That's a murder.
post
In Texas, murder applies when the person
Intentionally or knowingly cause the death of another person [or] Intend to cause serious bodily injury and commit an act clearly dangerous to human life that results in death
While manslaughter means
if they recklessly cause the death of another person. Unlike murder, manslaughter does not require intent to kill or cause serious injury. It focuses on reckless behavior that creates a substantial and unjustifiable risk of death.
Sure reads like those charges should bump from manslaughter to murder.
It all hinges on the intent to kill. I'm sure he now would say he didn't intend to kill. just to hit them and teach them to stay off the road. They have enough to charge them with both. And let a jury sort it out.
Saying you intended to hit someone with a motor vehicle is saying to intended to kill them, unless you're provably insane and don't understand that hitting someone is likely to kill.
I expect to see them say bike riding is a form of protest, and he was afraid. 😆
Even a legally "insane" defendant would most often be found to have met the "knowing" criteria; the bar is that of foresight or knowledge (including constructed knowledge in some jurisdictions) of "merely" physical harm that is likely to cause grievous injury or death. No metaphysics required.
For example, acting to cause the stoppage of breath (that "happened" to result in death) is an automatic pass for murder in many common law countries.
Agreed, intent is hard to prove. That's why the law also says, "knowingly." He definitely knew he could kill someone by hitting them with his car.
The man had priors for reckless driving, according to the article. And a bunch of other things.
just to hit them and teach them to stay off the road
That right there is intent to commit "an act dangerous to human life" under the Texas murder statute quoted above.
So when I shot my ex in the spine, it wasn't murder. I was only trying to paralyze them.
Read the article, it has his excuse, which explains the manslaughter reason.
ianal, but I don't think they could be charged with both murder and manslaughter. Wouldn't that violate double jeopardy? Otherwise there would be absurdities where people get charged with the whole spectrum of criminal intent just to see what sticks. (Which does totally happen anyway, when they can get away with it.)
If there’s skid marks, he better get upgraded charges. He has a history of this shit too:
Those jail records also showed prior arrests for Medina on counts such as deadly conduct by discharging a firearm, assault causing bodily injury, and reckless driving. Dispositions for those cases were not immediately available.
Though we all think we know what happened, intentionally and/or knowingly are much harder to prove. It has to be "beyond reasonable doubt". So if the available facts don't back that up, a manslaughter case could be a much safer way to get a conviction. It could be bumped up to murder if new facts come to light as part of the investigation, though.
Oh good. I came here to say exactly this. Good to know this isn't something I'd have posted a comment for,and have everybody tell me I'm wrong. When I'm clearly right.
Like how GIF is pronounced. The Q, Z, and R are not silent, but they are invisable. The other 44 letters are silent AND invisable.
As someone who gets around town on two wheels, I really, really fucking hate that it's expected of me to be the one cognizant of danger and not the motherfucker behind the wheel of a massive, metal death machine.
This will result in better pedestrian and cyclist laws right? I'm tired of being harassed and hit on my bike even in the bike lanes by vehicles.
I like this explanation but I’m no way some one who drives can not be excluded from murder. But isn’t also pre-meditated murder bc you had the option ‘physically stopped the car and reversed’.. No matter the circumstance weather it was intentional to not hit a ‘unintended’ - all sounds too meditated. They had the ability to disengage and not car if thier 2tn vehicle to be used as tank bullet..
This is America, where we blather endlessly about "freedom," but god forbid you actually try to exercise it or people will casually threaten to murder you. Or, as in this case, actually murder you.
Cycling in the US must be the absolute worst
Situational. Liberal areas tend to be better... but even then in my local very blue state we've got a trial coming up for a guy who was speeding and hit and killed a bicyclist.
Yeah, I'm not sure I'd associate cycling quality with a red/blue split. Places like Utah and Idaho are deep red and are practically paradise for cycling. Eastern Washington, where I used to ride a lot when I lived in Seattle, was similarly red yet great for cycling.
Left leaning places are typically more willing to spend money on cycling infrastructure, though, so that's something.
Actually I've never cycled in a better place than Berkeley.
Bike lanes suck. About 10% of the roads in Berkeley don't allow cars. Full roads, not bike lanes.
And the train is super bicycle accessible. Better than any other city I've ever lived in. Elevators and spots for like 5 bikes in every car but the first one
It's actually quite nice. But the US is large, and different places have very different people with very different attitudes towards cyclists (or other road users of any kind, for that matter)
I ride 10,000 km per year in the US and find the vast majority of drivers to be respectful of me.
With that said, there are some crazy people out there who really shouldn't be driving.
You may not be surprised to learn that the only thing that kills more children in the USA than guns (15%) is.... motor vehicles (20%). (Not including pollution, climate change)
She wasn't just accidentally struck by a car. She was intentionally run over by a car that took the time to stop, and then run over her in reverse.
The agency said Rapp and a fellow bicyclist were riding on a local road when Medina passed them in his car, stopped, and drove his vehicle in reverse. Medina then hit Rapp, and she was pronounced dead after emergency responders brought her to a hospital.
jail records also showed prior arrests for Medina on counts such as deadly conduct by discharging a firearm, assault causing bodily injury, and reckless driving.
Piece of shit ran her over on purpose. Even without that extensive rap sheet, I'd say bury him underneath the jail.
Medina passed them in his car, stopped, and drove his vehicle in reverse. Medina then hit Rapp
Wtf?
Why would they be investigating for manslaughter? Passing a cyclist, then stopping and backing to hit them in such a way that they die from it is clearly murder
Holy shit you're right. Journalists failed here, shame to their field.
She wasn't struck. She was literally ran over on purpose! That's fucking murder!
I was surprised that he was only charged with manslaughter, but then I remembered that she was on a bike in Texas.
The sheriff’s office did not provide additional details, saying the “isolated” case remained under active and ongoing investigation.
I really wonder what sort of PR strategy it is to call a vehicular manslaughter case isolated. Are they trying to emphasise that he didn't drive into a crowd or what? Or is the idea to make sure nobody gets any ideas about passing new laws for the protection of bicycle riders, since this was "isolated" rather that structural?
Fuck cars
I used to live in a rural mountainous area and would mountain bike avidly. There were tons of amazing and challenging trails. Only danger was a rattlesnake or I guess going off the side of the mountain but that would just mean rolling down the hill a bit in most places. That is it usually didn't mean falling to your death.
There were a lot of road cyclist who would bike on the tiny two lain mountain roads with blind turns where people would be speeding through. I always thought they were crazy risking their life like that. It just seemed better to drive to the trailhead and have a day in nature typically without ever running into another person.
US boxer Hannah Rapp dies after being struck by car targeted and murdered by driver while cycling in Texas
all 42 comments