Any non Google phone running graphene would be epic.
post
Volla phone (has choice between ubuntu touch and android rom) seems pretty cool.
Thanks for the reality check. While this a good development, I share your concern and we should not stop,or even slow, developing any fully free as in freedom OS. I tried PostmarketOS on an old Oneplus 6T recently and I estimate we have one or two more phone replacement cycles until I think it'll be ready for me to switch.
I have a 6T and was thinking about getting postmarketos on it, what didn't work for you? Which "desktop" did you choose for it? there's like 5 options for that and I really have no idea what to do.
I used KDE because that's what I use on desktop. I hear some of the others are further along. Flashing was easy. I could not set up my SMB shares in dolphin and if it wont talk to my NAS, it's not terribly useful to me. I will play around some more with it sooner or later. I believe I used Android- tools on Linux to send the partitions via fastboot commands. It was a 2 gen old phone for me (had the OP9 after it) so I wasn't worried about anything going wrong. Feel free to shoot me a DM if you get stuck and have a specific question. I will try to help.
They spotted an opportunity
Good. Now if only they could make the Edge+ with the same relative spec sheet and ditch the curved glass in 2027. I'd buy it in a heartbeat for Graphene. My next phone WAS going to be a Pixel for the broader case/screen protector support, but that would make me reconsider cause I would really miss the chop chop flashlight.
Chop chop flashlight?
Motorola phones have a feature that allows you to "chop" with your phone twice to turn on/off the flashlight. It sounds super mundane, but it is way more convenient than you can imagine. Especially for me as an athletic trainer when I'm testing pupil response during a concussion evaluation. They also allow you to twist your phone twice to open the camera, but I don't find that as convenient since double tapping the lock button also works.
That's pretty cool. Did you ever find it activating accidentally?
No. You have to be pretty deliberate about it. Honestly, its pretty impressive how well tuned it is.
Now I need to try it somehow
Just tried it on my razr, had no idea it was a thing but that's not surprising given I don't really set up accessibility features on my phones. You do have to be quite forceful with it, kind of whipping it back once at the end of a swing. Neat.
If you have tasker on Android or GOS there's a download for it called 'chop to flashlight' and can adjust the sensitivity so it doesn't turn on in your pocket or bag.
maybe my next phone will be a Motorola.
My last few phones have been Motorolas and I've been very very happy with them.
My only issue was that back then, I wasn't really paying attention to alternative OSs like Graphene, Lineage or e/os and was therefore not really too concerned with ROM support/chip set. When I switched over to e/os, two of my Motorola's (including the one I WANT to use with it) has no ROM support because it's running a Mediatek chipset. So I'm using my second to last one while my nice new one collects dust.
Moving forward I'll be paying more attention to Qualcomm vs Mediatek.
Me too. I've always bought Google Pixels but I don't want to give Google my money anymore.
So I'll probably buy a Motorola if this deal gets through.
Me too. I’ve always bought Google Pixels but I don’t want to give Google my money anymore.
what about used?
What phone do you use now?
I'm on a Google Pixel 9A.
But at least I didn't pay for it, Google paid me, thanks to a clever mix of a big 9A launch discount, a trade-in discount and the fact that the older Pixel I traded in had already been partially refunded because of the infamous battery problems.
i bought a mororolla 3 years ago and it still lasts 2 days on a charge. id say go for it.
If I can get GrapheneOS + headphone jack + SD card slot, I am in.
I'd add "less than 15cm tall" too. I've had enough of stupid giant phones that don't fit in pockets and where you can't even reach the top or other side with your thumb.
SD slot would be great. Fuck every major company getting rid of it, so you have to use their cloud provider.
Let's see if it gets released before GrapheneOS and unlockable bootloader get outlawed
I am sure they are also seeing a growing demand for more privacy, the only reason own a pixel is because of GrapheneOS. If I could buy a phone with the OS pre installed I would, don't know if they are going to do that. Also, by patterning with GrapheneOS they don't has the development cost and they can trade on Graphenes name
I actually bought a new Motorola phone 2 months ago precisely because i wanted a phone with an unlockable bootloader, and motorola delivered that.
Vote with your wallet.
Just wanted to echo the vote with your wallet sentiment. It’s the only power we have!
I once bought a Motorola one phone because it would have quick and lengthy updates. Motorola certainly didn't provide that.
Other than that it was a decent phone.
I have used Motorola for the last 5 years or so. They had superior battery life compared to the others and were inexpensive. I bought my last one for like 40 bucks on clearance. I won't spend more than 100 bucks plus tax on a phone anymore. I use minimal apps, don't take lots of pictures with it, mostly text and make phone calls on it. I don't keep social media apps on it nor restaurant apps. I mostly use the Maps, the Notes, and the browser applications. I don't like the android/google calendar interface but will use reminders/tasks. I also use book/reading/podcast apps (Librivox, Podbean, Kindle, and another one...). I had overly invested in Kindle years ago unfortunately. I don't really watch video on the phone as it is too small, but have YT music on it. I could use advice for alternatives that are better.
Something like that is what I've been waiting for a long time for. Really looking forward to it.
But how are they going to include useless "uninstallable" apps and advertisements?
Grapheneos is a pretty attractive selling point for a phone. They could even make money the old fashioned way: by selling phones.
Probably they will not support it for budget phones
which is fine, I mean, you'd want decent specs + a secure OS in this day and age
Not everyone want one tho, i saw people saying that they use 200€ motorola phones, tbh i am using a 230€ tablet and it's fine for normal tasks and drawing
yeah, I was looking at the Moto G15 for my next phone, but with this news, I'm considering waiting a little longer for a better OS
I'm on a second generation of Motorola phones. I gave them a shot with the 2020 g power and upgraded to the 2023 edge+. The g power was fine for about 2 years but then I really began to feel the brunt of having such a underperforming chipset. I'd definitely suggest getting something that's more in the midrange price bracket given my experience. My advice so take it or leave it.
