Livestock wrecks the climate! Meat is the problem you can easily solve at dinner - so what’s stopping you? You have heard the line so often, it now seems self-evident. We are told the Science is settled. But what if it is not? This page cuts through the half-truths and oversimplified narratives.
The food system is responsible for anything between one fifth and one third of human-induced greenhouse gas emissions. Agriculture and fisheries contribute about 40% of these food system emissions, while the remainder is split equally between associated land use and land-use changes (30%) and supply chain activities (30%).
Within the food system, livestock represent the largest source of agricultural emissions, impacting climate and emission budgets. On average, animal-sourced foods have a higher carbon footprint than crops, which is why dietary policies often encourage a shift toward more plant-centric diets.
However, directly comparing individual foods is simplistic and can lead to misguided interventions. Dietary change can involve both benefits and trade-offs. Carbon tunnel vision, focusing solely on carbon reduction, risks ignoring other critical factors, such as water scarcity, biodiversity loss, ecotoxicity, and social impacts, which may arise from prioritizing low-carbon foods. A more effective approach is to assess overall dietary patterns, considering their broader ecological, nutritional, and societal consequences.
...Continued at the url...
- Global data should not be used to evaluate local contexts
- Further mitigation is possible and ongoing
- Restricting animal-sourced foods only leads to small gains (1-6%)
- Dietary focus distracts from more impactful interventions
- Nutrition should be factored in when comparing foods
- Co-product benefits of livestock should be accounted for
- Livestock farming also sequesters carbon
- Rewilding comes with its own climate impact
- Large-scale afforestation of grasslands: not a panacea
- Methane should be evaluated differently than CO2
all 8 comments