This is the fediverse, so this is probably going to be extremely unpopular, but yea here goes.

Not saying you have to love it, or trust it blindly. Skepticism is healthy. But there’s a difference between “I use it carefully and check everything” and “I refuse to touch it.”

Historically, refusing new tools has never stopped them. Coopers didn’t stop the steel drum by refsuing to make them. They just ended up out of work while the industry moved on.

The realistic threat isn’t AI replacing you. It’s a colleague who uses AI well doing your job faster. And the skill of using it properly (knowing when it’s wrong, veriyfing output, knowing what not to use it for) takes time to build. Starting late means competing with people who’ve had years of practice.

You can have legit concenrs about ethics, energy, or jobs and still learn the tool. Opting out doesn’t fix those problems. It just removes you from the people who get a say in how it’s used.

PS. Ethically trained models exist and you can run models locally.

top 100 comments

sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[–] 159 points 15 hours ago (2 children)

YSK that the Luddites were not anti-progress or anti-technology. They were an early labor movement opposed to the sweeping social changes brought about by industrialization and capitalism. Just like most anti-AI, they were the very people who worked with, and best understood the machines.

The Luddite's reputation as dumb people who hate the future is 100% capital propaganda that's credulously slipped into history. I think it's ironic that you frame AI as "the future" when your argument is the same song they've been singing for two centuries.

People will decide how things go. How AI will develop isn't a force of nature, it's a choice that people will make. Believing AI is inevitable is a marketing strategy by the people who don't want you or me to have any say in the matter.

  • source
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 23 points 13 hours ago

    Completely agree on how Luddites have been misrepresented, and how there are tons of similarities between the industrial revolution and what we are going through now with ai.

    That's why I wouldn't compare ai "haters" to Luddites.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 31 points 14 hours ago* (last edited 14 hours ago) (2 children)

    Eh, it’s going to be a dumb tool like the internet.

    In the dot com bubble, everyone thought the web would replace stores, offices, everything. If you didn’t go all-in, you were already obsolete. Back then, there were also people vehemently against it (though not quite with the scale of the Tech Oligarchs today).

    LLMs are the same.

    It’s going to land in a boring middle ground between the doomers, haters, and glazers, and it will take some time to evolve (like the web did). It’s changing the world, but not that much. People who didn’t go all in will be fine, though those who abstain are perhaps not in an ideal position, as you’d be if you were a business refusing to use the internet today.

    …It will do some great damage, but that’s from the irresponsible tech bros we’ve handed power to. Attributing the damage to LLMs is absolving these people of culpability. The “AI” doesn’t do anything, people do.


    Also, you cannot separate the open models people theoretically can use from what the vast majority uses: Anthropic, OpenAI, CoPilot, Gemini. Or even the questionably ethical Deepseek, GLM, Mistral, GigaChat (the Russian LLM), or whatever APIs. Though I do think Nemotron API is cleaner than average, and gets a good bit of business usage.

    It’d be like arguing social media is healthy because the Fediverse exists. Yeah… theoretically, it’s maybe less bad. You could make the same argument about how crypto would be great if we lived in perfect society.

    And just FYI you don’t have to sell me on local machine learning. I’ve been running LLMs before Llama 1, GANs before that, I have MiMo loaded pretty much all the time. I think they’re neat, and useful. But I still think people who try to abstain from LLMs are acting reasonably, given the state of things.


    I do think the hate should be focused on a more useful problem: the corrosiveness of people like Musk, Altman, Elon, Sundar, and such. And the dystopia they’re advocating for. They are trying to shift culpability off themselves.

  • source
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 9 points 13 hours ago (1 child)

    Also, you cannot separate the open models people theoretically can use from what the vast majority uses:

    I'll just add that because a model is "open" doesn't mean it's "ethical".

    Many of these open models that you can use locally are still trained on stolen data and represent an exploitation of other people's intellectual labor.

    Whether that is problematic or "fair use" (legally and ethically) I think depends entirely on the specific use case.

    But there no question to me that people who are using generative AI to slop out some "content" in the hopes of making a quick buck in the short term are acting in a way that is bad for society and culture. We don't need more low-effort junk.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 1 point 12 hours ago* (last edited 12 hours ago)

    People who are using generative AI to slop out some “content” in the hopes of making a quick buck in the short term are acting in a way that is bad for society and culture.

    Then hold them responsible. And the entities that enable it, responsible.

    Imagine you went to a cybersecurity conference years ago, and loudly announced to the floor “Hey! My automated Go script hacked Chase Bank, and I don’t really know how because I used this Google subscription thing to do it, it just did! WOW, Go is so dangerous, but isn’t this subscription thing I used revolutionary?”

    If this was a commercial LLM today, the response be to… praise and fund the hacker, hype Google’s stock price, and make noise about scripting languages being existential threats to humanity??? And Chase’s lawyers would sit on their hands???

