Reddit killed the app I used.
post
Reddit was a death of 1000 cuts.
The strictness of communities. Shadowbans. Intercommunity drama. Overly critical usrers and doomers. Removing the ability to see upvotes/downvotes. Old reddit slowly going away. Api changes.
One day i just found i wasnt having fun on reddit anymore. It was just doomer content rolled into just another social media. I spent 12 years on that platform and l learned a lot. But now its mostly its just clickbait and drama to keep you on.
So i went on lemmy, contributed to the code for a bit. Found i liked piefed because of the better fediverse interop. Stayed here and contributed a tiny bit of code.
It was just doomer content rolled into just another social media.
I hate to tell you this, but you left New York and ended up in New Jersey.
NGL, there's parts of Jersey that are lovely.
I really meant that they left one thing for something very close to what they left
Maybe its because im on piefed now, but my feed is VERY nice and healthy (mentally).
I did. Mostly because at my age and with my shit eyesight, I was looking for something I was familiar with layout wise.
Old lemmy to the rescue! It's nice here, like Reddit was many, many years ago. Small, community-based and not rage-bot driven.
My word, as I look back on how Reddt pivoted in the last 5 years, I really can see it now.
This is really like the nice parts of Jersey. It's lovely compared to the fiasco I left.
Don’t forget the view in app and the constant sign in notifications. Fuck off. You’re a glorified website that should keep ya nose out.
oh god the intercommunity drama. I got banned for one group just for participating in another. Reminds me of middle school when I felt forced to pick between two fighting friends. 🙄
Right now, you cant say meshcore (like the word) in the meshtastic subreddit. You would never know until people started getting randomly banned. LOL sometimes its just want one mod decided for the others.
I just dropped in there to seeif my particular device is having issues and bam more drama.
Was banned permanently from Reddit for correctly identifying a certain South African billionaire's political leanings.
This is why I left. I saw post about people being banned from communities for things like that, or saying eat the rich, iD'ing Nazis, calling Palestine a genocide and calling for action. It was clear they had fascist corporate donors to appease and had chosen sides.
I left reddit when they shut down the 3rd party readers. I don't like ads, and I wasn't willing to compromise and use their shitty app, so I came here and haven't looked back since!
Fuck Spez
Former mod of r/jailbait
Never let him live that down. any time you mention Spez, mention that.
It started as fuck spez, but I've learned the value of opposing homogeneity online and I will never go back.
Reddit killed third party apps with absurd API fees.
I'm a hipster and also anti-capitalist. Tired of dogshit corpo social media enshittification
wow, nobody mentioned the open source thing yet. I'm here because I really like the open source thing and the idea of federated servers run by hobbyists.
I’m very appreciative of this. I want the people in charge here, not billionaires and CEOs.
Yeah, that is a big plus too (that, and the federation). This can hopefully mean that lemmy can never turn into what reddit currently is.
The API shenanigans
Yeah, same, when the apicalypse hit I was gone.
Why "apicalypse" and not "appocalypse"?
I'd been using Reddit for quite some time. I wasn't willing to use it if they weren't going to allow third party clients.
I left Reddit for Lemmy for the same reason I left Digg for Reddit: Enshittification, both technical and administrative.
I got sniped by a bot on Reddit, just two weeks shy of 15 years.
Didn't even ask for the account to be reinstated but got a denial reply nonetheless that claimed it was decided by a "human" (..who obviously could not understand, "..So long and thanks for all the fish.." was a goodbye, and not a "please reconsider.." "Human" responder my foot..).
They also won't let me delete the account.
Obviously its being run with AI now and the bots are doing the moderation and the refusal to delete accounts means they're also ginning the numbers for the investors.
It really went off the rails when the IPO dropped.
Also, they're deprecating the old reddit style and for people like myself with eyesight issues, the new layout is a visual mess.
I found old.lemmy.zip and fell into it and fell in love.
Haven't missed a beat and don't even thnk of Reddit anymore.
Every other post being "Promoted" bullshit, the slow-ass web UI, my former favorite app no longer working, and the bloated and track-y first party app. I was never a fan of "old reddit UI" , so that wasn't a crutch like it was for others.
The API thing. I was using RIF for a very long time at that point and had no intention of using the official Reddit app.
Least fucked option.
Reddit: fucked. Twitter: fucked.. Meta: fucked since forever. Bluesky: signs of future fuckededness. Mastodon: not what I was after.
Lemmy: hey, these people seem to be my kind of insane.
the 3party killstreak. My app got some workarounds later but decided against reddit
Reddit gradually began to suck. Enshittification started to take its toll, but I was protected because I used Old Reddit with a lot of blockers, and I never used the app. Then the API crisis happened, and I thought "Why am I supporting a corporate big-tech platform?" So I left, because a bunch of other people were doing the same.
TLDR: everyone else did everyone who counts did.
Reddit has just been steadily declining in quality the past few years.
The bullshit with the api and 3rd party apps was the start of it for me. I use to love alien blue. Then came the censorship… I’ve gotten two warnings so far within maybe a year of each other about upvoting, not making a comment or a post that would be offensive, inappropriate, or alarming but a fucking up vote. Apparently it violates a Reddit rule. Best part… they won’t even fucking tell me what I upvoted that was so egregious.
That was the final straw for me.
