I don't have any gum, but I have a mint. Would you like a mint?
post
If you really believe the dogma, you should be able to translate it to modern day working-class language.
Half the time I do that, someone creatively interprets what I mean.
Marxism isn't a dogma, it's a toolset. In any case you're generally correct in saying we should be able to speak to the working class, but we also shouldn't shy away from bringing them up to our level of understanding, either. Politics is for everyone, because everyone is impacted by it, so we should do our best to study ourselves so we can teach our fellow workers as best as possible.
Sometimes I wonder if all the commie hate is just by design to stop anyone and everyone from even remotely thinking about any socialist ideas at all.
I get that totalitarian communism and socialism is a terrible idea ... but at the same time, we shouldn't scorch earth the idea of socially leaning government or even social democracy entirely to the point where we only ever want to think that the current political reality we exist is the only way to go.
The thing is that socialism is much broader than Bolshevism. There is anarchist critics from Marx' time that aged very well. By conflating socialism and Bolshevism, capitalists make everything to their left look bad while Bolsheviks find allies in people who would fight against them if there were more alternatives.
Marxism-Leninism is the socialism that practically exists in the real world, with few alternatives. I haven't really seen any anarchist critique of Marx age well, personally, so if you have any suggestions I'd love to hear. In any case, capitalists understand that the Marxists are their staunchest enemies, which is why they distort and undermine public image of existing socialist countries. These socialist countries aren't the hellholes the capitalist class portrays them as, and painting the situation as the capitalists being truthful about their enemies yet lying about what socialism is just utterly confuses the mechanics at play.
I'm sure Romania wasn't as bad as my mom told me even tho she actually grew up there and I'm sure you have a different interpretation of Kronstadt than Emma Goldman and Alexander Bergman had who came to the USSR with critical support and after Kronstadt broke with it (this isn't direct critique of Marx obviously but when I point to earlier anarchists, you will say that that's not what happened later)
Romania is a mixed-bag, it was better earlier on but as I understand in the 80s it was rough due to austerity measures by CeauΘescu to pay back IMF loans. Of course I have a different interpretation of Kronstadt than Goldman, I'm a Marxist, not an anarchist, and moreover Kronstadt was spearheaded by a White Army sympathizer anyways. Not really sure what you're getting at specifically here.
The hate for leftist ideologies is just the result of years of right-wing, capitalist and fascist propaganda combined with the history of some fucked up dictators doing their shit in the name of communism or socialism just how fucked up fascists do their shit in the name of religion and the greater good.
The history of socialism and communism is told by the capitalist class, outside of socialist countries, and thus our views on their histories are a part of that right-wing, capitalist, fascist propaganda. It isn't just "communism bad," it's also exaggeration of problems, minimizations of successes, and fabrications or distortions of events and people.
Totalitarian communism and socialism...
Whoah, my lover, let me stop you right there. Communism is a stateless, classless society, by definition. If you have a government, you don't really have a communism, see? And socialism is also a far cry removed from what you seem to picture it as. The workers owning the means of production doesn't really tell you anything about governance, does it?
stateless
Wouldn't that be anarchist instead? I thought communism typically came with a state, just one made to serve the needs of the people.
The state (dictatorship of the proletariat after a revolution) in a Marxist communist philosophy is only a temporary situation as means to reach the goal of a stateless (anarchist) system eventually once capitalist counter-attacks are fended off and resources are redistributed eliminating class differences.
Both anarchism and communism share a very similar goal they just terribly disagree on how you reach that goal and whether the state apparatus will gradually disappear on its own eventually or should've we gotten rid of it from the beginning.
Anarcho-communists believe in the goal of a communist society just like Marxist communism which is a stateless, classless, moneyless society.
Same here, I've mainly heard the presense of the state as the discriminator between anarchism and communism.
The fact that so many people believe socialism as it presently and historically exists was and is "totalitarian" is precisely by design. The common sense of any society is the ideology of the ruling class, the structures put in place by communists to fight against capital and cement working class democracy are utterly alien to most of us who live only in capitalism, and therefore it's easy to confuse them for not being run by and for the working class.
Sometimes I wonder if all the commie hate is just by design to stop anyone and everyone from even remotely thinking about any socialist ideas at all.
If that's true, then the rabid tankies we see on here are truly a psyop
TL;DR: they're real, shit is bad, bro.
I've met rabid tankies in real life, including one of my best friends (rest in power). These days it's easy for us to dismiss each other as bots and paid trolls. We didn't evolve for the social situations we now find ourselves in; our brains are screaming at us that this tribe is unfair and we should find a better one.