    It makes no sense. In any sane world, the hacker would get laughed out, arrested, and the user interface promoting irresponsible usage of a tool would be investigated or sued. Yet somehow the world has bought the narrative of blaming the deeper tool, instead of the people selling it or the user abusing it.


    The reason we don’t is that very rich Tech Companies were already pushing slop for profit before LLMs, and they don’t want to disrupt that.

    Hence what I’m arguing is that people are angry at the wrong target. If one hates slop, if someone hates all this irresponsibility and enshittification, that anger should be more precisely targeted.


    EDIT: And yep, your point about training data is right, especially about the context of usage.

    A few models are better about this (Nemotron, for example), but the vast majority in use aren’t.

    Personally I think the whole IP system is screwed up, but that’s not a great excuse.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 89 points 15 hours ago (14 children)

    ethically trained models

    gonna need a big source there buddy

  • source
  • hideshow 14 child comments
  • [–] [S] 6 points 15 hours ago (11 children)

    Comma v0.1 was trained only on public domain and openly licensed text and performs about as well as Llama 2-7B:

    https://arxiv.org/abs/2506.05209

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 11 child comments
  • [–] 9 points 15 hours ago (10 children)

    and how well does Llama2 function against “frontier” models?

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 10 child comments
  • [–] 6 points 13 hours ago (3 children)

    Do you need a frontier model? There is an extreme amount of community around Llama and it works very well.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 3 child comments
  • [–] 7 points 14 hours ago (2 children)
  • [–] [S] 1 point 15 hours ago (5 children)

    Depends on the model, but that's not my point.

    You can even train your own, or the "Ethical" models might get a lot better in the near future.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 5 child comments
  • [–] 6 points 14 hours ago (4 children)

    Yeah. you can “train ethical models”. but are they useful. im not defending AI here. Just saying - “full open source” llama is wildly behind “closed source frontier models”.

    No point training something that turns out useless.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 4 child comments
  • [–] [S] 3 points 14 hours ago (3 children)

    Then don't use them, use a open weight model. The are very capable and can be run locally or on a rented server.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 3 child comments
  • [–] 0 points 14 hours ago (2 children)

    What? that wasnt my point. Stay on topic, why are you going off on some random tangent?

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 1 point 9 hours ago

    You... Uhh... Kind of don't have a point is the problem. Your dancing around a kind of vagary which means any response to you is going to appear off topic.

    Convey a defineable point, topic and logic and people will be able to debate or converse with you about it.

    Doing what ever it is here your doing is only going to result in people fumbling in the dark trying to meet you half way to nowhere.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 26 points 10 hours ago (4 children)

    It’s a colleague who uses AI well doing your job faster

    My professional experience so far has been that "faster" doesn't actually work unless you abandon the whole concept of responsibility entirely and just blindly trust the AI. Writing code has never been the long tail of software engineering. It has always been code review, software management and debugging, and so far AI has actually made that significantly slower in my experience.

    Just this week my colleague and I pointed out a very laughably obvious flaw in a "true believer's" code, and he just... argued about it, not because the AI can't be wrong, but because of the implication of him submitting code he clearly did not understand. So far, that's the norm, not the exception.

    Obviously it's not going anywhere, but the pendulum is so far past the equilibrium it's going to settle into eventually, that the loudest evangelists might as well just be wrong.

  • source
  • hideshow 4 child comments
  • [+] [S] -7 points 9 hours ago (3 children)

    This all or nothing extreems aren't reality.

    You can have AI help you add unit-tests you wouldn't have thought of.

    Once you are "Done" writing tests, and can't think of more scenarios, AI more often than not can. And can help you add better test coverage.

    I've heard many people say this, what is the downside here?

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 3 child comments
  • [–] 11 points 9 hours ago (2 children)

    A unit test you don't understand is worse than useless.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] [S] -1 points 9 hours ago* (1 child)

    Then read the extra tests it came up with and make sure you understand it.

    It catches things like a null check you might have forgotten, trivially easy to understand.

    You don't even have to have it write any tests if you want, you can ask it "what Unit-Test scenarios did I miss?" And write them yourself.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 3 points 8 hours ago*

    That last scenario is the correct usage IMO, and largely how I've been using it. However, in my experience the actual result in actual organizations is that every software engineering taboo just falls to some combination of ego, laziness, and whip cracking, one by one, until something gets properly fucked, and only then are strict rules established.

    My major beef is that it is too tempting to abuse it, and the abuse inevitably becomes too voluminous to properly inspect, and something inevitably breaks. The same thing happens with humans, but humans moving at human speed make it exponentially easier for humans to comprehend. For bullshit slopware, code nobody actually has time to understand is honestly fine, but for serious systems it is absolutely not ok.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 70 points 14 hours ago (2 children)

    Fall behind what? The race to slopify every product or the one to destroy the earth the fastest?