I can help you spoof the API and get your favorite third party app going again, if you really want. I was using RIF up until a few weeks ago. Still works too, I just got banned and decided it wasn't worth it to start over.
why a lot of people migrated here, right? By the way, I like you, I'll follow you :D
I'd been looking for Reddit alternatives for years, but most of them were full of sparse content I wasn't interested in and users who seemed like assholes. Lemmy meets a higher standard, and my interest in gradually moving away from Reddit and supporting others abandoning it has also gotten higher. The decentralized design is also a big plus, gives free network effects to potential new software efforts because they can freely plug into it.
I’d been looking for Reddit alternatives for years, but most of them were full of sparse content I wasn’t interested in and users who seemed like assholes.
Before a lot of people from Reddit came to Lemmy it was the same here.
Reddit was going downhill. Conversations are near impossible. You have to agree with the hive mind or you get down voted into oblivion. The monetization of the platform. The gamification of the platform. The AI bot problem.
There are too many to count. Lemmy is still small, and while it has its own problems, is not completely fucked yet.
You have to agree with the hive mind or you get down voted into oblivion.
Isn't Lemmy the same way though?
Reddit basically banned 3rd party apps to fake a growth and show shareholders they can be profitable... so yeah, they can get fucked.
Reddit killed my favorite app Joey so I, nuked my Reddit account by talking shit about a mod, came here, and never looked back.
It's the same layout/format as Reddit, but with far less bullshit or total fuckheads. When it was announced that Reddit was shutting down 3rd party API access, Lemmy came to my attention and I've been here since (though a couple previous accounts were on instances that have since shut down).
Reddit got rid of my All button because they want to push people into echo chambers and controlled feeds. I only made an account to bitch about the Knicks, let me lurk.
When you browse by all, you see the patterns of subreddits turning political, same recycled posts being passed around, generalizations, things taken out of context, agendas.
By the way this place isn't as different as you'd like to think, just a lot more 'fuck the USA' posts so idk, I'm still searching
To be honest, you will never find a generalized site/service that has many types of niche content like Reddit unless people coalesce to a single platform and the scale allows it.
I think it's fine if you end up finding your niche community on some esoteric website/forum, more power to you. But for a single one-stop collection of niche communities, I think the best way to get there is just to sit tight with Lemmy/Piefed/Mastodon, honestly, because at some point those communities will reach critical mass and be self-sustaining (but not if people don't stick around long enough for it to happen).
Of course also starting/contributing to your niche community speeds things along.
If you find anything, lmk. Lemmy is a fine reddit clone, but it doesn't have enough niche content.
Well, I guess to be completely honest with you guys
I got banned from reddit after 13+ years and over half a million comment karma. Same username if you want to go take a trip.
There was a post in the game collecting sub and the guy, a European, had a MAGA hat in the background. People were going back and forth, as they do. One guy then says that a European having a MAGA hat as a novelty souvenir is fine. To which I responded, Nazis only belong 6 feet under. I was slightly worried that a simpleton may interpret it as a threat, but I figured there's no way someone with common sense and critical thinking skills would think that.
Well, of course this one hit a little close to home to the admins, big surprise, and I was permanently banned. 13 years and 500,000 points later, I get banned for saying nazis deserve to be dead.
Honestly, I'm not surprised given how the site was going. Posts being removed, comments being deleted. That used to happen back in the day but never to the degree that it is happening now.
My only chuckle on the way out is knowing I modified the reddit API to use third party apps long after they were shut down.
I do wish this place was a bit more active, but it's still pretty good. It's not like I don't have alts on reddit anyway. My only regret was not selling my account for a ton of money before it got banned. Oh well lol
My story is similar to yours, though I just got a warning, not a ban.
The first warning was for "abusing the report function" after I reported a post defending Derek Chauvin. I stopped reporting to the admins after that, and over time grew increasingly uneasy with the direction of Reddit as a more and more fascist-friendly organization, and the willing and eager contribution of Reddit's CEO to millions of Covid deaths left a sour taste (and a nasty cough).
I got the second warning about a week ago after I joked the US government should go into the White House and Melania's lover's residence to arrest them since Trump pardoned a drug dealer, by the same reasoning the US government used to abduct Maduro and his wife. This was "threatening violence." That was the last straw, I quit Reddit after that.
It's not even that I mind them erring on the side of caution, or in this case on the side of insanity, it's the double standard that irks me the most. An obvious joke goes too far, but in certain subreddits (you know the ones) users can advocate ethnic cleansing, war crimes, etc. with reckless abandon.
That's a great story, honestly, 13 years?! That's already an exaggeration based on a simple comment. I came here looking for a safe space, where you're not criticized for not following a certain trend
Yep, that's also one of the reasons I came here. This feels like old reddit. I like the plethora of apps that are fully customizable, also like the old days of reddit. It really was a great time until it wasn't. This community is much more open. Transparency here is a wonderful thing, something that reddit lost a long time ago.
reddit's api drove people here to the point where conversation could happen. Was willing to go anywhere that didn't have mods that protect and coddle nazis.
I got banned from Reddit for quoting Worf from Star Trek.
I came here because I wanted to run some communities, but ultimately it was impossible on Reddit. All the names are taken, all the aging mod teams set in stone. You essentially have no meaningful opportunity to build anything new on there. In contrast, and especially with federation, the Fediverse is a completely different system. A fresh start - still after 2 years. And it has way better internal advertisement of communities than Reddit does.
And to be clear, on Reddit you can easily just shout into the wilderness at no-one. Big audience means you can get drowned out.
top 100 comments