This is the fediverse, so this is probably going to be extremely unpopular, but yea here goes.

Not saying you have to love it, or trust it blindly. Skepticism is healthy. But there’s a difference between “I use it carefully and check everything” and “I refuse to touch it.”

Historically, refusing new tools has never stopped them. Coopers didn’t stop the steel drum by refsuing to make them. They just ended up out of work while the industry moved on.

The realistic threat isn’t AI replacing you. It’s a colleague who uses AI well doing your job faster. And the skill of using it properly (knowing when it’s wrong, veriyfing output, knowing what not to use it for) takes time to build. Starting late means competing with people who’ve had years of practice.

You can have legit concenrs about ethics, energy, or jobs and still learn the tool. Opting out doesn’t fix those problems. It just removes you from the people who get a say in how it’s used.

PS. Ethically trained models exist and you can run models locally.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 31 points 14 hours ago* (last edited 14 hours ago) (2 children)

Eh, it’s going to be a dumb tool like the internet.

In the dot com bubble, everyone thought the web would replace stores, offices, everything. If you didn’t go all-in, you were already obsolete. Back then, there were also people vehemently against it (though not quite with the scale of the Tech Oligarchs today).

LLMs are the same.

It’s going to land in a boring middle ground between the doomers, haters, and glazers, and it will take some time to evolve (like the web did). It’s changing the world, but not that much. People who didn’t go all in will be fine, though those who abstain are perhaps not in an ideal position, as you’d be if you were a business refusing to use the internet today.

…It will do some great damage, but that’s from the irresponsible tech bros we’ve handed power to. Attributing the damage to LLMs is absolving these people of culpability. The “AI” doesn’t do anything, people do.


Also, you cannot separate the open models people theoretically can use from what the vast majority uses: Anthropic, OpenAI, CoPilot, Gemini. Or even the questionably ethical Deepseek, GLM, Mistral, GigaChat (the Russian LLM), or whatever APIs. Though I do think Nemotron API is cleaner than average, and gets a good bit of business usage.

It’d be like arguing social media is healthy because the Fediverse exists. Yeah… theoretically, it’s maybe less bad. You could make the same argument about how crypto would be great if we lived in perfect society.

And just FYI you don’t have to sell me on local machine learning. I’ve been running LLMs before Llama 1, GANs before that, I have MiMo loaded pretty much all the time. I think they’re neat, and useful. But I still think people who try to abstain from LLMs are acting reasonably, given the state of things.


I do think the hate should be focused on a more useful problem: the corrosiveness of people like Musk, Altman, Elon, Sundar, and such. And the dystopia they’re advocating for. They are trying to shift culpability off themselves.

  • source
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 9 points 13 hours ago (1 child)

    Also, you cannot separate the open models people theoretically can use from what the vast majority uses:

    I'll just add that because a model is "open" doesn't mean it's "ethical".

    Many of these open models that you can use locally are still trained on stolen data and represent an exploitation of other people's intellectual labor.

    Whether that is problematic or "fair use" (legally and ethically) I think depends entirely on the specific use case.

    But there no question to me that people who are using generative AI to slop out some "content" in the hopes of making a quick buck in the short term are acting in a way that is bad for society and culture. We don't need more low-effort junk.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 1 point 13 hours ago* (last edited 12 hours ago)

    People who are using generative AI to slop out some “content” in the hopes of making a quick buck in the short term are acting in a way that is bad for society and culture.

    Then hold them responsible. And the entities that enable it, responsible.

    Imagine you went to a cybersecurity conference years ago, and loudly announced to the floor “Hey! My automated Go script hacked Chase Bank, and I don’t really know how because I used this Google subscription thing to do it, it just did! WOW, Go is so dangerous, but isn’t this subscription thing I used revolutionary?”

    If this was a commercial LLM today, the response be to… praise and fund the hacker, hype Google’s stock price, and make noise about scripting languages being existential threats to humanity??? And Chase’s lawyers would sit on their hands???

    It makes no sense. In any sane world, the hacker would get laughed out, arrested, and the user interface promoting irresponsible usage of a tool would be investigated or sued. Yet somehow the world has bought the narrative of blaming the deeper tool, instead of the people selling it or the user abusing it.


    The reason we don’t is that very rich Tech Companies were already pushing slop for profit before LLMs, and they don’t want to disrupt that.

    Hence what I’m arguing is that people are angry at the wrong target. If one hates slop, if someone hates all this irresponsibility and enshittification, that anger should be more precisely targeted.


    EDIT: And yep, your point about training data is right, especially about the context of usage.

    A few models are better about this (Nemotron, for example), but the vast majority in use aren’t.

    Personally I think the whole IP system is screwed up, but that’s not a great excuse.

  • source
  • parent