While SailfishOS seems neat, it's worth noting that some components, like some drivers, the homescreen UI, the compositor, some QML components and the Android compatibility layer are closed source. The rest of the software stack seems to be based on open source components from desktop Linux. The package manager uses RPM.
post
Most here would love to have a fully FOSS phone. However, Jolla is still an excellent and simple proposition for the vast majority. We need to wholeheartedly support this and other significant movement away from US spyware/ ransomware/adware.
With Motorola going with GrapheneOS and Jolla coming back with a Linux phone, I wonder how Denmark will react. Will the Danish government make versions of Mit ID for these operating systems?
For those who don't know, "nemkonto" is a centralised digital ID system in the Danish government to which all your things are tied. You use a security app called "Mit ID" to log into places that make use of your personal information.
Your bank requires your Mit ID, your doctor requires your Mit ID, your ISP requires your Mit ID. Every time you log into anything remotely official you are required to log in with Mit ID.
On Android it requires Google's security services and a locked down phone to function. So rooting is not an option, as it takes away your ability to use your phone to simply... Exist... As a citizen.
You can get a code key device from the Kommune, but you can only use that to log into things through the Web browser of your PC. On your phone you are required to use the app, and if thr app doesn't work then you're simply not logging in. Something as basic as checking your bank balance becomes a major annoyance.
I've felt the pain of the mitID strictness, it really sucks. But can't you request the desktop version of a site om your phone when logging in and using the code key device?
The MitID keygen works on mobile browsers, it just has to be chromium based and all telemetry enabled. It is not a nice experience, but in a pinch itโs doable.
Ech... I don't use Chromium browsers...
Yea it sucks, but thatโs sadly how it is for most danish government sites. Itโs almost like everything is hardcoded for chromium and anyone not using that can get fucked. That is at least my experience though I should mention that librewolf on Linux works flawlessly.
I've been using it with Fennec (not Chromium) and Vanadium On Graphene as recently as this morning. Have had no issues with the code display
That sounds so dystopian and yet so many governments are moving towards similar ideas.
It does have quite a few upsides as well. Identity theft is harder than ever, everything requires 2FA, there is a lot less bureaucracy and paperwork, and almost everything just works.
Everything is digital, cash is only for drugs and old people. If I travel to the other end of Europe, it feels like the stone ages lol
Finland had a similar system. It's the only reason I can't move over to graphene or others.
Not all Finnish banks require play services for their apps, if any. Mine works just fine on eOS. Don't know about Mobiilivarmenne, if you'd rather use that
Is this a recent change?
I don't know about play services, but a few years ago I received errors that the security of my device was compromised or something, if I installed a different OS, and couldn't use banking apps.
Edit: come to think of it, it wasn't "a few" years, more like "many years" ago.
You can use the key card for manual input in that case. I had to use it for awhile myself
What stops you from using the code key device with your phone. Can it not plug into any USB port and output a code? If their site says it doesn't work on mobile, can you change the browser user agent?
Code key device is not something you plug into a USB. You push a button and it generates a code for manual input.
On websites that require a Mit ID log-in you have options to change to the code device instead. With an app on your phone it requires the Mit ID app to be present, as well as the phone to still have Google's security process running.
Several apps can have the Google security spoofed, but still require the Mit ID app. Mit ID, on the other hand, cannot be spoofed at all.
The code device works fine on Android and Grapheneos, I've never used the app.
I see, that's frustrating, especially if the same functionality isn't available via the web. My university's IT department helped with exceptions and gave me a workaround to the Windows/Mac-only VPN software they were using and made me a different kind of account to login on my Linux laptop so I could access intranet resources. Unfortunately, this wasn't advertised and I didn't find out about it until a year in.
Yup, my biggest reason for not running e/os on my Fairphone in denmark. Idk what to do other than carry 2 phones or wait
Re: the code device. All apps requiring MitID works perfectly fine on the phone without the app as far as I can tell. There's no need to use the web browser of your PC. Source: I had the code device and a phone with e/os/
Fediverse is like โoh, I wish there would be some other option to phones apart from android and iOS!โ When you show them thereโs another option, all are going like โitโs fucking obsolete, it canโt even run android apps and itโs not cheap enough, I will use android and iOS because they are better! And reasonable priced.โ
They are mostly different people. One group of people comments on their desire for something open when something closed is mentioned, and another group comments on the downsides of something open when it's being discussed.
My problem with Sailfish is the UI is proprietary, which is a step back from Android. I also don't think this phone uses a mainline kernel, which limits long-term support to whenever their chosen LTS kernel goes EOL.
What I want is a phone that has a fully functional mainline Linux kernel, which currently does not exist. It'd be even better if the primary bootloader was replacable, similar to how coreboot can be installed on some laptops.
It is very nice to see a phone with a removable battery and a microSD card slot, though.
