[–] [S] 2 points 3 weeks ago (5 children)

And that’s the bacteria they want to use in cattle, wombat front stomach bacteria so cows can get more energy from their grass and not release methane

really? thats fascinating... changing the rumin bacteria load.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] [S] 4 points 3 weeks ago* (6 children)

    all carbs get turned into serum glucose, glucose drives insulin, elevated insulin wrecks havoc with your cardiovascular system.

    i love this meme, they are making fun of meat eaters, but they were not wrong.. it originally said fruit... which isn't wrong..... sometimes irony swings all the way around to truth.

  • source
  • [–] [S] 2 points 3 weeks ago* (last edited 3 weeks ago)

    Variety is the spice of life.... i used to believe that... now it just means i was missing something.

    i used to be a big boredom eater. now i know if i don't want food... i'm just not hungry... no more grazing for me.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] [S] 2 points 3 weeks ago* (last edited 3 weeks ago) (7 children)

    Adding seaweed to cattle feed could reduce methane emissions by 82% [Roque et al. 2021]

    That is new to me

    In the US, avoidable food waste represents 2% of the total GHG emissions [Venkat 2012]. In UK households, >10% of meat purchases that are still safe to eat are thrown away [Taylor 2020].

    That's a shame! we have freezers!

    The Australian red meat sector considers the possibility of achieving a carbon neutral status by 2030, based on a combination of soil carbon sequestration [see below], vegetation management (trees on farm), and mitigation strategies to decrease emissions [Mayberry et al. 2019; Davison et al. 2020; MLA 2023]

    Good on ya, mate!

    The carbon benefit of globalized plant-based diets would not simply eliminate the current 12% contribution of livestock greenhouse gas emissions. Increased crop production to replace lost nutrients would offset much of the gain, resulting in a net reduction of only a few percentage points.

    Meet the new boss, same as the old boss.

    Eliminating all U.S. livestock would cut national emissions by only 3% due to substitution effects, while raising concerns about nutrient security.

    some vegetarians can have a larger footprint than omnivores when relying on high-impact produce.

    heh, importing food across the globe is antithetical to sustainable systems, eat locally produced food!

    Livestock serve as convenient scapegoats,

    heh

    Global tourism accounts for 8% of GHG emissions. The fashion industry alone generates 10% of the global GHG budget, whereas pet food accounts for 1-3% of global GHG emissions. Digitalization and data centres also carry a substantial carbon cost; ICT is projected to account for over 14% of the global emission budget by 2040, with smartphones surpassing the emissions from desktops and laptops. By 2030, communication technologies could represent 23% of the emission budget. The use of email alone can result in 0.1-0.6 t CO2-eq per person per year.

    wait, what? email at 0.6t/yr ? that is alot of spam

    Using environmental metrics like CO2-eq/kg to compare very different foods is misleading, as it overlooks their nutritional value. The quality of protein and the presence of essential micronutrients should always be taken into account, knowing that animal-sourced foods are crucial sources of these nutrients. Despite their lower carbon impact per kilogram of product, ultra-processed foods offer little nutrition, lead to substantial dietary emissions, and cause health problems.

    they never factor in global money spent on NCDs into the plant based cost, but they should.

    The MyPlanetDiet randomized controlled trial, which is the first large-scale intervention trial to test if a low-emission diet meets nutritional requirements, revealed higher inadequacies for vitamins B2, B6, B12, iodine, calcium, zinc, selenium than the control diet which contained more dairy, meat, and eggs, but less legumes, nuts, and seeds [Leonard et al. 2025].

    i had no idea they already did a trial on a low-emissions diet, this isn't even 100% plant based.... yet

    When also accounting for priority micronutrients (vitamins A, B9, and B12, calcium, iron, zinc), the carbon footprints of ASFs are even closer to their plant-source counterparts than what is found in protein-based comparisons, even if animal-sourced foods typically remain still somewhat higher than plant foods [Katz-Rosene et al. 2023].

