Why does this shit distro deserve all this funding and support? There's many better options doing a lot more for the ecosystem yet this gets the attention. It's don't understand.
post
Nonetheless, it seems the company has sacrificed a moral position for a “mission-driven” position. In the same message to staff, Faugno says “the scale and growth of [Omarchy’s] use among our customers is significant - Omarchy has grown to be the second most used Linux distribution among 1Password users."
I didn't know Omarchy existed until, like, yesterday, so this is surprising. Do 1Password users just tend not to use Linux, so second place isn't many users?
I feel like this has to be made up, downstream repack distros almost never show up on the top 10 usage stats. You will always see Ubuntu way ahead of Kubuntu.
Not to mention 1Password is a pretty popular enterprise app and I have yet to see some insane sysadmin actually roll with arch as their distro of choice. Most are probably on RHEL or some other enterprise derivative.
It's probably not made up because 1Password is pre-installed and bound to a hotkey in Omarchy. Linux users making informed decisions about what to use for password management probably don't pick 1Password most of the time due to its terrible security record.
I said somewhere else that giving money to a distro won't even have an ROI, but I didn't know about this. If the distro is promoting their product that's a whole other thing.
That piece of information seems like key context. 1Password didn't just give money simply because they like the product. More or less, it's product placement in return for funding.
I'm on the fence if that's better or worse.
Ah didn't realize it came preinstalled lol.
spoiler
Prepackaged "superior" arch distro and the best they could come up with was 1Password? seriously lol?
Terrible security record?
Of the items listed in your link, only the second one seems problematic, in that I wish they had discovered the (non-password but still privacy related) issues first. Even that section acknowledges all of the issues are fixed. The only section that makes it sound like there is still a problem is the last one, which states that version X still contains the vulnerabilities, but in reality that's just how versions work. Patching a vulnerability creates a new version.
Is there ANY record of passwords being leaked from 1password because of their own lack of security??
lol what. 1Password literally has one of the best security records out there. They’re the ones actually inventing new more secure ways of doing things. The fact that those are all of the issues over the years and they’re one of the most popular pw managers on the planet is pretty indicative of how strong their security actually is. And they’ve never had a password breach, unlike lastpass.
I haven't checked but I would guess that 1password comes pre-installed in Oligarchy and they're counting every user that loads the client as a "user."
"popular distribution"? Omarchy is neither of those two words, is it?
Whatever it is, it's a stupid name, it sounds kinda like an STD.
https://distrowatch.com/dwres.php?resource=popularity
- 12 mo: #21
- 6 mo: #19
- 3 mo: #16
- 1 mo: #12
Obviously growing in popularity. That's what aggressive marketing usually gets you.
If you don't like that, perhaps consider stop talking about it, and him. Instead, every second week somebody writes an article about "DHH is fascist". What the fuck do they think the effect of those articles is?
Are people actually so dumb that they think accusing him of fascism will make him disappear? That's like high-octane clickbait fuel.
Same with Trump et alia. It's garmonbozia.
I don't write any articles on him or his dot file collection. The reach of Lemmy comments is close to zero and even more so among the red pilled who know the truth.
The DistroWatch Page Hit Ranking statistics are a light-hearted way of measuring interest in Linux distributions and other free operating systems among the visitors of this website. They correlate neither to usage nor to quality and should not be used to measure the market share of distributions. They simply show the number of times a distribution page on DistroWatch was accessed each day, nothing more.
"popular Linux distribution known as Omarchy."
I've literally never heard of it.
It's yet another distro being shilled by god knows who on YouTube and other social media.
The fact that it's being pushed so hard without anything of note about it is already suspicious to me.
I've seen a handful of videos about it recently that have been pushed into my algorithm. There's definitely a campaign to get it out to influencers. Never heard of it prior to this week.
It's just a fork of Arch, with tiling, that's been slop coded with AI. Something anyone could recreate without AI in a couple hours if they're familiar with Arch.
But could you recreate it with $30mil and AI‽
/s
Don't forget that's "macOS inspired".
Meanwhile actually good distros are drowning at the bottom of the ocean.
yeah this is like a bunch of other internet things where I kinda hate it even seeing it. for me its not a thing of interest.
I only know of it because I was on Distro Watch this week looking for top mention distros I never heard of. The mentions position is likely because of this donation. lol
I've heard the name but have not spent the time to find out what it is. I thought it was some immutable distro. I think the same about bazzite and catchy (sp?) which are other distros I see mentioned from time to time and believe are immutable and flatpak-y and that's all I know. I realise I'm just one data point but I never see a lot about these sorts of distros in my general browsing.
