LG was the only one mentioned in the GamersNexus News Story because that is the only brand they could afford to do a deep dive chosen because of the MacAfee popup scandal, and what they covered goes FAR beyond what this RTINGS rerelease of an older story they had done earlier but focused on just ACR. The GamersNexus story went far deeper, but at $80K for doing it for one brand, you are going to have to wait for them to make enough money back before they take on another brand.
post
I saw someone saying monitors are going this way now.
I've been using one over HDMI ever since "smart" started getting slapped on everything.
HDMI cables can carry Ethernet.
Search: Ethernet over HDMI (HEC)
Just as a general rule, if a television requires internet connection then its not your friend.
I think you all know why are are here..... Yes, you really really want a dildo!!!!
Repeat after me...
I want to buy a red dildo!
I really really wish I knew where they sold 12" red, silicon dildos with real looking veins and pullable foreskin!
Just keep repeating that mantra and by tomorrow mornin... A couple of minutes, you'll get temu showing you all the possibilities of the world of dildos.
I don't think this news surprises anyone. (well it shouldn't at least) Don't connect your tvs to the internet ever peoples!
You dont even need to connect it yourself. It can use any open Wifi in range as gamersnexus has shown. It is WAY worse than people think.
And partner networks. Like in Canada there is/was "Shaw Go WiFi" where any shaw customer could connect and get internet access. If a tv brand partnered with them, all their shit could connect to those instead.
Problem is they are finding ways to still connect like via hdmi connection via your pc or other device connected that does have network access. Or public/open wifi and in large apartments or routers from Comcast and others that share wifi for other subscribers they piggy back off all of these.
Its crazy because them selling the physical hardware isn't super profitable but all your data is! This they need anyway to get it that they can
The only way to avoid this, other than buying a dumb panel or projector, is to physically burn or disconnect the modem and any microphones.
All the smug people who think they have not connected their TV to the Internet because they "didn't give it access" are pretending like they are dealing with some cornball 1950's company, not a 2020's brand adversarial guv-corp entity. Crack it open and burn it, or Dremel a bit in exactly the right spot.
Well barring an insecure neighbor wifi. An isolated vlan does the trick.
I wonder if they are willing enough to pay for Amazon sidewalk access https://www.aboutamazon.com/news/devices/everything-you-need-to-know-about-amazon-sidewalk
You really just replied to my comment saying that is insufficient, under an article saying that is insufficient, with 'that is sufficient'?
Um... What does blocking all internet access not prevent here? By isolated VLAN I mean isolated. I.e. fully blocked from internet access LAN local replies only. 0 WAN access.
It doesn't prevent exactly what my comment said it doesn't prevent 'an adversarial entity physically residing within the space'. If I showed up with a pi bristling with antennas, loaded with an unknown, encrypted payload, and plopped it into your living room, would you just hook it into a vlan and be like "there, now I'm safe"?
if a device manufacturer is so hell bent on their devices phoning home that they'll connect to an insecure wifi or a wifi network run by a 'partner' provider.. they're gonna be doing that whenever it can't phone home via a configured network connection, too, and not just when there isn't one set up.
Gamers nexus talks about your exact point at this Timestamp. And he agrees with you.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=6IFVTcM28KA&t=635 He says something like, “A common misconception is taking your TV off your network is enough to stop them from spying.”
i just thought up a nightmare scenario and now i want to beat the shit out of my printer more than i usually do
Every computer that connects to the Internet is vulnerable.
Hasn’t this been known for years? There’s stuff for it built into ad blocking lists and stuff. I use NextDNS on my network, highly recommended.
Watch the video, it's much more extensive and aggressive then it sounds.
Yeah back when you could still get a dumb TV, the smart TVs were cheaper. The only way that makes sense is if they're selling data to subsidize the cost of the TV.
I guess well have to start mapping TV models with microphones and drown them in silicon or something
It's usually in the remote.
Sony put a mic in both. It has a switch to "turn off" the mic on the TV but IIRC the TOS says right up top they're still listening.
Cheap universal learning remotes don't have mics, that helps a little.
Seems like a terrible place for an active listening device.
Not really. It's closer to people than the TV is.
Why would you pick the small battery operated device that gets lost under couch cushions when you can put a mic in the big thing that is plugged in 24/7 and by design has a central and open placement in a room?
Why not both?
Apparently that's what some of them are doing.
Why not put an active listening device in your bank card? Why not secretly sew it into your clothes.
I'm not saying there can't be one in the remote, it's just that the TV itself is a much better option; always has power, doesn't rely on chemical batteries, doesn't need to maximize battery life, (typically) placed with open facing to a room (for clear and consistent audio.
Sure, you can put an always-on listening device on the remote, but you're gonna use more battery to power it, you're gonna need more hardware to handle communication to the TV, and more battery to power that. It's a pretty big compromise for a device that is supposed to go years without changing the batteries. All that trouble to put one in the remote when you can/probably have one in the TV already, and then then remote gets stuck in the couch cushions, or put in a drawer, or lost, or replaced with a different remote. It just doesn't make sense to me to put that kind of effort into what will inevitably be an unreliable and inconsistent spying device.
Yeah don't use anything with voice commands. It's just microphones recording everything.
A lot of smart tv remotes have voice command buttons.
Anything capable has one. Apple tv. Nvidia shield. Android box. Roku.
What can do high quality content and not require that a mic be in the room
A Linux box you build and configure yourself as a media station. Plenty of generic keyboard remotes exist without mics in them.
Pc building is not cheap these days. I wouldnt say its beyond me but it is not an accessible route and difficult to get parity in features. For one CEC HDMI is nigh impossible on 99% of non custom boards.
