So, question first, for those who just want a "quicker" discussion: What games are worth paying $100 for?

Longer form, for the forum types: Games were $50 or so for a long time, then they went up to $60. They told us digital would drive the price down, but then it went up to $70, with some games going for $80. A threatened boycott got the price of The Outer Worlds 2 reduced, but then Rockstar came out and said GTA VI will be $100. Almost nobody balked, nobody threatened a boycott, and gamers came out to vote for $100 games.

So, the question is, where do we go from here?

I don't think every new game will be $100... but I think Elder Scrolls VI, Fallout 5, and most Call of Duty games will be. Maybe others.

I'm curious not only what game you'd pay $100 for (Mass Effect 5 anyone?), but I'm even more curious what, if anything, you think is going to stop the next publisher from deciding their game is worth $100 (whether it is or isn't).

I think the big reasoning a lot of people said GTA VI was worth the $100 was because it's been 13 years since GTA V. Well, it's been 15 years since the last Elder Scrolls game, and 11 years since the last Fallout (we're not counting online/MMO stuff, because GTA V's online has been going strong this whole time, too).

Also, in a year, will you pay $100 again for the PC version of GTA VI, if you're a PC gamer?

Lastly: do you think the expansions will be free, or are you sure you're (or they're) actually not done paying/charging for GTA VI? And yes, they've said the city is designed for future expansion. Not sure if that's story expansions, or just online.

Bias disclosure: I didn't buy GTA VI. I don't hate it, I just wouldn't have bought it at $70 or above. $60, maybe, but probably not. I generally hang back and pay $10-20 for my games after they've been out a few years. My wife got me Pragmata for my birthday, and we spent $50 on that. Since then, I've bought Starfield for $30, Prey for $8, Dishonoured for $10, and pre-ordered Stage Tour for $36 (it'll be $40 at release). I definitely buy games, but $100 gets me a lot more than just one game. If you take Stage Tour out (because it hasn't released yet), the rest of my purchases put me at $98, and that's for four games, including one that released this year and is probably the GOTY if we set sequels, spinoffs, and remakes aside. It's certainly the most original. I'll get GTA VI eventually. I liked pretty much all of them since the original. Even liked the second one.

That said, I did buy the Pip-Boy Edition of Fallout 4 (something like $130?) and then I turned around and bought the complete edition on Xbox a couple years later for like $55. Then I bought it again on GOG to experiment with on my Mac for around $10, so I have absolutely spent more than $100 on one game! So, totally not trying to be a hypocrite or anything! Just wondering where we go from here.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 73 points 21 hours ago (8 children)

Because if you don't have all the content in the game for $80, then the full game is $100. It doesn't matter if it's just a few in game stores or whatever. If content is locked behind an extra paywall at launch, then the lower price is not the cost of the full game.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 8 child comments
  • [–] 34 points 20 hours ago (5 children)

    Every AAA launch in the last decade has had more expensive deluxe editions, why is this case more special?

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 5 child comments
  • [–] 19 points 20 hours ago (3 children)

    It's not, those digital deluxe editions (if they had Day One DLC), then they also had higher prices than advertised

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 3 child comments
  • [–] -1 points 18 hours ago (2 children)

    By this logic, the existence of premium model vehicles means that their lowest priced version isn't the actual price of the vehicle.

    Tiered pricing for different variants does not mean you're not getting the "full product". It means you have the option to pay more for additional content.

    Once the DLC for a game is released, if they sell a bundle with the base game + DLC, is the base-game-only SKU ”not selling you the whole game"?

    That interpretation would be kinda absurd.

    You can have opinions about whether some content or another should've been in the base SKU or not based on price, but it's absurd to say they're not selling you the "full game" unless there are substantive elements missing that the game feel incomplete.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 0 points 5 hours ago (1 child)

    Once the DLC for a game is released, if they sell a bundle with the base game + DLC, is the base-game-only SKU ”not selling you the whole game"?

    yes, quite literally. Are you saying that buying a game and not being able to access all the content available is "buying the whole game?"

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 7 points 18 hours ago

    I’m done with acknowledging this sentiment. Games have tons of niche content only targeted to those interested now - lots of varied costumes, and only a few people who care to collect them.

    Maybe you don’t like the structure, but I can still enjoy games even when I don’t have 100.00% of the costumes or 10x extra potions or useless cruft. We came a long way from days when whole questlines got cut off.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 1 point 1 hour ago

    That argument just doesn't hold up though. If the base game is $80, but for $1000 you get an extra dance animation that doesn't change any other gameplay, that doesn't mean the game costs $1080. I get what you're trying to say, but you've oversimplified.

    The reality is, we live in a world of rampant wealth inequality, a "K-shaped economy", and every industry is trying to figure out how to sell their product to both ends of the K without pricing the other end out.

    The way it shakes out in reality is subjective: if you feel not being able to do that dance animation negatively impacts your gaming experience, then fair enough, the game costs $1080. But if you feel the $80 base price gets you an entire game, then the game costs $80. And if you think going over to a friend's house with a 6-pack to play it for an couple of hours is enough to get your fill, then the game costs a 6-pack.

    And remember that in this case, either way, you're paying for a very limited digital licence, so no matter what you're getting robbed.

  • source
  • parent