    ohh, i should read that paper

    Unhealthy diets lead to enormous health costs as well as important carbon footprints [Eckelman & Sherman, 2016], the pharmaceutical industry being more emission-intensive than the automotive industry [Belkhir & Elmeligi 2019]. Moreover, obesity not only brings carbon costs related to disease but also a 20%-increase due to greater metabolic demands, higher intake of food, and higher mobility costs due to greater body weight [Magkos et al. 2019; Kortetmäki & Oksanen 2020].

    ahh, they do speak about food and metabolic health, but don't really generalize to NCD

  • source
  •  

    Let's talk salt, primal cuts, induction cooking and pan compatibility. Oh and we're going to cook RIBEYE.

    summerizerRibeye reboot

    • The episode opens with "John Wayne ate steak," the first line from Good Eats, and returns to the original ribeye lesson.
    • Alton Brown no longer cooks ribeyes with the old cast-iron sear plus oven finish because modern induction gives him more repeatable heat control.
    • The reboot is organized around the meat, the heat, and the method, because each variable changes the steak.

    Meat selection

    • Ribeye comes from the rib primal, a tender and flavorful area between the chuck and short loin.
    • The farther a cut is from horn and hoof, the more tender it tends to be.
    • Ribeye stays forgiving because its fat can protect it from mild overcooking and dryness.
    • A ribeye is not a single uniform steak; each rib location changes the muscle mix.
    • The eye is the longissimus dorsi, the cap is the spinalis dorsi, the complexus grows toward the chuck, and the small costarum adds only a few bites.
    • A steak near the eighth rib gives a four-muscle, cap-heavy eating experience, while a steak near the tenth rib carves more uniformly.

    Salt and drying

    • Each side gets about a teaspoon of kosher salt 8 to 12 hours before cooking.
    • The salt first pulls moisture from the surface, then dissolves into a micro brine that soaks back into the meat.
    • The uncovered refrigerator rest, plus occasional turning, dries the exterior and builds a tacky pellicle.
    • The pellicle improves browning and supports Maillard reactions when the steak hits the pan.
    • A fan can shorten the drying window to about 6 hours by increasing airflow.

    Induction heat

    • Induction is used because it allows repeatable heat levels, using a 1-to-20 power scale in place of vague gas flames.
    • Induction heats compatible pans through an oscillating electromagnetic field; the cooktop gets hot mainly from pan contact.
    • A magnet test identifies useful induction cookware: stronger sticking means better ferrous compatibility.
    • Cast iron works strongly on induction but stores heat and responds slowly.
    • Aluminum fails the magnet game unless it has a steel layer.
    • Nitrided steel is tough, slick, and induction-ready, but its dark surface hides pan-sauce color cues.
    • Magnetic stainless steel gives enough induction response, faster heat control, and a bright surface for sauce cues.

    Cooking method

    • The recipe uses unsalted butter, fresh black pepper, beef tallow, shallot, crushed garlic, and thyme.
    • The cold, salted steak gets melted beef tallow so it solidifies on the surface and holds pepper.
    • The steak goes straight from the refrigerator to the pan without a counter warmup.
    • Cooking starts at medium-high, about 75% power, with flips every minute for 6 minutes.
    • Frequent flipping lets heat enter one side while the other side rests, building crust while protecting the center.
    • The target is 122°F through the side, followed by lower heat and added time as needed for steak size.
    • Edge searing covers the raw-looking meat along the sides of thick ribeyes.

    Pan sauce and serving

    • Peppery tallow leaves the pan after searing so burnt pepper does not dominate the sauce.
    • Butter, thyme, shallot, and briefly cooked crushed garlic form the aromatic base.
    • Garlic must stay pale because brown garlic quickly turns black and makes the dish taste burnt.
    • Ice cools the pan and supplies water for a butter emulsion, giving a simple water-butter sauce.
    • Bias slicing, butter sauce, and ribeye fat make medium doneness acceptable.
    • The result is not ultimate prime beef; it is a choice ribeye made very good through control of meat, heat, and method.