  • source
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 24 points 15 hours ago (10 children)

    the amount of people I know that are way more successful than me despite of refusing to use email make me somewhat optimistic

  • source
  • hideshow 10 child comments
  • [+] [S] -11 points 14 hours ago (9 children)
  • [–] 11 points 13 hours ago (7 children)

    You already can't seem to read properly...

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 7 child comments
  • [–] 6 points 12 hours ago (4 children)

    To be fair they didn't really write the sentence properly.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 4 child comments
  • [–] 5 points 11 hours ago (3 children)

    sorry, I'm not a native

    could you explain the error please?

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 3 child comments
  • [–] 3 points 7 hours ago

    Apart from what the other person said, the wording makes it ambiguous whether you or the people you know are the ones who refuse to use email. That could be inferred from context but you could have made it explicit, maybe by phrasing it as "their refusal to use email" or similar.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 3 points 11 hours ago* (1 child)

    The word "of" doesn't belong there. Just drop it and the sentence is grammatical. Alternatively, change "despite of" to "in spite of".

    Also the sentence was perfectly clear to a native speaker who actually read all the words, just kind of awkward.

    Maybe they are just referring to the lack of punctuation and capitalization, but that's also common in informal communication such as social media comments from native speakers as well.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 17 points 14 hours ago (1 child)

    This isn't an unpopular opinion. This is a woefully common talking point.

  • source
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 34 points 15 hours ago* (7 children)

    I gotta say there isn't really much of a skill to modern LLMs, they are fairly easy to start using. The most difficult part is actually with how to not over-rely on them. Maybe I'm biased because I've been (cautiously) using local LLMs for boilerplate writing since like 2023, but to me the concept of "write english text, get code back" is about as simple as it gets for a tool.

  • source
  • hideshow 7 child comments
  • [–] 18 points 14 hours ago (2 children)

    Yeah its like a moderately and situationaly useful tool that has a lower barrier to entry than just about anything else in tech. Everything looks like a nail when all you have is a hammer and all that. The problem is people insisting that it is more than what it is because they have bought into the marketing hype and the very nature of the tool means its output is always plausible. Not everyone needs a hammer to do their job.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 9 points 14 hours ago (2 children)

    Disagree.

    Getting it to write code, or an email or something is easy.

    Getting it to do anything as good or better than I can is fucking impossible.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] -1 points 13 hours ago (1 child)

    You're overusing it then. It's not supposed to "do anything as good as you". It is supposed to fill in the trivial stuff (boilerplate/single-function implementation/etc), that you know exactly how to write but would take you a half hour, but in 30 seconds instead.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 0 points 9 hours ago

    Overuse is highly subjective.

    Most code IS boilerplate, once you break it down.
    The machine is great at holding context, so it’s excellent at things like root-cause analysis from crash logs, better than I am, really.

    So it has different strengths, and it should, in theory be as good as I am at code. But that has not been my experience.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 1 point 10 hours ago

    This. All the most zealous true believers I work with have accomplished is enacting new policies about how AI can be used, because they inevitably fuck something up with it. This past year the number of bugs shipped actually doubled, and when you look at productivity metrics which consider this, those engineers are the least productive in our unit.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 57 points 13 hours ago* (last edited 12 hours ago)

    Ridiculous and false. "Falling behind" is bullshit FOMO bait that doesn't really reflect how things work.

    First off, as someone approaching 40, I learned how to use a computer multiple decades after the computer was invented. And as someone who learned to program in the 2010s, I was able to learn C++ 25 years after it came around. Despite all that, I work as a programmer today. It's never too late to learn a genuinely useful skill.

    Second, "using AI" is not some kind of trade or skill that needs to be honed, like painting, playing a musical instrument, or speaking a foreign language. Rather it is a substitute for skill, and a replacement for thoughtful execution. It doesn't take years of dedicated practice or specialized knowledge to learn how to skip steps and cut corners. Anyone competent who wants to "learn to prompt" can do so in a day.

    If anything, people who use the computer to think and work for them are arguably paying for it in ways that we aren't fully aware of yet...

    What happens when you skip leg day at the gym? Your legs get weaker! Likewise, there are already studies that show that offloading thoughtful tasks to AI is bad for your brain and decreases you mental skills.

    The realistic threat isn’t AI replacing you. It’s a colleague who uses AI well doing your job faster.

    If your work can be delegated to AI, then why would someone hire you to do it at all? If I were your boss I would cut out the middle man and use AI to do the work myself.

    And maybe you're thinking "but the AI isn't good enough to do my job well!"

    Maybe so. But that hasn't stopped other people's bosses from trying to replace them, has it?

