25 years is a good run. They’re obligated to make them so they break down on weekends.
post
25 years is fantastic. 3x what my last one did. We now have a softener and I'm purging it occasionally. Going for 12 years (9.5 left) before I'll need to convert to electric.
We moved into a house in 2014 and it failed in 2015... the one they replaced it with failed twice through the years and finally leaked everywhere in 2025. So 2 in 10 years is my run. I have shit luck.
Mine is a combi-boiler which means it runs the heat in my house, too, so when it goes out we have no hot water and no heat. They're also much more expensive, and the doorframe has to come off to fit any modern model.
I've done two of those in ten years, as well. So, yeah, with you there in bad luck club.
I wanted to go to an on demand tankless but couldnt afford it and everyone keeps telling me not to for some reason... big water heater companies propaganda I can only assume! Jk... mine is electric since we have no other options so I couldnt do your setup if I wanted to I think. But the alternative is all electric base board and although reliable it costs a fortune in winter and again to poor to invest in better to help myself. Just stuck.
You couldn't pry a tankless from my cold, dead hands. Worked a bunch of overtime to buy one out right for 2,000 cad. We were renting one before. The contract expired and returned the rental. Installed myself in a few hours. Works good if you buy one that's the same as the rental because it's just plug and play.
According to the tag on mine it was installed in 1996. It finally blew last month, but given that I was paying attention it did give me plenty of warning by way of visible rust bubbles starting to form around the seams.
A lifespan of around three decades is exceptional for a storage tank water heater, so I really can't complain. The thing came with the house. I replaced it with a zooty hybrid heat pump model which by my admittedly rather fuzzy math will pay for itself in roughly... five years. (Before anyone asks, the Technology Connections video didn't have anything to do with it. That was always my plan for whenever the old one's number finally came up.)
I remember my dad building a "water heater simulator" when my parents installed geothermal heating 15-20 years ago.
It was a plywood box built to the exact dimentions of the water heater, and was needed as the location for the heater is VERY tight and cumbersome to get to and goes through several narrow and low doors.
With the simulator he could figure out the best way to get it into the space for it.
This reminds me I need to drain mine
I feel like I'm near the end of life for mine. I kinda want to be proactive and clean it, flush it, but at this point I feel like if I touch it at all it's gonna break.
Yea, don't do that...
I've learned - you either regularly maintain systems or don't touch them at all.
If you do drain it, and it is an electric one, remember to turn off the brraleaker(s) for the immersion heater(s). Most don't have a sensor that kills power to the heaters when water is low, causing the immersion heaters to overheat in the open air and blow.
I’d definitely set the cost aside and watch. That’s what I did. I’ve been anticipating it to go out to be honest.
Keep up with replacing the anode rod on the new one!
Who's it made by? That's a great run.
We replaced a 30 year old water heater last year. We love with very hard water too.
It’s an old 40Gals Rheem. Back when they made them good. Replaced it with an A.O Smith. Wasn’t too bad. $550 for a similar size and all.
We went the other way 🤣 40 -> 50 gal. Went with Bradford White.
I think Rheem is still top of the charts on consumer reports and others. The service we went with didn't supply them though and we got a discount deal on water heater, fornace and AC. The furnace and AC are shackelford. It's the off-name for Carrier. We had their AC and furnace for 30 years, so fingers crossed 🤣
I don’t need that much really. It’s just 4 of us and the old was more than enough. Didn’t want to spend more, ya know. My friend who’s replacing it recommended A.O smith over Rheem saying Rheem isn’t as good as they used to be. Same price anyway, so I went with his recommendation
My water heater turned off earlier in the week, looks like all it was is the gas was turned off down the line temporarily earlier in the day. The heater is so old it doesn't auto ignite. Followed the instructions and got it back on, super dull to do at 11pm.
Pretty sure it peed on the floor.
did you replace the anode rod during that time?
No sir, we don’t do that round here. Lol.
How often should you do that? I haven't yet...
For that matter, do you drain yours once in a while?
I am not a plumber, just some random internet guy, i think how often depends on how corrosive is your water and if you use magnesium or aluminum zinc rods, i got well water and replace with aluminum every 8 years, but been told should be every 5
An excellent opportunity to get a heat pump water heater.
These things expensive as hell. Also, the reviews on them are really bad. The idea sounds really good, but I'll pass for now.
Seems to me like they work well if you understand the constraints they come with.
Then again, I live in a country where gas heating is essentially unheard of, with the options to a heat pump system would be direct electricity, or district heating where applicable.
Understandable. I’d spend that much money only if I had no other options. I get it. Gas is food good for now.
I'm guessing that's supposed to be "gas is good" for now, unless you're on a diet I'm so far unfamiliar with?
I have switched to this iPhone recently because the wife kept nagging about “iMessage”, and man this fucking keyboard is going to cause me brain cancer. It switches proper words to words that don’t even fit the context and leave incorrectly spelled words alone. What’s worse is that it doesn’t switch it right away, no, it waits until I’m deep into a sentence then sneaks in the wrong word for me. So, the “food” was actually “good”, but the fucker switched it. Keyboards will need to fucking stop speaking for us.
all 54 comments