As a person who doesn’t really give a shit. I’ve even forgotten that I’m on Wayland. Everything I need works and that’s all that matters to me. Y’all can keep your wars to yourselves
post
I know how LongtimeUser4 feels. His use case is ludicrous, sure, but xkcd's ideas don't come out of nothing.
I am dreading trying to rewrite my scripts that currently rely on xdotool and wmctrl. When last I looked into it, the equivalents didn't cover the features I use, and the rationale from Wayland seems to be "why would you want to do that, old man?"
I was the old person for the longest time but then I learned how ridiculously insecure the clipboard system in x11 is and I was suddenly like "oh would you look at the time, it's wayland o' clock already"
Could you elaborate, please?
Any program running in the x session can read every keystroke, record your whole screen, and take a copy of everything put onto the clipboard at any time. It's been mostly fine in practice in the past but more people are on linux now and it's generally a bigger target than it used to be
I still use a x11 session for xdotool sometimes. That tool is so awesome
What features do you use? I was able to replicate just about everything I do with ydotool. It's admittedly goofy to setup, but once you understand it, it works fine.
ydotool was still in its infancy when I last looked and I haven't wanted to look again because I suspected that the situation would not have changed.
So anyway, I've just woken up and am too dopey to care, so I went and looked. ydotool does not do what I want.
My scripts move, resize, change the title of, and sometimes even ask a window to close (wmctrl -c).
As best as I can tell, I have to hope that my DE provides something that will do some of what I want, or else write generic code that figures out where a window is on screen and makes exactly the right mouse movements and clicks to resize a window or close it, which is highly non-trivial. And changing a window title would appear to be impossible.
So what you're saying is you're pro murdering children???
(disclaimer/context: see alt-text from the linked comic)
Thanks to this wayland debacle, I accepted that as an X11 user I'm now retro. So I totally embraced this attitude. I don't care about how awesome Wayland will one day be. I'm happy with all my old scripts running trustworthy xdotool and wmctrl.
Once I allowed myself this paradigm shift, I became happy. I've attained digital Ataraxia.
What is the origin of this meme? Why do they want to kill this poor man who presumably lives there and just mowed the lawn?
Apparently the original:
The edit looks less edited than the original.
Right? Knives look more natural than clothes unmoving from a package, wayyyy to much cornstarch if the shirts are holding that well.
in my mind wayland is a separate thing with a lot of overlap with x11
i still use x because it seems you cant vnc into wayland. rustdesk makes me click "share screen" on wayland. steam makes me click "share screen". if i was at that pc, i woukd just use that pc. i am remoting because im away.
i use x because there is no wayland doesnt have an android client i can use with termux to do full linux stuff on my phone when im away from home.
x will not be obsolete until wayland is a 1:1 replacement. there are still very valid use cases for x and it makes me sad to see everyone kicking it to the curb
dont get me wrong, i use wayland on my pc and laptop, but x still has a place on my computers.
im newbie to linux, and im using linux mint xfce, and i dont understand the meme hehe
you're using fhe good old X11 then
Me too brother, me too. The command line is scary, but powerful, only if you know the correct incantations. You look those up in the tome labeled "Google"
i only use sudo apt update && sudo apt upgrade, and reboot lol, even when i turn off my laptop i use the mouse
This is completely fine. No need to use the terminal if you feel more comfortable using the mouse. I would only recommend to substitute upgrade for full-upgrade in your command. This really installs all available updates even if it requires to install new dependencies.
I've been using Linux for ~17 years and Xfce is my goto interface. You're in good hands.
I love and use Wayland and KDE but MAN my best remote tool still hates wayland.
Yup. RustDesk for me. When prompted on the PC I tried giving access to all screens imstead of one, now it can never "'get display info". That plus issues with Chromium and CEF made me go back to X11 and alter the setup
Wayland still lacking adoption and functionality for basic and essential needs after more 15 years and with such budgets, really speaks volumes about it's architecture and decisions.
