"Hate" is too strong, but I don't watch them. I don't care for singing in movies as a rule, unless the movie is about a singer. Even then, I don't want multiple full music videos embedded in the movie. Just not my thing.
We're not alone:

"Hate" is too strong, but I don't watch them. I don't care for singing in movies as a rule, unless the movie is about a singer. Even then, I don't want multiple full music videos embedded in the movie. Just not my thing.
We're not alone:

Why stop as a kid? I can't really enjoy myself when watching a musical played out on stage, and I saw some epic spectacles. (Les Miserables, Sissy, Soldaat van Oranje). It's just not for me.
When it's cartoons, it's not so bad for me. The silliness of breaking out into songs fits that world better for me. But make it a live action movie and please let me leave the theater.
I don't know why, but I become irrationally angry when there is some musical where the actors do that fucking moronic thing where they look up wistfully and sing REAL LOUD. What are they looking at? Why are they fanning their arms out in that big slow arc? Who does that?! Why is that supposed to be entertaining?
That and the "really excited" sing that people do, big corny smile, they're all jazzed up about going out to buy a new hat or something for no good reason. "Hey, let's go downtown and buy a HAT!!!!". JFC. Do audiences really demand this sort of nonsense?
In live action, it always feels like a format that is more for the actors than the audience. I do sing for hobby myself and I try to be technically really good, practice over and over, and aim for a performance I would be proud of, So i have some experience with this myself (what you would do to enjoy yourself during singing, vs what would be actually fun to listen to). All those dumb moves you describe somehow just naturally come out of me while singing. Playacting out the song as a real story in my head makes me able to put more emotion in the song, and doing that will immediately summon my inner 'musical actor/performer' so to speak. So now it kind of looks like a guitarist bobbing along to the song to me. You don't NEED to do that, but most musicians will enjoy doing it. I just sing Toni Braxton - Un-break my heart flatout better, if I can sometimes make my hand into a fist and dramatically and powerfully move it down.
So again, those are the exact same things that annoy me, and it just looks like what the performer themselves would most enjoy doing at that time, seemingly without caring about the actual final product (a horrible live action musical)
Nope, I loved them and still sing the songs from classic musicals like My Fair Lady and Sound of Music on a regular basis. Also a huge fan of Gilbert and Sullivan and and also most every recent Broadway music that has been nationally popular.
Noting that I do not consider cartoons, like Disnay cartoons, musicals. I only think of musicals as being live action from the start (not live action from a cartoon) or as plays.
Yes. At 50, I still do. They are tacky, kitschy and written for either kids or kidults.
I thought I hated musicals. But Phantom, Jersey Boys, Hamilton, Moana, Encanto, Coco, and others have convinced me otherwise.
I still don't like musicals for being musical. For example I hate Cats and Le Miz and Wicked — they all have like one song that hits and everything else is meh, and I need most of the songs to hit in a musical.
But music can engage you and speak on an emotional level that words and speech struggle to (not always, though. Kirk's speech at Spock's funeral and the Presidents speech in Independence Day are good melodrama.) Sometimes words that would be completely trite if spoken take on an authenticity when sang to music. I give you Meatloaf's entire oeuvre.
I don't have rules for what works and what doesn't, and certainly there wouldn't be universal agreement. But I have a deep appreciation of really good musicals.
I was willing to hear you out but Les Miserables is full of amazing songs. It's basically only amazing songs. Hell the opening song "Look Down" beats most other musicals best songs. Then you've got the standard best song of "I Dreamed a Dream", or my personal favorite "On My Own". Plus let's not forget the anthem "Do You Hear the People Sing". Or how about "Master of the House"? Let's even look at the lesser known songs, "Empty Chairs and Empty Tables", beautiful. Or "Back and Red", inspiring! Or even just quick songs like the "Confrontation".
Genuinely. Take another look at Les Miserables. It's really amazing.
(Cats also has lots of fun songs, but Memory is the clear standout. The film is garbage, but if you can see it live it's a more enjoyable experience. The trick is to treat it as more of a talent show versus a story.)
(Wicked also has at least two standout songs. Also by comparison Wicked is more story focused. So if you don't like the story that's fair. I enjoyed it, but that's ok if it's not for you.)
I've only seen Les Mis once, and that was the movie. Maybe the songs grow in you over time. But for whatever reason the songs didn't hit for me. I didn't mean to impugn it as a work of art, clearly it is beloved by many, many people. I love Anne Hathaway as an actress, and I Dreamed A Dream was a great song, but I can't recall liking another song.
Are Disney movies like that considered musicals? I guess I never thought of them like that.
I consider the movies from the Disney renaissance, starting with The Little Mermaid and maybe ending with Tarzan, to be musicals. These also happen to be the movies I grew up with, so grain of salt I guess.