    References

     

    testing RFK Jr.’s reported carnivore-style diet for 30 days: meat, fermented foods, dairy, and a noon-to-7 p.m. eating window. The month produced weight loss, ketosis by urine strip, weaker workouts, intense food restriction effects, and follow-up bloodwork showing much higher LDL than earlier bloodwork.

    summerizerSetup

    • The narrator used RFK Jr.'s meat-and-fermented-foods diet as a 30-day test amid chaotic health information.
    • The rules came from RFK Jr. media clips: meat, fermented foods, and a noon-to-evening eating window.
    • The tracked outcomes were starting weight, subjective wellbeing, mental clarity, and word retrieval because RFK linked them to his own results.

    Rules

    • The first rule set allowed meat, fermented vegetables, yogurt, and a basic men's multivitamin.
    • Testosterone replacement and RFK Jr.'s broader supplement routine stayed outside the test because he could not list it fully.
    • The fasting window changed from noon-to-6:00 p.m. to noon-to-7:00 p.m. after the fuller RFK clip.

    Daily Eating

    • Early meals were bacon, eggs, ground beef, steak, salmon, yogurt, kimchi, sauerkraut, and cheese.
    • Strict carnivore rules removed plant products, including garlic, onions, olive oil, pepper, spices, lemon, bread, and produce.
    • Home cooking became the default because restaurant meat often used plant oils, seasonings, or sauces.
    • Eating enough calories inside the narrow window was harder than eating meat itself.
    • Travel, work, movies, birthdays, moving apartments, and refrigeration limits turned normal meals into logistics problems.

    Rule Confusion

    • Shawn O'Mara's materials made the rules less clear because the book used foods that strict carnivore spaces rejected.
    • The Fox segment centered meat and fermented foods, while the book included onions, garlic, blueberries, spinach, lemon, and crisp breads.
    • The "living" food idea made fermented vegetables acceptable while non-fermented vegetables became suspect.
    • RFK's ice-cream event made the diet look less rigid than the interviews made it sound, so pepper returned to the food.

    Online Health Noise

    • Carnivore spaces minimized LDL concern and encouraged distrust when doctors warned about cholesterol.
    • Beef tallow and seed-oil content gave opposite answers with equal confidence, and the science stayed unverified inside the viewing experience.
    • Confident scientific language kept feeling persuasive even when the underlying point sounded weak or unclear.
    • Hank Green's explanation grounded the plant question: humans are omnivores, individual sensitivities can exist, and plants can be beneficial.
    • The fermented-food chewing explanation did not make sense because food still mixes after swallowing.

    Body and Exercise

    • The corrected starting weight was 191.6 lb after a mistaken weigh-in that included the camcorder.
    • Digestion stayed mostly fine, and the first days were physically easier than expected.
    • Running and lifting became weaker around the second week, and one run slowed by about 90 seconds versus the average pace.
    • Strength training in jeans failed twice because the workouts felt unusually difficult and injury risk felt higher.
    • A urine ketone strip near the end showed that the rules were followed closely enough to reach ketosis.

    Social and Mental Effects

    • The diet blocked many normal food moments: pizza, brunch, birthday food, street dogs, movie snacks, drinks, and shared meals.
    • Food became less about taste and connection and more about compliance, timing, refrigeration, and repetition.
    • Cravings intensified as the month went on, especially for bread, produce, hot dogs, cake, lime, and peanut butter and jelly.
    • The restriction briefly quieted the narrator's long-running worry about making healthy choices at every meal.
    • The restriction also revived old body-image patterns, with weight loss feeling rewarding even while the focus felt unhealthy.
    • A stress dream about eating chocolate pie and trying to vomit made the disordered side of the experiment obvious.