Popular for Linux, not popular for Marvel movies.
It's virtually unknown in the Linux world too. It's literally something they made up overnight and are trying to astroturf.
I'd say "what a time to be alive" to see the day someone considers it worth astroturfing a Linux distro, except there's probably some nefarious shit behind it.
Oh well if you've never personally heard of it, it must not be popular, right?
I'm not OP but yeah, basically. People who are passionate about a specific topic will know what's up in that area.
I can name half a dozen of the most popular Arch-based distros off the top of my head because... they're actually well-known. Meaning they've been around for years, I've used several personally and can argue their pros and cons, and they feature prominently in objective lineups like the Steam Hardware Survey. Omarchy is none of these things.
1Password says "Our contribution is made to the Omacom Foundation, not to an individual" but there are many instances of their VP of product praising DHH https://x.com/jmeller/status/1971530423030387081 https://x.com/jmeller/status/2094132068342964671
The backlash to 1Password’s funding should have been predictable
Managers don’t know shit
1Password does not endorse hateful, dehumanizing, or exclusionary views, including those shared publicly by DHH.
Except... ya just did. Big 'ol cashy money endorsement.
Or did you forget about that already? Because we didn't.
Art / artist.
Why I use KeyPass -- which is FOSS -- instead of entrusting everything to a privately-run paid website which can turn against everyone at anytime.
edit: to that wiseacre below, do you think it's better to go back to passwords in a notepad? 🤣
KeePass is great, but it needs multi-user, granular permissions and conflict resolution on sync. Sharing with multiple simul users is like trying to work on stone tablets.
It's funny you don't think that could happen to them too. Such confidence.
You know keepass is a local keystore, right? There is no "them".
Unless you're the one literally writing the program. It is being developed by other people who at any point in time could have issues. Just saying not saying they do now but it can certainly happen.
Well you better not use any software ever then, never know what 'can certainly happen'. Get a grip.
Its GPL licensed, there'll be a dozen different forks before you know it.
there'll be a dozen different forks before you know it.
Aren't there already?
The passwords are saved into a vault file. You can choose a different software that is capable of opening the vault. I use keepassXC for example. there's some variety of programs that can open this filetype, on many different platforms.
You can fork it
You think if the developer bails out, the software will magically disappear from everywhere, leaving you with no way of recovery whatsoever?
Let's say they decide to pull the plug. Everything you have that's already running will keep running. Code can be forked (in fact with keepass, it already happened). Data can be exported after the fact. Other software can actually open keepass database file.
You really don't see the difference between this and "the server stopped sending you your own data, oops"?
You don't auto update it, and you store the keys locally, and if you need passwords on a device you use a VPN to access them, I'm not to concerned about updating my manager I'm more concerned about my VPN 😂
But I get what your saying.
1Password is a paid service. The money given to for the service can go to organizations the user doesn't agree with.
KeePass is free.
How is it the same?
Wasn't Omarchy literally just a couple of dotfiles for Arch and a easy Installer?
It is currently more than that, and it even has its own repos/mirrors, but the fact that basically every rich person is throwing money at this project should be a huge warning sign to everyone to avoid this.
But at the end of the day, it's nothing revolutionary. It's customized Linux with a tiling window manager, all funded by billionaires and developed by a turbo racist.
It also has a few native apps now.
Why does Omarchy even need this money when it’s run by a billionaire?
This song have just been sent to Arch or some Linux foundations.
How the fuck is Omarchy "popular"? I've been on Linux going on a decade, give or take, and I first knew about it when someone here in Lemmy mentioned that Dell and some other shit companies were proton a few millions on it.
It's popular to a lot of the non Foss tech job devs that want to try Linux after mostly using macOS for Dev work. It comes with keybinds they are familiar woth has a pretty UI by default and is arch base. They probably work for companies that are also right wing so it's something they don't care about as much as people in alignment with the Foss ideology.
Compared to today's mask off fascism in the states the guy behind Omarchy is pretty tame and probably less mask off evil than the people they work for
Youtube has been feeding me Omarchy video lately, it seems like every single one I tried to watch brought up using Grok. I don't know anything about Omarchy, but it was enough to give me the feeling something wasn't right.

top 82 comments