    The goal of a company is to make the most profit for its owners, right? Capitalism 101. It does so by maximizing its revenue and minimizing its costs.

    You are a cost. And so if it is cheaper to pay for tokens than it is to pay for man hours than we are ALL equally replaceable, especially by lazy and stupid management who have no eye for quality, artistry, thoughtfulness, etc.

    All of our higher ups are just one stupid decision away from deciding that they can do everything with AI instead of having a team of people.

    And that is a big problem for society...

    You can have legit concenrs about ethics, energy, or jobs and still learn the tool. Opting out doesn’t fix those problems. It just removes you from the people who get a say in how it’s used.

    If you "have legit concerns about" the ethics of something, but continue to do it, what kind of person does that make you? A hypocrite at best.

    In my view, today's generative AI industry is built on a brazen and unprecedented exploitation of other people's stolen labor at a scale not seen since slavery. And you don't need to take me at my word on that.

    When I see people make stupid Ghibli slop, I don't see it as harmless or cute in the slightest. I can only think about artists like Hayao Miyazaki, Kazuo Oga, Hideaki Anno, and so many countless other people whose work and vision I respect who have been ripped off and have had their life's work thrown into some silicon valley corporate tech dweeb meat grinder without so much as basic consent.

    As such, how could I possibly use it in good faith without betraying my values?

    I'll have no part in that. It's unworthy of dignity or respect, and I am if nothing else a proud person. If that's the future of society, I'll opt out.

    PS. Ethically trained models exist

    Please name some. I have searched quite a bit and have only found 1 model that seems to be ethically trained.

  • source
  • [–] 54 points 13 hours ago (2 children)

    People that use AI are the ones falling behind.

    Losing the ability to think for themselves, losing the ability to create. Its sad

  • source
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 16 points 12 hours ago* (last edited 12 hours ago) (1 child)

    Yeah, it's like saying "Using Pervitin for sports will cause you being left behind. People who use it will be faster than you."

    This argument falls apart when you consider the extreme athropy of skills, cognitive thinking and general frustration threshold. It is making you unable to work without the tool, and dependant on it.

    And the tool does not make any financial sense, and is literally billions of revenue in debt. And once the honeymoon phase ends, and they will have to figure out how to actually start making money, you and your company, will be priced out of all your "new and faster skills", while anyone who avoided it will be waaay better than you for the jobs that are left.

    I'm pretty certain that only the megacorporates like Meta or Google will be able to keep using AI native workflows. Your startup the semi-sucesfull web dev company you work at will not be able to afford it.

    The end of this fiscal year is going to be great, once every company sees their AI bill and yearly result. Looking forward to it, I expect a lot of posts about "our AI spending is limited, what do I do".

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 0 points 9 hours ago

    It's unlikely people will be priced out of it. Not in any meaningful way. That logic shows a misunderstanding or ignorance of the current landscape.

    One of the biggest unspoken problems is the good enough effect.

    Local and mod scale models that can run efficiently and meet or exceed the needed utility level for most small to medium applications is basically here right now.

    Which undercuts the big companies entire business model to some degree.

    At current pace, a skilled developer can use the existing models to do real work. While your avg person with no skill can only really do very small scope things or generate slop.

    But if those models keep at pace then larger and larger workloads keep falling past the good enough line. Each time that happens the entire business model of the big ai companies becomes more and more shaky.

    Open weight models by their design undercut the very value and service the big companies are selling.

    The same thing happened in game hosting on a smaller scale. You had dedicated small companies early for huge premiums.

    But then as the software got better, more efficient faster, you stopped needing specialty technology a lot of compute. And you could start hosting it on your own computer or a small server. At that point it became more efficient to sell cheaper and in bulk than it was to sell a specialty good.

    All those early movers in the market died out basically overnight and then all that was left were the small bulk sellers and self-hosters.

    If openweight models keep at their pace, there is a legitimate chance that it's going to be cheaper to buy a bunch of old server racks and cheap older gpus in a generation or two to run models at a fraction of the cost instead of paying these big companies.

    The only thing these big companies could then sell is management in other services around it. Which is still a fraction of the value and profit of what they're doing now which still is going to collapse their entire business model.

    Lot of people seem to be acting like gpus are just never going to get any faster as well. And a faster GPU into more efficient GPU means that models go farther and farther.

    A lot of the value right now comes from the simple fact that really only one generation maybe too. Arguably worth of GPUs are even viable for this sort of work.

    And two or three generations of gpus. We're going to see speeds and efficiency. Make what we're doing now seem kind of quaint.

    Yeah the models will be bigger than and more bulky and need that more compute. But again the only thing that matters is the good enough line.

    If you could run anthropics mythos class frontier b******* on $1,000 server that you're leaving in your little small business is closet. Then even if they never got any better at all from what they are right now.

