Had an exchange that went like
"The workers don't know how to run the business"
"Did the owner tell you that?"
"... shit."
Had an exchange that went like
"The workers don't know how to run the business"
"Did the owner tell you that?"
"... shit."
What's more depressing than socialist architecture? Homelessness and starvation in a land with plenty.
May I add the “owning vast media conglomerate mega-phone allowing the yacht owner to blast said explanation to the entire world” part?
Ghisline Maxwell’s dad published our textbooks
No, they hate “the other” would get treated kindly like them. There are some vengeful/racist garbage that have this “out group” damning thing, which sets us all into the pain with high ass premiums and shit. They paint over their rationalization as “rugged individualism,” but it’s basically “no, doesn’t deserve the services that I should get.”
And yes, above.
Imagine your politician showing up at the Ford dealership telling you you've been cut off. You can't buy another Ford F-150 King Ranch they say. You look up at the American flag and it is red with yellow stars.
The people explaining it to me: no yacht but username@lemmy.ml
It is a pity, because socialism doesn't need to be what Marxist Leninists get a hard-on for.
You don't have to have a centralised hierarchical system where the workers are but "considered" instead of having democratic control.
And they'll do it with a straight face.
Me personally, I think it the workers don't have control over society, it's not socialism.
Obviously, this is Russina propaganda. They are jealous of our freedom and prosperity. This is just a try to confuse us into becoming gay communists, so our military degrades and they can use their Mexican and Canadian proxy cells to take over our god-given country.
i don't hate communism. i hate the version of it that has left lasting damage on my country after 45 years.
And all the bad consequences they told you would result from it are pretty much what capitalism is doing all the time.
A lot of people are capitalists when it comes to chipping in but are socialists when it comes to getting a hand out
I don't think a trans person from Twitter has a yacht
I hate the version of it that was explained to me by my father who lived in it.
It's funny. My dad worked for Exxon in the 1970s. He'd go to St. Petersburg on business during the Detente Era. Learned the language. Had a bunch of Russian friends. Promised to take us there when we were older, because he had a real dream of a world united in peace and prosperity.
But then the 1980s happened, the price of oil tanked, projects were cancelled, the USSR collapsed, Dad got laid off, we had to downsize our quality of life significantly, and all those dreams went up in smoke.
Dad got a lower paying job in Houston. He started watching Fox News. His opinions on foreigners, on socialism, and on world peace soured significantly. He got incredibly angry when I went off to college and started learning world history, particularly "Marxist" history that failed to venerate the US. He also became a QAnoner and COVID denier. His last years were incredibly rough.
I guess I learned a lot watching his opinions shift over 50 years of life. Idk if it was "Communism Bad" though.
Promised to take us there when we were older, because he had a real dream of a world united in peace and prosperity.
My father did the exact opposite, and miraculously managed to get permission to leave the country to work abroad, and be "exploited" by these filthy capitalists at 10x wage he'd earn for the same job in socialist "paradise". Then state fucked him over with income tax, then he fucked them back by asking for tax payment plan spread over two years. Inflation that state falsly claimed to be very low eaten most of the debt within first year. Welcome to Poland in the 80s, country that couldnt design their own car so they had to license fiat 500 design from the 50s to be produced from mid 70s onward.
Your father didnt live in that system, he just saw very tiny piece, that wasn't representative of the whole.
Your father lived in the United federation of planets?
FYI: Star Trek is fiction
So is the idea that socialism ever actually existed. As such, they must have lived in a fictional world.
If it didn't work, then it wasn't real socialism. Heard that one a million times
I wouldn't boast about hearing it a million times and still failing to understand it personally but you do you. It wasn't socialism because it wasn't socialism.
I wouldnt boast about repeating emprically proven mistake.
But maybe thats the way? Maybe you need to taste it yourself with all the conseqences for reality to finally breach the propaganda barrier in your brain?
I mean, you're doing the equivalent of saying "well, my daddy grew up in North Korea and he's told me all about how democratic republics are really bad" and you actaully expect to be taken seriously.
You've even declared it to be empirically proven too. How are we not supposed to laugh at you?
“well, my daddy grew up in North Korea and he’s told me all about how democratic republics are really bad"
What even is this? My dad said the exact opposite.
So, your dad told you how good socialism was and you hated that?
I see no point in engaging in dishonest discourse
You're the dishonest one here. Just because a country declares themselves to be a democratic Republic, like North Korea, it doesn't mean they are. The same applies for socialism. A wealthy ruling authoritarian elite ruling over people with no rights isn't socialism and it never will be, even if you don't like it.
