At the point when someone engages in that kind of intellectual dishonesty, I think it's fair to go with the philosophical nuclear option and point out that the entire concept of ontology is founded on and limited by epistemology. If they're going to use dirty tricks to pin you, it's okay to dive into the ravine leading to solipsism.
post
All my friends hate TERFs. Fuck TERFs.

Fuck TERFs!
If anyone is wondering: Feminism-Appropriating Radical Reationary Transphobes
Edit: yup
Yeah fuck them (the TERFs if it wasn't 100% clear 🤷🏼♀️) off into the fucking sun, what a waste of air pffff!
You know, these "believe the science" folks (implying science stops at XX/XY) are really shit at believing actual science
Chromosomes are way more complicated than what is taught in High School but a lot of people take the simple abstractions we teach and then assume that's all there is.
Also, chromosomes aren't what actually does anything, they just correlate based on where the relevant genes tend to be. The Y chromosome will likely disappear eventually and it won't really change anything.
"speed of light isn't real!!! This is basic Newtonian physics!! What the fuck do you mean 'bending spacetime' and 'time dilation' are you even listening to yourself???"
"basic biology" chuds haven't advanced beyond kindergarten level biology
Humans are apes. Apes are monkeys. Monkeys are fish. There's no such thing as a fish. There's no definitive consensus on whether viruses are alive. Nothing biological is as simple as people would have you believe.
There’s no definitive consensus on whether viruses are alive.
This is one that I wish more people understood. A cell contracting a virus is like picking up a strange thumbdrive you found in the parking lot and inserting it into your laptop. By itself, it does literally nothing. But combine it with a host CPU and some power, and you're in for a bad time.
Well, that and the fact that antibiotics do nothing for viral infections. Knowing the above helps make that a lot more clear.
Then you have second and third order effects. Antibiotics helped fight off a bacterial infection so your immune system had more spare capacity to fight a viral infection? It's easy for people to learn the wrong thing.
It's like ivermectin and COVID19. Some patients improved due to it. All those patients had actual parasites that ivermectin killed. Idiots doesn't understand that the parasite connection matter.
Thought about that recently: assuming the AI Bros are correct, and it is possible to sufficiently approach sentience with current or near-future technology. In that case, it would be fair to say that such a brain simulation is sufficiently approaching being alive for most purposes. Is the brain file alive when it is dormant on some flash drive? Is the combination of the brain file and a running computer alive? Is the brain file running on a computer, but with read-only memory alive? Is a person who is on drugs that block memory formation alive?
I honestly don't think it's possible to have a satisfying answer to all that. IMO, the whole thought exercise is bound for the absurd territory currently occupied by "what is a fish?" This technology will clearly challenge our thoughts about "aliveness" and sentience, but we may have to settle for the notion that there's no hard-and-fast boundary. That is, at least where any philosophical discussion is concerned. However, I do think that we'll have to eventually come up with some legal definitions for civility's sake, which are bound to have some odd corner-cases; we're already here when talking about brain-death.
Are you alive in between plank seconds?
Excellent question. Made me stop smoking weed. Your short term memory being temporary on holiday is horrifying.
Funny thing, a very Zen approach to life is to treat a person as a process rather than en entity. So a process that can go on under the limits of the physical model it's in, can be alive. In the same way, it would also be alive if run in a simulation that's paused every night for backups and maintenance.
Also, since the Planck time is the limit, there's no 'between' Planck units of time. Just as in integer computation, there's no 'between' the integer numbers.
Planck is our rendering resolution. If it’s a simulation, that’s the clock speed of the cpu.
I formulate it for myself as viruses being like a wrench of such a shape that, when it's thrown into factory machinery, the factory cranks out another such wrench. However, I'm one of those people who are hazy on why viruses could be considered alive. (Maybe under a broad definition like life keeps the entropy out for a while to perpetuate itself?)
I like that definition
If you mean the life one, I've read it somewhere as an offhand remark, but it was long ago so can't recall now who wrote that.
the thing is that "viruses" is a very broad umbrella, there's everything from "literally just a couple genes inside a bubble of fat" to "might literally be a cell that went all in on parasitism to the point that it lost the ability to replicate on its own".