But Sailfish does run Android apps.
There is a reason itโs a duopoly, making a competing phone eco system to rival two of the wealthiest companies in the world is not easy. Microsoft tried but even they didnโt have enough money. People need apps, because companies want us to use their apps and there are only two app stores, one is walled off so you basically have to run Android apps or convince every company to make an app for your OS. Iโm not wealthy so I only buy a phone every 8-10 yearsโฆ if I canโt ensure I can do my banking shopping and entertainment on my phone I canโt buy it, and every banking/shopping/entertainment site is designed to be terrible on a phone so they can get you to install their app.
I get what you mean, but I'm of the same sentiment: I don't need 1TB of internal space nor to play Cyberpunk on the go, I just need a simple phone for calls, texts, GPS, bank and other lght tasks, and I can't spend โฌ650 for maybe half of those to work; it's frankly too much.
Absolutely same, with one caveatโฆ I want my phone to have the best possible camera I can get. ..two caveats, I want to also keep my phone for as long as possible. If I use a phone for five years and itโs still fast and has a relatively nice camera after five years, 1200-1500USD is totally reasonable.
I didnโt even need to upgrade to THIS phone when my last one was five years old, but I wanted more space for pictures (I keep about 20k on there at a time)โฆ and switching to 120hz for scrolling web sites also was a huge bonus
I wasn't able to read the article, for those who are in the same boat it's copied below. Sorry no images.
Edit: Saw the archived link, mybad ๐
The โEuropeanโ Jolla Phone Is an Anti-Big-Tech Smartphone
Julian Chokkattu
7 - 9 minutes
Jolla may not be a household name, but for more than a decade the Finnish company has positioned its Linux-based Sailfish OS as an alternative to the mobile software duopoly that is Googleโs Android and Appleโs iOS.
Now, 13 years since it tried to cut through the market with the Jolla Phoneโa device which remarkably received software updates through 2020โit's back with a successor of the same name.
This time, the company is positioning its handset as the โEuropean phone.โ This bit of marketing caters to the growing distrust in US digital services and platforms that has arisen since Big Tech sidled up to the second Trump administration.
The new Jolla Phone (pronounced โYollaโ) costs โฌ649, mimics the Scandinavian design of the original, and has secured more than 10,000 preorders since its preview in December 2025. Those orders are expected to begin shipping at the end of June. At Mobile World Congress 2026 in Barcelona this week, the company divulged more details about the phone's hardware.
Alt Android
Jolla has had a turbulent history. After the company floundered the launch of its Jolla Tablet in 2015, it nearly went bankrupt and pivoted to licensing Sailfish OS to automotive companies and governments, including Russia. After the invasion of Ukraine, Jolla had to cut ties with Russia, and a corporate restructuring meant that Jolla's assets were acquired by the company's former management under a new company called Jollyboys.
Image may contain Electronics Mobile Phone Phone Computer Hardware Hardware Monitor and Screen
The new Jolla Phone.
Courtesy of Jolla
It got back into the smartphone game in 2024 with the Jolla C2 Community Phone, made in collaboration with a local Turkish company, and it was this experience that gave Jolla the courage to jump back into the hardware business with the new Jolla Phone. Unlike the C2, this device is completely assembled in Salo, Finland, where Nokia phones were manufactured more than a decade ago.
โEuropeans want more European technology,โ Sami Pienimรคki, CEO of Jolla Mobile, tells WIRED. โPeople want to go away from Big Tech, and the other trend is that European people want sovereign techโit makes it possible for our kind of company to have a position in the market.โ
Building a smartphone from scratch was also much harder over a decade ago, but today, Pienimรคki says the operation can be fairly lean without having to โpay too much up-front.โ
The components are sourced from various vendors and countries. The MediaTek Dimensity 7100 5G chip hails from Taiwan; the 50-megapixel main and 13-megapixel ultrawide camera sensors are from Sony; the 8 or 12 GB of RAM is from SK Hynix in South Korea.
โThere are Chinese components as wellโwe are totally open about itโbut the key is that, as we compile the software ourselves and install it in Finland, we protect the integrity of the product,โ Pienimรคki says.
What makes Sailfish OS unique over competitors like GrapheneOS and e/OS is that it's not based on the Android Open Source Project, but Linux. That means it has no ties to Googleโno need for the company to โdeGoogleโ the software; meaning there's a greater sense of sovereignty over the software (and now the hardware). Still, it's able to run Android apps, though the implementation isn't perfect. Another common criticism is that it's not as secure as options like GrapheneOS, where every app is sandboxed.
There's a good chance some Android apps on Sailfish OS will run into issues, which is why in the startup wizard the phone will ask if you want to install services like MicroGโopen source software that can run Google services on devices that don't have the Google Play Store, making it an easier on-ramp for folks coming from traditional smartphones without a technical background. You don't even need to create a Sailfish OS account to use the Jolla Phone.