    Results

    • On day 30, weight was 186 lb, a little over 6 lb below the corrected starting weight.
    • Extra mental clarity and word retrieval did not arrive; the result was the same self after a month of meat-heavy eating.
    • The first peanut butter and jelly sandwich after the diet tasted extraordinary because ordinary foods had been absent for weeks.
    • Follow-up bloodwork showed much higher bad cholesterol than January and triggered a medication recommendation plus primary-care follow-up.

    Health System Message

    • The doctor's cholesterol message included medication and diet-and-exercise guidance, so it did not match the idea that doctors only give pills.
    • Distrust of doctors can become more powerful when people cannot afford enough medical access to have real conversations.
    • RFK's health story makes personal choice feel like the master cause of illness, but the narrator's cancer experience made that feel false.
    • Illness is not always earned by bad choices, and health does not give full control over whether people get sick.
    • A politics of total personal control can turn sickness into blame, which is the part of the diet culture the narrator found most disturbing.

    References

    They didn't really do zero-carb - the bacon they bought was sugar bacon. Secret sugars got into his protocol, i wish he would have used a ketomojo or a cgm to track.

     

    We reviewed data on the American diet from 1800 to 2019. Methods: We examined food availability and estimated consumption data from 1800 to 2019 using historical sources from the federal government and additional public data sources. Results: Processed and ultra-processed foods increased from <5 to >60% of foods. Large increases occurred for sugar, white and whole wheat flour, rice, poultry, eggs, vegetable oils, dairy products, and fresh vegetables. Saturated fats from animal sources declined while polyunsaturated fats from vegetable oils rose. Non-communicable diseases (NCDs) rose over the twentieth century in parallel with increased consumption of processed foods, including sugar, refined flour and rice, and vegetable oils. Saturated fats from animal sources were inversely correlated with the prevalence of NCDs. Conclusions: As observed from the food availability data, processed and ultra-processed foods dramatically increased over the past two centuries, especially sugar, white flour, white rice, vegetable oils, and ready-to-eat meals. These changes paralleled the rising incidence of NCDs, while animal fat consumption was inversely correlated.

    Annual total caloric and macronutrient availability per capita from 1909 to 2010 (Source: USDA ERS).

    Full Paper - http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fnut.2021.748847

     

    The mechanisms underlying impaired temperature regulation in older age, and the ability of older adults to physiologically adapt to heat exposure remain understudied. This study determined the effects of older age on the neural control of body temperature during heat stress and its plasticity in response to passive heat acclimation. The neural control of body temperature during heat stress was quantified with measurements of skin sympathetic nerve activity (SSNA), local sweat rate (LSR) and cutaneous vascular conductance (CVC) performed on older (n = 15, 60–78 years) and younger (n = 16, 21–40 years) adults before and after seven consecutive days of hot water immersion. Pre-acclimation, the onset threshold of SSNA (mean difference [95% CI]: −0.12°C [−0.38, 0.15], P = 0.518), LSR (−0.14°C [−0.37, 0.08], P = 0.265) and CVC (−0.09°C [−0.33, 0.14], P = 0.600) did not differ between older and younger adults. Heat acclimation reduced resting core temperature and increased sweating in both groups. Post-acclimation, the onset threshold of SSNA (−0.19°C [−0.36, −0.02], P = 0.024), LSR (−0.15°C [−0.29, 0.00], P = 0.036), and CVC (−0.23°C [−0.41, −0.06], P = 0.009) was reduced in older adults and these reductions did not differ from those observed in younger adults (P ≥ 0.703). These results show that older age does not alter the neural control of body temperature during heat stress, nor its plasticity to heat acclimation. The implications of these results are that passive heat acclimation may be a practical strategy to improve the physiological resilience of older adults to extreme heat events.