I guess we'll never get to see this empirical evidence of this un-named country was socialist 😂
The issue isn't that I don't like socialism as most proponents describe it. I also like Hogwarts as the books describe it. The issue is I still think trying to build Hogwarts is dumb. Just like trying to implementing socialism the way people described it to me. It just clearly wouldn't work, because people don't magically stop being selifsh and greedy for money and power when you change economic systems.
I've said this a few times before, but it's wrong to think that most people are greedy/selfish. The capitalist class and the political figures they buy are extreme outliers. We over-index on them due to a mix of negativity bias and the fact that they say everyone is greedy to justify their own positions of power.
Just think about it: Humans are an inherently cooperative species. We developed language so that we could work more effectively in groups and slowly built up complex social relationships that lead to us becoming wildly successful. The fact that some psychopaths learned to take advantage of our group dynamics shouldn't damn everyone they are exploiting.
This isn't even about being selfless/altruistic: The vast majority of us just straight up do better when we support each other. Even if the other person doesn't directly reciprocate, living in a society where it is the norm to help others comes around to help you at some point.
But beyond that, there just isn't a lot of value in essentializing people like that. Very little about modern society is natural. We aren't born knowing how to do math or drive cars, but we have the capacity to learn those things. We've grown through social evolution, not biological. That's why a critical part of building socialism is raising class consciousness. We aren't just changing the structure of society, we're changing the people to be able to create that new structure. Just as serfs learned that they need not be subservient to their lords before they were able to self govern, we must teach people that they have the power and the right to turn over the current hierarchy and create something better.
Wait so the fact that the more money I have the more giving I feel is actually normal ? I thought I was unique. I couldn't understand how billionaires weres constantly handing out thousands of stacks of hundreds to the homeless.
I'm not sure I believe it. Or maybe most IRL folks I know are just assholes.
So much word salad and none of it is relevant. Who cares if politicians and bilionaiers are extreme outliers or not? They exist. Capitalism as we have it now does not deal with them properly. But every socialist system I have ever seen concentrates power even more than capitalism. At least there is some split of interest between billionaiers, politicians, and milionaiers. Plus billionaiers are not a very cohesive group as their interests also do not align with each other perfectly.
In pretty much every socialist system I have seen proposed, all power is handed to elected politicians. And by human neture, the outliers will get elected, just like they do currently. No magical fix for gullible voters in socialism. That is why you never have "real socialism" in history. It turns to autocracy because of how the system interacts with human nature.
"No matter what points you make I'm dead set in my beliefs and I'm never changing them no matter what."
There, I shortened your walls of text for you.
I am very concerned by the number of liberals on lemmy who seem adamant about not wanting to read more than a tweet's worth of text. It's not like I write books. In theory they're adults. They should be able to read a couple paragraphs if they want to have a serious conversation.
Ah, thank you! So much more readable than the 4 pagaraphs from darthelmet.
I dont disagree with the notion that a "changing of the guard" won't fix everything. It just means there's different people that risk being corrupted, assuming they weren't already. Like how after the French Revolution it just meant there different rich people in control.
But to say something we shouldn't even try because a certain percentage of the population is greedy, or psychopathic, or whatever other trait you want, isn't that great of an argument. You could say capitalism will never work because people are too dishonest and will lie to fool investors. Which is something that actually happens right now. Enron. FTX. Theranos.
This is THE issue imo. How do we deal with these people? I dont think ANY political philosophy can address that effectively. The original idea of splitting power into three houses wasn't bad, but these past two years have shown it wasn't enough.
But to say something we shouldn't even try because a certain percentage of the population is greedy, or psychopathic, or whatever other trait you want, isn't that great of an argument.
Why do you think the choice is socialism or do nothing? I am arguing for doing something else, namely focusing on reforming democracies and breaking up mega-corporations into smaller companies while keeping the basics of capitalism.
This is THE issue imo. How do we deal with these people? I dont think ANY political philosophy can address that effectively. The original idea of splitting power into three houses wasn't bad, but these past two years have shown it wasn't enough.
If you believe this, then you are paying too much attention to the US and not enough to the EU. The EU is semi-working and a lot of the things that aren't are US corporations and other foreign interests messing things up from the outside while not being fully under EU jurisdiction.
This is THE issue imo. How do we deal with these people? I dont think ANY political philosophy can address that effectively.
Effectively is relative. I don't think any philosophy can address it perfectly (outside something crazy sci-fi like handing power to an AGI). But clearly some approaches work better then others. Look at Netheralnds, Norway, ... They have issues but they work well enough.