Jollaโs effort is hardly the first to push the antiโBig Tech narrative. A wave of other hardware and software companies offer a deGoogled experience, whether thatโs Murena from France and its e/OS privacy-friendly operating system or the Canadian GrapheneOS, which just announced a partnership with Motorola. At CES earlier this year, the Swiss company Punkt also teamed up with ApostrophyOS to deploy its software on the new MC03 smartphone. Jolla is following a broader European trend of reducing reliance on US companies, like how French officials ditched Zoom for French-made video conference software earlier this year.
Murena CEO and founder Gaรซl Duval wrote in a statement emailed to WIRED that the company believes it has a different mission from the Jolla Phone as it's trying to bring the existing mobile app ecosystemโminus the permanent data collection by Google and third-party trackersโwithout a learning curve for the average person. โWe want to make privacy possible for the everyday person without the need for technical expertise or a development background,โ he says.
The Phone
A common problem with these niche smartphones is that they inevitably end up costing a lot of money for the specs. Take the Light Phone III, for example, a fairly low-tech anti-smartphone that doesn't enjoy the benefits of economies of scale, resulting in an outlandish $699 price. The Jolla Phone is in a similar boat, though the specs-to-value ratio is a little more respectable.
It's powered by a midrange MediaTek Dimensity 7100 5G chip with 8 GB of RAM, 256 GB of storage, plus a microSD card slot and dual-SIM tray. There's a 6.36-inch 1080p AMOLED screen, the two main cameras, and a 32-megapixel selfie shooter. The 5,500-mAh battery cell is fairly large considering the phone's size, though the phone's connectivity is a little dated, stuck with Wi-Fi 6 and Bluetooth 5.4.
Uniquely, the Jolla Phone brings back โThe Other Halfโ functional rear covers from the original. These swappable back covers have pogo pins that interface with the phone, allowing people to create unique accessories like a second display on the back of the phone or even a keyboard attachment. There's an Innovation Program where the community can cocreate functional covers together and 3D-print them. And yes, a removable rear cover means the Jolla Phone's battery is user-replaceable.
Pienimรคki says that while the device doesn't have FCC approval, you can theoretically import it into the US, and it should work with the major US carriers, though compatibility is rarely a given. Jolla is considering a separate US launch, though right now it's focusing on the European Union, the UK, Norway, and Switzerland.
Antti Saarnio, Jolla Groupโs chairperson, reiterates that the Jolla Phone will be a niche product. โMost of the people using Android or iOS will not switch, but we should treat this as a stepping stone for something new,โ Saarnio says. The โpath to real volumeโ will come from the mobile market breaking down into new form factors, powered by artificial intelligence.
He's likely referring to Jolla's Mind2, a privacy-focused AI computer, which is still in active development. It plugs into a PC and connects Jolla's AI assistant to apps like email and calendar locallyโno cloud access required. The chatbot-like interface lets you ask it questions about your data, whether you're fishing for something from an email or a private message. While the new Jolla Phone won't have any AI capabilities at launch, Saarnio says an integration will be an option users can enable later this year.
Jolla has street cred for supporting its devices for a long time, but we'll have to wait and see how the fresh hardware holds up and just how much the company has polished the Sailfish OS experience, especially since it's much easier today to get started with a deGoogled Android alternative.
and a 32-megapixel selfie shooter
Do the people who want a Linux phone that isn't Android, also want a selfie camera? Those 2 things don't seem to go together.
the new Jolla Phone wonโt have any AI capabilities at launch, Saarnio says an integration will be an option users can enable later this year.
Again, Linux and LLM?
I personally don't like the phones/software targeting the privacy-demographic, because of all the pro-crypto and LLM stuff. Anyone have suggestions for phones for people who care about privacy, but care more about ethics? So no: LLMs, crypto, Russia/Chine/USA components?
Do the people who want a Linux phone that isnโt Android, also want a selfie camera? Those 2 things donโt seem to go together.
Yeah, I want to be able to have a video call with my family that doesn't look like ass. I'd also like to be able to attend meet/zoom calls without being called out for using a potato.
the new Jolla Phone wonโt have any AI capabilities at launch, Saarnio says an integration will be an option users can enable later this year.
Less so, but then again, if I'm in control of my data, getting a on-device speech to text for a conversation would be good, if I could use the hardware to fuel a swipe text model, that would be net positive.
Selfie cam: oh.
Personally I've never seen the advantage of my or others' faces in calls/conference-calls.
LLMs: are there open-source ones, not built from stolen text?
Don't think LLM, think specific training data. instead of tapping out T H I S, you press down at the T, swipe over to the h, up to the I and left to the S then release.