I still liked the movies as a whole. I just got annoyed when they started singing. Now that I'm older I can say I simply don't like musicals rather than outright hating them. Kids sometimes have a hard time sorting out their feelings and attitudes. I certainly did.
Do they sing about their feelings, and not just as an aside in the shower or something, as in, a full song is sung?
Then yes, it's a musical.
I did dislike most musicals as a kid and that is also true as an adult. In most cases it feels like the singing doesn't really add anything, just as an excuse to do a dance routine which I also tend to dislike. Especially when it feels like the majority of time is spent singing.
The few exceptions that I like are ones where I think the music actually contributes and liking the songs helps. For example, I don't like the Lion King songs but I do like Aladdin's and the songs from Nightmare Before Christmas. Mulan Rouge's use of songs was interesting!
Seeing as your list of "acceptable" musicals is nearly identical to mine, have you ever seen Sweeney Todd?
Sweeny Todd and Mulan Rouge are pretty much the only live action musicals I really liked. (Though I can't say that I'm going out of my way to find more)
Sweeny Todd with Depp and Bonham Carter was fine, but I don't have any urge to watch it again or to see any other version.
Mulan Rouge I've watched at least 3 times and enjoyed it each time. I've seen Aladdin and Nightmare over a dozen times and enjoyed both every time. I can't think of any others I enjoy, but there's probably a few more that I think are fine like Sweeny Todd.
I rally dislike Rent and Grease and Cats and musicals like those, both stage and/or movies. Just not my thing.
I sat through the songs, and learned them from absolution, and even got them stuck in my head and sang along, but I wouldn't have missed them at all.
Fuck musicals. Also, fuck comedy songs too.
It's very, very rare to be able to get decent music AND a decent story/joke to be told at the same time. I've got like 3 examples :
Loved Weird Al as a kid, I guess I still do. UHF was great.
Nightmare Before Christmas gets a pass because I love stop motion more than I hate musicals.
Moulin Rouge I probably would dislike immensely if I were forced to watch it.
What if the music is part of the story, like Phantom of the Opera?
Um. Frank zappa is amazing.
Yes He is.
I don't particularly find "Jazz from Hell" or anything else particularly funny though.
I mean, his music was full of humor though. Iirc he made a song and also spoke about music containing humor and that being a good thing.
Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying he didn't make jokes in his music, I just didn't find it particularly funny.
That's the problem. It's very, very hard to get the balance right between the two, and also, hit the correct audience at the same time with music and comedy. Different people can like different things for different genres.
I like weird al because I enjoy fast paced, complex music, and a down to earth sense of humour that isn't too base, but kinda within your classical comedy. Zappa's stuff is too dry or too base. I like the dry stuff in measured quantities, and I like the base stuff to be in the right context.
Musically, Zappa is amazing. But the comedy, doesn't hit the mark. And that's ok. That's why I love Jazz from Hell.
I disliked the singing scenes in cartoons the same way I disliked the talking scenes in action movies.
The term "hate" gets tossed around too lightly. I've always taken it to be synonymous with wanting something dead or destroyed. When I think of things I truly hate I can only think of cancer. Fuck cancer.
I clarified in a post up the thread that I don't "hate" musicals as an adult, but as a kid I had a hard time articulating why I felt a certain way so I would have said I "hated" them back then. More to the point I didn't like when the characters sang vs just talking. So I liked The Lion King aside from the singing. I just "dislike" musicals now rather than hate them.
Now that you mention it, I think I didn't watch many Disney movies or similar as a kid. My earliest memories are Spaceballs, Top Secret, Airplane! and Young Frankenstein.
Oh, and Banana Joe, which is very very bad
I've always loved (good) musicals. I still do, especially opera. There's no better value for live music than opera these days.
I don't really enjoy musicals, and never did. I like music (a admittedly narrow range of rock/punk/metal and close relatives), but whatever they're doing in musicals usually doesn't do it for me.
Nope! I am the exact opposite! If a movie or show has a musical number in it, I am more likely to want to watch and enjoy it.
I grew up watching (and having a huge crush on) Gene Kelly in An American in Paris and Singing in the Rain. I watched The Sound of Music and The King and I over and over again. I loved musicals as a kid and still do in my 40s. Repo the Genetic Opera is amazing!! Give me all the Bollywood and Tollywood!! Give me more Eega and RRR!!
I love music and musicals! 😁
Oh man. The sound of music just dragged on and on and on for me. It didn't even have an interesting plot for me either. I'm glad somebody enjoyed it though.
Lack of interesting plot is, in my opinion, a bit of an odd criticism, there's a lot going on there - a good romance plot is the center of the story but you also have ofc the Nazis invading and the escape from Austria. I do agree it drags in places.
Oh lol. I don't typically find person-oriented stories to be compelling. (As compared to event oriented stories (like 2012), or visually interesting ones (like transformers or pacific rim), or what have you.) The sound of music in particular was primarily driven by the characters in it, rather than the visuals or events, so it didn't really catch my fascination. It didn't help that watching it was for homework, though.