What is crazy to me is there being clear examples of countries with systems that work well enough to give great living standards to their people and people saying "fuck that, let's try a system that doesn't work even on paper and always resulted in horrible suffering when tried. I am sure this time will be better." Like why?! Even if you believe there is a way it could maybe work, why take the risk over systems that have proven themselves?
But every socialist system I have ever seen concentrates power even more than capitalism.
Billionaires go to prison and get executed in China, because power is concentrated in the Party and politics are in command.
That seems pretty fucking good to me.
Executions without fair trial sound good to you? Yep, .ml
Believing billionaires deserve to live? Yup, reddit.world
Remember, China has fewer people in its prisons than the US does. Seems like their trials might be more fair.
They just recognize that billionaire criminals need to be punished for the crimes, instead of becoming president.
I feel like capitalism with strong regulation and social safety nets is the way to go tbh. Good laws that allow for the thriving of coops and stuff. It's just kinda hard to maintain that without a recent memory of a cataclysmic war, ig.
Terms like Capitalism and Socialism mean different things to different people. Yes, there are official or academic definitions you could reference. I'd argue that the larger movement of socialism is less about a well-defined prescription of how to run a society and more about criticism of capitalism, its consequences, and finding better alternatives. It's about diluting the power of the wealthy (the capitalist or owner class, those who are hoarding the power and wealth) as much as possible and using democracy to distribute that power among the working classes to create a more fair and just society.
What aspects of capitalism make you feel it is a better way to organize society?
What aspects of socialism make you feel it is inferior?
I think letting individuals control capital results in more innovation and less bureaucracy.
Collectivization has historically not worked, for various reasons. Markets function better than the state controlling the economy.
It's like churchills quote about democracy.
so capitalism where capital doesn't bestow social power. maybe the capital should be owned by the people so it can't be exploited against them.
I don't hate it, I just don't think it works
Can you elaborate?
I believe when you centralize all economic power in a government it will very likely breed corruption, nepotism and eventually fascism, making it impossible to transition to worker owned means of production.
You're doing a meme right now. This isn't what socialism is, textually, like, not even related.
What is it then?
Spoiler alert: you will probably describe social democracy
Socialism is literally when you decentralize economic power. What you are describing is state-capitalism.
Isn't anarchism a form of socialism though? It doesn't have to be centralised.
I personally hate socialism because I was born in a socialist country and had a shitty childhood. Inb4 someone from hexbear or lemmygrad explaining me that my experience is not valid because it was "not real socialism".
Why does it not actually being socialism not bother you?
Could say the same about "not actually capitalism".
All those versions have the same problems if horrible, greedy people are at the helm.
Capitalism under an oppressive ruling class would have 99% not owning anything, and necessities priced out of reach.
Same logic:
You don't hate capitalism. You hate the version of it taught to you by someone who took the easiest educational track possible.
actually, i do hate capitalism with all its complexity too. imo the market is a useful tool when kept in check by having to compete with planned, government-subsidised alternatives, but private ownership of capital is what generates 99% of the problems with it. either the workers should own the capital or the public should. the best option is probably somewhere between the two.
I think a significant number of us hate whatever system we are living in right now, no matter what it's called.
No, I hate it because all it ever produces are societies run by ultrarich megalomaniacs who rape children.
Wow, talk about USA centric. You know there are a few other counties, right? That are not run by those?
To be honest I don't hate any kind of ideology, they're all the same: If they're run by good people, they'll be good. If they're run by bad people, they'll be bad.
Instead of worrying about which ideology will save the world when it will obviously be corrupted anyway, just elect good people and let them fix whatever system they're in.
That's a lazy approach
Have you ever thought that ideologies are the ideas of a person and that bad people have bad ideologies, ever heard of nazism or fascism? Do you think they would be awesome if the best person in the world was using them? I doubt
The greatest type of rule is always going to be an Enlightened King. The only reason that doesn't work is because of the succession problem, so yes.
clearly ignorant about the measurable effects of wealth/power on human cognition. also ignorant of actual systems of power and control, you understand a vibe and how much you love yourself. please read a book written by someone serious.
and hook me up with your drug dealer, I need the good shit.
you don't think systems matter at all? so if a good fundamentally decent guy was managing white supremacist chattel slavery, it would be fine?
Absolutely not, that much should be obvious.
Good people will ignore or bend the system for good, evil people will use it to be even more evil.
Hate is too strong of a word, but I don't love it based on people that I know and trust who don't have yachts ( or even dingies) that I've been fortunate to work with that have lived in Russia and China. Now if you are talking more social democracies as seen in Europe for example, I'm more interested.
all 97 comments