If you search for magazines on fedia.io, it shows the number of subscribers.

You can crosspost it to the most active communities for instance on .ml and .world
If you search for magazines on fedia.io, it shows the number of subscribers.

You can crosspost it to the most active communities for instance on .ml and .world
It's simple! Stupid questions go to asklemmy, non-stupid ones go to nostupidquestions.
Post to all of them!
...except .ml and hexbear
.ml is bad and full of gross people but it's also "the lemmy run by the developers" (who are gross people) so lots of people default to it and they either become gross or they get tired of the gross people and eventually move to a at least marginally less gross instance like .world, that's why there are multiple versions of lots of communities.
In general, you should decide which community to post on based on the relative grossness of the instance and the size of the community. This requires knowing which instances have high grossness, but you will gradually gain that experience over time, for example you have hopefully learned today that .ml is very gross. You could also just post to both.
Just use whichever, they're all federated.
if I post to one with less traffic, doesn't that decrease the chance of someone coming across my post?
You can cross-post, so the original question can be .world, .ca, or whatever, and cross posts in the others. Personally, I like to have the original post in a smaller instance, so cross-posts in the bigger instances will link to it! It'll make for a healthier Fediverse, but you do you my friend.
Try and avoid .ml though, the admins have some not so nice political opinions and moderation is pretty poor. Most Some instances have defederated from them because of this.
.world is okay and is the big one that almost everybody will follow, but because it's so big moderation there is not the best either. Definitely cross post there to reacher a wider audience, but if a community exists on smaller instance, prioritise posting there!
Some instances to look out for:
Most instances have defederated from them because of this.
This is not true. "Most" instances have not defederated from .ml. I checked all of the servers you listed and each of them are federated with lemmy.ml. i also checked db0, lemmy.zip, .world, and sh.itjust.works. you can check servers yourself by going to the /instances page of any server.
It's a strange position where a lot of people don't like lemmy.ml but lemmy.ml still has large communities so admins keep them federated.
It is true that some users like me will have .ml blocked for the reasons you mention though. And it's still a good idea to avoid posting there imo
Huh, didn't know that. Retrofed, the instance my account is on, is defederated from .ml though, but yeah the others I have checked are not! A lot of users have blocked it, yes, and many of the .ml communities have become less active as a result (which is good! More diversity and less centralisation of the Fediverse is good!)
I'm not familiar with your server but retrofed.com/instances shows lemmy.ml as federated with last communication 35 seconds ago. They do have hexbear and lemmygrad blocked
Huh, weird. When I search for .ml communities on both the web client and various mobile clients, they do not show up (but they do on the other instances, strange)
mander.xyz used to be the big science-focused instance but it is currently down :(
Generally, the most popular or at least the most recently active. If multiple are active, I'll just cross-post to the multiple relevant communities. That said, I also generally avoid .ml due to the numerous problems with their administration.
At least on Fedia, I'm not seeing anything like a subscriber count to steer me.
This is really weird to me. On PieFed via Boost, I can see both subscriber count and post count.
Thank you, yeah: I remember seeing that information in the past. Maybe it's a fedia.io thing? Not knowing which version to use leads me to just generally not post a lot. So then I forget how to find this information out.
Originally I had an asklemmy type of question, today. But then I didn't know where to post it, so I thought I'd ask that on nostupidquestions. Now I don't recall what I wanted to ask in the first place lol
As an aside, I used Boost back in the reddit days. I thought it only worked with lemmy (.world?). Didn't realize it works with PieFed as well
As an aside, I used Boost back in the reddit days. I thought it only worked with lemmy (.world?). Didn't realize it works with PieFed as well
Yep, as of recently. Not everything is great yet, so for example, support for flairs was only just added to the beta branch, but its at least got all the same functionality of Lemmy added at this point.
If your choices are literally anything, or .ml, you take the option that isnt .ml.
Post on them all... Waiting for a Lemmy client that let you post simultaneously to multiple communities with the same name....
I thought of taking that approach. But seems like spamming, somehow? Or is that just considered acceptable, currently, because of the limitations of the platform?
Cross posting is acceptable and even supported (in reading) by many clients
On many clients, cross-posting is supported, and on Piefed, which is federated with Lemmy, you can see comments from all cross-posts automatically!
Just make sure the post does line up with the rules (different instances have different rules) and doesn't go too off-topic (e.g. don't post your Linux meme in a tech support community)
Crossposting is annoying, don't do this. There's no reason to do it, Lemmy is small enough that everyone will see both if it gets more than a few upvotes.
No, cross-posting is good! It promotes a healthier Fediverse as you can give activity to smaller instances. As long as you are reasonable and it is clear that something is a cross-post, it should be okay!
I think just using the lesser known community is better. Instead, the crossposts on the smaller comms get barely any engagement and you end up with fragmented comment sections and a feed that sometimes has the same article 3 times in quick succession.
The fediverse needs something that joins crossposts together before it's viable. I think certain apps already have this.
My own habit (I post several news stories a day, and often to many communities with the same or similar names) is approximately this (no guarantee that I follow it 100% of the time):
One good example is stories about privacy (e.g. legal or political news): I usually post them to the "privacy" communities on lemmy.world, lemmy.dbzer0.com and sopuli.xyz, but I skip the one on lemmy.ml and programming.dev (unless related to programming) as well as the one on lemmy.ca (description says it is only for "tips and tricks to protect your privacy" and not news stories).
I don't worry all that much about it. If one person is subscribed to another instance then all users can possibly see it.
I would go more on vibe than subscriber count. Instances are significant and you're going to get wildly different responses based on where you post.
Post on whichever one you feel like until you find a reason not to.
Lots of people will talk mad shit about instances they don't like and it's like a game of telephone where things get exaggerated and distorted. People dislike us at .ml for ideological reasons and if you don't share that ideology your experience may be different. The truth is you won't generally have problems with posting on .ml unless you're trying to start shit.
all 35 comments