    We have passed the good enough line.

    The entire industry is self-cannibalizing and and basically living in a pretend world as if technology is never going to advance. In everyone seems to be in the same delusion. The haters most of all seem to be forgetting technology advances and improves with time.

    And that means that these companies can't keep doing what they're doing because what they're doing requires technology to stop advancing and it's not going to stop.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 26 points 8 hours ago

    Fall behind in what, exactly? What skill am I not developing by not using it? What do you mean by "learn the tool"? The entire purpose is that there's absolutely nothing to using it. If I hypothetically decided to stop washing my clothes by hand and use a washing machine for the first time today, would I really be meaningfully worse than someone who's used one their whole life? I'm aware there are little tricks to getting better results out of it, but honestly I think it's mostly diminishing returns. AI, that is. Though the same could be said about washing machines.

    I'm going to use my brain and stay sharp while my colleagues continue to outsource thinking to a machine. We'll see who really falls behind in a few years. I don't think their "years of practice" prompting will get them much.

    Opting out doesn’t fix those problems. It just removes you from the people who get a say in how it’s used.

    When I choose not to use it, I'm not contributing to its demand.

    you can run models locally

    On what hardware? I'm not buying shit right now.

    Apologies if I come across as angry. This opinion is indeed unpopular on Lemmy but I'm afraid I'm the one with the unpopular opinion in the real world, which I find incredibly frustrating.

  • source
  • [–] 12 points 9 hours ago (6 children)

    Studies have shown that AI use, no matter how "careful", will result in cognative decline and skill loss, which results in more AI use, which results in more... You get the idea.

    In order to maintain a skill in something, you actually have to use your brain for problem solving. Offloading that to a deep learning algorithm means no longer keeping your brain sharp.

    Oh I have no doubt that these deep learning algorithms, so vapidly marketed as "AI", will only get better and better. But as a result people will only get stupider. And as the AI continues to recycle old habits, and its own habits, for training data, more and more problems will occur over time. Problems that wouid require humans to fix, humans who no longer have the skills or the intelligence.

    So no, I don't think I'll fall behind.

  • source
  • hideshow 6 child comments
  • [–] 5 points 8 hours ago* (5 children)

    Literally every single study I have seen on that topic has also had the same exact problem.

    It assumes a person will not replace the saved time with any other skill. That they will proceed to not research, learn or engage in any other activity at all.

    Every single time that gets accounted for those studies are proven flat out wrong.

    Fundamentally those studies are right in the sense that yes, if you don't use your mind and you don't use your brain, you don't exercise it. You go stupid.

    People overwhelmingly will do something else and develop a different skill if a tool or a utility makes a previously hard task suddenly easy.

    Yes, people will lose certain computer skills. That just means that they now have the available time and resources to work on other skills.

    Some people are going to be lazy pieces of s*** and not. But that's true of every time. Anything is made easier.

    It's the same argument you could have against the very concept of a user interface.

    The invention of a GUI made nearly everyone lose the ability to use a terminal. We should get rid of GUIs they're rotting the mind of people and making them lazy and stupid.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 5 child comments
  • [–] 4 points 4 hours ago

    The invention of a GUI made nearly everyone lose the ability to use a terminal. We should get rid of GUIs they're rotting the mind of people and making them lazy and stupid.

    Guess what? They're doing just that but instead of syntax-based terminal it's a chatbot. Are we smart yet

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 6 points 8 hours ago

    People overwhelmingly will do something else and develop a different skill if a tool or a utility makes a previously hard task suddenly easy.

    The studies haven't shown this at all. Not even close. What they have shown is that AI will gradually get used more and more and more till it replaces even the most basic requirement for thought in their daily lives.

    This has absolutely no similarity to the development of the GUI. It's not one skill that gets replaced with another. It is the complete removal of critical Human thought and problem solving. EVERY skill a person does is built upon these two things, and it's being eliminated.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 2 points 1 hour ago

    The invention of a GUI made nearly everyone lose the ability to use a terminal. We should get rid of GUIs they’re rotting the mind of people and making them lazy and stupid.

    You're forgetting one thing: the proliferation of the GUI made computing an accessible function for people who never learned to use a CLI in the first place. It didn't make people forget how to use a terminal, it just made people who can use a terminal more valuable. AI doesn't create any such pathway because it's being used to replace the people who knew how to use a terminal, and doing so poorly.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 11 points 14 hours ago* (last edited 14 hours ago) (2 children)

    We're all going to be left behind. The projection is that all these data centers being built to facilitate AI will increase global Co2 emissions by 70%. Jfc what future is there with AI? Local models also use more energy than other uses of compute, simply more distributed. The energy they use isn't zero.