I'm not here to defend tankies. But many of us are desperate. I want to believe that we're one election away from abolishing the secret police, but in my heart I have no faith that we will. The other countries that are currently doing better seem to be sliding towards fascism anyways - there's no escape. So we need to deal with this here and now, and none of us have a complete answer, which is scary.
many of us are desperate
Yes. I know I am. The internet/Lemmy is making my life worse and yet I somehow think it's better to be informed anyway. I don't know the right way to stay informed but I've been struggling with the extremism and negativity here for a long time. I've blocked hundreds of accounts, yet regardless I keep getting pummeled with hate any time I push back against opinions that I find extreme or wrong in any way.
Seems the only way to fit in here is to generalize groups to extremes. And you're right, we didn't evolve to handle this shit. But also, I think a lot of people don't even try to maintain objectivity. That opening scene in 2001 A Space Odyssey is accurate. We're just apes, looking to inflict violence against those that would challenge us. It fucking sucks, because even the people who start out not wanting to hurt anyone will turn rabid when pushed. And pushed is all we get anymore. It's the time in human history most conducive to better behavior, but alas, we don't get that. We get trillionaires killing millions of Africans on purpose. Oligarchs laughing in our face that they could shoot someone on Fifth Avenue and be loved for it. Then the reaction to people like that is to want to kill anyone with some variable amount of money labeled as "too much". Nuance is a construct, it's not real. Everything is an overreaction.
Nah, the group modernly called tankies have existed for well over a century. People can get heated when they are often surrounded by misconception after misconception, thick with the propaganda of the Red Scare. Despite what people like to believe, nobody is actually immune to propaganda.
Mine's mostly born of constant tankie atrocity denial and downplaying.

Yeah, fuck tankies and any authoritarian leftists, but keep in mind not all leftists are like those
Most of the ones I see are happy to defend authoritarianism, so it may be the vocal asshole problem.
I feel you, three big instances of Lemmy are filled with them, I just blocked all three on my side. I consider myself an anarcho-communist, and I'll say it again and again, fuck Stalin, fuck Lenin and fuck Mao. These three fuckers ruined the reputation of the left for decades because they were power hungry assholes
See, leftist ideology is a lot like CrossFit or veganism. There's nothing wrong with it. It's probably good for you. But the most annoying people in the world just can't shut up about it.
And before anyone says it: NoT AlL VEgAnS/CrOsSFiTs/LeFtisTs
Bruh 6AM?
Bruh we get up at 4AM to shout that shit around here. DonΚ»t want to hit traffic.
There's a time when the operation of the machine becomes so odious, makes you sick at heart that you can't take part, you can't even passively take part.
And you've got to put your bodies upon the gears, and upon the wheels, upon the levers, upon all the operatus and you've got to make it stop!
And youβve got to put your bodies upon the gears, and upon the wheels, upon the levers
Today I learned that Chief Tyrol's speech was based on a real one! I always thought his delivery was a bit strange, and apparently it's because he based his mannerisms on the real Mario Savio's in giving that speech. Which is very cool, but a bit weird because then he goes back to not being like Savio.
I have no idea who Chief Tyrol is
I looked it up for you. Apparently it's a battlestar galactica character.
I never could get past the first two episodes. Just... such a slow wank fest.
I assume it is not a Star Trek spin-off?
No, very much opposite in a lot of ways. The setting was actually interesting and what I like about it.
Imagine a society where humans are pretty widespread, but the origin planet is lost to the mythos of the past and legend. The humans create AI, and it kills, or at least begins to, humans. The humans at the main planet have the last vestiges of military, and they start fighting a running battle trying to escape the incoming AI forces. Everything else is lost, only a convoy remains. Aaaaaand cue the start of the show.
Capitalism is great and all, except it's kinda late-stage now and it's not really working for the useless eaters any more.
Under capitalism we have cooked the planet, and are now trying to grow aliens in a lab in the hopes they will save us instead of annihilate us.
Idk man. I think it might be time to try literally any other system.
Useless eaters? That's an explicitly fascist term.
I don't know how I feel about using it for billionaires, pretty funny on the whole, but you may get some troubling people following you if you use their language, even ironically.
I too like small cars that can not take a turn without falling over. The Ford Bronco is US product #1 with parts, "responsibly sourced from China."
IDK much about communism, but the one thing I do know is that you don't want literal pigs in your revolution.
ALL HAIL SNOWBALL
SNOWBALL was a TRAITOR secretly working with farmer jones. NAPOLEON is the only pig that can lead this GLORIOUS REVOLUTION.
Fuck lenin
He was a terrible person and a terrible leader is why. I am a anarcho/council communist so not apologizing for any sort of capitalism here but the way Lenin ran things was shit! They were so focused in not being like the bourgeoise they replaced that it ran so inefficient with 10 different stupid coincils and they were not pro worker either except for a couple of branches who Lenin and his guys actively hindered. Stalin gets flack because of how terrible he ran things but as terrible as he was he inherited that system from lenin
What specifically was bad about the Soviet system, and what was bad about Lenin as a leader? The Soviet system was very efficient, especially in the first several decades before World War II. Workers saw enormous benefits, like democratization of society and the workplace, free education and healthcare, and rents at or below 10% of monthly incomes, with 40 hour work weeks. Women joined the government and gained the ability to no-fault divorce their husbands. Workers gained a ton from socialism.