The NPU takes that squiggle you just made and runs it against a model that's been trained on tens or hundreds of thousands of squiggles to deciper the word you just swiped. It's not trained on books, or the whole of humanity and the internet, it's just trained on the keyboard app you're using and other people who have used it. if they swipe and keep going, the word was right and the squiggle counts, if they went back and corrected the text, that's the answer for the squiggle.
There are all kinds of AI things out there that aren't LLM based.
Will the Android Signal client work on it, or does getting one involve forfeiting any means of communication with people who donโt know what a XMPP server is?
There is an unofficial native client for Signal called Whisperfish.
I think their refusal to allow third-party clients but also only maintain the official one for select few platforms is one of the things that is a big fat minus for Signal
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HzCMKbhK-EY
Pity about the pay-walled factory reset and the closed source software they use like drivers, homescreen UI, the compositor, some QML components and the Android compatibility layer
It wouldn't bother me so much if they weren't specifically positioning themselves as privacy and FOSS advocates
What. What do you mean pay-walled factory reset?!
Jolla crowdsourced a tablet in 2014, blew by their initial goal, then delayed and delayed and eventually canceled the project claiming they would try to offer refunds. They refunded half of the contributions of most of the backers and then pocketed the other half, over $1M. I don't know if their new phone is anti-big-tech or not, and I'm all for alternatives to Android and iOS, but this is not a company I can trust.
Anyone have experience with these? Specifically looking for how "drop in and replace" it is compared to GrapheneOS.
I'd love to give it a shot, but i worry a bunch of my daily use apps won't work. I'm working to replace a bunch of the more big tech ones (Spotify, Audible, etc), but would also need to be sure Signal and HomeAssistant work seamlessly.
Jolla has something called AppSupport in their SailfishOS that this phone uses. AppSupport seems to make it possible to run Android apps directly in Linux, without the need of Waydroid. This allows for a more pleasant experience where you don't have to open Waydroid first before using an Android app. You can access them directly in the SailfishOS app drawer I think.
I have outdated experience. I loved their first generation device back in 2014. It was again a bit expensive compared to its specs, but I loved its UI and multitasking way of working.
Eventually I switched to an Android device mainly because my banking and communication depended on it. Now there are even more tightly coupled. So maybe in the future I'll go with two devices: one low end Android for official biz that maybe stays in a drawer, and a good Linux phone.
Will it run my bank apps? That's all I care about, really.
It's a bit hit and miss. Some work, some don't. There's a topic about it on the Sailfish forums.
I hope it wonโt run bank apps. When my bank tries to shut down their website and force me onto a smartphone (which is inherently not a smart move for privacy and security), I want to be able to show them that their app wonโt run on my linux phone so there is pressure to keep the website running.
Fuck phone banking. Letโs have some separation of church and state.
boot lickers who want to run corporate spyware โ Android or iOS
freedom seekers who want to keep their dignity and autonomy โ linux
Worth noting that banks deliberately block alternative platforms. Some detect whether they are running in an emulator and refuse to run. And โemulatorโ is very loose. I saw a bank app refuse to run on a laptop that natively ran Android.
So, is the Jolla phone with Sailfish OS better than a Fairphone with /e/OS?
If it's closed source it is not anti-big tech
am statesian. should i be pronuncing this holla (with a rolled l) or yoya or jola or i'm sure i can think up something to make the linguists on here scream like ghรธghษ
So, as an American (unfortunately) is there a way to get one of these?
Honestly wish somebody would go for a nokia style form factor. with signal protocol integration, rcs, usb c and beefy battery, maybe 5g?!, performant processor, custom os/NOT ANDROID its so ugly on smaller screen sizes also not performant, also some really fun apps like: email, rss reader, web radio, tetris, also a compass, and a keychain hole, and a 100โฌ price tag.
Google will not spy on you and most of the code is open source. I'm not sure if it has been audited.
โฌ700 for a phone??? Am I a joke to you?
you say that like apple hasn't trained everyone to get used to a 1200 euro bi-annual upgrade cycle
The most I've payed for a phone has been 350 โฌ. Alternatives to the current duopoly must exist and I am glad they are getting more recognition, but this would still be double of what I am willing to pay; like, I earn 1,151 โฌ a month, so 700 is the better part of my salary.
There's an argument to be made that this is a reasonable price, and that much cheaper phones should be treated with high suspicion.
I mean, if they don't rob your data, they have to get money somewhere and they are also making you pay for the OS i guess
They are manufacturing a limited run. It's normal for prices to be higher.
Buy a pixel phone(2nd hand) and install Graphene OS
hardware is compromised. OS cant change that.
first youll have to give me your cellphone number, date of birth, email account, access to all your pictures, videos, contacts, call history, text messages, app data, biometric data, location, search history, IP address, and tell me which one of these pictures has a car in it, so we can train our Artificial intelli........i mean....make sure you are human........and while your at it......give me them cookies, too.
top 90 comments