    I'm not saying there aren't uses for AI, there are. Broad general use however is simply part of a hype cycle that I hope gets washed away with the bubble burst.

  • source
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 2 points 7 hours ago

    This article is not saying global emissions will be increased by 70%, just datacenters:

    As a result of the growth in fossil fuel generation for datacentres, emissions associated with this sector were on track to rise by 70% by 2030, the IEA said.

    This is a problem, but datacenters only account for around 0.5% of global emissions, so the scale of the problem is relatively small compared to other sources of pollution. It's also more practical to solve directly, they only need electricity, and you can power them with renewable electricity, which they are already increasingly doing:

    Overall, fossil fuels provide nearly 60% of power to data centres, according to the IEA. Renewables meet 27% of their electricity demand and nuclear another 15%.

    (These figures are based on the electricity these facilities consume, rather than any contracts they have to buy clean energy credits.)

    In the IEA’s central scenario, by 2035 the ratio of the data-centre electricity mix switches from around 60% fossil fuels and 40% clean power to 60% clean power and 40% fossil fuels, as shown in the chart below.

    The simplest thing to do would be to mandate that all new datacenter construction have its own onsite power, and that power must not produce any Co2 emissions, that would prevent the 0.4% emissions increase or so that they would otherwise cause.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 11 points 5 hours ago

    Then I choose death.

  • source
  • [–] 21 points 14 hours ago* (last edited 7 hours ago)

    People keep telling me this exact same thing. I keep doing my thing just fine.

    We focus way too much on maximizing productivity and maximum output. This is just another step in that trend and there's always been some of us who protest/reject that for many reasons. I'm not worried

  • source
  • [–] 10 points 3 hours ago* (last edited 3 hours ago)

    I work in the field of mental health, should I start inputting individuals trauma and personal histories into a LLM for what reason? So I can risk a data leak that could literally cause someone to take their life if information is exposed in any sort of way?

    Do I need AI for personal notes and insurance documentation dictation that was 100% accurate without AI for some reason? (I personally still type everything myself though)

    My partner and I go camping at music festivals for fun along with some hiking, our primary extracurricular activity, what benefits is AI going to have integrated into that? I use solar for power with an on demand power station that doesn't use AI, no issues there.

    I have several past jobs where you have to physically monitor someone so they do not harm themselves or others. This isn't minority report (yet, nor would I want it to be), what benefit is there to AI in that scenario?

    The problem I have with AI is that all of its evangelists are like, "EVERYONE NEEDS THIS FOR EVERYTHING" and I'm a couple years into this crap existing, not needing it, happy and fine.

    I've had to hear the same/similar pitch for VR like clockwork every 10 years since 1970. What am I, are we falling behind on, in any of the previously mentioned? Geesh.

  • source
  • [–] 8 points 3 hours ago (1 child)

    On team "I refuse to touch it." I've been a computer guy pretty much my whole life. My current job is almost certainly my last one doing computer things. I absolutely know I have fallen behind by never learning how to 'do AI' in an industry where the only thing that matters anymore is knowing how to do AI effectively. I don't care, the software business is already dead to me. It means I'll never make as much money as I did 5 years ago but it looks like neither will anyone else soon. Fuck it. My spite will sustain me. In all seriousness, my next job will probably be a mobile dog grooming partnership, and making ceramic pottery as a side hobby.

  • source
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 24 points 9 hours ago* (1 child)

    That is exactly what the billionaires like you thinking. That is why trillions of dollars are being poured into AI data centers. That is why every AI exec says their AI is a threat to the internet or a threat to all humanity, it's them hyping up their models over the other guy's.

    These are sloppy tools. If you asked it to prop up a table it might use 10,000 popsicle sticks, or 3 wagons. The table top may or may not be upright, it could be vertical. It still accomplishes the instruction.

    And you want AI to dig into millions of lines of code? AI will find an iteration that fits the instructions, but makes no design or maintenance sense. The databases and code will feel the ramifications of AI code for many years.

  • source
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 29 points 14 hours ago (6 children)

    The ethical and environmental issues cannot be resolved. That is why I am *on principal *against LLMs.

    That said my main issue with LLM's is that they make you dumb, erase your ability to do tasks you used to do, perhaps with some effort.

    I do use our company's Claude account from time to time, but only to collate large numbers of documents. Never for actual thinking.

  • source
  • hideshow 6 child comments
  • [–] -5 points 13 hours ago* (3 children)

    The ethical issues can absolutely be resolved. Environmental too if they use green energy.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 3 child comments
  • [–] 12 points 13 hours ago (2 children)

    Your energy source being green does not make your product green.

    If you buy green energy supply from the grid, the grid has to balance that by bringing in more supple. Which is likely to come from underused fossil fuel burners. You "made your product greener" at the cost of making everyone else's less green.