VMware Player still can’t copy and paste properly between the two machines on Wayland. How on earth is that affected by the desktop compositor?
Wayland is so smooth. When I go to my friends house and use mint I'm instantly reminded how shit x11. Screentearing on the desktop, cmon what year is this.
I thought Cinnamon finally added Wayland support now? Anyway I had the same experience. Using Mint is how I realized 90% of distro recommenders on reddit and Lemmy have 0 fucking clue what they're talking about
They added experimental support and i think they made it mostly functional in the upcoming release but dont quote me on that last bit
Wayland is so smooth
My plasma desktop is very noticeably slower and choppier with Wayland. The most visible example is when I switch workspaces and instead of the animation taking a fraction of a second it takes a second or two. It honestly feels like my laptop (which isn't that old) was aged a decade by simply switching to Wayland.
I moved from X to Wayland when Fedora dumped X, and the first weeks were a pretty unstable experience (mainly because the Nvidia drivers still had some issues after implementing explicit sync), while performance never was an issue. Nowadays all of those problems are solved. Desktop streaming works fine with both pipewire and through whatever Sunshine uses, game FPS are comparable to Windows with some variation depending on title, and my desktop experience is buttery smooth.
If you're getting screen tearing, it's not X11's fault. It's the graphics manufacturers putting speed over stability.
I had an old Nvidia card that I never had a problem with under X11. The moment I upgraded to an AMD card, screen tearing, screen tearing everywhere.
To fix, you generally need to slap a small config file into /etc/X11/xorg.conf.d that tells the graphics driver that slow and steady wins the race.
The AMD solution literally contains the line Option "TearFree" "true". Ridiculous.
Link to one of many sites providing the full solutions: https://linuxjunkies.org/guides/fix-screen-tearing-on-linux
If you’re getting screen tearing, it’s not X11’s fault. It’s the graphics manufacturers putting speed over stability.
This is the central part of why wayland adoption has been difficult. With X11, the idea is "the buck stops here", with wayland it's "this is out of scope."
Now, in terms of managing a cleaner project, which is wayland's goal, that's fair.
However, in the practicalities of seamless adoption and not breaking shit, it's not being the "drop in replacement and new standard" it's hoping to be.
You need screen tearing for gaming. Wayland allows screen tearing on games but sync for everything else configured with a single check box.
Now that it at least supports my multiscreen, multi UI scale setup, it feels like Wayland is what all DE's want to be. It's so smooth and fast, and can always impose it's will on all the windows. What do you mean this window won't minimize and always stays on top?? WAYLAND SMASH. There I fixed it.
It feels very luxurious and decadent to have a DE that is so frocking good and reliable.
I still haven't cracked remote applications with Wayland and that's a deal-breaker. I use ssh -Y hundreds of times each day.
I've had some success with waypipe but it's not easy. I was able to open a chromium window on a remote machine using waypipe --no-gpu ssh user@remote 'chromium --ozone-platform=wayland'
Both the host and remote machines were running Arch.
Yeah, I've been exploring waypipe too. Most of my X11 use is inside a Docker container, so I run an ssh -Y session to a remote host that's running Docker and launch a container which starts a X11 application that runs over the session into my workstation.
At the moment I haven't figured out how to use waypipe in that environment, since as I understand it, it expects to be installed at both ends, when I really want it across the equivalent of a bastion host, ie. A calls B which calls C, with waypipe installed on A and C, with A being a workstation and C being a container running on B.
The short answer is you can't
The only way I know of is to use RDP
I love the benefits of Wayland (display scaling, negative coordinates, hdr) but wish it had anything remotely as useful as xrandr (I have a 768x1024 16:9 plasma tv).
I'll give it a shot, but I doubt it has a way to do seperate horizontal and vertical scaling, or rotate the screen 17.5° as a joke
There's also the trick of xrandr of using --panning and --scale for a larger-than-physical desktop you can edge-scroll around in. Wondering if that is even possible in wayland?
what are the benefits of negative coordinates?
top 96 comments