    Full Paper - https://doi.org/10.1113/JP290417

     

    Belinda and I dive into the hidden history behind our dietary guidelines, tracing how a 19th-century religious health movement helped shape the modern demonization of meat and the rise of fiber, breakfast cereal, and plant-based dogma. She breaks down how the Seventh Day Adventist Church, John Harvey Kellogg, and powerful food and academic institutions worked together to manufacture the "Blue Zones" longevity story, and why the real history of Sardinia, Okinawa, Ikaria, and Loma Linda tells a very different tale about meat, pork, and animal fat. Make sure to listen to the full interview to learn more.

    Belinda Fettke is an independent researcher known for investigating the historical, religious, and commercial influences on modern dietary guidelines. After her husband, orthopedic surgeon Dr. Gary Fettke, was investigated for advising patients to reduce sugar and refined carbohydrates, she began researching the origins of nutrition policy and public health messaging. Her work focuses on the intersections of religion, industry, and dietary recommendations. The interview explores how these factors may have shaped modern views on meat, plant-based diets, and chronic disease.

    summerizerGary Fettke and the origin problem

    • Gary Fettke’s medical-board case began after public comments on sugar, carbohydrate reduction, type 2 diabetes, diabetic ulcers, and amputation prevention.
    • That case led from a personal defense into the origins of plant-based dietetics, fiber messaging, dietary guidelines, Blue Zones, and anti-meat ideas.

    Weston A. Price and ancestral diets

    • Weston A. Price found isolated communities with strong teeth and physiques, and their foods centered on animal proteins, animal fats, vitamins A, D, and K2, sunlight, seasonal carbohydrates, and traditional preparation.
    • His work fits a recurring pattern: ancestral diets used animals, fat, fermented foods, seasonal plants, and local preparation, not modern plant-only rules.

    The Adventist and Kellogg chain

    • The modern plant-based chain runs through Seventh-day Adventism, Ellen G. White, John Harvey Kellogg, medical evangelism, cereal foods, meat stand-ins, and dietetic institutions.
    • Ellen G. White’s health reform made flesh meat a spiritual and moral problem, with perfection, salvation, sexuality, and children’s plates tied to diet.
    • John Harvey Kellogg grew up inside that world and built foods designed to remove meat, eggs, milk, butter, spices, alcohol, caffeine, and stimulating foods from the table.

    Health reform, industry, and dietetics

    • One temperance stream tried to address alcohol, urban poverty, dirty water, disease, factories, and social disorder.
    • A second stream fused religion, vegetarianism, Swedenborgian and Eastern-influenced ideas, anti-meat teaching, and moral reform.
    • John Harvey Kellogg built bland vegetarian foods for the sanitarium, while Will Keith Kellogg added sugar to make cereal commercially successful.
    • Lenna Frances Cooper and early dietetics carried Kellogg’s food inventions into professional nutrition, so industry was embedded from the beginning.

    Adventist dietetics and plant-based evidence

    • Adventist medical evangelism used the Garden of Eden diet, clean-and-unclean meat rules, hospitals, schools, food companies, and research to move society toward plant-based eating.
    • Harry Miller’s infant soy formula is part of the same animal-food-removal project.
    • Adventist Health Studies created influential plant-based evidence, but their vegetarian and vegan categories do not mean what the public thinks those words mean.
    • Those definitions let weekly or monthly animal foods sit inside vegetarian and vegan categories, while headlines translate that into plant-only advice.
    • The public message then hides the need for supplementation and the missing animal nutrients, especially B12 and fat-soluble nutrients.

    Blue Zones as marketed longevity

    • Blue Zones marketing tells people to eat 95 to 100 percent plants, retreat from meat, restrict eggs and dairy, and treat saturated-fat avoidance as a longevity pill.
    • The Blue Zones analysis rejects that interpretation because every ancestral Blue Zone checked had meaningful animal foods, and pork was a major theme.
    • Sardinia, Okinawa, Ikaria, Nicoya, and Loma Linda were turned into plant-based stories by selective timing, religious fasting periods, weak records, changed definitions, and modern marketing.
    • Adventist Health’s 2020 acquisition of Blue Zones made the Loma Linda and Adventist connection explicit.
    • Blue Zones programs then move from ancestral community life into wellness tourism, employer programs, tracking, lifestyle packages, and branded longevity services.