    The greenest energy use is no energy use at all. Stop defending billionaires, they can pay for their own army.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 4 points 12 hours ago (1 child)

    Not to mention that every joule of energy used for computation turns into heat. It doesn’t matter what the power source is: it all ends up as heat in the atmosphere.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] -5 points 9 hours ago

    If you think the ethical and environmental issues can't be resolved then you fundamentally do not understand humanity. You do not fundamentally understand the actual problem you against.

    And you're giving an absolute pass to the people responsible for the problem. And you're blaming a f****** tool.

    People are far more complex and able to come together to fix things then you're giving them credit for.

    Now I could take an argument that it's unlikely that they'll be resolved because rich assholes are rich and assholes.

    But to try and claim that it physically cannot be resolved under any circumstances. Is b******* of the highest caliber.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 16 points 14 hours ago (2 children)

    AI is a really great search engine that you have to check your sources on everything it spits out. Reddit is not a source unless you're talking about gaming. I have had the llm spit out a valid source that says something completely different within that valid source. I guess it's somewhat good at checking your grammar.

    Loosing a trillion dollars a year, the environmental damage and the taking of water resources makes it not worth it, imo. If they just said, hey we've got a great tool instead of what they gave us, then yeah, it probably would have been fine. Now they're sitting on a time bomb.

  • source
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 1 point 12 hours ago (1 child)

    Reddit isn't even a source for gaming those dingledongers will lie about games they never played and get 10 brazillian updoots by other people who never played the game

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 33 points 14 hours ago (1 child)

    AI is easy to use, that's its biggest selling point. There's nothing to "fall behind" on.

    If it turns out to be useful you can just pick it up and catch up instantly.

  • source
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 13 points 13 hours ago

    If anything, whoever picks it up later is going to have the advantage.

    If you eat up the "AI is the future, use it or end up homeless" bullshit marketing, you have to eat the "bro trust me, Claude super max 47.0426.80 is Soo dumb and obsolete, the new Claude super max 47.0426.81 model is so much better".

    Which means that the "tricks" you learned for the old versions might not even make sense in the new ones. Why say "make no mistakes" every time, if they already hardcoded it in the newest models.

    Why learn something that will be obsolete in 3 months? Remember. According to these guys, when chatgpt launched, it was 3 months away from leaving every software developer out of a job. How many months has it been since then?

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 21 points 15 hours ago
    [–] 14 points 12 hours ago (2 children)

    Upvoted cuz here on lemmy this seems like a very unpopular opinion. I can see AI being around in some form, but it's just way overhyped.

    Eventually it will get enshittified to extract maximum profit from users and people can get nostalgic to the "good old days of ai" when it would just tell people they could put glue on pizza to hold the cheese together for free.

  • source
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] [S] -1 points 11 hours ago* (1 child)

    It for sure is overhyped, and it's a bubbel.

    But it also has many uses and is going to stay around.

    Pretending it's poison and the devil like many people on here do is also delusional.

    The truth is somewhere in the middle.

    Like Nuclear, it can be used for good or bad.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 1 point 9 hours ago

    I mean, its been around for decades. They just slapped a friendly UI on the latest version and decided to start calling it AI.

    Most people are going to be against yhe cost/benefit ratio and how its being marketied, not that it cant be a good tool under the right circumstances.

    We're just not being offered those circumstances because those in charge of the products would rather use it to enrich themselves in power and wealth.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 13 points 14 hours ago (4 children)

    That’s all nice, but said colleague will suffer from cognitive decline soon enough. We’ll see I guess.

  • source
  • hideshow 4 child comments
  • [+] -7 points 13 hours ago (3 children)

    AI means more output. No longer are you taking a few weeks to make one website or app, suddenly you're building 10 or more per month and thinking harder than ever because you're now a project manager orchestrating a team of agents which always are building and needing your input and feedback. Going from slowly writing code to being able to solo do the work of a team of people and cover multiple roles. You're zooming out and doing more.

    In my experience, colleagues who have been slow at picking up AI, or not using agentic AI has been frustrating. They'll spend an afternoon building or debugging something which Fable could have done far better in a few minutes. Their output is inferior to what AI assisted development can do and it shows.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 3 child comments
  • [–] 10 points 12 hours ago* (2 children)

    The AI artist can make 1000 images in the time that it takes the varnish on a single oil painting to dry. But does anyone actually give a shit about those 1000 image?

    Much the same, programming is not about producing the most lines of code in the least amount of time. It is about making thoughtful and logical contributions to a system in order to make the program in question better, more secure and more useful to the end user.

    AI can be useful in helping to find theoretical bugs. But given that we live in an era of enshittifaction and crumbling infrastructure, I think there are many remaining questions about whether it is helping to make software meaningfully better.