The Sound of Music and The King and I were both ones my mom watched a lot. Not my favorites, but I like the songs. Now, Gene Kelly? Hell fucking yes, I will watch that man shake his ass all day long and I don’t care if he was old enough to be my grandfather lol I come from a pretty musically inclined family though, so it’s always been a part of my life.
I will once again plug Eega. It’s one everyone should see. I mean, who wouldn’t love watching a man reincarnated into the body of a fly only to have to save his lady love from the city thug? Plus, there’s an entire fly dance number at the end!
Yes, and still do. I also hate musical episode in a series. IASIP is one of my favourite tv shows but I despise the musical episode. It is not needed.
The only musical I really finished was Sweeney Todd, but that's only because for some reason I realised very late into the movie that it was a musical and at that point I was too interested in the story. So I begrudgingly finished it lol
Same, as a young kid I found the song portions of children's movies rather tedious to get through. Imagine my surprise years later when I found out the songs are added with the intention of helping capture kids' attention during films. I wonder if it's because the lyrics often contain interesting/pertinent information but it is much harder to comprehend than standard dialogue, especially as a kid. To this day I hate when stage musicals' songs contain plot-critical information, as I often can barely parse what the actors are singing, especially during chorus portions (at least with movies you can turn on closed captioning).
I don't really enjoy much of the musical or sing-song film out there, but I have an exception. Grease! I can watch that movie over and over and it never gets old. John Travolta was so dreamy lol.
Yes, especially live "plays" which was a bit of a dilemma because my cousin was in the drama club and always performed. I love my cousin so I'd go to see him but I always hated the shows lol
An "interesting" result of that was actually seeing howard stern a few times. Apparently he has a relative that was also in those shows
I was never a fan of musicals (& if ever subjected to a Disney film, would moan "oh God, here comes the singing"), but in the last couple of years I've caught a few musicals (because they were the film picked for a watch party) and thought... "you know, I really enjoyed that film, even though it was a musical".
Examples:
Still not a fan of traditional musical numbers (as opposed to Harpo's skits) crammed into Marx Brothers films. Watched an Indian action film, Don, & was a bit discombobulated when the musical numbers showed up.
I still don't go out of my way to watch musicals, but now not so adverse to giving a few a chance.
PS and of course just realized I've had at least one lifelong exception to the "I don't like musicals" rule, The Blues Brothers.
Yes and you nailed the reason. A very short list of exceptions:
I generally don't like musicals though the Disney movies are the exception. For me it has nothing to do with the time, it's just the style of music that seems to mostly be used for musicals, especially Broadway musicals. They've all got this certain flair to them that just, eh, not my thing.
As a kid I didn't understand genre and stuff as much so it was just "no musicals" and thankfully I've moved to the point where I can enjoy a few for what they are.
I did, always wanted to skip the singing parts as a kid.
I like them now though.
Exact opposite. Musicals are the shit!
Every Disney cartoon up until Toy Story. Cats, Phantom of the Opera, Little Shop of Horror... I probably would have loved Rocky Horror Picture Show if I ever saw it as a kid. My favorite episode of Buffy the Vampire Slayer is "Once More With Feeling," the musical one.
As an adult I want to know where all the musicals went.
For some reason, watching Annie always made me feel deeply uncomfortable. Kind of messed up any musicals for me.
Uncomfortable as in the story, or uncomfortable that a child had such a fucking amazing voice and the skill to match most adult performers?
It was just this hard to pin down vibe that the actual child actor in the film felt like they were being abused. Not the character. But the girl who played Annie. The feeling manifested when I was a kid as young as the actor in the film. Just a vibe.
Still not a huge fan. Though I saw The Book of Mormon when they came through town a bit ago and it was awesome.
Only if the music bit is warranted. If it's just randomly inserted that didn't prompt it, yes I hate it.
Only musicals I can remember liking are Disney cartoons and Flight of the Concords because it was funny.
I hated them until I saw Shrek the Musical, aged 40 something, at my local theatre. The effort those kids put in and the enjoyment they were getting out of it made me cry. Yes, Shrek the Musical
I'm kind of the opposite, I liked musicals as a kid. Oklahoma, South Pacific, Guys and Dolls, West Side Story - the songs were on the radio all the time and I still know most of the lyrics. Now, I can't bear musicals. I hate that "belting it out" style of singing. It's just not for me.
The Rocky Horror Picture Show is the last musical I really enjoyed.
Not sure if I hated them, but I would always skip the Tomas the Tank Engine musical sing-a-long tapes when watching them as a kid. But I guess it was half the singing and half because all they did was show clips from previous episodes with music over it. I just wanted to see a normal episode and not clips I've already seen.
all 74 comments