You don't need high specs these days. I was looking at the Moto G 2024, because it's the latest version to support Lineage OS, and it has a Snapdragon 4 Gen 1, I think it is, which is actually just slightly better than my OnePlus Nord N200 on Geekbench, which is fine.
The main difference is that my OnePlus Nord N200 was released in 2021, and it has a lower geekbench score than the Moto G 2024, which was released in 2024, with a lower-end chip. But my OnePlus cost $300, where the G24 was released at $200, and is now available for $130.
So at its release, I would have gotten more storage and a better CPU for $100 less, and now it would be $170 less.
I have one. It's honestly not bad. The only thing it could use is 8GB RAM and not 4. Otherwise it's perfectly good for my uses. Seems quick enough, has a jack, etc.
What I do when I'm shopping for a new phone is go to the LineageOS download site and look at what the mid-range devices are available for each of the OEMs and then make my choice from that list. Otherwise, the Moto G 2024 probably wouldn't have crossed my radar screen. A couple of years ago I had the Moto 1 5G Ace and thought it was a great device except that the charger port started to give out on it and so I couldn't reliably charge it. That made me realize that at some point I would like a device with wireless charging even if I do primarily use the USB charger so that if the USB port ever breaks I can just charge it wirelessly and not have to give the phone up entirely.
Supposedly the article says that Motorola will be implementing "some" of the features from GrapheneOS in some of their other phones. So whilst not GrapheneOS proper, you still might see some graphenOS like/lite type stuff on budget phones.
Graphene might be marketed towards enterprises first. Look at that leaked slide again: it mentions "bloatware-free interface with Business Edition."
The bigger leak is Motorola acknowledging they ship bloatware, IMO
Ironically I bought a cheap moto g because microslop intune settings where I work do not allow for Graphene os in the attestation check. Only use it when wfh so if I'm away from my desk I don't miss teams calls and look like I'm doing laundry (which I probably am)
Motorola doesn’t have to sell apps. Apps sell themselves. And an App Store that isn’t riddled with crap is appealing to everyone.
I mean, they could still include those on the base model of the phone, but just officially support flashing Graphene for those who want to do it. I am reasonably certain the target markets for pre-installed apps/ads and people who would be interested in flashing Graphene are completely separate groups. Kind of like how a stock Pixel is basically Google/Gemini Spyware, but Thayer doesn't matter to someone who buys one to install Graphene.
a future smartphone to have GrapheneOS pre-installed
I'll not trust Lenovo (Motorola is Lenovo) preinstalling stuff on my phone. They've already ship Windows laptop with literally malware and backdoors (even in UEFI, so persistent across format) preinstalled.
I will rather install it myself.
Fully agree on that. Always better to start fully fresh, even without such problems.
That said, it's still important that it will ship pre-installed. That way app-developers who block GrapheneOS cannot excuse their actions anymore by saying that it was your decision to use another OS, and therefore not their problem.
That's nice, but how much will those phones cost? Will GrapheneOS be an option on the low end devices or will they only support "some" devices, which happen cost as much as a Pixel anyway?
Pixels have hardware documentation and are directly supported by Android, making them possible for the GrapheneOS dev community to support. Good luck doing that on a Samsung.
Motorola is doing good here. Also, buy a used Pixel 8, you'll have almost three years of support left.
That's the thing, even used Pixels are almost twice the price of what I paid for my new phone.
Back when I bought my phone I considered that route. but then since I can't replace the batteries on new phones without risking destroying the device. And there's a big probability that the phone comes with an almost dying battery.
I also understand that GrapheneOS can't be installed on any "unlocked" phone, it needs to be OEM unlocked and most sellers don't know/specify, so ended up considering too expensive and too much of a risk.
I asked Motorola for an OEM unlock code for an Edge 30 Neo and got it straight away. I then installed Lineage OS 22, and the phone is working really well. The total cost is one-third of what a used Pixel 8 would cost.
Pick your poison. Want cheap? Be tracked. Want privacy? Pay the price.
Hey mate, don't need one of the Motorola's, buy a second hand pixel, I've got a 6 and a 10 pro (soon to be converted to GOS now that there are stable builds since it's my daily).
It's a bit of a shock compared to stock android but you'll actually feel like you own and control your phone again (like I do here on the pixel 6), but you'll lose features like the scam block, hold for me etc. that the stock OS does).
The onus becomes on you to keep the device secure, you can do another user profile to install stuff you want separate and it works nicely. It's all sandboxed and asks your consent before giving any permissions to an app, like android used to.
I'll buy if decent specs and price good
I solely need camera, contactless payments and projection for cars. If it is capable of these I am pre ordering.
Contactless payment will not happen under grapheneOS, it relies on google play services and integrity check. Graphene does have sandboxed play services, but it doesn't pass integrity check.
That's not true. Google Pay (or Wallet?) doesn't work on GrapheneOS. NFC and contactless payments work perfectly fine. You can use Curve Pay or in Poland BLIK via bank apps.
Same here, and unfortunately there is no digital wallet providers in my country other than Google Pay, Samsung Pay and Apple Pay.
Projection for cars?
Does GrapheneOS support Google Pay?
It's the other way around. Google specifically blocks Goodlgle Pay being used on GrapheneOS. I believe there's another contactless payment app called Curve or something that works on GrapheneOS. Requires Google Play Services installed though.
No but nfc is present and nfc contactless pay works if your banking app has it native in their app. Curve pay is a good workaround.
Yup, it uses a sandboxed version that you can control.
Edit: Fuck me...it's early and my dyslexic ass read "play" not pay.
top 91 comments