I love telling people the largest fish in the world is the blue whale. Everyone gets so mad.
some categories are monophyletic, like mamals, or dinosaurs. all descendants of mammals will always be mammals.
But some are paraphyletic, like fish/lizards. where it's just our attempt to categorising things, like all descendants of fish are fish EXCEPT reptiles and their descendants. And all descendants of reptiles are reptiles EXCEPT birds and mammals.
so no, whales aren't fish. but will always be mammals
thing is: the paraphyletic categories aren't actually defined by evolutionary relationship, they're very very clearly just based on how things look/act. Just look at how people talk about fictional alien species, if it's a thing that swings between branches then it gets called a monkey, if it swims in the water it's called a fish.
There is too such thing as a fish! It's just not universally agreed upon.
My definition includes humans and all vertebrates, and all species that are more closely related to each other than they are related to organisms in the Tunicata clade. My definition of fish is synonymous with vertebrate.
Reasonable people may disagree!
and all species that are more closely related to each other than they are related to organisms in the Tunicata clade
Glad you specified this -- my hagfish siblings were ready to throw down.
counterpoint: anything that looks like a fish is a fish, including alien species.
Apes are not monkeys, apes and monkeys are primates.
Ages ago in college I had a psych class that would give you one bonus point for every test if you wrote "Chimps are not monkeys" on the top of the page
apes are monkeys, we're in the same clade and the only reason people don't consider us monkeys is because we don't want to place ourselves in the same group as them.
It's like saying ONLY yellow carrots aren't actually carrots, but orange/purple/black ones are.
Being in the same clade doesn't make you the same thing. Carrots and blueberries are in the same clade (Asterids) but you wouldn't call a blueberry a root vegetable.
you're.. repeating my argument back at me as if it can somehow prove me wrong..
Being in the same clade makes them part of the same clade, that's how taxonomy works. Apes and monkeys are part of the same clade, thus apes are monkeys.
From wikipedia: "Traditionally, all animals in the group now known as simians are counted as monkeys except the apes. Thus monkeys, in that sense, constitute an incomplete paraphyletic grouping; alternatively, if apes (Hominoidea) are included, monkeys and simians are synonyms."
Apes and monkeys are part of the same clade, thus apes are monkeys.
Blueberries are the same clade as carrots, therefore blueberries are carrots
dude, you're just making shit up
I'm not making anything up, I'm rephrasing your claims. Clades are not collections of the same thing, they just have a common ancestor. Monkeys and apes belong to the same clade, meaning they have a common ancestor, not that they're the same thing - just like the blueberry and carrot.
People really do be confusing the fundamental nature of reality with the arbitrary categories humans put things in so we can point at them.
C’mon internet somebody must be able to magic up an archive link of that convo
via https://nitter.perennialte.ch/search?f=tweets&q=%22trees+are+a+social+construct%22 (which has lots more):
i wonder if this is the same person as the one in the screenshot? this was maybe their first post about it, with 10 replies. it looks like the main account they were talking to was suspended, but you can see a screenshot of maybe-it here.
edit: yeah it must be the same event, since they also mention palm trees and wood here
I knew you’d come through, oh benevolent internet hive mind!
seriously thanks @cypherpunks@lemmy.ml, appreciate it
TERFs misunderstanding palm trees just nerdsniped me into some localish history I personally lived through:
In 2011 then Wisconsin Governor Scott Walker was pushing through sweeping legislation that was attempting to kneecap the political power held by the teachers union in Wisconsin. This was after Republicans had sweeping victories in 2010 in blowback against Obama, and also notably around the time that Republicans redistricted Wisconsin to jerrymander it to hell and back for Republican control
Madison Wisconsin loves a good protest, and protest people did with an estimated count of over 100,000 protesters showing up. I was going to school in Madison at that time and we ended up with 6 days straight without sufficient staff present to open any schools in the entire Madison Metropolitan School District
Finally for the palm tree tie-in: Fox News "accidentally" aired earlier footage of riots in Sacramento when reporting on the protests occuring in February in Madison. One thing that's very different about Wisconsin when compared to Sacramento is that it gets quite cold and snowy in February in Wisconsin, with temperatures often falling below 0F (nowadays with the destabilizing polar vortex even more so! Temperatures plunge 20-30 degrees below zero at least once every year in Jan/Feb now!) you'll notice it is snowing in most of the photos of the protests in Madison. Another thing that's very different about Wisconsin and California is that we do not have palm trees in Wisconsin, but there are lots of palm trees in California. Activists observed this "accidental" mixup of footage, and assembled inflatable palm trees around the protests to call out Fox News
I hope you enjoyed my off-topic digression
Another social construct regarding of trees: Pine is considered "soft wood", and there's "hard wood" that is softer than pine.
