I'm not arguing that in the current environment, with TFW cheap labour, etc. immigration has't had neg effect on productivity, wages, etc.
But that doesn't answer the question of why things were different in the 1950-75 period. The analysis says we can accept immigration at 0.85% per year at the moment to keep prod stable. In the 2015-2025 period population grew by 1.1% per year. Yet in the 1950-75 period, pop grew by 2.3% per year, prod grew and real wages more than doubled. Something must have been different back then to produce such stark results. What was it?
On a related note, do you believe that growing productivity causes growth in wages?
BTW, thank you for engaging in good faith. I'm doing the same whether we agree or not. 😊