    After all, we don't need 10 new apps, we need better ones.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 1 point 9 hours ago

    Respectfully, AI isn't the cause of enshitification. The people using it are. AI doesn't have any actual intelligence. It's just a fancy algorithm that is really good at picking out items inside the model to create random, but usually understandable output. It also "hallucinates" and gets a lot things wrong. If the user doesn't spend time with what the AI puts out and improve and correct it, the output will be, at best, subpar. However, if someone takes the AI output and corrects the mistakes, then adds some "polish" and improvements, that output can become a useful, and productive, application. AI is just a fancy tool. Compare it to a circular saw. If you saw your leg off with it, it's not the saw's fault. It's the user who screwed up, unless they intentionally wanted to cut their leg off.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 0 points 9 hours ago

    Comparing image generation to code generation are two very different workloads.

    Image generation is also split up into how you define and categorize the art or image that you need.

    Do you need a general color blind palette and background for a website? AI is going to be better. It just is it's going to be able to do that sort of job faster. That's not art but it is image generation.

    Do you need some generic little stand-in stock photo? Then it's going to be easier to just use a machine to generate that or by a stock photo license. Again it's not art.

    Art is for the purpose of expression. Any picture can be art. It just comes down to who made it in if they're expressing something.

    You really just can't compare image generation to code. It's just two very very different arguments and workloads.

    And I mean, if you want to make something more secure, being able to throw an endless unsleeping machine at something that breaks it in every conceivable possible way to find every possible vulnerability and bug... Yeah, you can't really ask for a better tester than that.

    You're going to f****** hate fixing all the s*** it fines. You probably shouldn't let it fix it. But it's good of finding it.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 13 points 14 hours ago (1 child)

    I'll watch it burn. The whole "AI" slop bubble.

  • source
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 17 points 14 hours ago (2 children)

    https://www.mcsweeneys.net/articles/brain-eating-lizards-are-here-to-stay-so-we-might-as-well-get-used-to-them

    Ignoring the completely brain dead take here, humans managed to ban ozone stripping chemicals to save the earth. It’s not too late to ban LLMs. People like you thinking that it’s the future are the actual problem.

  • source
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] [S] 3 points 11 hours ago (1 child)

    I will put all the money I have on a bet than banning AI won't happen in our lifetimes.

    The box has already been opened, and it has so many uses, people won't give it up.

    Even if it's just a more powerful search engine, that is reason enough for people to want to keep it.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 6 points 9 hours ago (1 child)

    My boss just gave me a lesson in how to use AI to do some of my job, and... well it didn't really do it that much faster than me, and I can't really trust the output from it, so I'd have to verify the info, and the only way to do that is to just, do that actual work, so it really just makes my job harder...

    That being said, I think it will definitely be a useful tool in the future, however, I still view it as I would any other piece of technology. Right now it's in it's beta stage. It's almost working right. It's almost user friendly, there are ways to optimize the data centers so that it doesn't destroy our environment.

    These are all things that will improve, and I expect it to, over time. But right now, it's still the hallucinating, lying, environment destroying shiny new toy that requires a lot more work.

    I'll use it when it's fixed. When it's stable.

    I'm the kind of gamer that's waiting till GTA 6 gets a PC port, so I'm used to waiting for a bit to get a better, more polished, finished product.

  • source
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 1 point 8 hours ago

    It's an overpriced, expensive novelty toy at the moment.

    Some of the smaller models are useful for a little things. But most of those run on CPU and aren't really all that helpful for any real.

    And two or three generations of gpus and improvements to hardware models that are currently considered frontier probably will run on reasonable home equipment. Not your Grandad's computer, but like a high-end gaming PC or workstation more than likely.

    At that point we'll probably hit the good enough threshold where it'll be useful and reliable enough to do mundane tasks with little to no error.

    And that's probably where all this is going to end up after the bubble popping. It's all just going to kind of be mundane and boring. It's going to change the world but not in any overly large way at least not quickly.

    It's probably just going to be like the.com bubble and everything is just going to slowly shift over like a 20-year span.

    The whole business model of a giant company selling AI subscription honestly is cannibalizing itself when you step back and look at it. They're making more efficient models that are more compact and faster generation after generation at a ridiculous speed.

    The moment a new generation of hardware comes out to run these things even faster, you've suddenly just massively hurt your ability to sell the lower end of your stock.

    Given enough generations of hardware and models. You'll reach a point where the small models are doing what the giant models could do generations ago. At speeds faster than those models could do generations ago.

    And what the hell does your average small business even need with a super fast super big model when something they can run off computer that they have right there that they own in their own office can just do.

    You just end up at a point where you can't sell your product. People aren't going to need frontier class models forever. The better the mid-tier wants to get and the better the low tier ones get the less of a value proposition the frontier ones become.

  • source
  • parent
  • load more comments
    view more: next ›