    The five-place tour

    • Sardinia’s mountain zone was a shepherd, cheese, pork, preserved-meat, sunlight, and communal-land culture, not a year-round plant-only diet.
    • A Lent visit could make Sardinia look temporarily plant-heavy, while the rest of the year included meat, broths, stews, preserved pork, and cheese.
    • Okinawa’s koseki records, wartime destruction, U.S. occupation, pig losses, pork culture, Spam use, goat foods, and later longevity decline undermine the sweet-potato vegan story.
    • Ikaria’s Greek Orthodox fasting made half the year look plant-forward, while the rest included whole-animal feasts, goats, strong wine, smoking, seafood, snails, and shellfish.
    • Nicoya combined pork and other animal products with maize, squash, beans, nixtamalization, and local food traditions, not Mediterranean low-fat salad eating.

    Guidelines, schools, and lifestyle medicine

    • The Loma Linda-Harvard line runs through Mervyn Hardinge, Frederick Stare, Adventist researchers, Walter Willett, lifestyle medicine, and dietary-guideline influence.
    • Mervyn Hardinge trained through the College of Medical Evangelists and Harvard, while Harvard food-industry funding and Adventist plant research converged on anti-animal-fat messaging.
    • Sanitarium Australia pushed low-fat, minimal-meat resources for doctors, diabetes, pregnancy, dietitians, and families while selling the products that fit that message.
    • Australian school nutrition materials connected through Life Education and Sanitarium moved children and teachers toward anti-animal-food resources.

    Crete and the Mediterranean diet

    • A Mediterranean diet is not one uniform diet; it covers many countries, religions, fasting calendars, climates, and histories.
    • Crete’s postwar data came from starvation, German occupation, destroyed crops and livestock, imported ration foods, poor infrastructure, young average death age, and Rockefeller rebuilding.
    • Ancel Keys’s Crete work sits on top of Leland Allbaugh’s war-ration context and a Lent-period survey, while later olive-oil industry messaging turned that into a plant-and-oil longevity story.

    Dietetics, profession, and industry

    • Early dietetics connects white Protestant reformers, domestic science, professionalized cookery, industry support, Kellogg products, and removal of food knowledge from ordinary cooks.
    • The first American Dietetic Association gathering already had industry in the room, and the profession grew beside cereal, processed foods, and scientifically formulated products.
    • The later research plan follows temperance into Kellogg’s cornflakes, Coca-Cola, dietetics, anti-meat messaging, and the professional capture of nutrition.

    Pork, anthropology, and the closing arc

    • Pork functions as a test case because pork, lard, tallow, chicken fat, and olive oil expose the religious, biochemical, and cultural layers behind fat advice.
    • The pork taboo story runs through Judaism, Islam, Moses, trichinosis fears, dirtiness language, and modern anger toward pigs despite pork being practical, fatty, and nutrient-dense.
    • Gary’s case opened the door to a larger anthropology of dietetics, religion, food industry, Blue Zones, and the missing animal-food history behind nutrition education.

    References

     

    Saturated Fat

    Often maligned for the damage glucose spiking foods and seed oils have done. Saturated fat has been the whipping boy of observational based researchers since the 1960s. That vilification doesn't hold up if you use a unbiased eye to review the literature: Saturated Fat from animal sources is good for you!

    saturate fat easy to read articleSaturated fat and health risks: the evidence to date

    convincing evidence for a direct link between saturated fat and heart disease is lacking.

    saturated fat published paperSaturated Fats and Health: A Reassessment and Proposal for Food-Based Recommendations: JACC State-of-the-Art Review

    Most recent meta-analyses of randomized trials and observational studies found no beneficial effects of reducing SFA intake on cardiovascular disease (CVD) and total mortality, and instead found protective effects against stroke.