It's certainly off the beaten track, and they're definitely outnumbered by all the Android boxes, but they're not hard to find preconfigured either. I'm just kind of biased since I prefer to build stuff myself on principle.
https://www.ebay.com/itm/176976068094
Idk if I'd call a $100 set top box (buy once cry once) "inaccessible". Wouldn't be my first choice, and I also wouldn't be surprised if things like this come bundled with spyware/bloatware (just one of many reasons to prefer self-build IMO).
HDMI CEC seems pretty standard on most modern-ish mini PCs as well. They'll run you 2 or 3x the price of the one in the link, but the market's not short on used - I'm still finding somewhat decent deals despite the hysteria around prices.
I've put way to much effort into this. Got an Android TV and took about three hours to investigate all the preinstalled apps before removing bloatware and spyware via adb before replacing the launcher and other adware. Of course I had to do this three times because I deleted necessary stuff the first two times.
Additionally this little shit got its own cage behind my firewall with connectivity whitelists, DNS redirects, and so on.
Wasn't LG one of the last ones of all monitor brands to go full Gestapo on the users?
Soon they’ll start putting modems in the TVs that connect to the internet whether we liked it or not. Pihole would then don’t mean shit and the only way to block them is to physically remove that modem. We need governments that actually give a shit about people, because I have no idea how any of this shit is even legal.
Thats our cars now. Remove the modem and car goes limp
I didn’t even know that. Fuck me
Yeah it is sickening, in the US they sell your driving data to insurance companies.
I just dont like the data being collected at all.
It's legal as long as they share the data with the NSA. Look up PRISM
Google Amazon sidewalk :(
Shits been going on for years already
Some can already bypass something like a Pihole because they have hardcoded DNS.
ah but hardcoding DNS makes it much easier to firewall their outbound connections. 🙃
I’ve had an experience with my Samsung tv that indicated that it had its own hardcoded DNS. Because no matter what manual DNS I used, the fucker kept showing me ads. And then I ran into this random list that had something like cdn.samsungcloud.com or some shit like that and there were several different ones of this one. I blocked those, and all the ads were gone. Of course that also caused several essential services to stop on the, like firmware and app updates, but for thay, I’d let it through every now then to get the updates then back to blocking.
I just bought a new TV for a new place. Got a good deal on a Roku, which of course I know comes at a cost of them harvesting my data. Well, plugged in Ethernet just to set up the tv (using a bogus account, temp email) and then unplugged the Ethernet. It'll never see internet ever again, just hook it up to a Pi for all my streaming needs.
That’s the fucking way. Lmao. If everyone did the same, these companies would lose so much money they’d then stop this spying shit.
I've refused to ever connect my Samsung to the Internet at all. Is it actually worth connecting for updates? Or can I keep on chugging along with my outdated firmware
I do update it when they release actual picture improvements updates. If it says “security updates” I skip it. Sometimes they release updates to their picture algorithms and I want those.
Do you set up a one way connection with your router so outbound connections are blocked and isolated from being able to see other devices on the network?
Also, is updating offline using usb flash drive not possible on Samsung TVs?
RTings is good shit. Always has been.
I’m glad some “oldschool” independent reviewers have survived the death of the internet.
I still have a 60" Vizio from 2015 and I dread the day it dies. I'm plenty capable of blocking network traffic at my router, but I'm not looking forward to spending the money or dealing with the headache of a modern smart TV. There was a post the other day where a user with a Roku TV couldn't get rid of a pop-up on their screen unless they stayed connected to the internet. Good old enshittification.
Consider getting a RV (Caravan) TV. Some are deliberately simple, without all the smart TV frou-frou, internet connectivity, advertising or other nonsense. You can get models that run on DC, AC or both.
Jaycar Electronics in Australia used to sell Rovin caravan/RV televisions like that. The NCE 24-inch LED TV is another example, although it's obviously much smaller than your Vizio. I'm sure both are still on Amazon or eBay - probably around $100 USD.
If you want something closer to your current screen size, look for the SONIQ E55UV80A. It's a 55-inch 4K non-smart TV with HDMI and USB inputs, but no Android TV, Google TV or streaming apps. It's an older model, so availability might be an issue. Still, I'd guess it'd be around the $300 USD mark.
Basically, new dumb TVs are still made and still cheap just harder to find now. You'll have to read the reviews re: quality. I track them because like you I'm prepping for when my current TV goes tits up.
PS: you don't have to spend $$$ on a commercial display to get a dumb TV, though if you want to you can do that too. NEC makes a 55 inch commercial display (E558 multi-sync) that costs around $1K. Samsung too IIRC.
Surely there is a market opportunity here. I would pay 2-3 times the average TV cost, for a TV that had a board capable of running apps, but had zero of its own telemetry, and had granular permissions controls for other installed apps. Basically a GrapheneOS TV.
You should be able to control the behavior of how apps run on your hardware.
Imagine being able to run apps like Grayjay, NewPipe, etc. on a modern TV with no telemetry, no content ID or "ad partners", no homescreen ads, no passive listening mics, etc.
A TV ages much slower than the hardware needed to run apps. It just makes no sense to combine them. Get a great, dumb TV and a cheap TV stick that you can replace after a few years.
This isn't exactly the solution you're talking about, but all of the major brands come with dumb versions. They're just the commercial grade TVs. No smart anything, no tuner, etc. They are pricier though, but this is probably what I'll go with for any future TV.
I been using my Sony TV offline and paired it with a minipc running Fedora. Unless you are into streaming Netflix I found it to be superior for using it to watch YouTube due to being able to use Firefox and playing MKVs compared to relying on Android apps.
Smart has become synonymous with Spy. If it is Smart, then it can used to Spy on anyone. Privacy is a myth in this "Smart" age.
no comments (yet)