This makes me think of Dan McClellan's furniture definition thought experiment, noting that there's no set of characteristics that is necessary and sufficient to describe furniture.
i think when i discovered terfs were just bullshit artists was when graham linehan tried to mansplain being a lesbian to linda riley
Basil forming wood entered the chat.
... or did I remember that wrong?
i think most herbs tend to become woody at the base if you just let them grow big enough and they experience a bit of wind to encourage it.
Wasn't there this meme going around a few months ago, that basil was a pseudo-tree/pseudo-shrubbery/whatever? Or did I dream that up? (Or maybe it was in German memespace)
never heard of it, but again that's just what a lot of plants do.
being a tree just means it's woody and has a single main trunk with smaller branches coming off it, and shrub just removes the trunk requirement.
Plants are absurdly flexible in how they grow, so depending on the environment you could literally clone a single plant (by propagating cuttings) and have it grow radically differently just because you placed it in a different location.
Basically any tree can be turned into a bush by just cutting the trunk at the ground and letting it regrow, it's called pollarding and has historically been extremely widespread to make sticks and get easily harvestable leaves that you can feed to your livestock.
There's no such thing as a fish!
People keep misusing morphological categories and acti like phylogenetic categories are the only ones that exist.
trans people also involve wood in places, or lack thereof in others
separates trees from other plants
Ahh were fighting today then.
*reaches up to shelf to pull down paleobotany textbook *
Ok, I knew trees were not a monophyletic group. But didn't know the wood thing.
Someone please elaborate on that part. Why are palms not wood? I'm assuming bamboo isn't either?
I’m not sure about palms but isn’t bamboo just like, grass on roids or something?
It seems you're spot on
Palm trees, despite their tree-like appearance, have a unique structure that sets them apart from traditional woody trees. Their trunks are actually made of a dense, fibrous material that is more akin to a thick, woody grass than to the solid wood found in trees like oaks or pines. This material, often referred to as palm wood, is composed of the tightly packed leaf sheaths that form the trunk. While it provides support and stability, it lacks the lignin and cellulose that characterize true wood.
Hmm, so according to this page:
The major components of bamboo are cellulose, hemi-cellulose, and lignin, taking up above 90% of the whole weight
Which would mean that based on the implied definition you quoted, bamboo is wood. Which I admit, does rather go against my intuition.
bamboo is absolutely wild and i love it: it grows so fucking ludicrously fast that you can see it under the right circumstances, the shoots are edible, and the mature plant is so fucking robust that you can use it to make industrial scaffolding.
It's kind of bizarre it's not a more popular material, like i've got some cutting boards made of bamboo and unless you look at the grain structure you wouldn't notice it's not normal wood! Fucking give me cheap bamboo furniture!
I know part of the problem is that in North America it has the capacity to be invasive. We absolutely should be using it more often as a cheap wood alternative and an eco friendly plastic alternative, but at least here in North America we do need to show some care with it to ensure we don't wind up even further damaging our struggling forests
yeah i'm mostly astonished that bamboo doesn't make up like 10% of china's exports, even just using it to make rayon for fabrics seems like such a painfully obvious thing and yet.. nope, it's just something you can find on the label of the odd sock..
in a sane world polyester would not exist and 95% of all clothing would be made from bamboo-sourced rayon.
That's why bamboo is so popular for rayon production. Fun fact: rayon and cellophane are both just cellulose and therefore can decompose


top 90 comments