    Whole-fat dairy, unprocessed meat, and dark chocolate are SFA-rich foods with a complex matrix that are not associated with increased risk of CVD. The totality of available evidence does not support further limiting the intake of such foods.

    We have done a deep dive on this paper before: https://discuss.online/post/28134438

    Animal Protein

    The evidence against red meat is tenuous, relying on observational epidemiology (again), it doesn't hold up to unbiased examination.

    animal protein easy to read article

    What does the research show with respect to meat’s potential harm?

    the data linking fat to cancer risk are inconsistent, incomplete, and unreliable.

    The most consistent (albeit weak) associations between cancer risk and fat have been found over the years in observational studies looking at red meat and the risk of colorectal cancer. However, two more recent, important papers published in Annals of Internal Medicine make the case that available evidence from randomized controlled trials and observational studies does not support recommendations to lower red meat intake for prevention of cancer or heart disease.

    For more on the science behind concerns about red meat and cancer, see our evidence based red meat guide.

    Another question that has received much attention over the years is whether there is an association between fat intake and breast cancer. The Women’s Health Initiative (WHI), the largest randomized trial to address this issue, found no statistically significant reduction in breast cancer risk with a lower fat diet. In addition, a meta-analysis of seven prospective studies including 337,000 women likewise showed no association between fat intake and breast cancer risk

    Quote source

    animal protein published paperWhat is the role of meat in a healthy diet?

    Despite claims by the World Health Organization (WHO) that eating processed meat causes colon cancer and red meat probably causes cancer, the observational data used to support the claims are weak, confounded by multiple unmeasured factors, and not supported by other types of research needed for such a conclusion. Although intervention studies are designed to test the validity of associations found in observational studies, two interventions of low-fat, low-meat diets in volunteers that failed to find a benefit on cancer were not considered in the WHO decision.

    It is likely that the association of red-meat consumption with colon cancer is explained either by an inability of epidemiology to detect such a small risk or by combinations of other factors such as greater overweight, less exercise, lower vegetable or dietary fiber intake, and perhaps other habits that differentiate those who eat the most meat from those who eat the least.

    We have done a deep dive on this paper before: https://discuss.online/post/25112884


    Philosophical defense of animal foods

    The key concept is a food source that has been consumed in abundance throughout all of recorded history is not the cause of modern chronic diseases that only have skyrocketed in the last 100 years.

    Fat and Meat didn't cause type 2 diabetes, cancer, heart attacks, obesity to explode - something that happened in the last 100 years did.


    What if I'm wrong?

    I'm sure there are lots of people chomping at the bit to tell my why I'm wrong: and I'm open to that. I just ask any evidence you want to argue with you have actually read completely yourself

    it would be nice if the counter evidence

    • isn't weak observational epidemiology with hazard ratios less then 2
    • takes into account carbohydrate and seed oils confounders
    • ideally a head to head interventional trial!
    • doesn't use intermediate end points, but actually hard outcomes - the gold standard is all cause mortality

    just remember: observational data (even meta-analysis of observational data) cannot inform us of cause and effect. The problem with epidemiological studies

    If a hypothesis relies only on observational data, it must account for observational data in the other direction. If a hypothesis doesn't account for discordant observational data, it isn't a good hypothesis and must be discarded. i.e. the anti-meat theory needs to account for meat positive observations

    Good faith guidelines for literature discussion

    • actually read everything you cite before you cite it.
    • read the entire citation, not just the abstract and conclusion
    • be willing to discuss what you cited in depth: by citing it your asking other people to read it to discuss it with you
    • don't use a LLM to generate a wall of 'evidence' without reading it and understanding it completely
    • citation bombing, i.e. dropping 20 citations, isn't a show of strength - it demonstrates weakness and an attempt to appeal to consensus
    • talk about one point at a time - trying to overwhelm a discussion of one topic with many what-aboutisms, gish galloping, is a sign of weakness.

    graphical flare

    view more: ‹ prev next ›