People who are using generative AI to slop out some “content” in the hopes of making a quick buck in the short term are acting in a way that is bad for society and culture.
Then hold them responsible. And the entities that enable it, responsible.
Imagine you went to a cybersecurity conference years ago, and loudly announced to the floor “Hey! My automated Go script hacked Chase Bank, and I don’t really know how because I used this Google subscription thing to do it, it just did! WOW, Go is so dangerous, but isn’t this subscription thing I used revolutionary?”
If this was a commercial LLM today, the response be to… praise and fund the hacker, hype Google’s stock price, and make noise about scripting languages being existential threats to humanity??? And Chase’s lawyers would sit on their hands???
It makes no sense. In any sane world, the hacker would get laughed out, arrested, and the user interface promoting irresponsible usage of a tool would be investigated or sued. Yet somehow the world has bought the narrative of blaming the deeper tool, instead of the people selling it or the user abusing it.
The reason we don’t is that very rich Tech Companies were already pushing slop for profit before LLMs, and they don’t want to disrupt that.
Hence what I’m arguing is that people are angry at the wrong target. If one hates slop, if someone hates all this irresponsibility and enshittification, that anger should be more precisely targeted.
EDIT: And yep, your point about training data is right, especially about the context of usage.
A few models are better about this (Nemotron, for example), but the vast majority in use aren’t.
Personally I think the whole IP system is screwed up, but that’s not a great excuse.