no gov assistance here or at least one that can cover even the average rent alone for a max of 2 months in your LIFE. Food? Hahaha medical? Hahahhaha so yeah open to options, but I'm not a martyr. Something you non us people seem to forget is how concentrated most places are like France with Paris that's it you protest in one city and get things done. We don't have that luxury. We also do not have that culture. We do not have that small of a place to organize. One area falls short and none of this works out. Logistically it's a nightmare to even think about. Revolutions of that size are not started in a year or even years. Those are in the size of decades and you might get a part of the country to split off maybe. For work related things most of these companies would rather shut down camp and reopen under another name than let a union form. They have fired entire campuses before just to avoid it then hire up in no time to replace you. This isn't like it is out there.
Do I think most of my fellow Americans are sitting on their asses? Absolutely. Do I think most even give a shit enough to vote let alone start a movement or be a part of one? Haha hell no we got less than 33% turnout to even vote. People in my area actually just up and vanish when they even talk about this. We are working on it but you all either need to be patient or drop the bombs yourself if that schedule isn't for you.
Why would you be fired when you are your own boss‽ Prison should have been abolished a long time, or do you think it should exist?
All of you are your own bank,you don't need a fractional reserve larcenist to maintain your finances.
We also do not have that culture. We do not have that small of a place to organize. One area falls short and none of this works out. Logistically it’s a nightmare to even think about. Revolutions of that size are not started in a year or even years. Those are in the size of decades and you might get a part of the country to split off maybe.
Then time to get started. You are not alone, you're not the only person hurting, you're needed.
The boss's song:
(to the tune of Little Teapot)
I'm a little fascist
Hear me out
This is my ego
This is your fault
When I get all worked up
Hear me shout!
Be more grateful
Or get the fuck out
I'm a very special big boy
Don't you know?
Make me look dumb
And it will show
I can turn a chance boon
Into a rout
Question my strategery
And you're out!
"We think that middle-management employee and cops have distinct interests than other workers" That line came from the previous website of the CFE CGC, the french "trade union" of managers and cops. It's cops federation is a fascist one, and their help engineer from the metropolis getting job in colonized area instead of autochtones people
They are also class traitors. If they’re not vanguarding the proletariat, they deserve the guillotines too.

all 37 comments