IDK, maybe killing shitloads of people by shipping them off to gulags?
That didn't happen, though. The overwhelming majority of deaths in the GULAG system were from starvation in the 1940s, due to the Nazis invading Ukraine to starve out the Soviet people. Further, the GULAG administration began after Lenin, and was disbanded in 1956. Below is the mortality rate data from Wikipedia:
Year Deaths Mortality rate %

A correct analysis of the Soviet Union is necessary, because it was the first socialist state. We need to be critical, but base our critique on fact, not fiction. There's plenty that went wrong, but there's also plenty that went very, very well. We can learn from both.
Ah, so people didnβt die in gulags except those that died in the gulags?
Got it.
Wikip says that over a million died in gulags before β53.
Guess youβve just moved the goalposts to βthey arenβt enough to matter, and weβre not gonna really count that because cherrypicking.β
You claimed Lenin killed a shitload of people in GULAGs, which didn't even exist when Lenin was in power, and the overwhelming majority of those that died in GULAGs died because of Nazi-inflicted weaponized starvation. What's your actual point? Over 700,000 of total deaths were during World War II. Of the people the Soviets were directly responsible for, these numbers were far more in line with contemporary prison systems.
What specifically was bad about the Soviet system,
Donβt play word games with me. You said Soviet system, and now you play games and say oh, I only meant Leninβ¦
Fair enough, I did ask two questions:
What specifically was bad about the Soviet system, and what was bad about Lenin as a leader?
I assumed you were answering both, so my mistake on not realizing you were only answering the Soviet question. In any case, incarceration rates weren't terribly high, and mortality rates weren't either. Many soviet prisons were actually fairly progressive even by today's standards. Prisoners were paid wages equal to those outside the prison, handcuffs were seen as barbaric and largely unnecessary, and prisoners could even go on vacation. Some prisons even had people going home for the weekends.
The reason for the Soviet prison system acting in the way it did, was because they believed in rehabilitation over punishment for most crimes. They believed that the best way to do so is to train people on how to be productive, pro-social workers. Not all prisons had the same progressive conditions, though, and this varied largely by severity of crime and region.
As I said, we can learn from what they did well, while also recognizing where they faltered. Both are necessary if we are to carry their torch, and repeating nonsense Red Scare framing only serves to divorce us from the common historical task of the working class globally.
Ah, so right back to βnot dead enoughβ
Well, canβt fix an apologist. Bye.
Edit: well I shouldβve known, my fault for not realizing. The .ml cowbee. Wasted my time. Already blocked the instance, just add one more to the pile.
Sure? I thought it was fairly obvious that I'm a Marxist-Leninist, I've never hidden that. I believe the hundreds of millions of workers that worked, fought, and died to build and protect socialism weren't fools.
So what do you have to say about them toying with militarization of labor?
The central point of Animal Farm is that workers are stupid and incapable of understanding their own conditions, and thus will endlessly be taken advantage of by charismatic leaders. Itβs a deeply aristocratic take that erases the agency of the working classes. Orwell was also a snitch, keeping lists of Jews and communists to report to the British feds.
Having worked in a range of professions over decades, a lot of it "customer facing", I can wholeheartedly say with full conviction that a lot of people -worker or otherwise- are as thick as a bucket of pigshit, and that's not being entirely fair on the pigshit.
I'm not trying to make any kind of political statement here, merely pointing out that a statistically significant portion of people are comically stupid.
People are generally able to understand their own interests, and are capable of learning and growing.
If that were true, Nigel Farage wouldn't be half as popular as he is.
Or, Nigel Farage's support base has a specific class character that does benefit.
The only thing they have in common is that they're easy to exploit.
We're talking about fishermen who think "Reform will fix what the EU did to our fisheries", for example. There is no explanation for that other than sheer stupidity.
Why not? Training some pigs to advance against the police in protests would be awesome
IDK much about communism, but what I do know I learned from an anticommunist propagandist fiction writer.
Another normal day.
You can't be referring to Orwell here, can you?
Who else would they be referring to? The central point of Animal Farm is that workers are stupid and incapable of understanding their own conditions, and thus will endlessly be taken advantage of by charismatic leaders. It's a deeply aristocratic take that erases the agency of the working classes. Orwell was also a snitch, keeping lists of Jews and communists to report to the British feds. Fuck Orwell. That's all without getting into the allegations that he was a sex abuser when he was young as well.
Brother do you need gum? I have plenty to share.
all 9 comments